Essay, Research Paper
It can be easily assumed that almost everyone has heard the tale of the American Indian princess, Pocahontas ? the narrative of a mysterious young girl who rescues an English explorer from death only to fall in love and win his affections in return. It is one that is quite popular and has even been developed into an animated movie by Walt Disney Pictures. Regardless of which version they may have heard, most people are familiar with the legend now thanks in part to Disney. However, what they are not familiar with, are the facts. All too often, we accept what is presented in films as history without any thought into the matter. Did Pocahontas and explorer John Smith ever actually meet? If so, how did they, and was there ever the feeling of love between them? There are similarities, but more differences between historical fact and what is presented in the Walt Disney motion picture.Aside from obvious deviations of the film, such as the language , there are others including how Pocahontas and Smith meet, which they did in fact do. In the movie from the beginning, Pocahontas is an independent, curious woman who stumbles upon the English settlement. As a result, Captain Smith notices her and assures her that he will do her no harm. The two instantly warm to one another. While this makes a wonderful opening for a movie ? we view a great scene of the English working hard to establish a settlement ? it is not how they met at all. In his book Pocahontas and Her World, Philip L. Barbour offers a more accurate account of the two?s first meeting. He explains that John Smith was the one who was adventuring, not Pocahontas (as Disney depicts). He says that “on or about December 29, 1607″ , Smith was led into the chief?s hut as a “prisoner” by Indian braves. Inside, he witnessed chief Powhatan ? Pocahontas? father ? lying in comfort, surrounded by women he thought to be the chief?s wives . According to Barbour, Smith was treated well and given food and drink. What happened next was more exciting than a modern day film could depict, but also very complicated to explain in a film geared toward younger audiences. After some dicussion among the elders, “two big stones were brought in, and Smith was forcibly stretched out on them. What appeared to be executioners stood over him with clubs ready ? Suddenly, a little girl rushed from Powhatan?s side, knelt, and placed her head over Smith?s. The executioners released their captive, and the little girl pulled him to his feet” .That, as described by Barbour is how Captain John Smith and Pocahontas met for the first time. Yet, what is all of his talk about Pocahontas being a little girl? In the Disney animation, Pocahontas is a young woman of at least seventeen; yet, Dorothy F. Thompson describes her historically as a girl of ten or twelve years old . Pocahontas? true age leads to questions regarding her relationship with Captain John Smith. It is obvious now that Pocahontas could not have been Captain Smith?s love interest. Smith was a grown man and there would have been no reason, at least by normal standards, for Smith to have feelings for a child. There is a possibility, on the other hand, that Pocahontas (at age twelve) was at an age to have had somewhat of a “crush” on Smith , or was plainly fascinated by him. Barbour discusses in some length Pocahontas? respect for John Smith because “he was good natured. He was cheerful with her, but did not laugh at her [or her people] like many of his companions” . Smith in turn was fond of Pocahontas as he might be a daughter. She was the one who always brought baskets of corn to the settlement, and so it would have been easy for him to grow an appreciation for her. The two shared a common curiousity for one another. Although this is evident, a love interest is not.Pocahontas had saved Smith?s life, and that would have been an obvious reason for his liking to her. Disney?s Pocahontas builds on the rescue, making it the climax of the film ? the young heroin risks everything to save the man she cares for. Historically, we already know that Pocahontas didn?t even know Smith at the time of the “rescue”, never mind care for him. So then what exactly was the act that Pocahontas engaged in? Smith himself believed Pocahontas was his savior because as J.A. Leo Lemay notes, “there are eight unmistakable references in Smith?s writings to Pocahontas?s saving his life” . The most accepted explanation offered as to what really happened is that the execution was actually one of ceremony, something that Smith did not understand. The captain had been “adopted” into the tribe and the “execution” was part of the ritual. Barbour explains how “Indian boys in their early adolescence were subjected to far more fearful rites when they entered manhood” . Pocahontas was chosen to play the part of Smith?s “savior” in his initiation. From then on, there was a special relationship between John Smith and Pocahontas. He was obviously in gratitude, and Dorothy Thompson explains Pocahontas? involvement as a possible crush on the Englishman. Frances Mossiker however, offers a more realistic explanation to describe her possible thinking. He claims that: “she had made a commitment at the [cermonial] altar, [and] had assumed a responsibilty Smith ? as [his] tribal sponsor, guarantor, intermediary between his people and her people”.By examining history, we can easily see how different a legend can be from the actual truth. In Disney alone, there are many discrepancies between what is in the story, and what is accepted as historical fact. The scene of the “execution” has been misinterpreted, and it is only in the film that a love affair between John Smith and Pocahontas could be possible. It is truly a case of an imagination?s romance.
