, Research Paper
I believe that throughout history, the Tsars felt threatened. They then reformed in order to stay in power, and to stay in for power alone. However, this mindset only had an effect when the Tsar’s power was threatened. Nevertheless, I believe that to find the factors that had an effect on the Russian system of government, one must look for the reason why felt threatened. Here war was an important factor, however it was not the only factor. Otherwise reform would not have occurred without war. I believe that if these other aforementioned factors were important enough to cause political change, then they must rank alongside war in terms of importance. However it was not “the locomotive of history”. i Together with discontent in the populace, and its manifestations (strikes, revolutionary activity, and assassinations), I believe War invariably changed the Russian political system. I believe war had an impact for several reasons. Throughout the period described Russia took part in three wars, in which they were crushed. Firstly, when a country fails in war, some would see it as being a sign that the country is less advanced in general. Firstly, the realisation that one’s country was backward and prone to invasion threatened the Tsar’s power, which then induced political change. He realised that if something was not done to improve and modernise that external enemies could be more of a danger than internal ones. I have chosen an example to illustrate this. After the 1854-6 Crimean War, Alexander II initiated the emancipation of the Serfs, the creation of the Zemstvos, the Dumas, and the independent judiciary. He was even compelled to consider relinquishing a sizeable proportion of his power to the populace, but died before being able to implement these ideas. This was as a direct result of Alexander having the aforementioned realisation. Secondly, war has the inevitable effects on the populace. Unlike Bismark, the Tsars did not have the political clout necessary to ensure that a war was properly prepared for. Subsequently, the long drawn out wars slowly demoralised the Russian people and resulted in discontent. Aside from destroying any pride they had in the “system”, they were subjected to witnessing the death of their comrades and the draining of their country. However, war when carried out swiftly and with success can have positive benefits for the popularity of a ruler. Bismarck’s foreign policy showed this. But the wars in which Russia was involved in only served to weaken the resolve of the people, and the power of the Tsar. The floundering war effort was a factor in the Bloody Sunday, the October Manifesto and the first revolution of 1917. Yet there were other factors in these political upheavals and others, as I have said before. The other main factor I believe was important was the discontent of the populace. Ultimately, the Tsar’s power rested on support from below. When this support was not there, he had to act to regain it, as he felt threatened. The loss of public support came about for a number of reasons. Firstly, I would like to address the reasons why the Tsar sometime lost the support of the peasantry, and the effect this had. I believe that the peasants and proletariat lost faith in the Tsar, very gradually because while “privileged Russia” had worked tirelessly to become more westernised, the situation of the “dark masses” had become ossified. The only Russia that had existed was in the five-mile radius of their shantytown. Beforehand most peasants were politically unaware. However the effect of factors such as education, war and poor living conditions was to make them more politically aware. Under the shiny veneer of a happy, hard-working peasant lay a bitter hatred of the upper classes. All moves to industrialisation and urbanisation had been done without regard to him or his expense. He felt useless and was disenchanted with his country and situation, but did not realise what he could do about it. However when these factors arose, a political consciousness came with it. It was ultimately the humble peasant who caused the single most important political change in this period. The realisation that things could be better manifested themselves as strikes, revolts, assassinations and revolutionary activity, which then served to initiate political reform. These strikes and the spread of revolutionary activity then served to spread these ideas. This then resulted in the metaphorical vicious circle of strikes, which subsequently formed more strikes. The major factor I mentioned in the development of a “class consciousness” was the poor living standards. If we accept the notion that “man is an objective, natural, physical, sensitive being, he is a suffering, dependent and limited being, … that is, the objects of his instincts exist outside him, independent of him, but are the objects of his need, indispensable and essential for the realization and confirmation of his substantial powers… The first