’s Conscience Clause Essay, Research Paper
It should come as no surprise to anyone that we have countless ethical and moral dilemmas everyday on this planet. With over six billion people, each with their own upbringing, there are bound to be conflicts between people. So many people having so many different religions; so many others doing as they feel is right, whether that be considered socially right or wrong. Conflicts might as well be expected in this world of ours. America, the great melting pot of the world, is merely a smaller model of the same situation. A great example of this is what is now known as the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause. Many pharmacists are not happy with their work because they are forced to fill a prescribed order for a drug, whether or not they agree with its purpose. This clause, if passed in the legislature of a state, allows the pharmacist, in short, to decide according to their own morals and beliefs whether they will give a prescribed medication to a client. This is causing huge controversy already, and it has a long way to go before it will be law of the land. Although, it is hoped by many that this will become law of our land as well as all others. On one hand, is this newly created clause giving an absurd amount of power to pharmacists? Or is it enough? Do pharmacists deserve more say in a prescription that this clause will allow them? It is the aim of this paper to answer these questions. It is my belief that this Conscience Clause, with amendment, will provide a fair amount of power to pharmacists and thus will create a workable solution to the said problem. Before anything, let us show the written Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause. This clause, as revised by the 1998 American Pharmaceutical Association reads:”1.) APhA recognizes the individual pharmacist’s right to exercise conscientious refusal and supports the establishment of systems to ensure patient access to legally prescribed therapy without compromising the pharmacist’s right of conscientious refusal. 2.) APhA shall appoint a council to serve as a resource for the profession in addressing and understanding ethical issues. (Brauer, 1)” I would agree that this Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause does a good job of giving power to the Pharmacist. Also, I would agree that the idea of creating a council is a bit of genius. It is rather obvious that the future will be filled with people challenging different instances. However, I don’t feel that enough power is kept in the hands of the people with this Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause.Pharmacists are obviously very intelligent and skilled people, as they must attend college. However, the average person sees them completing tasks that a robot could finish. For as much as you or I see of them, they merely read a prescription and get the medicine. Granted, it may take an entire year of college to be able to read a doctor’s handwriting. Still, this is almost a humiliation for their profession. Why hire college graduates and pay tens of thousands of dollars per year when any person off the street could do this work? Because pharmacists must have a vast knowledge of what any given medication will do to a person. They study chemistry, physics, biology, and various other health science courses which will teach them the effects of all types of drugs. And why is this education necessary if it cannot be used? This is a question that many pharmacists are asking themselves. A part of the hopeful answer to this problem has come in the form of this conscience clause. According to the Michigan Occupational Information System (MOIS), a pharmacists’ general job tasks include verifying prescriptions; weighing, measuring and mixing drugs; determining the identity, purity and strength of medications; dispensing medications; ensuring that patients understand instructions on medications; monitoring medication therapy of patients; keeping comprehensive records of patients; sorting and preserving drugs; and finally ordering and maintaining supplies. Because of the extensive records and such that pharmacists keep, they have a good handle on each of their patients. They also, with few exceptions, know much more about the prescribed medication and how it will affect the patient. For this reason alone they feel they should have the right to counsel their patients to some extent. Some pharmacists feel that they should be allowed to outright hold a medication from a patient. According to Gallup Poll, “for the last eight years, pharmacists have been rated as the most trusted [professional] (even above clergy)(Brauer and Gargaro, 1).” The true question, however, is whether this trust can last long if a pharmacist cannot legally hold from dispensing medication if they believe it will be harmful to the patient. What boundaries does a pharmacist have with their clients? Do they have a professional, if not moral, obligation to counsel their clients? Should they go so far as to withhold medication? It is only fair to say that this conscience clause is only hoping to be a step in the right direction. Not all pharmacists support it. In fact, it is most largely supported by pro-life pharmacists. Currently, it is most often used when a pharmacist doesn’t believe in dispensing abortifacient “morning after pills” (MAP) which are intended for birth control but can be used after conception as a sort of early abortion. Because of this Pharmacist’s for Life International (PFLI) is most actively behind the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause. The biggest problem resides in that pharmacists are using this clause whether or not it is law in their state. Currently, it has been passed in South Dakota, New Jersey, Louisiana, California, Wisconsin, Puerto Rico, and the Canadian province of Alberta (Brauer, 1). Though it is snowballing in it’s movement around the nation and eventually the world it is far from accepted around the US as a whole. The biggest current problems lie in nationwide chains such as K-Mart and Wal-Mart. These pharmacists are being required, under penalty of their job, to fulfill all valid prescriptions. This is a case which has been brought into our own home state of Indiana. On Dec. 19, 1996, Karen