Другие работы по теме:
History Of Animation Essay Research Paper Not
History Of Animation Essay, Research Paper Not many Disney shorts have been released recently. I think their entertainment and historical value is to be better appreciated by being released on video and DVD. Here is a list of video/DVD release ideas that I propose:
Pocahontas Essay Research Paper Many moons ago
Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper Many moons ago, an Indian girl was not yet born but there were many problems with Indians and the white man as the Indians. This unborn child would become a huge part of colony history between the Indians and the English; this child was to be recognized in history by many different names the most famous name would be Pocahontas.
Pocahontas Essay Research Paper Response to PocahontasPeople
Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper Response to Pocahontas People today tend to scrutinize every aspect of anything that crosses the silver screen. The Disney company is always questioned on the reality of their films. Some see racism, bias, or ignorance toward history. Now for a cartoon that?s supposed to entertain children, Disney does it the best.
Pocahontas Essay Research Paper PocahontasThe story of
Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper Pocahontas The story of Pocahontas happened the same time as the founding of Jamestown, the first permanent English colony in the New World. Her story begins with her first visit to the colony as a child of ten or eleven. The event that captured her fame, was her rescue of Captain John Smith from murder at the hands of her father.
What Is America Essay Research Paper John
What Is America? Essay, Research Paper John Smith and Jonathan Edwards were two well-respected leaders in the colonial times, but they had very different beliefs. John Smith believed that the colonies were a great place for a man to make something of himself. Jonathan Edwards on the other hand believed that the colonies were just another place for man to sin.
Comparison 2 Essay Research Paper A Union
Comparison 2 Essay, Research Paper A Union of Crossings The feeling and power of love affect every human being on the face on this planet, but it is how each individual handles the various dimensions of this complex emotion that creates a unique situation. The theme of love can be found in the chapter in the New Worlds of Literature text titled Crossings.
Disney Land Essay Research Paper Welcome to
Disney Land Essay, Research Paper Welcome to the number one vacation destination on earth! There’s enough magic here to fill your entire vacation. In this wonderful kingdom timeless tales of fantasy and your favorite Disney Characters come to life in seven magical lands. A quick flip through these pages, and you’ll discover why you won’t want to go anywhere else.
The Flea Essay Research Paper The Flea
The Flea Essay, Research Paper The Flea by John Donne John Donne’s The Flea exhibits his metaphysical ability; his aptitude for turning even the least likely images into elaborate symbols of love and romance. This poem uses the image of a flea that has just bitten the speaker and his beloved to sketch an amusing conflict over whether the two will engage in premarital sex.
Pocahontas Essay Research Paper Biography of PocahontasFor
Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper Biography of Pocahontas For more than two centuries since the death of the Indian princess Pocahontas, legends and stories of romance have been imbedded into our minds, but her dramatic life was more important to the creation of a segment of American history than legend.
Pocahontas Essay Research Paper Who really was
Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper Who really was Pocahontas? Was she like the Indian girl in the Disney movie, who saved her reservation? Yes and no. She was an Indian of the Algonquian Indians. Her father was Powhatan,
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay Research Paper After
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper After watching the disney movie, Pocahontas, many people have found a large amount of historical inaccuracies in both the setting, and the characters portrayed. An example is: the topographic features of Virginia aren?t at all like the waterfalls and mountains shown in the movie.
