Can intellectual advancement lead to a general regression in our existence? Both Rousseau and Virilio deal with this question, but in very different ways. Rousseau examines this question in the broadest sense, by back tracking to the origin of intellect. Virilio, on the other hand, speaks of a very specific type of intellectual advancement, namely-the invention of a long range nuclear missile. Both would agree that intellectual progression can be advantageous to the human race, but whether or not the advantages outweigh the disadvantages is questionable.
Rousseau argues that man existed in a ?natural state,? where he had basically no intellect. The ?natural man? did not speak, own property, or interact with other humans. This independent man, knew only compassion and how to survive. With intellect came evil. ?But by nature, man is good, self sufficient, compassionate to others when they do not threaten him, and incapable of pride, hatred, falsehood, and vice, society, precisely because it develops man?s faculties, which corrupts him.? ( Rousseau, p. 20)Through the birth of property, man began to calculate and think. He saw what his fellow man had that he didn?t, and became jealous. Now since man was able to see the nascent inequalities amongst each other, many evils arose. Rousseau makes it clear that mankind was better off without intellect.
Virilio point of view on the matter can be inferred. He does not feel that man is better off in this ?natural state.? He is a twentieth century writer, who feels that technology is an overall good thing, but there are some very serious repercussions from certain technological advancements. In his essay he explains the negative repercussions of a long range nuclear missile. Since this missile can reach across half of the world in an insignificant amount of time, distance begins to disappear; if an enemy can be destroyed a few thousand miles away instantly, than it doesn?t matter how far away the enemy is.
Peace, as well, is sacrificed with the creation of such a fast and destructive weapon. Virilio argues that we are never really in peaceful coexistence with the countries in the world, because any country?s major city can be destroyed in a matter of minutes. A hundred years ago, it would take a country lots of time of preparation to attack an enemy, but now with some launch codes major cities can be destroyed in under fifteen minutes. How can we ever feel at peace if there is relatively no time or distinction between peace and destruction. Virilio also believes that ?the more speed increases, the faster freedom decreases.? (Rousseau, p. 142) He uses an example of the Cuban Missile Crisis. he says that the reaction time to a missile, launched from Cuba, that the political leaders had was fifteen minutes. Today, it would be under a minute, so they had no choice but to automate the decision. We lose the freedom to have certain choices, that there is no longer any time for or room for human error.
The connection between these two writers might not be clear. Rousseau speaks of intellect in general, an Virilio speaks of certain technological advances ,but they both question the overall benefits of certain revolutions that come along with the intellectual advances. Even though they may not agree on whether or not a ?natural state? of man was better, they both feel that there are serious problems with intellectual advances.
If we really examine our lives, are we better off with all this technology and intellect than man in his ?natural state?? Yeah, sure we have air-conditioning, better means to travel, longer life expectancy, and much more. At the same time we, have more pollution, more diseases, and more crime. Rousseau compares the ?natural state? of man with animals because that is the closest thing to it that he can observe. He makes an excellent point when he says do you ever see an animal commit suicide? Has all these advances made the human race happier?
Both the two of these writers, one might think that along with intellect comes, basically all vices in the world, a decrease in freedom and peace, but that?s not the end of the story. Even Rousseau acknowledges the benefits of advances of the human mind. ?I admit, however, that the evil is not as great as it could have become. By placing healthful herbs beside various harmful plants, and by placing within several injurious animals, the antidote for their wounds, eternal providence has taught sovereigns, who are its ministers to imitate its wisdom.? (Rousseau, p. 59) Even though he does acknowledge the benefits, he still feels overall man is in a worse state than that of the natural. ?But here the effect is certain, the depravity of our souls have been corrupted in proportion to the advancements of our sciences and arts toward perfection. ?(Rousseau, p. 39)
Virilio and Rousseau make it clear that any advance is the human mind leads to a radically different way of life than before. It can lead man out of a natural and independent state, to a world where all men are interdependent, and collectively conquer nature?s obstacles. It can transform a world once perceived as enormous to contract by the ?juxtaposition of every locality, all matter.? (Virilio, p. 136) Along with these revolutions come new rules. How man is to deal with these revolutions, is a great challenge.
The human mind has great capabilities attached with great responsibilities. With intellect man can kill, but man can also heal. The choice is ours what we make of our powers. Rousseau could be right that we entered a world of vices, but we also entered a world of happiness. The natural man knew nothing of sadness or happiness. With these advances comes a choice to better our lives or not. I believe that intellect has added meaning to our lives, and technology has bettered our lives, but that doesn?t matter. What matters is we have the power to better our lives through our minds, and use our ?developed faculties? to transcend the ?natural state.?