Brauer, a resident of Lawrenceburg, Indiana, lost her job at a Cincinnati K-Mart because she was unwilling to dispense MicroNor, a “minipill” for the purpose of birth control. However, she feels that the pill is used more often as a MAP than as an actual birth control pill. She had worked for K-Mart for seven years prior to being fired, and her district manager was well aware of her feelings on MicroNor and other MAPs. However, nationwide pharmacy cutbacks and increased hours provided a new situation for her. She was now working in two separate K-Marts, one of which was located in Cincinnati, Ohio. Generally, when a patient wished to refill his or her MicroNor, he or she would be moved to the other pharmacist working, as Karen felt the drug was morally wrong. Unfortunately, one day she happened to be the only pharmacist and was presented with the task of refilling MicroNor for a patient. She told the client that they were temporarily out of stock and that the prescription could be transferred to another pharmacy. However, as Karen Brauer herself states, “In Ohio, a refillable prescription belongs to the patient and must legally be transferred at the patient’s will.” The client filled the prescription at another pharmacy but later found out that Karen had merely chosen not to fill the prescription. The client called K-Mart headquarters, and the order was given to have Karen either submit to fulfilling such prescriptions in the future or to have her job terminated. She kept with her morals and was subsequently fired from K-Mart. The reasoning behind the termination, in K-mart’s wording, was as follows:
“1.) You have no way of knowing for what MicroNor is being prescribed and must assume it is being prescribed for birth control which is MicroNor’s indication. 2.) Since you are the only pharmacist on duty you offer the customer no alternative of filling the prescription for MicroNor but to go elsewhere. 3.) It is your obligation as a K-Mart employee to accomidate all K-Mart customers and not send them to competition (Personal Interview Record, 1).” She was then given one final chance to submit to filling all future valid prescriptions regardless of her beliefs. However, she denied K-Mart of such pleasure by signing her name under a paragraph which read:”In order to live in accordance with my conscience, I must refuse to dispense prescriptions with a major abortifacient mechanism or action. I regret coming into conflict with KMart over this issue. I have been pleased and happy to deliver pharmaceutical care to KMart’s pharmacy customers these past seven years (Personal Interview Record, 2).” And this same treatment has occurred with other K-Mart and Wal-Mart employees. Enough so that PFLI considers these firms alone a reason why a Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause is necessary immediately. Now, let us get into what a conscience clause would give, what it would take, and other such details. First and foremost, it gives piece of mind to the pharmacist. They aren’t forced to prescribe a drug they feel uneasy about for any reason. And if the client is adamant about receiving the medication, that can still be arranged; it will take only another pharmacist. Most importantly, this gives the client the knowledge that, for one reason or another, the pharmacist does not feel comfortable about the medication. This knowledge and some time spent counseling the client could help him or her come to a better solution, perhaps even saving them from making a horrendous mistake. But can’t some pharmacists abuse this Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause? Can’t they use it as means of escaping some amount of work? Yes, they can, which is an unfortunate side effect but one which can be taken advantage of. With an addendum to the conscience clause this can be taken care of more than it is now. I would include in this clause the fact that a pharmacist who denies filling a prescription must refer the client to another pharmacist. This way, we will lose the pharmacists who wish to deny prescriptions in order to avoid paperwork, as they will then have to provide details for the client to contact this other pharmacist. Also, this way a pharmacist can help the client not to feel enraged at the idea of the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause. Is a pharmacist who denies filling a medication imposing his or her morality on his or her client? Perhaps this is a fear of clients. If their doctor has told them that this medication will solve their problem, why should they be possibly forced to listen to a pharmacist deny their prescription and tell them of their moral error? This is another situation which can be avoided merely by changing the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause slightly. I would propose that a pharmacist who denies filling a prescription must present this dialogue to some extent: “I’m sorry, I will not fill that prescription for you. Would you like me to tell you the reasons why, or would you rather have me point you to another pharmacist?” By doing this, the pharmacist is giving the client the choice on whether he or she would hear reasoning for not honoring the prescription. However, the pharmacist still retains the right not to honor the prescription. Thus, I would add a third line to the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause as written by the 1998 American Pharmaceutical Association. It would read as follows: “3.) No pharmacist, under penalty of removal from APhA, will give counsel to a client without oral agreement. Similarly, directions for contact with another pharmacist must be given at time of refusal.” With this third item added, I feel that the revised Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause is worthy of the ages. This may not be the absolute biggest issue on every mind, but it certainly affects the vast majority of people at one point or another. And by helping to refine this newly created process from the veritable beginning, it makes any transition much smoother. As said in the introduction, the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause is a formidable clause but in need of some amendment. And that is exactly what it has received. Truly now, the Pharmacist’s Conscience Clause can stand the test of time.