The Jamestown Fiasco Essay Research Paper The
The Jamestown Fiasco Essay, Research Paper The Jamestown Fiasco The mistakes made by the early settlers at Jamestown, which threatened their survival is the fact that they didn t harvest for themselves, but rely on Indians. During the
John Smith Essay Research Paper John Smith
John Smith Essay, Research Paper John Smith has proved himself to be an inspiring leader and a skilled explorer who played a significant role in American history. His many accomplishments included helping found the original colony of Jamestown, saving it from a starving time, leading various expeditions of exploration, and courageously escaping from the Indians.
Correlation Between Tempest And The New World
Essay, Research Paper Of Plymouth Plantation by William Bradford, The General History of Virginia, New England, and the Summer Isles by John Smith, and The Tempest by William Shakespeare, seem to have one thing in common in that they all touch upon the aspect of life in the new world. While The Tempest alludes to the new world and focuses on an imaginary concept of a utopian society, The General History of Virginia, New England, and the Summer Isles and Of Plymouth Plantation offer first hand accounts of life in the new world.
Time Warner And Disney Essay Research Paper
The dispute between Time Warner and Disney and the decision to pull ABC programs off the air on Monday and part of Tuesday has many viewers at Queens College thinking about how much media companies value money before their audiences.
Patricia Smith Essay Research Paper Patti Smith
Patricia Smith Essay, Research Paper Patti Smith Homepages, Biographies, and Interests a patti smith babelogue – The premier site for any and all information, from contacting patti to poetry, sound clips, performances, etc.
John Smith And William Bradford Essay Research
Paper The author John Smith, a pilgrim who arrived to the Americas, wrote a description of the new land in his book ? A Description of New England ?. In this book Smith shows a wonderful world of vast food and pleasure. Also, William Bradford another pilgrim who arrived to Plymouth on the coast of Massachusetts, wrote a book called ? Of Plymouth Plantation ? in which he describes what really happened their, how the pilgrims actually lived.
Eternal Romance Essay Research Paper Being an
Eternal Romance Essay, Research Paper Being an atmosphere or feeling characterized by a sense of love or by the idealization of everyday life, romance does not only belong to young people. In fact, all human beings are likely to be romantic regardless of age, sex, nationality, profession and color of skin.
Captain John Smith Is Successful Than John
Rolfe Essay, Research Paper Rakesh Patel His 151 2/2/99 Captain John smith was more important to the success of Virginia by 1630 then John Rolfe.. Like many famous heroes, John Smith was feisty, abrasive, self-promoting, and ambitious. He was an experienced soldier and adventurer, the man who boldly went out and got things done.
Mr Smith Goes To Washington Essay Research
Paper The film Mr. Smith Goes To Washington (dir. Frank Capra, 1939) emphasizes honesty verses falsehood. Jefferson Smith (James Stewart) has great honor and he upholds his integrity. Smith is always in constant danger because he lets his honesty take over. Fallacy and lies manipulate Smith s integrity to achieve their purposes.
Comparison Of Bradford And Smith Essay Research
Paper Brian Bird CP English 11 Comparison Essay Comparison Essay Although Captain John Smith and William Bradford, historians and leaders of their respective colonies, Jamestown and Plymouth, wanted to attract settlers to their colonies through their writings, the specific means they took to accomplish their goals varied.
