Materialism Vs Dualism Essay, Research Paper
Materialism vs. Dualism
There is no doubt that we are physical beings, but there is a question as to where our consciousness comes from. Can this consciousness come from a completely physical make up or do we have another non-physical entity? Does consciousness come from a physical brain or a non-physical mind? The two competing views of this question are materialism and dualism. Materialism views the world as being made up of only physical things, while dualism believes that everything has a physical and non-physical make up.
Dualism claims that the mind is separate from the body. This can be broken down into substance dualism and property dualism. Substance dualism, introduced by Ren Descartes, states that the mind is a separate non-physical entity. Descartes believed that people have a physical body and brain and also a non-physical mind. This mind is where all consciousness comes from. Descartes claimed that if you could build an automaton of a monkey, the automaton and the real monkey would be indistinguishable. However, if you built an automaton of a human, the human and the automaton would be different. I think this statement in essence is true. I do not think that an automaton of a human would think and feel as a human being would.
The other view of dualism is property dualism. Property dualism is based on the theory that all things are physical but some physical things also have non-physical properties. Thomas Nagel explained in his manuscript, “What is it like to be a bat,” that while a person could know everything about a bat physically he still would not know subjectively what it is like to be bat. If this were true, and the total experience of being a bat could not be reduced to the physical make up of the bat, then materialism must be false. If a bat can not be explained entirely by physical descriptions then there must be something more to a bat than its physical make up. While these theories show that there is a significant difference between a conscious and an unconscious being, neither of these theories address the issue of how a non-physical mind can control a physical brain. It seems rather impossible for a non-physical entity to interact and control a physical entity. Another issue with dualism is what keeps a particular person’s mind attached to that person. If a mind is a separate entity from a brain, and it is not bound by any physical means, then it seems possible that a certain mind could take control of another brain.
Materialism is based on the idea that everything is made up of only physical things. There is no difference between the mind and the brain; they are one in the same. One supporter of this belief system is Paul Churchland. Churchland believes that all of our thoughts and experiences can be understood physically if we were to all learn neuroscience. According to Churchland our feelings and experiences can be explained by our brain states. There is not an objective and a subjective view of our experiences, but one physical description for both. The problem with this idea is that something seems to be left out when describing our thoughts and feelings by describing brain states. Nagel explained that there is a difference between the physical act of something and the experience of that act. For example, in his bat analogy Nagel argues that we can not know what it is like to be a bat even though we may know everything about a bat physically. Churchland, however, argues that since we do not know everything about a bat we do not know what it would like to be a bat. This argument still leaves a sense of something being left out. It seems to me that there is more to our thoughts and emotions than just certain physical brain states.
Another materialist, Richard Dawkins, claims that humans are merely survival machines for their genes. According to Dawkins, molecules capable of making copies of itself, which Dawkins refers to as a replicator, created defense mechanisms to protect itself. These defense mechanisms eventually evolved into human beings. In Dawkins view humans are merely the protectors of our genes. This theory makes no distinction between a conscious being and an unconscious being. It leaves the question, “At what point does an organism become conscious?”. Does an organism suddenly become conscious after it has attained a certain level of complexity, or are even the most basic of organisms conscious? Dawkins claims that this argument is of no real importance, but I think it is rather important. Is it possible that the right combination of unconscious material can make conscious material? If all organisms are conscious, then even the most basic of animal life and even plant life is really conscious. This seems quite impossible.
The answer to the question as to which theory I prefer, materialism or dualism is rather difficult. Science supports the theory of materialism much more than dualism, but dualism is better at explaining the difference between us and other organisms. I would have to say, despite the scientific evidence, that I prefer dualism over materialism. It is difficult to overlook the scientific evidence of materialism, but harder still to imagine that I am really not significantly different from a slug. It just seems to me that materialism just can not explain why there is such a difference between humans and other organisms.
Другие работы по теме:
The Identity Theory Essay Research Paper The
The Identity Theory Essay, Research Paper The identity theory, also known as reductive materialism, is one of the views Churchland uses to describe mind-brain correlation. Churchland believes that
What Does It All Mean The MindBody
Problem Essay, Research Paper Human beings have a conception of at least two different kinds of things that exist in the world, mental and physical. Any of us could generate a long list of obvious physical things and clear cases of psychological things. And we assume that both of these types of things, mental phenomena and physical phenomena, are part of our world.
Hate Literature Essay Research Paper Hate literaturematerialism
Hate Literature Essay, Research Paper Hate literature/materialism currently exists on the internet, and is expanding at a high rate, causing disturbance to society. Although the internet is known to be a free base to express opinions, thoughts, and general information, exploiting that particular use can be rather dangerous, especially when offending one’s culture.