historical fact is the production of the means to satisfy these needs.”ii Thus while Russia remained a backward, agrarian society, with production and efficiency too low to satisfy the demands of the populace, discontent was likely to be rife. And in the cities where the close proximity of each worker to the other, combined with Dickensian working conditions, discontent was likely to have occurred much faster. However, here ends the parallel with Marx. The fact is that people were unhappy, and realised that their conditions were worse, inferior to what they could be, as in Western Europe. Thus they pushed for change, in the form of a revolt. Education only served to heighten the number of revolts. By educating the masses, a new intelligentsia formed. The “four-tier system of schools from primary to the university level”iii, and then subsequently the universal primary education in 1908 took the “dark masses” from being an indifferent class to one that was more revolutionary and literate. The massive support for the leftist revolutionary groups in the 1906 and 1907 Duma elections, (who managed to receive sixty-four percent of the voteiv despite a suffrage system weighted against them), showed that the peasants were not revolutionary. I would argue that education had a role to play in this. My logic is that because the workers knew that things could be better, and that they were being exploited, that they could subsequently improve their situation by pushing for reform, through strikes or even through revolution. These factors were of paramount importance in the Bloody Sunday rising of 1905 and the subsequent October Manifesto, and later the February revolution. Because the peasantry had become more revolutionary, they supported the middle class that had emerged in the push for more power. If Father Gapon and the Provisional government had not carried with them the support of the populace, then something similar to the abortive Kapp Putsch in Germany, 1919 would have occurred. However, the workers and even the soldiers were behind them, which meant that reform was very necessary to keep the populace in check. i Leon Trotsky ii Karl Marx, Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 iii Encyclopaedia Britannica (1998) iv Based on data from Access to History: Reactions and Revolutions: Russia 1881-1924, Lynch, 1992. Page 50
Другие работы по теме:
School Reform: Pros and Cons
Svetlana Levanova, 512 AE SCHOOL REFORM: PROS AND CONS Essay Suddenly the whole society realized the necessity of a school reform. We clasped our hands with great surprise and exclaimed: “Why, but we have to change it!” There's no smoke without fire. If we inspect the issue more profoundly it will be clear that the idea emerged not so accidentally.
Russian Crisis Essay Research Paper The Russian
Russian Crisis Essay, Research Paper The Russian Crisis On July 13, 1998 the Managing Director of the International Monetary fund (IMF), Michael Camdessus said, The IMF team currently in Moscow has reached an agreement with the Government of Russia on a major strengthening of Russian economic programs ( IMF Board ).
Chechnya Essay Research Paper CHECHNYAChechnya is an
Chechnya Essay, Research Paper CHECHNYA Chechnya is an independent republic located in the middle of the Caucasus Mountains. This land has always belonged to the Shemite people, decedents of the Shem. The neighboring republics all around them are very similar ethnically.
Ivan The Terrible Essay Research Paper Ivan
Ivan The Terrible Essay, Research Paper Ivan the Terrible was the first czar of russia. He was a very cruel ruler.His father and mother died shortley after his birth.So his grand father Ivan The Great Took him in as a son. He was very cruel to ivan,
Archudukes
… Wars In Europe Got A + Essay, Research Paper -Archduke Francis Ferdinardo of Austia Hungarywas killed in Sarajero,bosnia -The blackhand-wanted bosnia to be part of Serbia-not Austria Hungary. Serbia
Freedom Bound Essay Research Paper In his
Freedom Bound Essay, Research Paper In his book, Freedom Bound, Robert Weisbrot argues that the civil rights movement is interwoven with American political reform of the time, and furthermore, that “the black quest for justice and the national crusade for a ‘Great Society’ are best understood in relation to each other” (Weisbrot xiv).
The Fall Of Tsarism Essay Research Paper
It was clear by this stage, that it needed a revolution in order to reform the Russian autocratic Tsarist system.? ????? I would therefore conclude that it is extremely clear that the autocratic system
China Reforms Essay Research Paper Section II1
China Reforms Essay, Research Paper Section II 1.) There have been numerous attempts to reform China in the late 19th century to build up China’s strength and make it a world power once again. There have been many prestigious intellectuals and organizations that have attempted to do this. One of these intellectuals who had a great influence on other reformers was Yan Fu.