My Paper Essay Research Paper 895 Mae
My Paper Essay, Research Paper 895 Mae Lynn Drive Fenton, Missouri 63026 March 4, 2000 Mr. John Smith Director of Central Service St. Mary?s Hospital P.O. Box 656
Walt Disney Essay Research Paper This book
Walt Disney Essay, Research Paper This book is about the life of Walt Disney, an American legend. The Arthur begins the tale with a view of the family before Walt Disney’s birth
Jane Eyre A Romance Essay Research
Paper Jane Eyre: A romance? Usually Jane Eyre is thought of as a romance novel, however in how many novels that are categorized as romance do you find a woman as the heroine? Jane has to go through many hardships in her life to accomplish the tasks that would ultimately make this story out to be a typical romance .
Arthurian Romance Essay Research Paper Arthurian RomanceArthurian
Arthurian Romance Essay, Research Paper Arthurian Romance Arthurian romance has been changed over and over again throughout the years in order to keep up with the audience of the moment. Throughout history Arthurian romance was and still is being used in many different forms. The Celtic s Arthurian romance was much different from that of the French.
Romance And Love Essay Research Paper Romance
Romance And Love Essay, Research Paper Romance and LoveWhen I was assigned this topic to write about, I immediately thought of Eros. The ancient Greek word that describes the romantic side of love. Philos andAgape are really more spiritual in nature, but Eros, now that’s a physical love.I envision Eros as the sweaty fumbling in the back of old Chevrolets, and thefirelit evenings where everything seems to go just right and the sex is perfect,And even in the dark, rent by the hour hotel rooms where men and womenwith no names briefly join and then quickly part, never knowing the otherpersons name.
Romance Essay Research Paper Romance and Love
Romance Essay, Research Paper Romance and Love; an essay When I was assigned this topic to write about, I immediately thought of Eros. The ancient Greek word that describes the romantic side of love. Philos and Agape are really more spiritual in nature, but Eros, now that’s a physical love. I envision Eros as the sweaty fumbling in the back of old Chevrolets, and the firelit evenings where everything seems to go just right and the sex is perfect, And even in the dark, rent by the hour hotel rooms where men and women with no names briefly join and then quickly part, never knowing the other persons name.
True Romance Essay Research Paper True Romance
True Romance Essay, Research Paper True Romance Once again, Quentin Tarantino outdoes himself. The movie True Romance wasexcellent. It presented real issues that some people are forced to deal within their lives. The title of the movie is misleading. You would think thiswas going to be a love story. Actually it is, but unlike any love story I’ve ever seen.
Virginia Essay Research Paper In the world
Virginia Essay, Research Paper In the world today there are many things that are alike and that are different. These things have comparisons and contrasts. There are also comparisons and contrasts in old literature. There are many things alike and many things that are different about General History of Virginia and of Plymouth Plantation.
Early American Literature Essay Research Paper Early
Early American Literature Essay, Research Paper Early American literature consisted mainly of diaries, journals, short stories, and Indian creation stories. Since some of the language used was of older English and other languages, early American literature was difficult to read.The first story I read was Spanish Explorers in the New World.
Adam Smith Vs John Keynes Essay Research
Paper How can John Maynard Keynes version of capitalism be compared to Adam Smith’s? Both are considered to be the molders and theorizers of the economic era. They are both very different in thinking, one complex the
Walt Disney Studios Essay Research Paper The
Walt Disney Studios Essay, Research Paper The Walt Disney Company is a company that developed from the vision and work of only a small amount of people, mainly Walt Disney. Disney Studios became a big success because of the creativity, determination, and effort put forth by Walt Disney who never gave up and got upset when people wouldn’t work as hard as him.
The Daughter Of Time By Josephine Tey
Essay, Research Paper Josephine Tey?s The Daughter of Time is a historical novel that looks at the belief that Richard III, King of England, murdered his two nephews in order to maintain his power. This novel also
Essay On Legends Essay Research Paper Legends
Essay On Legends Essay, Research Paper Legends Essay Disney movies have always created various stories based upon legends. To name a few: ?Hercules?, ?Pocahontas,? and ?The Sword in the Stone.? The characters in these movies have shown various characteristics that possess values that are thought of as great, even years after this these films have been released.