Другие работы по теме:
Power Essay Research Paper Power is as
Power Essay, Research Paper Power is, as anyone will tell you, a tantalizing addiction. The natural human craving for power derives from the simple ideals of a genuflecting mass of humanity; bowing, scraping, praising and carrying out one?s every whim. The sheer exhilaration of controlling, manipulating, and yes, even hurting someone is almost too much for out feeble minds to overcome.
Creative Writing A Murder On The Eighth
Night Was Caused By An Old Mans “evil” Eye Essay, Research Paper Creative Writing: A Murder on The Eighth Night Was Caused By an Old Mans “evil” By Oscar Villa______
Sonnet About Death Essay Research Paper Death
Sonnet About Death Essay, Research Paper Death is full of sorrow and surprise Sooner or later it comes at anytime. Even though I do not remember my demise In my hearts I still remember my greatest crime.
Tuesdays With Morrie Essay Research Paper This
Tuesdays With Morrie Essay, Research Paper This book is an intriguing description of an old mans battle with death. More specifically that man is suffering from Lou Gehrig?s disease or amyotrophic
Poseidon Essay Research Paper The greatest god
Poseidon Essay, Research Paper The greatest god ever? This is a very good question but an obvious one to. Of course its Poseidon ?me? which I tell everyone. My name is Poseidon god of the seas and creator of the trident and the horse. I?m the borther of Zeus, Ares, Hera, Demeter, Hestia and son of Cronos and Rheia.
Sexually Transmited Disease Essay Research Paper The
Sexually Transmited Disease Essay, Research Paper The world today has slowly come to a very scary time. We have been plagued with a number of diseases, which can be acquired with the greatest of ease. As immune as one may think they are to the sexually transmitted diseases, there is nothing one can do or pay for that would take away what could end up being a part of ones life forever.
Tempest And Othello Essay Research Paper TOPIC
Tempest And Othello Essay, Research Paper TOPIC 3 The central issue depicted in both plays The Tempest and Othello is about money. Money in substantial amounts can represent great power and strength over the ruling nation. It plays a major role in our everyday society and one that is fully illustrated in both of Shakespeare’s play.
Utiliatariasm And Its Authors Essay Research Paper
Utilitarianism is the principle idea for the greatest happiness for the greatest numbers. In other words, maximize the pleasure while minimizing the pain. One such philosopher and believer of Utilitarianism is Jeremy Bentham, who lived from 1748 until 1832. He believed that there should be a moral system, and that it should do two things.
Macbeth And Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth And Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth by William Shakespeare tells the story of how one mans love of power leads him to murder and madness. Macbeth is a great soldier, a man that is fit
Poem Du Fu Essay Research Paper It
Poem: Du Fu Essay, Research Paper It is often contended that the greatest and most important works of Chinese poetry was produced during the Tang dynasty. Many critics consider Du Fu to be the greatest Chinese poet during the dynasty and quite possibly of all time. His unique style and mastery of Chinese language is unparalleled.
Jordan And Magic Essay Research Paper Greatest
Jordan And Magic Essay, Research Paper Greatest Guard There are many athletes that people consider to be the greatest guard in NBA history but, none of them compare to these two, Magic Johnson and Michael Jordan.
Athenians Vs Spatans Essay Research Paper Through
Athenians Vs. Spatans Essay, Research Paper Through out history there has been a great deal of great societies to rise and fall from power and fame. Two of the greatest societies still studied to this day are the Athenians and the Spartans. Both societies differ and many different ways but they where both very alike.
Socrates Essay Research Paper He was heir
Socrates Essay, Research Paper He was heir to the greatest empire on earth?but did not know it. Under his brilliant leadership, Rome was restored to unity and order after years of civil war. Augustus was Julius Caesar`s grand nephew and adopted son, and unbeknownst to him, Caesar had decreed that on his death, Augustus should succeed him as Consul of Rome.
Phidias Essay Research Paper Phidias
Phidias Essay, Research Paper Phidias Phidias is often considered one of the greatest ancient Greek sculpturs. As an Anthenian sculptor, he worked primarily in bronze or in gold and ivory,
Creative Poem Essay Research Paper Hope you
Creative Poem Essay, Research Paper Hope you are enjoying the Day! To have a friend, you must be a friend, Starting with yourself. The greatest hunger a person has is to be needed.
The TellTale Heart Essay Research Paper Paper
The Tell-Tale Heart Essay, Research Paper Paper on: The Tell-Tale Heart True! nervous very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad? The Tell-Tale Heart, a short story written by Edgar Allan Poe, is about an insane butler who plans to kill the man that he is working for. In the film adaptation the narrator shows us, the viewers, how careful and cunning he is about the way he kills the man he works for.
The Attributes Of The Christian God Essay
, Research Paper According to Christianity, the attributes of God can be organized into two categories: Physical and ethical or moral. Some terms address God’s transcendence of physical ideology, others address God’s Devine intellect and will. There are a multitude of terms from which to choose when labeling the attributes of God.
