St. Thomas Aquinas Essay, Research Paper
What is the Best Way to Prove God? A Comparison of St.
Thomas Aquinas St. Thomas Aquinas is one of the greatest
theologians that has ever been. He recognized that there
were some people who doubted the existence of God because,
to them, logic did not allow for or explain God’s existence. Being a
devout Christian, he naturally believed in God, but he wanted to
prove God’s existence to those who could not accept things on
faith alone. As a result, we have five proofs of the existence of
God by St. Thomas Aquinas, all of which are based on logic and
observation of nature. One of his proofs is based on the idea of
a first mover and another is based on the idea that intelligence
is necessary to direct non-intelligent objects. I believe that
this fifth argument is better that the first. St. Thomas
Aquinas’ first argument tries to prove that there must be a
first mover. He calls this first mover God. He proves this by
saying that whatever is in motion must have been put in motion
by something else. He then defines one type of motion as the
reduction of something from potentiality to actuality, and says
that nothing can make this movement except by something that
is already in actuality in the same respect as the first object is
in potentiality. He goes on to say that no thing can be both
actual and potential in respect to the same aspect and, thus,
that nothing can be both moved and mover. In this, he means
that nothing can move itself. Therefore, if something is in
motion, it must have been put in motion by something else, which
must have been put in motion by yet another thing, and so on.
However, this cannot go on to infinity, as St. Thomas Aquinas
explains, because there would never have been a fist mover and,
thus, no subsequent movers. This leads to the conclusion that
there is a first mover, and this first mover is what is called
God. His fifth argument is actually much more simple. Just by
observing the world, we see the non-intelligent things always
act toward an end. (It is this observation of the universe that
is the basis for the sciences, especially the science of physics.)
We also see that non-intelligent things cannot move toward
their end unless directed by an intelligent being. As an example,
St. Thomas Aquinas uses an arrow. An arrow will not achieve its
purpose (that of reaching its mark) unless directed to do so by
an archer. Obviously, humans are the intelligent beings that
direct the small objects of our world, but there must be a
greater intelligence that directs the larger bodies of the
universe, such as the stars and the planets, since we obviously
have no control over them. This higher intelligence is what we
call God. These two arguments approach the problem of proving
God’s existence in two completely different ways. One goes the
route of saying there must be something that started
everything, and the other says there must be something that
controls the things that are here, even if “it” did not create
them. Both of these arguments seem, at first, to be good and
valid in their separate approaches. However, the first on does
have one major flaw as I see it. St. Thomas Aquinas says that
the line of movers cannot go on to infinity, which common sense
would tell you to be true. He thus establishes the arbitrary
endpoint of God. The problem I see is that this argument could
always be tested to be false by asking the question, “What
Moved God?” St. Thomas Aquinas would probably answer that
nothing mover God because God has always existed. I personally
believe this to be true, but, to prove his first argument, St.
Thomas Aquinas must accompany it by another argument that
proves God has existed forever. Then, God would not need to
have been moved since He would have always been. This would
make for a kind of circular flaw in logic or paradox, in that he
could not prove God existed until he proved God has existed
forever, and he obviously cannot prove that God has existed
forever until he proves that God exists at all. Because of this, I
do not believe God can be proved by means of St. Thomas
Aquinas’ first argument or by any similar means. In St. Thomas
Aquinas’ fifth argument, however, I do not see any flaws in
logic and I do not thing it needs to rely on any other arguments
to be valid. Just by observing the universe, we have found that
it operates according to certain rules or laws. However, it
seems very unlikely that these laws just appeared out of
nowhere, that they emerged with the creation of the universe.
