Reconstruction 2 Essay, Research Paper
Reconstruction
Following the Civil War, a movement called Reconstruction took place, which lasted from
1865 until 1877. During this movement, the former states of Confederacy were ruled by the federal government or
by local Republican governments.
There were many expectations of Reconstruction. Actually, these expectations seemed more like
goals. These goals were bettering the relationship between different races; and making changes in the areas of
politics, social life, and economics.
After the war, historians generally described Reconstruction as a total failure that had hurt every
American, including Northerners, Southerners, whites, and blacks. Going by this interpretation, Congress was
being ruled by radical Republicans, and imposed military rule upon the states of the South. The historical
profession was ruled by the picture of Reconstruction. Northern and Southern white historians wrote about the
movement with two main issues in mind. The first issue was that the South had the ability to solve its own
problems without the help or interference of the federal government. The second main topic discussed was about
former slaves who were thought to be incapable of running a government.
Many people had their own views and ideas about the Reconstruction era. Two particular people were
Eric Foner and Thomas Holt. Both of these men were professors of history.
Eric Foner thought of Reconstruction as a “splendid failure.” He believed Reconstruction gave African
Americans in the South a picture of a free society in which they would be a part of ; but it was only a temporary
picture. This temporary vision was of how a free society could look, but not how it actually was at that time.
Foner argued in his writings that Reconstruction gave blacks an opportunity to strengthen their family ties. In this,
Foner shows why he thought Reconstruction had benefits for people.
Foner wrote about two black historians and their views on Reconstruction. In his writings, he spoke of
Thomas Holt and Nell Painter. He said they insisted that “Reconstruction was not simply a matter of black and
white.” Foner argued back that conflicts erupting inside the black community, no less than division amongst
whites, molded Reconstruction politics. In this, Foner supports why he disagrees with Painter and Holt.
Due to what has been found in the past twenty years, Foner wrote about the idea of portraying
Reconstruction in a different was. Viewing it as “an episode in a prolonged historical process,” rather than “a
specific time period, bounded by the years 1865 and 1877.”
In Foners writings, he talks about the old interpretation of Reconstruction. He said that “Reconstruction
had been a time of real progress and its failure a lost opportunity for the South and the nation.” I think this shows
that Foner recognizes that the movement wasn’t one hundred percent perfect and beneficial.
Throughout his writings of “The New View of Reconstruction,” Foner argues for his ideas and views by
stating why he feels the way he does about the issue. Although Reconstruction had not accomplished radical
goals, Eric Foner still believed the movement to be a “splendid failure.”
Thomas Holt had a different viewpoint on Reconstruction than Eric Foner. Holt felt that Reconstruction
was a political failure, but he did acknowledge some successes it had, like: the establishment of a public
education system, and the general process of democratizing a state. In this, Holt gave the Reconstruction
movement a little bit of credit.
Holt did not agree with Foner’s label, a “splendid failure”, on Reconstruction. Holt supported his
viewpoint in his writings of “Black Leaders and Black Labor: An Unexpected Failure”. Holt felt that blacks were
consigned to a special group in America’s class society. Politically, he felt they were reduced to nothing.
Economically, he felt they had to deal with poverty, convict lease, debts, and they had to sell their labor in a
buyer’s market.
Holt also stated that blacks were not the only ones who had to bear this oppression. There were other people in
other states who were also suffering. In this, Holt recognizes that there wasn’t just one unparticular group
suffering.
In Holt’s eyes, blacks were politically blocked out and had no say what so ever. He felt that
Reconstruction failed to produce “critical economic reforms for working-class blacks because of social and
cultural divisions within the black community.”
At first, I leaned towards agreeing with Foner. After reading Thomas Holt’s article, I changed my
viewpoint. I came to the conclusion that I don’t agree with Reconstruction, and the things that it did to the people
of society. Many people suffered in many ways. People suffered politically, socially, economically, and
financially. Blacks struggled during the Reconstruction era to get further ahead, and they did. They gained
ownership of a region. Unfortunately, that all ended in 1877, when Southern white Democrats took their region
back from “Negro rule.”
I can’t even imagine how the blacks felt back then when they were in that situation. Reading about it
even makes me feel hopeless.