Gulf War Essay Research Paper Controversial Issues
Gulf War Essay, Research Paper Controversial Issues: Justifying the Persian Gulf War On January 16, 1991 the Gulf War had officially started, and for good reason. In August of 1990, Saddam Hussein sent armies to Kuwait, to take it over. When the United States had unwittingly given Saddam help when fighting against the Iranians, we had also given him a military that was one of the world’s largest and most lethal.
Primal Instinct Essay Research Paper In the
Primal Instinct Essay, Research Paper In the Lord of the Flies William Golding has a group of schoolboys crash on an island and become barbaric. The reason why the boys turn wild is because of their
Power Of One Essay Research Paper Power
Power Of One Essay, Research Paper Power of One I did not enjoy this movie. I thought it was poorly done, the camera shots were very basic, it was extremely predictable and ?deja vu?. Since I am no
Hamlet Fate Essay Research Paper Hamlet FateIn
Hamlet: Fate Essay, Research Paper Hamlet: Fate In our world today psychics try to predict what will happen in our futures. What may happen in the future is controlled by a power far higher than
8 Nights Essay Research Paper 8 nightsA
8 Nights Essay, Research Paper 8 nights -A murder on the eighth night was caused by an old mans “evil” eye. An unidentified old man was murdered in his own residence last night when his butler confessed to murdering him. The butler?s motive was to get rid of the old man?s “evil” looking eye.
The Godfather Essay Research Paper Violence and
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper Violence and The Godfather Throughout time there have always been people who held more power than others. There are many different methods used to both demonstrate and maintain the power which they possess. Often times violence is the method chosen to achieve these goals.
English11 Essay Research Paper Ones greatest enemy
English11 Essay, Research Paper ?One?s greatest enemy is like saying you are your worst enemy?. The book by John Knowls ?A Seprate Peace? to me the statement seems to be true because about ?one?s greatest enemy?. The two people that choose is Finny and Gene because they seem to be the best people to use.
Theseus Or Hercules Essay Research Paper Theseus
Theseus Or Hercules Essay, Research Paper Theseus or Hercules? Theseus is most worthy of emulation. He was a great hero in Athens. “Theseus was, of course bravest of the brave as all heroes are, but unlike the other heroes he was as
Tuesdays With Morrie Essay Research Paper Tuesdays
Tuesdays With Morrie Essay, Research Paper Tuesdays with Morrie Summary This book is an intriguing description of an old mans battle with death. More specifically that man is suffering from Lou Gehrig’s disease or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS); a disease that affects the neurological system. There is no cure for this disease, and the only good that can come out of having it is the chance to say goodbye.
Antony
& Cleopatra Essay, Research Paper Antony & Cleopatra-Act I, Scene 5 Cleopatra: Pray you stand farther from me. I know by that same eye there’s some good news. What, says the married woman you may go? Would she
Ivanhoe Strengths Essay Research Paper The greatest
Ivanhoe Strengths Essay, Research Paper The greatest strengths of Ivanhoe were the themes of the novel. All the characters in Ivanhoe were in some way affected by the major theme of the hatred between the
Poetry Research Paper Essay Research Paper Poetry
Poetry Research Paper Essay, Research Paper Poetry can both broaden and intesify an experience9…0 it can also illuminate, clarify, and deepen an occurence in a way a reader never considered.9…0poetry communicates expereince by appealing to both the thoughts and feelings of its reader.Poetry demands total response from the individual-all the intellect, senses, emotion, and imaginaTION. (CL)
Absolute Power Essay Research Paper Absolute PowerThis
Absolute Power Essay, Research Paper Absolute Power This job started off as any other for 66 year-old Luther Witney. He had everything checked off as he was about to break an entering into the worlds richest mans mansion in Mudleton, Virgina. He successfully got in and went straight up to the vault in which he noticed some time earlier when he got a tour of the house.
Political Theories Of Hobbes And Locke Essay
, Research Paper The Political Theories of Hobbes and Locke In the sixteenth century, the rise of the state and decline of the feudal system brought about the question of authority, whose is absolute, God or man? Should the state have power over its subjects or the subjects over the state? Soon after the theory of sovereignty and the theory of social contract were developed, but even these still drew debate.
Narcissus And Goldmund
– Herman Hesse Essay, Research Paper Throughout this book Hesse continuously explores the idea of the conflict individuals experience when searching for their true identity. Narcissus and Goldmund, two medieval men whose characters are metaphors for the underlying theme of mans individual search for self and the human experience.
On The Road Essay Research Paper On
On The Road Essay, Research Paper On The Road The novel On The Road is based on one mans true stories about his craziest adventures through the United States and Mexico. This is one of the greatest novels of all time and nothing I have read so far seems so realistic. Jack Kerovac, who is the author of the book, places himself as the narrator.
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.