, Research Paper
Of the two opposing views presented by many critics concerning Lear?s temperament at death: Joyful or angry and blind, neither of them fully embraces the situation?s complexity. When Lear dies it is angrily and blindly as well as joyfully, both in tandem. At the end of the play King Lear, similarly to Gloucester (although his situation is more complex), dies betwixt two alternating extremes of passion: joy and grief. As for the blindness it is difficult to say as I will elaborate on further on.
The joy centers around two issues. The first is Lear?s reconciliation and achieving of atonement with his good and loving daughter Cordelia, whom he unjustly wronged previously in the play. She has forgiven him entirely and this sets his heart partially at rest. Secondly he also partially redeems himself and his faults as he has learned through betrayal and hardship, a great deal about his own nature, others? natures, as well as the hierarchical nature. About his own nature he learns that he is not always right and is headstrong. About the nature of others he has also learned a great deal, he understands that love cannot be measured by superficial praise as he discovered with Goneril and Regan, oftentimes the one who says what you need to hear not what you want is true to you, this is the case for both Cordelia and Kent. About the nature of hierarchy, Lear has understood that he was wrong in assuming that he would be able to maintain the powers and train of a king while not upholding the responsibilities. Lear has also learned humility from his experiences throughout the play. At the end of the play he has a much better understanding as to many aspects of the past, he can now release the resentment that he felt at some point for each daughter as he is partially liable for the entire situation.
The combined anger and grief that Lear carries to the grave is due to a multitude of factors. The first concerns his state of distraction as a result of Cordelia?s murder, which robs him of the joy that he anticipated at spending time with her in prison, so that he could begin life with her anew this time more conscious and enlightened than before, her dying he does not have the option of cherishing the deeper connection that has been forged between the father and daughter.
?No, no, no, no! Come, let?s away to prison;
We two alone will sing like birds i?th?cage:
When thou dost ask me blessing, I?ll kneel down,
And ask of thee forgiveness: so we?ll live,
And pray and sing and tell old tales, and laugh
At gilded butterflies, and hear poor rogues
Talk the court news; and we?ll talk with them too,
Who loses and wins; who?s in, who?s out;
And take upon the mystery of things,
As if we were gods? spies: and we?ll wear out,
In a wall?d prison, packs and sects of great ones
that ebb and flow by th?moon.?
(Act 5 scene 3 line 8-19)
As we see in this passage he envisions a happy future for the two of them, where it does not matter where they are as long as they are together. His joy that what was utterly wrong is now partially right is replaced with complete grief. And yet it is difficult to know what he believes at his time of death. He is distracted, not in his right mind imagining or ?clinging onto the supposition? that Cordelia is still alive. Lear alternates between berating the others present for not howling for her in mourning,
?Howl, Howl, Howl! O, you are men of stones!
Had I your tongues and eyes I?d use them so
That heaven?s vault should crack. She?s gone for ever.
I know when one is dead, and when one lives;
She?s dead as earth. Lend me a looking-glass;
If that her breath will mist or stain the stone,
Why then she lives.?
(Act 5 scene 3 line 256)
And yet at the same time self delusively imagines finding signs of life on her lips. His losing of Cordelia physically is highly important to him as he sees her continued life as the redeeming of all his sorrows. Thus her death would represent, for Lear, a lack of redemption.
?This feather stirs; she lives! If it be so,
it is a chance which does redeem all sorrows
That ever I have felt.?
(Act 5 scene 3 lines 264-6)
At this point we are presented with two possible interpretations. He may have died ?blindly? believing that Cordelia was alive, which would have resulted in his death being much less guilty-ridden, painful and angry, resembling then, Gloucester?s death. On the other hand if Lear died knowledgeably grieving her death, then he went to the grave angry at himself yet at the same time ?seeing? the truth of the situation. At his time of death, Lear also suffers from having learned his lessons about the nature of man too late to save his beloved daughter (which is unredemptive knowledge). He is largely a victim of his own and others? natures, and although he consciously understands this fact, the realization creates inner turmoil. The burden of guilt is upon him. Had he pursued a different course of action earlier in the play (namely the retaining of power as opposed to the division of his coronet among Albany and Cornwall), his daughter would still be alive and well, the war against France would not have been, and the loyalty splits within the once-his kingdom would not have been. This realization culminates at the end when Lear no longer has the facade of folly to hide behind, he must thus face these truths frankly. His suffering moves us closer to him as we identify with his fate: to move towards his true daughter then immediately after their reunification to be separated from her.
We can therefore conclude that of the two opposing views, a joyful death versus a death surrounded with anger and blindness, neither is entirely correct. King Lear?s death is shrouded in much complexity which leads one to believe that Lear must have simultaneously felt both joy and anger at the former at his daughter?s having forgiven him, the latter at himself as well at ?nature?.