In December of 1876, there was an election that ended Republican hegemony in South Carolina. Two
different legislatures claimed to be the real representatives of the people. In this dispute, the economic future of
black laborers took a fatal turn. The laws that had given workers a lien on the crop of a planter were now wiped
out. This was done by the Republican Mackey House. After all, this era, this Reconstruction, had not been such a
“splendid failure.” In fact, it had been an unexpected failure, just as Thomas Holt said.
I think the dispute that lead to the law change, surrounding the black workers ownership of land, was
the last and final thing to convince that Reconstruction was not a great thing. In a way, I feel that the black
workers were cheated. They were given something they had always hoped for, and then it was taken away right
from under their noses. This incident probably left the blacks wondering when that great day would come when
they had ownership of something, something that was just their that no one could touch or have control of.
I think this did give the blacks a false vision of a society they had hoped for. If things like this happened
to them, how would they ever gain hope? This entire situation seems like a big tease to the blacks.
Furthermore, I think that Reconstruction shouldn’t have even taken place, and maybe then, the blacks
would have had more faith and hope in their future.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
The Effects Of Reconstruction Essay Research Paper
The affects of the Civil War, and the actions that led to the war were very detrimental to the United States. The nation was not in good shape, and was all divided up. President Abraham Lincoln saw this division, and wanted to reconstruct the nation, by restoring national unity. Reconstruction did not only restore national unity, but more importantly it helped the blacks gain the personal rights that they deserved.
Kkk Essay Research Paper Despite the civil
Kkk Essay, Research Paper Despite the civil rights amendments being passed over 40 years ago, racism continues to thrive in America. A good example of this is the southern-based organization called the Ku Klux Klan. Immediately following the Civil War, this group came about during the Reconstruction Era.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper The Reconstruction Era
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper The Reconstruction Era The Civil War was one of the bloodiest wars in American history. Its damage to America was profound. It tore at the very fiber of America itself. The Reconstruction Era however was as damaging to America as the Civil War itself. Its damage has its roots in the reasons America went to civil war.
Socrates Essay Research Paper He was heir
Socrates Essay, Research Paper He was heir to the greatest empire on earth?but did not know it. Under his brilliant leadership, Rome was restored to unity and order after years of civil war. Augustus was Julius Caesar`s grand nephew and adopted son, and unbeknownst to him, Caesar had decreed that on his death, Augustus should succeed him as Consul of Rome.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
Birth Of A Nation Essay Research Paper
How the South was portrayed and why the Civil War was a tragedy There are two sides told in every story. In D.L. Griffin s Birth of a Nation the story is told through the eyes of two families, the Camerons who are from the south and the Stoneman s who reside in the north. The notion of this film was pro-south during the Civil War and the Reconstruction Period and was such a tragedy because war isn t a glorious.
Reconstruction Era Essay Research Paper The period
Reconstruction Era Essay, Research Paper The period, in which the United States began to rebuild and unify the Union from 1865 to 1877, was known as Reconstruction. Much of the early work of it dealt with the legal questions of bringing the defeated states back into the Union. Presidents Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson, and also the members of Congress, each had different plans of how Reconstruction should be handled.
To What Extent Was The Reconstruction Period
A Success With Respect To Black Americans? Essay, Research Paper The Reconstruction period was not as successful as most people think it was with regards to African Americans. Though some factors may be seen as more successful then others, but overall the Reconstruction period (with respect to African Americans) was very unsuccessful.
Reconstruction Era Essay Research Paper Reconstruction EraThe
Reconstruction Era Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Era The Reconstruction period can be defined as the time after the Civil War when states were debating on what to do with a partially seceded nation. The Union, known as the North, wanted to come to agreements with the Confederacy, or the south, on how to successfully bring the states together again as one nation.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Greg TaylorThe period
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Greg Taylor The period that occurred following the Civil War is known as Reconstruction. In the South, during this period of time many people suffered. There was great amount of property damage done to such things as farms, factories and railroads. Many other things were destroyed that citizens depended upon to keep their economy strong.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper English 102Jeff StaytonSection
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper English 102 Jeff Stayton Section 39 February 15, 2000 Why Reconstruction failed The reconstruction of the south was the period during and after the Civil War where several different groups in the government tried to solve the economic, political, and social problems that arose as a result of the Civil War.