The Great Gatsby Essay Research Paper Characters
The Great Gatsby Essay, Research Paper Characters in books can reveal the author feeling toward the world. In TheGreat Gatsby Fitzgerald suggested the moral decline of the period inAmerica history through the interpersonal relationships among hischaracters. The book indicates the worthlessness of materialism, thefutile quest of Myrtle and Gatsby, and how America’s moral values haddiminished.
Karl Marx Essay Research Paper 181883 German
Karl Marx Essay, Research Paper 1818-83, German social philosopher and revolutionary; with Friedrich Engels, a founder of modern Socialism and Communism. The son of a lawyer, he studied
Age Of Reason Essay Research Paper The
Age Of Reason Essay, Research Paper The age of reason was a time of Empiricism and of Materialism, which brought out philosophers like John Locke and George Berkeley as well as authors like Swift and Pope. These philosophers and authors belong to the Age of Reason because of their use of anti-emotional thought and the idea of Occam’s razor.
Intro To Philosophy Essay Research Paper Phil
Intro To Philosophy Essay, Research Paper Phil or Sophie? In philosophy, there are three main worldviews: Scientific Materialism, Spiritualism and Idealism/Realism/Rationalism. Scientific materialism is holds much in what we observe. What we hear, see, feel, taste, and smell, is what s real. It is totally physical.
Modern Science And Materialism Essay Research Paper
Modern Science and materialism What is real? This question has puzzled many what is really real or what is reality. Reality as I shall explain is one that is according to materialism and proven by science. Materialism is defined, as the metaphysical view holding that matter alone is real. This is what Hugh Elliot proves in his argument Modern Science and Materialism.
Marxism And The Revolution Essay Essay Research
Paper Marxism and the Revolution Essay Two important ideal s in Marx s ideas were the philosophies of Materialism and Dialectics. Materialism in philosophy is the recognition that the material word, the world we can see, hear, feel and touch is the only real world. Therefore it is logical to base our
Reconstructing The American Dream Essay Research Paper
Reconstructing the American DreamThere is an old adage which says, “The root of all evil is money.” This, however, is not true in America. In America, money is not the problem, the love of money, or materialism, is the problem. Materialism is at the core of our American dream. We grow up learning that success is rooted in material wealth and power.
Immoral Materialism Essay Research Paper Immoral Materialism
Immoral Materialism Essay, Research Paper Immoral Materialism The desire to be rich is part of every American s dream, but does one change when one becomes rich? Can one be happy and wealthy? Just as the characters in the novel The Great Gatsby, written by Scott Fitzgerald, people believe that money will buy them a happy life.
Themes Materialism Essay Research Paper In the
Themes: Materialism Essay, Research Paper In the novel, The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald successfully portrays that materialism as the corrupt source of the society. Like Fitzgerald, Jay Gatsby is a sensitive young man who idolizes wealth and luxury, and falls in love with a beautiful young woman while stationed at a military camp in the South.
Defending Materialism Essay Research Paper Defending MaterialismDualism
Defending Materialism Essay, Research Paper Defending Materialism Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the world is explicable only as a world composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body.
The Great Gatsby And The Pursuit Of
The American Dream Essay, Research Paper Gatsby s Pursuit of the American Dream The American Dream means that by persistently working hard, one can achieve success; this is in contrast to other countries where the immigrants came from, in which one was either born into money and privilege or not, and if you weren t, there was no way of achieving this success.
Materialism In Society Essay Research Paper Effects
Materialism In Society Essay, Research Paper Effects of the Media’s Materialistic Influence on Society If one were to take a survey of the American people concerning what they think they need most in life, the results would be very centered in materialistic values. The media’s materialistic influence on American society, fueled by corporations’ need to profit from consumerism, has created a society full of problems.
The Great Gatsby 4 Essay Research
Paper Characters in books can reveal the authors feeling toward the world. In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald suggested the moral decline of the period in America history through the interpersonal relationships among his characters. The book indicates the worthlessness of materialism, the futile quest of Myrtle and Gatsby, and how America’s moral values had diminished.
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
The Corruption Of The American Dream Essay
, Research Paper Fitzgerald criticized the American Dream in The Great Gatsby through Gatsby and Wilson, and symbols such as Gatsby s car. The American Dream is the pursuit of materialism, centralism, and idealized love. Gatsby s character partially fulfilled the American Dream, but kept on pushing for the final part of the dream, even though he had lots of money, he had to get back his true love, Daisy.
SalingerS A Perfect Day For Bananafish Essay
, Research Paper The characters in Salinger’s “A Perfect Day for Bananafish” seem to exist in opposite worlds. On one hand, Salinger creates Muriel to represent materialism and superficiality and on the other hand, he creates Sybil to provide justification of the child-like innocence rarely found in society.
Consciousness Essay Research Paper The relation of
Consciousness Essay, Research Paper The relation of consciousness to the material world is puzzle, which has its origin in dualism, a philosophy of mind which posits their fundamental separation. Dualism, in turn, has its roots in folk wisdom. The belief that humans are more than bodies and that there is something in human nature that survives bodily death has its origins in prehistory; it becomes explicit in the mythology of Ancient Egypt and Assyria and was formulated into a philosophical position in the Platonic thought of Ancient Greece.