Другие работы по теме:
Birth Control Essay Research Paper In beginning
Birth Control Essay, Research Paper In beginning my research, which was surfing the web for information on sexuality, I began with the topic of “birth control.” I found birth control to be intriguing because it had a wide range of possible choices to choose from. In beginning to search for this topic, one of the first pieces of information that I located was the statistic of, “without use of any birth control method, for every 100 fertile women, 60-80 females will become pregnant during the course of a year in which intercourse occurs regularly.
Trem Essay For Eng 102103 Essay Research
Paper The pharmacy was very busy place. The pharmacist was talking on the telephone and working on the computer at the same time. After a while the printed some papers on the white printer. As he was counting the pills he pulled from the shelf, a customer asked, where are your pain relievers . The pharmacist told her here where to go.
Soft Drink Industry Essay Research Paper The
Soft Drink Industry Essay, Research Paper The Soft Drink Industry When there is industry there is competition. The bigger the player, the harder they can play. The big players always try to consume many of the small competitors. When they do this they can expand their market share. A perfect example of this is the soft drink industry; Pepsi and Coke have always been archrivals.
Contributions Of Native American To The Advancent
Of Mediacal Essay, Research Paper Stories of Native Americans contributions to the advancement of health and medicine traces were discovered in a small town in Nali, Africa. The very first onset of the beggining of modern pharmacology is the substance called “quinine”. This is the substance that came from a bark of a tree that grew in high elevations.
Career Report Essay Research Paper Over the
Career Report Essay, Research Paper Over the past few weeks I have been researching my interests, values, and goals. Throughout this research a lot of things that were already evident to me, were proven for a fact. My interests included researching different aspects of science and data analysis. Analysis has always been a big part of my life because I analyze everything.
Do Coatings On Pills Affect The Digestion
Of The P Essay, Research Paper Dan Jahncke’s Pill Problemdone by: Dan Jahncke1-15-96 8E Science Gleason Question: Do coatings on pills affect the digestion of the pill? Background: People get sick all the time. Usually they take some kind of over-the-counter drug (OTC). One of the well-known over-the-counter drugs is Tylenol, a drug that relieves things for headaches to fevers.
Hopeful Encounter Essay Research Paper Hopeful EncounterThe
Hopeful Encounter Essay, Research Paper Hopeful Encounter The sun was setting. Far to the east, threatening black clouds arose from the fumes of pollution from the several smokestacks towering over the city. The streets were pocks marked
Global Warming Deforestation Nuclear Waste And Pollution
Essay, Research Paper Q. Discuss some issue of personal, local, or international concern and its importance to you. Through out my high school year I have researched on many issues and all of the issues are important to me. All of the issues are important to me because in a way all of the problems are connected to each other and one problem leads to another.
Valley Drug Mart The Lawton Entry Essay
, Research Paper SITUATION ANALYSIS George Farin is the sole proprietor of the Valley Drug Mart that he has built in his hometown of Middleton, Nova Scotia, over a period of fifteen years. The business has thrived and grown through the acquisition of the towns’ only competition and the relocation to a 7000 square foot building.