Lenin Essay Research Paper lenin was born
Lenin Essay, Research Paper lenin was born 400 miles east of moscow, his background was highly privilaged. his father was a school inspector and in the army and his mother was the daughter of a docter. the first phase of lenins life was spent in political exile in siberia. his second phase in adult life was when he returned to russia following the collapse of tzarism. in october 1917 he became head of the russian government. his work eventually destroyed his health. during the final period of his life he was incapable of political activity. . lenin was a commited marxist who was against the old tzarism.
Reform Party Essay Research Paper A Reform
Reform Party Essay, Research Paper A Reform is a way of changing society. During the 1880?s and 90?s many people had different opinions on reform and how society was to be changed. This was the ending of the war and people needed a brake through both everyday life and politics. Since there were so many people there were different arguments about how the reforms should be.
German Exports To Rusia Essay Research Paper
German Oct exports to U.S., Russia, UK rise FRANKFURT, Jan 7 (Reuters) – German exports to North America, Japan, Great Britain and Russia rose significantly in October last year,
Anna Karenina By Leo Tolstoy
(1828 – 1910) Essay, Research Paper Leo Tolstoy is considered one of Russia’s greatest nineteenth-century novelists, an honor he shares with Dostoievsky.
Stalinism 2 Essay Research Paper Stalinism To
Stalinism 2 Essay, Research Paper Stalinism. To mention this term, this policy, is to evoke panic and fright in almost all Russians. Stalin rose to become the dictator of Russia in 1929, and remained in that position until 1953. He morphed the Soviet Union from what was once one of the world’s most underdeveloped countries to one of the greatest in industrialization. “Socialism in one country” was his policy, and it quickly became a ubiquitous law.
American Third Parties Essay Research Paper Americas
American Third Parties Essay, Research Paper America?s Third Parties ? which one is biggest? August, 1999 America currently has five nationally organized third parties: Reform, Libertarian, Green, Constitution (U.S. Taxpayers), and Natural Law. Each of these five parties has received 100,000 votes for at least one of its candidates in the past 20 years.
Causes Of Change In The Russian System
Of Government 1800-1917 Essay, Research Paper “Nothing short of war could have any impact of the Russian system of government.” How accurate is this of the Tsarist system of government from 1800-1917. The Russian Tsarist system under the Romanovs was extremely resistant to change in all forms. Reforms were brought in only to preserve and little improvement resulted from these reforms.
Stalingrad Essay Research Paper Stalingrad was a
Stalingrad Essay, Research Paper Stalingrad was a key city in Russia s defenses and Germany s aspirations of conquering eastern Europe. As a port city on the Volga, Stalingrad s location proved to be important during World War II. Its heavy industry gave Germany a strong motive for invading the city. Stalingrad also was well known as an important center of communication.
Presidency 2 Essay Research Paper There are
Presidency 2 Essay, Research Paper There are currently eight candidates running for the United States Presidency. Even though there are eight running, there are only two that are most likely to win. These two are Vice President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush. The election all depends on what the candidates debate about and where they stand on the issues.
LongTerm Cause Of The Russian Revolution Essay
, Research Paper In 1812 Czar Alexander the First had sworn an oath that Russia would never make peace as long as an enemy stood on Russian soil. Little did he know that not much more than a century later the enemy was those who were native to the Russian soil-the people. The Russian Revolution was an event that shaped the rest of the 20th century worldwide.
The Cause Of Conflict Essay Research Paper
The Cause of Conflict Spinoza explained (p.3) ?violence by reference to human imperfection…and logically, the end of conflict must depend on the reform of man?. Spinoza believes that because man does not cooperate to achieve harmony without self-interest and self-gain, the ultimate result is incessant quarrels and physical violence.