The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism And Materialism
Essay, Research Paper The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism I am faced with the philosophical task of defending either dualism or materialism, depending on which one is most attractive to me. So either I support the theory of dualism, which is the belief that there is both a physical and a spiritual state, or I believe in materialism, which is the belief that everything that exists is material or physical.
Affluenza Essay Research Paper Affluenza is the
Affluenza Essay, Research Paper Affluenza is the unhappy condition of overload debt, anxiety and waste resulting from the dogged pursuit of more, and unfortunately it is taking the nation by storm. Greed and materialism plant the seed to this dreaded disease that effects people of all classes. Today’s society has imprinted the idea of “buy more” into our heads through every form of media possible.
Thoreau Essay Research Paper Jerry PetercuskieEnglish 20103Dr
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Jerry Petercuskie English 201-03 Dr. E. Brinkley November 27, 1996 THOREAU AS A PROPHET Thoreau was a simple man that believed in having only the basic necessities in life. Thoreau lived a life of simplicity at Walden Pond. In Walden, Thoreau gives a background of his life and some life experiences that he has encountered.
American Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper American TranscendentalismTranscendentalism
American Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper American Transcendentalism Transcendentalism as espoused by Ralph Waldo Emerson is essen tially an idealist philosophy, derived from Kant’s concept of the Tran scendental and opposed to the skepticism of Locke and the Empiricists. In the essay The Transcendentalist, Emerson wrote, “[Kant showed] that there was a very important class of ideas or imperative forms, which do not come by experience, but through which experience was acquired; that these were intuitions of the mind itself; and he denominated them Tran scendental forms.”1 According to Emerson’s understanding of Kant, Transcendentalism becomes a union of solipsism, under which the only verifiable reality is thought to be the self, and materialism, under which the only verifiable reality is the quantifiable external world of objects and sense data.
A Perfect Day For Bananafish Essay Research
Paper Picture walking into a hotel room and finding a man dead on a bed. Upon closer inspection it becomes obvious that he has supposedly taken his own life with the gun that lay beside him. In talking to his wife who was asleep on the bed next to him when this incident occurred, it is learned that he just walked in the door and shot himself late the previous night.
Dualism Essay Research Paper DualismIn this paper
Dualism Essay, Research Paper Dualism In this paper I will be discussing the philosophical perspective of Cartesian Dualism. To draw upon reliable sources my information will be base from the textbooks Doing Philosophy as well as the Unfortunate Dualist found in the anthology Mind s I. I will make an attempt to show that Smullyan s theories based on anti-dualism do not hold weight in modern philosophy
The Problem With Dualism Behav Essay Research
Paper Jeff Extra Credit Assignment #1 a.1) The main hindrance for dualism is to explain how something non-physical (mind, soul) is associated with something physical (body). According to dualism, the association between the person (mind, soul) and the body is so intimate that many people falsely believe they are indistinguishable from their bodies.
Dualism Essay Research Paper Dualism
Dualism Essay, Research Paper Dualism I believe that the popular or “ghost in the machine” form of substance dualism best solves the mind body problem. My views in this area have
The World Is Too Much With Us
And The Chimney Sweeper (compare And Contrast Essay, Research Paper Poems are a particular way an author shows to the reader of what he feels and thinks about the actions of the world. In the poems ?The World is Too Much With us? and ?The Chimney Sweeper? both poets make the reader feel piety and disgust of human Nature.
Hopi Essay Research Paper The Hopi Way
Hopi Essay, Research Paper The Hopi Way The Hopi Indians are a remarkable tribe who lives on a reservation in the desert and mountains ofArizona. The word Hopi can be translated to peaceful or happy, this description is appropriate for a culturewhich lacks tenseness, competition, and materialism. The Hopi are like any other tribes in North America,the Hopi have a strong sense of “extended family”, which means attachment to other Hopi, their heritage,and ceremonies.
Daisy Does Not Love Gatsby Essay Research
Paper Daisy Does Not Love Gatsby The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald is based upon three characters involved in a love triangle. (However…meaning behind this) Daisy, a beautiful yet insecure young woman is married to Tom, but also accepts the courtship of Gatsby, her first true love. Set in the 1920s, tangled into the web of lovers are complications such as materialism, greed, adultery, and power hunger.
The Great Gatsby Essay Research Paper Haja
The Great Gatsby Essay, Research Paper Haja Turay English 3b Mrs. O?conner In the book the Great Gatsby, none but a few people had the idealistic ?American Dream?. To some characters it seems the ?American Dream, ?has replaced by materialism and greed. What does the American Dream mean? What does it stand for? If a person has achieved their American Dream how should they go about living? The American Dream is the vision to be successful and to provide from and family the best way you can.