According to currently accepted scientific theory, the universe
started with the big bang. This theory also states that, if
anything existed before the big bang, we cannot predict what it
was like because physical laws did not govern the universe at
that time. So, it seems, physical laws must have just appeared as
a result of the big bang. Science, which traditionally tries to
explain the universe without the “crutch” or involvement of
God, cannot and could never explain why these laws exist in the
first place. The only explanation I can see is that God has put
them there to govern the universe. This is the same argument
St. Thomas Aquinas uses, and it seems to be completely self-
supporting and free of any flaws in logic. For these reasons, I
believe this argument to be better than the first argument.
Proving the existence of God is a worthwhile task. If someone
did come up with a complete, foolproof argument for the
existence of God, the people of the world would have no choice
but to believe in His existence. However, even though St.
Thomas Aquinas makes a worthy effort, I believe that such a
task is not possible through logic and reasoning alone. There is
an element of faith that must be present for people to believe,
and if that element is not there, no matter how foolproof an
argument seems to be, there will always be those who do not
believe. In his fifth argument, St/ Thomas Aquinas makes as
close to foolproof argument that I believe anyone could make,
and, for me, it does prove God’s existence. However, if that
element of faith is not there, I do not think you can completely
prove God’s existence to everyone.
Другие работы по теме:
The First Cause Essay Research Paper One
The First Cause Essay, Research Paper One of the most commonly pondered philosophical questions is the mystery of the universe’s origin. For countless centuries mankind has speculated as to how and why the universe as we know it came into existence. Unfortunately, in attempting to answer this question, we simply raise more questions; each as unanswerable as the last.
Aquinas On Kingship Essay Research Paper On
Aquinas, On Kingship Essay, Research Paper On Kingship Chapter 12 In this chapter, Aquinas focused on the duties and responsibilities of a king. He thinks that, nature shows us how to act with reason; and the best way to learn the duties of a king is focusing on the examples of government that can be found in nature.
Critique On Whether God Exists Essay Research
Paper “Whether God Exists” Countless philosophers since the beginning of recorded history have pondered the question of whether God exists. One such philosopher, Saint Thomas Aquinas, put forth his own theory on the existence of God. In his text “Whether God Exists”, he stated that through his five arguments he could prove God’s existence.
Greek Writing Essay Research Paper Western CivilizationProfessor
Greek Writing Essay, Research Paper Western Civilization Professor Babcock Fall 2000 The Magna Carta, St. Francis? Admonitions, and Thomas Aquinas? Summa Theologica are all-important works of the High Middle Ages. These documents explain a great deal to the reader about civilization at that time. This paper will first, demonstrate why the Magna Carta, Thomas Aquinas? Summa Theologica, and St.
Is There A God Essay Research Paper
Does God Exist? God not only exists in the understanding, but in reality as well. God, according to Anselm, is a being “than which nothing greater can be conceived” (Anselm 29). According to this concept God could not simply exist in an understanding because that would leave the possibility of a greater being than God – He who exists in reality as well as understanding.
Proofs For God
’s Existence Essay, Research Paper The first argument introduced by Aquinas states that nothing could move, unless it is being moved by something else, suggesting that there is an original mover. Aquinas asserts that motion is nothing else than the reduction of something from potentiality to actuality, but nothing can be reduced from potentiality to actuality except by something in a state of actuality.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper Our
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper Our government has gone through many changes. Our founding fathers had different ideas of how or government should be. Alexander Hamilton wanted a strong centralized government while Thomas Jefferson wanted a Democratic form of government. Today the government is a blend of both ideas.
Society Of Utopia Essay Research Paper Sir
Society Of Utopia Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas More’s Utopia has been labeled as “the first original story by a known Englishman.” This Englishman, Sir Thomas More, was a noted statesman, author, and Archbishop of Canterbury who boldly opposed the divorce and remarriage of the overbearing King Henry VIII and because of this was unjustly beheaded.
Aquinas Essay Research Paper According to Aquinas
Aquinas Essay, Research Paper According to Aquinas everything is created was created by God. Aquinas made five proofs to proof the God exists and HE created everything. His five proofs are motion, efficient cause, possibility/necessity, gradation, and governance of the world.