Copyright James McGuire 1999
Другие работы по теме:
Machiavellian Philosophy In King Lear Essay Research
Paper Machiavelli s ideas influence some of Shakespeare s characters in the play, King Lear. To use the critic A. P. Rossiter s phrase, Shakespeare s plays are about, the survival of the slickest. The characters in King Lear that reflect the Machiavellian philosophy are the two sisters, Goneril and Regan, and the son of Gloucester, Edmund.
Wisdom Does Not Come With Age Essay
, Research Paper Although it is never too late to learn, those lessons learned in old age are often the most difficult and the most costly. Following Lear s dispute with Goneril, the Fool tell him, Thou shoulds t not have been old till thou hads t/ Been wise [I, v, 43-44]. In William Shakespeare s tragedy King Lear, Lear illustrates that wisdom does not necessarily come with age.
King Lear Essay 1 Essay Research Paper
Service and loyalty are big parts of the plot of King Lear. Some characters of this play show complete loyalty and service to the king. One of these is Kent. Throughout the play, Kent is completely loyal to his king, even after the Lear banishes him from the kingdom. This tells me that some people can be loyal to the end.
Cordelia And Lear Essay Research Paper Throughout
Cordelia And Lear Essay, Research Paper Throughout the play, King Lear, we are awaiting to see the reunion of Lear and his daughter Cordelia. In the begining of the play Lear wrongfully disowns Cordelia because he does not get the flattery from her that he wishes to hear. However, through much torment after he is reduced to nothing, Lear realizes that he cannot always get what he wants just because he is a king.
King Lear Essay Research Paper In King
King Lear Essay, Research Paper In King Lear, the unnatural elements seem to always dominate the natural elements throughout the play. There exists a reversal of order in the play where the evil prosper in the downfall of the good, and where man’s life is meaningless and arbitrary. King Lear, the tragic hero, dies in the end despite the torment and agony he had to endure to regenerate and repent.
King Lea The Role Of The Fool
Essay, Research Paper In the play King Lear, by William Shakespeare, there are many intriguing characters. Perhaps the most intriguing of them all is the fool. The fool seems to exist outside the play appearing and disappearing without warning. The fool is, however, a necessary character to the evolution of Lear’s character, since he is the personification of truth and reason.
King Lear
’s Death Essay, Research Paper King Lear’s Death At the end of Shakespeare’s play King Lear, Kent and Edgar survive to be offered their power and titles back so that they can jointly rule with Albany. The title character of the play is not so fortunate. Lear enters carrying the dead body of his loving daughter Cordelia, then collapses and dies beside her.
Good Vs Evil In King Lear Essay
, Research Paper In the King Lear play, Shakespeare creates many conditions in which humans live in the world. The main characters in the play are used to portray Shakespeare’s ideas. One of these ideas which Shakespeare is trying to portray is evil between the characters and in the world which are emphasized throughout the play.
Tragedy Of King Lear Essay Research Paper
Hamlet, Othello, Macbeth and King Lear are the four most prominent and revered works that William Shakespeare had ever produced, though the first three that I mentioned seem
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearHumans
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear Humans have qualities such as kindness, consideration, compassion and above all pity. Sometimes, however, human nature can be very primitive, like that of an animal, to act instinctively and without morals and consciousness. Further, it can cause one person to be dreadful toward another.
King Lear Suffering Essay Research Paper King
King Lear: Suffering Essay, Research Paper King Lear: Suffering Suffering takes on many appearances, depending on how it is received. In King Lear, suffering was very painful to two people, and the giver wasn’t
King Lear The Role Of The Fool
Essay, Research Paper King Lear: The Role of the Fool In Shakespeare?s, King Lear, the Fool plays three major roles. One of these roles is of an ?inner-conscience? of Lear. The Fool provides basic wisdom and reasoning for the King at much needed times. The Fool also works as amusement for Lear in times of sadness and is also one of the only people besides the Duke of Kent and Cordelia who are willing to stand up to the King.
King Lear Act 5 Scene 3 Essay
, Research Paper Unseen text-King Lear (The passage is taken from Act 5,scene 3 and only Lear speaks throughout) The thing I find most interesting about the language used in this passage, is the dream like image it creates. I think the amount of contradictive language, used in the passage is also of some note as it creates ambiguity.
Madness In King Lear Act 4 Essay
, Research Paper Madness in King Lear: Act 4 In Shakespeare’s play King Lear, Shakespeare introduces many themes. The most important theme shown in King Lear is the theme of
The Fool In King Lear Essay Research
Paper The Fool is a tremendously substantial character in William Shakespeare’s tragedy, King Lear. Traditionally, fools were the equivalent of court jesters and were thought to be insane. They were customarily physically and sometimes even mentally impaired. Persons became fools as the result of an aristocratic individual’s compassion or boredom.
King LearBlindness Essay Research Paper King Lear
King Lear-Blindness Essay, Research Paper King Lear is in many ways like Nunez in the story The country of the Blind . They are both simliar because they both do not realize that they are both blind in what others think of them. They might think that they are right beacause both of them think that the people around them are inferior because of the way that they appear.