After Reconstruction Essay Research Paper After the
After Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper After the Reconstruction There were several factors that lead to the Northern Republicans abandoning Reconstruction. Some of the factors were due to an increase of racial violence, an economic depression, and the corruption of the Republican government. Racial violence was a key factor due to Southern Democrats resorting in trying to intimidate by abuse of the African Americans and also poor whites.
Success Of Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Reconstruction
Success Of Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction was the time period following the Civil War, which lasted from 1865 to 1877, in which the United States began to rebuild. The term can also refer to the process the federal government used to readmit the defeated Confederate states to the Union.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Reconstruction SelfdestructionAfter the
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Self-destruction After the Civil War racism was widespread throughout the south even though there was much effort by the North in creating equality throughout the newly reformed nation. Even though Reconstruction fell far short of its intended goals, the nation was reunited in the governmental sense and many laws were enacted in respects to the equality of blacks.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper ReconstructionReconstruction the period
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction Reconstruction, the period that followed the Civil War, is perhaps the most controversial era in American history. Reconstruction witnessed major changes in America’s political life. At the national level, new laws and constitutional amendments permanently altered the federal system and the nature of American citizenship.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Reconstruction took place
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Reconstruction took place after the end of the civil war, and it also was impacted by social, economic, and political. The main reason for reconstruction was to put the union back together and free the slaves once and for all. Reconstruction took three eras to be completed.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper The ReconstructionThe Reconstruction
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper The Reconstruction The Reconstruction held out the promise to rectify racial injustices in America. The Reconstruction, rising out of the Civil War had as its goals equality for blacks in voting, politics, and use of public services. Even though movement, was born of high hopes it failed in bringing about their goals.
My Fuck Life Essay Research Paper Each
My Fuck Life Essay, Research Paper Each piece was marked with four numbers: the first indicated which span; the second, noted which row of stones; and the last two indicated which position in that
Abraham Lincoln 2 Essay Research Paper Abraham
Abraham Lincoln 2 Essay, Research Paper Abraham Lincoln Abraham Lincoln: a true American that made the United States a more unified nation, and a more peaceful place to be. Lincoln was a man of great wisdom and determination, and these traits are what made him into one of the greatest peacemakers of the time.
Recon 2 Essay Research Paper RECONSTUCTION PAPER
Recon 2 Essay, Research Paper RECONSTUCTION PAPER The reconstruction period was a time of recovery for the country as a whole. To heal the deep wounds of the civil war. The loss of cities, towns, homes, and family members. Whole cities were burned level, and widows were left scattered all over the country with a small pile of smoking rubble left as their houses.
Ida B Wells
’ Campaign Essay, Research Paper Ida B. Wells’ Campaign The anti-lynching campaign of Ida B. Wells took place in the post-Reconstruction era. By the end of the Civil War, slavery was abolished but there was a problem. No one knew what to do with all the ex-slaves. They didn t know how to put them into the existing society.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Breast Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Postmastectomy breast
Breast Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Post-mastectomy breast reconstruction is not a simple procedure. Reconstruction of a breast is done when the natural breast has to be removed due to cancer or other diseases. Breast removal is referred to as mastectomy. The best candidates are women whose cancer has been eliminated by breast removal.
Kkk Essay Research Paper KKK The History
Kkk Essay, Research Paper The History of the Ku Klux KlanThe Ku Klux Klan (KKK) is one of America’s oldest and most feared groups.Driven by the dream of a world with only one master race, the KKK often usesviolence and moves above the law to promote their cause. They didn’t start ofviolent, or to promote white supremacy.
The Kkk Essay Research Paper The KKK
The Kkk Essay, Research Paper The KKK is one of the oldest, largest Whites’ civil rights organizations. Many people are completely against the KKK but I personally am a neutral person. I don’t think that all their actions are reasonable but some are, and some of the statements they make are very reasonable.
Reconstruction Essay Research Paper Before the Civil
Reconstruction Essay, Research Paper Before the Civil war most blacks were considered slaves. As slaves they had no personal rights. After the war, a lot of things changed for the blacks. The process, which helped these blacks to gain rights, was called Reconstruction.
Struggle For Blacks Rights After Civil War
Essay, Research Paper After the Civil War and the emancipation proclamation by lincoln the slaves of america were free. This was a huge step in making our country truly free to all people. The reconstruction of the south did not however work out smoothly for the freed slaves. There were many road blocks along the way such as the “Black Codes”, the Plessy vs.