The Role Of The Friar In Romeo
+ Juliet Essay, Research Paper The Friar directly and indirectly took part in suicide, murder, and other tragic happenings. The Friar is an honored man, who sells herbs and medicines to the people of Verona. He is a type of ancient pharmacist, who has potions for both causes of good and evil. There are three specific instances of the Friar playing a major role in Romeo and Juliet: the impossible marriage of Romeo and Juliet, Juliet’s “death” plan, and Romeo’s death.
Character Essay Research Paper aracterPhilThe sun was
Character Essay, Research Paper aracterPhil The sun was setting. Far to the east, threatening black clouds arose from the fumes of pollution from the several smokestacks towering over the city. The streets were pocks marked and dented with the recent shower of acid rain. Hot boiling steam from the sewers made the temperature of day much hotter than it really was.
Pharmacist Essay Research Paper Pharmacists have a
Pharmacist Essay, Research Paper Pharmacists have a great impact on healing patients. They work with doctors to ensure that the patients receives the best treatment by making sure the medications are pure, safe, and properly prepared. A pharmacist provides information about drugs and drug treatments, dispenses drugs and other prescribed compounds by physicians, podiatrists, and dentists.
Pharmacist Essay Research Paper As a pharmacist
Pharmacist Essay, Research Paper As a pharmacist, your job is to dispense drugs prescribed by physicians and other health practitioners and to provide information to the patients about the medication they are using. Pharmacists advise other physicians and other health practitioners on the drugs prescribed.
Career Review Pharmacist Essay Research Paper IntroductionOn
Career Review: Pharmacist Essay, Research Paper Introduction On the surface, daily routines of Pharmacists may appear to be rather simplified and involves little work hazard and responsibilities. As pharmacists dispense prescribed drug and medicine by doctors or dentists, they may provide assistance to those who seeks help with non-prescribed products.
How Drugs Effect The Economy Essay Research
Paper The word drug is defined as ?any substance other than food that can affect the way your mind and body work.? There are hundreds of different drugs, each with its particular effect on the body?s nervous system. For instance, narcotics are a series of drugs that affect the mind, causing mental changes. The United States Government will not allow new drugs to be prescribed by a doctor or sold by a pharmacist until the drug has been thoroughly tested and proven to be medically safe.
Jerry Seinfeld
– Essay, Research Paper SeinLanguage by Jerry Seinfeld is a book filled with all of Jerry’s thoughts, views, and opinions on the things we do in life. The book has all of his annoyances and pet peeves. Instead of describing his life he discusses life in general in a comedic way. Some of the things he talks about are, personal maintenance, traveling, jobs and careers.
Trash On The Internet Essay Research Paper
With the increase of on-line crimes and fraud, stricter laws must be placed on the sale of such problematic items as guns, prescription drugs, and human blood and organs over the Internet. The selling of these and other items has created many problems in recent months. Most of these items are auctioned online through popular sites such as e-bay.
Hapkido Essay Research Paper Name February 2001Pharmacy
Hapkido Essay, Research Paper Name February 2001 Pharmacy School Essay Born in a third world country, one that lacks most of the modern technologies and little job opportunities, one phrase that I remembered best is that of older people complaining on how they are tired of this thing or that thing . Like them me too was tired of a lot of things.
Rite Aid Essay Research Paper Rite AidRite
Rite Aid Essay, Research Paper Rite Aid Rite Aid is a retail drugstore chain that believes in quality. They operate over 3,800 drugstores in 30 eastern states. Rite Aid offers health and personal care products, office supplies, cosmetics, seasonal merchandise, a variety of brand names, and a private label product line.
Short Story Analysis The Necessary Knocking On
The Door By Ann Petry Essay, Research Paper Ann Petry was born in Old Saybrook, Connecticut. She is white and was living in a neighbourhood where the majority of the people were black. Anyhow, Ann Petry when through her childhood without any prejudices against racial difference. It was only later that she encountered racism.
Mkt Plan For Coke Product Essay Research
Paper Company History A pharmacist named Dr. John Stith Pemberton invented the refreshing taste of Coca-Cola in 1886. Concocted by a mixture of caramel-colored syrup in a three-legged brass kettle while in his backyard. He then decided to try to market the drink at Jacobs Pharmacy in his hometown of Atlanta, Georgia.