King Lear Motifs Essay Research Paper King
King Lear: Motifs Essay, Research Paper King Lear: Motifs Shakespeare uses many motifs to expand on the themes of the story. His most-used motif revolves around filial responsibility. Each of the two plots contains
Character Analysis In King Lear Essay Research
Paper Cordelia The virtuous daughter whom King Lear mistakenly rejects . knowing she will marry , Cordelia refuses to assert that all of her love will forever go to her father , unlike Regan and Goneril, her hypocritical sisters . Lear mistakes Cordelia’s honesty for a lack of affection and disinherits her , though the king of France recognizes her innate worth and marries her anyway .
Analyzing King Lear
’s Tragic Flaws Essay, Research Paper ANALYZING KING LEAR S TRAGIC FLAWS King Lear is a play about a tragic hero, by the name of King Lear, whose flaws get the best of him. A tragic hero must posess three qualities. The first is they must have power, in other words, a leader. King Lear has the highest rank of any leader.
King Lear By William Shakespeare 1564
– 1616) Essay, Research Paper Since King Lear’s setting is pre-Christian Britain, some readers chafe under the sort of nihilistic fatalism that colors the characters’ thinking (”As flies to wanton boys we are to the
King Lear4 Essay Research Paper Lear s
King Lear4 Essay, Research Paper Lear s words: I am a man/More sinn d against than sinning. is an expression of Lear s internal anguish and pain, triggered by his two evil daughters Gonerill and Regan. Surely, Lear s statement is to some degree, agreeable, since his sufferings was an result of Gonerill s and Regan s thirst for power, which led to their attack on Lear.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Animal Imagery
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Animal Imagery in King Lear In the play King Lear by William Shakespeare, a collection of images are used to express different points Shakespeare is trying to relay to his audience. One reoccurring image is that of animal images. Shakespeare incorporates these animal images when King Lear and many of the other characters in the play talk about Goneril and Regan and the animals that Lear and the other characters compare the two sisters to are not very pretty.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Imagery in
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Imagery in King Lear (King-Lear) In the immense amount of writing that William Shakespeare had done in hiscareer as a playwright and or writer in general there
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearIn
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear In the play King Lear written by William Shakespeare a collection of images are used to express different points Shakespeare is trying to relay to his audience. One reoccurring image that kept popping up was animal images. Shakespeare displays these animal images when King Lear and many of the other characters in the play talk about Goneril and Regan.
King Lear Essay Research Paper The ending
King Lear Essay, Research Paper The ending of King Lear has proven itself very controversial in its history. in shakespeare’s other play, the conclusions are simple: Othello kills himself, Macbeth is executed, ans everyone dies in hamlet. lear, however, is not as simple as the preceding, and in fact, leaves many questions unanswered.
King Lear And The Fool Essay Research
Paper Sebastian Crichton King Lear and the Fool There is much to be said of Lear and The Fool. I believe that The Fool in King Lear serves as an unbiased advisor, providing Lear with many lessons that a more powerful being would not have attempted, due to fear of the king’s wrath. The Fool had the ability to be totally honest with Lear, fore he had no rank or status to be stripped of.
King Lear Play Essay Research Paper In
King Lear (Play) Essay, Research Paper In the play King Lear, Lear reaches old age without achieving any wisdom. This statement is very true, many evidences can be found throughout the acts. For example: Lear is ignorant of the truth, he only hears what he wants to hear and he makes several rash decisions that leads to his downfall.
King Lear Essay Research Paper Many of
King Lear Essay, Research Paper Many of the passages of King Lear, particularly those between the characters of Lear, Kent, the Fool, and Cordelia, all share a common theme. The imagery of nothing, as well as that of blindness, echoes throughout the play. King Lear is in many ways about nothing. However, Kent, the Fool, and Cordelia make him more than nothing does by serving faithfully, speaking bluntly, and loving unconditionally.
Kinglearcompare And Contrast Lear And Cloucester Essay
, Research Paper In The Tragedy of King Lear, King Lear is quite cruel to his loving daughter, Cordelia. Cordelia expresses her true love for her father, and Lear disowns her. Lear makes his three daughters, Cordelia, Regan, and Goneril, tell him how great of a father and king he is, in order to own and rule a part on England.
King Lear Essay Research Paper King LearKing
King Lear Essay, Research Paper King Lear King Lear is the tale of a vain, prideful, and foolish old man who is blinded by his rage and too stubborn to mend his ways. The “self”
King Lear And The Fatal Flaw Essay
, Research Paper How central is the idea of a fatal flaw in King Lear? More than any of Shakespeare s plays, King Lear explores the concept of a fatal flaw and the terrible downfall it could lead to. It is indeed the most central idea in the play. Shakespeare shows us how one flaw in an otherwise normal person can lead to their ultimate demise.