Economy Of Russia Essay Research Paper The
Economy Of Russia Essay, Research Paper The phase in the business cycle that Russia is in is Prosperity. Prosperity is the high point of the business cycle. The Gross Domestic
Post Soviet Russia Essay Research Paper In
Post Soviet Russia Essay, Research Paper In December of 1991, the Soviet Union disintegrated into fifteen separate countries. Its collapse was hailed by the west as a victory for freedom, a triumph of democracy over totalitarianism, and evidence of the superiority of capitalism over socialism. It was a relief for many to watch the Soviet Union brake down, finally bringing the cold world to an end.
Boris Pasternak Essay Research Paper Boris Pasternak
Boris Pasternak Essay, Research Paper Boris Pasternak was born in 1890 in Russia. He would alwayes stand up for what he believed in. Boris was a wise man that did not stand up for the issues the communists pushed on him during his day. This made him a target of the Russian government. The government was arresting people like him quite often but still he did not bend to write their propaganda.
Ww1 Essay Research Paper The Causes and
Ww1 Essay, Research Paper The Causes and Effects of World War I? Omar Nova Home Room 306 World History/English 1 Mrs. Denicola/Mrs. Fisk April 11, 2000 Thesis Statement:
Executive Powers Essay Research Paper Executive Powers
Executive Powers Essay, Research Paper Executive Powers Russia v. Japan Brian Mitchard May 8, 2000 MW 3:30-4:45 Summary of Powers Within the constitution of a nation, powers are delegated to certain institutions of that nation?s government. Although in many cases similar, nations can vary drastically when defining the organizational structure from which they operate.
Campaign Finance Reform Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Finance Reform Essay, Research Paper Campaign Finance Reform: Soft Money One of the key issues facing this year?s Presidential Campaign is campaign finance reform. More specifically, whether or not to ban soft
Catherine II And Stalin Essay Research Paper
Catherine II (the Great) and Joseph Stalin were both leaders of Russia that demonstrated an awareness of the West. They tried to emulate some of the elements of the West while purposely neglecting others. For
Russia Revolution Essay Research Paper The Russia
Russia Revolution Essay, Research Paper The Russia Revolution was a true political revolution. By this I mean there was a fundamental change in the way leaders came into power and in the goals for the country. In theory, leadership changed from a monarchy to socialism. The goals for the country changed from ownership and control of wealth was by few to control by the proletariat (the workers).
Yellow Journalism Essay Research Paper Did Boris
Yellow Journalism Essay, Research Paper Did Boris Yeltsin really resign? The people of Russia were led to believe that on New Years Day, January 1st, President Boris Yeltsin suspiciously and suddenly resigned. Some people claim he was to old and to senile to finish his presidential term, others claim he was too sick, deathly sick, others claim he was just fed up with the horrible condition of the Russian Government.
Peter The Great Essay Research Paper Peter
Peter The Great Essay, Research Paper Peter the Great or Peter I, czar of Russia, reigned from (1672-1725). In many ways he bettered the country of Russia, but in other ways he hurt Russia. The ways in which bettered the country outweighs the bad
Peter The Great And Catherine The Great
Essay, Research Paper Peter was the first of the Romanov Czars. He ruled Russia for about 40 years. Peter?s most important contribution to Russia is his trying to westernize and modernize his country. He did that by traveling through Europe, and by that, learning new ideas and ways to modernize his country.
Three EmperorsS League Essay Research Paper 1
Three Emperors?S League Essay, Research Paper 1. Three Emperors?s League: In 1873 this league linked the monarchs of Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia in an alliance against racial movements.
Alexander Iii Essay Research Paper Considered Russia
Alexander Iii Essay, Research Paper Considered Russia s last true autocrat, Alexander III was the epitome of what a Russian Tsar was supposed to be. Forceful, formidable, fiercely patriotic, and at 6 4 towered over his fellow countrymen. He was the embodiment of the fabled Russian bear. He came to power at a critical point in Imperial Russian History.