Saint Thomas Aquinas Writings Essay Research Paper
In “Summa Contra Gentiles”, by Saint Thomas Aquinas, one of the major proofs of the existence of God is the second proof. The second proof is based on the “everything has a cause” theory. He states that there are ordered lines of efficient causes, and nothing can be it’s own cause. Yet it is impossible for the line of efficient causes to extend into infinity.
God Essay Research Paper I think this
God Essay, Research Paper I think this is all valid because Saint Thomas Aquinas is saying that God has to exist sometime in life to make the Earth and nature and so forth. If their were to be a infinity then there would be no first or last causes to have happened. There would be no first or last causes to have happened.
The Eye Of The Dragon Essay Research
Paper Character Sketch In The Eyes of the Dragon, the author Stephen King shows that Thomas is more than just a character to us. Thomas shows his traits as being naivete, jealously, and low self-esteem in
Theology In The Middle Ages Essay Research
Paper Who were some of the outstanding theologians of the High Middle Ages and what were their ideas? Why was theology so important in the Middle Ages? For about the first 1000 years after the death of Christ, paganism, propoganda and superstition were popular beliefs. The thoughts of two theologians of the time period, Peter Abelard and Thomas Aquinas, would change this belief system forever.
Thomas Aquinas 4 Essay Research Paper The
Thomas Aquinas 4 Essay, Research Paper The tundra comprises of arctic plains encompassing most of the earth s terrain north of the coniferous forest belt. It is dominated by sedge, heath, moss, willow, and lichen. These areas are called the arctic tundra. Similar plains, which are called the alpine tundra, occur above the timberline in the high mountains of the world.
The Problem With Religion And Morals Essay
, Research Paper The Problem with Religion and Morals The likes of many philosophers including St. Anselm, Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine have written that organized religion is the only source of human beings leading a moral life. One of the defenses of organized religion is that it is the basis of society’s morals and therefore it is necessary to prevent social barbarism.
Does God Exist Essay Research Paper Does
Does God Exist? Essay, Research Paper Does God Exist? St. Thomas Aquinas has written several important works. Some of them are: The Disputed Questions on the Power of God, Exposition of Dionysius on the
D O E S G O
D E X I S T Essay, Research Paper D O E S G O D E X I S T ?St. Thomas Aquinas has written several important works. Some of them are: The Disputed Questions on the Power of God, Exposition of Dionysius on theDivine Names and Disputed Questions on Spiritual Creatures. Most ofAquinas’s works have been written to try to prove the existence of God.
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Critical Analysis Of The Ethics Of St
. Thomas Essay, Research Paper Critical Analysis on the Metaphysics of St. Thomas Aquinas Metaphysics is the philosophical study whose object is to determine the real nature of things to determine the meaning, structure, and principles of whatever is insofar as it is. Although this study is popularly conceived as referring to anything excessively subtle and highly theoretical and although it has been subjected to many criticisms, it is presented by metaphysicians as the most fundamental and most comprehensive of inquiries, inasmuch as it is concerned with reality as a whole.
Aquinas
’ First Proof Of The Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper I have chosen to write St. Thomas Aquinas proof citing motion as proof of the existence of God. Although I must admit to being a little confused the wording, I see it as being in terms of ability too, act of, and the first to act.
The Summa Teologica By Thomas Aquinas Essay
, Research Paper The Summa Theologica by Thomas Aquinas Born in Italy, Thomas Aquinas was one of the most educated men of his time. Aquinas, whose family were noble, was educated as a monk and later
Saint Thomas Aquinas Essay Research Paper Saint
Saint Thomas Aquinas Essay, Research Paper Saint Thomas Aquinas Saint Thomas Aquinas was a philosopher, theologian, Doctor of the Catholic Church, and is the patron saint of Catholic Universities, colleges, and schools. He was born in Rocca Secca, Italy, in 1225 and was born into a wealthy family. He even was related to the kings of Aragon, Castile, and France.