Ru486 Essay Research Paper RU486 is the
Ru-486 Essay, Research Paper RU-486 is the recently approved abortion pill. It affords women an opportunity to have a non-surgical abortion within the first seven weeks of pregnancy. The guidelines require for the woman to have multiple doctor visits, as well as counseling so this is a bit different then the morning after pill.
Waiting Room Madness Essay Research Paper Waiting
Waiting Room Madness Essay, Research Paper Waiting Room Madness You know the waiting as well as I do. You hate it too. The terrible waiting. The time you dread more than a five foot needle stuck in your backside. You feel the rage. You work harder than hell for some decent medical insurance only to wait like a flea-bitten dog for a miserable bone.
Medication Errors Essay Research Paper Medication Errors
Medication Errors Essay, Research Paper Medication Errors are among the biggest issues devoted in health care setting today in America. According to a recent Journal of the American Medical Association, medication error causes more than 10,000 of injures and deaths every year. Medication giving include five basic rights: Right patient, Right medication, Right route, Right dose, and Right time.
Pharmacist Career Report Essay Research Paper Pharmacist
Pharmacist Career Report Essay, Research Paper Pharmacist Career ReportPharmacists are responsible for safe transfer and drug administration for patient care; watching over technicians; order entry; drug monitoring and providing drug information to nurses and physicians. Dispenses drugs to wards, clinics, and clients; prepares special compounds and approved prescriptions and consults with medical staff about the use and control of drugs.
History Of Pepsi Essay Research Paper Caleb
History Of Pepsi Essay, Research Paper Caleb Bradham wanted to be a pharmacist. Somethings just never work out. Caleb had to drop out of school and return home when his father’s business failed. He opened a drug store on Broad Street in New Bern, North Carolina.
Woman Warrior Essay Research Paper Maxine Hong
Woman Warrior Essay, Research Paper Maxine Hong Kingston reflects upon her childhood by starting off the second half of the book in titling it At the Western Palace. The irony of the title is that Kingston s family thought that they were bringing her aunt into a better lifestyle from a Communist country. However this proved not to be true.
Analysis Of The Doctor In The Cantebury
Tales Essay, Research Paper Analysis of the Doctor?s Character Geoffrey Chaucer has created a wide variety of characters in ?The Canterbury Tales?, in order to explain the status of the existing classes in the society of his own time. What makes ?The Canterbury Tales? such u unique story, is the technique the author uses describing his characters.
Similarities
& Differences In German & English Essay, Research Paper Jeremy Johnson September 26, 2000 Similarities and Differences All human communications involve language, and its use as such implies that there must be certain similarities. All languages have an alphabet, a lexicon, and a set of rules establishing how sentences are constructed.
The Dialogue With Alternative Medicine Essay Research
Paper Conventional medicine has little to learn from alternative medicine Suppose you catch a sudden flu after a frantic night out, what would be your first treatment? Do you rush to the pharmacist nearby or your
Mans Inhumanity To Man Essay Research Paper
Mans Inhumanity to Man Miss Cambell lived alone in her pokey one-bedroomed appartment on the bottom of 23rd Street. She was an introvert and always had been. She never went out after work and her life seemed to be one long routine. One thing that Miss Cambell loved to do was plan dinner parties. She would make up imaginery invitation lists, construct a lavish menu and prepare a concise shopping list to go with the menu.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Arnold was
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Both his parents were of long-established, well-respected New England families. He was helper to a pharmacist when he was a young. However, he liked the battlefield to a druggist’s life and enlisted in the militia during the French and Indian War (1754-1763).
HERE BEGINS THE BOOK OF THE TALES
OF THE SUPER BOWL Essay, Research Paper October 16, 1994 10-K Creative Writing GENERAL PROLOGUE HERE BEGINS THE BOOK OF THE TALES OF THE SUPER BOWL: When the frigid air of January has blanketed every treetop and house alike with its gentle frost; when birds, squirrels, and the like are nowhere to be found close to home- then folks long to go on trips to temperate sites; and especially from every corner of the States they travel to Pasadena every few years, to watch The Super Bowl there; the finals for the great football season which has entertained them the past few months.