Thomas Aquinas 2 Essay Research Paper THOMAS
Thomas Aquinas 2 Essay, Research Paper THOMAS AQUINAS Saint Thomas Aquinas, as a philosopher, wrote several works that justified Christianity in a philosophical context, taking cue on Aristotle’s old writings. Naturally, Aquinas took up on the Church’s “ultra-conservative” views on sexuality and worked to rationalize them through his own theory of natural law.
St Thomas AquinasProofs Of Gods Existance Essay
, Research Paper St. Thomas Aquinas: Proofs of God?s existence. Aquinas says that God?s essence (feeling) is his existence. That there is no Actual need for proof of his existence. Before he actually developed his
Plato Essay Research Paper There are many
Plato Essay, Research Paper There are many ways in which the philosophy of Plato and Aristotle have reached that of that of Saint Thomas Aquinas, due to the fact that Aristotle thought the world that we live in today is the ultimate reality. While Plato thought the world that we see every day is real but is not the ultimate reality.
Oung Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper Young
Oung Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Young Thomas Edison I read the book Young Thomas Edison , by Sterling North. The book tells about Edison’s Young life and how he greatly succeeded through out the years. It tells about his
What Is God Who Is God Essay
, Research Paper What is God? Who is God? Why do some people conclude that a God exists? Saint Thomas Aquinas goes from the fact that there must be a first efficient cause to the conclusion that God is that cause. Why must Aquinas make the extraordinary jump from there being a cause, to assuming that this cause must be God? Would it not be just as plausible to make matter the first cause? Matter is the substance that any physical object is composed of.
Cosmological Argument Essay Research Paper How Well
Cosmological Argument Essay, Research Paper How Well Does the Cosmological Argument Hold Water? The Cosmological Argument is one of the most heavily disputed arguments for God’s existence of our time. The argument in its simplest form is: “Everything has to be caused by or created from something else . . . therefore there must be a first cause, namely God.” The very basis of the argument, everything is caused, is what makes it an argument.
Essay On Mary Thomas Story The Movie
) Essay, Research Paper Essay on Mary Thomas Story Mary and Isaiah Thomas face many problems in their community and they resist the bad influence because they have inner strength.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Man
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Man For All Seasons Essay In the play, A Man For All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is faced with a number of difficult choices, namely whether to support the King’s decision to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn and the consequences of that decision. More makes his decision to oppose the marriage early on, but even though it is something he does not waver from, he still has trouble with it, especially when he see the pain it causes to his wife and family.
Theory Of Knowledge Essay Research Paper Joe
Theory Of Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Joe Janszen Philosophy 390 Paper #1 10-1-00 Theory of Knowledge ? First Short Paper The skepticism of the existence of God has been a heavily discussed topic since the existence of man. Many philosophers have had many writings analyzing the facts and possibilities to prove this argument.
LAW Ceciro Plato Aristotle St Thomas Essay
, Research Paper QUESTION: Define the origins of natural law and the contributions of the following theorist. PLATO ? The idea that law should strive to reflect certain universal, absolute, and eternal truths or virtues.
Thomas Edison Essay Research Paper BibliographyThomas A
Thomas Edison Essay, Research Paper Bibliography Thomas A. Edison and his Kinetographic Motion Pictures. Rutgers University Press. 1995. This book gave me a lot of the information I needed on the basic history of Thomas Edison?s work in the motion picture industry. There were also pictures
LAW Ceciro Plato Socrates St Thomas Essay
, Research Paper REVIEWING KEY CONCEPTS 1) Define natural and positive law. Identify the fundamental differences between the theories of natural and positive law. Give an example to illustrate each of these theories.
Natural Law Theory Essay Research Paper Natural
Natural Law Theory Essay, Research Paper Natural Law Theory The natural law theory is a theory that dates back to the time of the Greeks and great thinkers like Plato and Aristotle. Defined as the law which states