"…A little rebellion now and then is a good thing…It is a medicine
necessary for the sound health of government." Thomas Jefferson Thoreau, a
transcendentalist from the mid 19th century and Martin Luther King Jr., the
Civil Rights movement leader of a century later both believed the necessity of
medicine for government. Although they showed disagreement of opinion on issues
regarding voting, both writers agreed on the necessity to reform the government
and the means of accomplishing it. In King’s Letter from Birmingham Jail and
Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience, both agreed on injustice of majority to rule over
minority, both resisted the government passively, and both wanted a better
government immediately. The majority is not necessarily right, but they have
always been the ones in power because they are the strongest and the most
influential. Therefore, all the laws are written by the majority, almost all are
in favor of the majority, and all are enforced by the majority. According to
King, a law drafted by the majority is only just when the minority are willing
to follow it. He wrote "An unjust law is a code that a numerical or power
majority group compels a minority group to obey but does not make binding on
itself" (2:475). In other words, if a law denies the right of the minority
or is inflicted upon the minority by force, then it is not a just law. Similar
opinions are shared by Thoreau, when he writes "But a government in which
the majority rule in all cases cannot be based on justice…"(1:1425). Both
agreed that if a law is unjust, it is the duty of the opposition to break the
law, and do what they believe to be right. Once a law is broken, the person must
be willing to accept the consequences, which may be the penalty of imprisonment.
Although laws may be unjust, but it must be respected regardless. King fears
that anarchy will result if laws are not respected; Thoreau describes that
rebellion will be the consequence if laws are not given respect. Consequently,
both chooses to passively resist the laws they believed that are against their
morals, and are prepared to accept imprisonment . The exercise of passive
resistance is the basis of the title of Thoreau’s work, and King presents
several examples of "civil disobedience" in his letter, including the
Boston Tea Party. King not only exercises passive resistance, he also provides
the procedure to be followed for any nonviolent campaign. They are: collection
of the facts to determine whether injustice exist; negotiation;
self-purification; and direct action (2:471). He points out that he has gone
through all the steps, and direct action is what brought him to the Birmingham
Jail. Recognition of injustice and passive resistance described by both authors
is to point out the need of government reformation. Thoreau calls for a better
government, immediately, and points out that the fastest way to improve
government is to "let every man make know what kind of government would
command his respect, and that will be one step toward obtaining it"
(1:1425). King does not directly states the need to reform government, but
instead, he states the need to reform the existing social structure, which goes
hand in hand with governmental progress. He advocates social equality and racial
justice, believing "Anyone who lives inside the United States can never be
considered an outsider anywhere within its bounds" (2:471), and passively
fighting against unjust laws forced upon the minority. Even though Thoreau
agreed with King on the issues, he also made contradictory statements directly
against what he supported. He wrote "If the injustice is part of the
necessary friction of the machine of government, let it go, let it go…"
stating that if injustice was inevitable and helped to improve government, then
it was justified. Opposed to his passive resistance, he also justified bloodshed
as he stated "But even suppose blood should flow. Is there not a sort of
blood shed when the conscience is wounded?" (1:1432). As for improvements
to government, he believed "That government is best which governs not at
all" (1:1425). Thoreau’s writing is vague, and mostly an appeal to the
intellect, which sharply contrasted with the writing of King, an appeal to the
emotion of the readers. Although both writing made similar points, they are also
a sharp contrast of the other and undoubtedly very unique.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth Essay Research Paper MacbethIf it hadn
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth If it hadn’t been for the three witches, Macbeth would never have killed Duncan nor Banquo. Macbeth, also would not have been killed my Macduff. The three witches are the
The Senegal Tribe Essay Research Paper The
The Senegal Tribe Essay, Research Paper The Senegal Tribe Many students of African history wonder why the native people of Africa did not rise up in violent rebellion against their Imperialist conquerers. What
King Tutankhamon Essay Research Paper Tutankhamon the
King Tutankhamon Essay, Research Paper Tutankhamon ,the 12th king of the 18th Dynasty, was only eight or nine years old at his succession. His father, Smenkhare, died at the age of 25, the cause remains a mystery.
Slaves Essay Research Paper Stephen B Oates
Slaves Essay, Research Paper Stephen B. Oates, the author, recalls the unlawful accounts of Nat’s mother, Nancy, while being forced into slavery. Being just a teenage, she was abducted in North’s Nile River Country by slave raiders. She was then marched hundreds of mils to the coast and sold to the Europeans.
Shay
’s Rebellion Essay, Research Paper I believe that the states had all the rights to take the tools and properties of the farmers to pay off the farmer’s debts. I think that the property was a kind of collateral for the money that the farmers borrowed for the ammunition. I do not think that Daniel Shays and his band of farmers had any right to rebel and close down the banks.
The Rose Essay Research Paper In Mexico
The Rose Essay, Research Paper In Mexico they celebrate the birth of Jesus and the coming of the three kings. Their celebrations begin 12 days before Christmas. When
Shays
’ Rebellion Essay, Research Paper Shays’ Rebellion After the American Revolution unsettled economic conditions and a severe depression tore the young nation. Paper money
Rebellion And Conformity Essay Research Paper A
Rebellion And Conformity Essay, Research Paper A Japanese proverb says, The nail that sticks out will be hammered down. Society tries to place many regulations on us as individuals as to what is admissible and what is not. We must decide for ourselves whether to conform to such a social decorum. We are taught as soon as we are old enough to grasp the idea that it is undesirable to be unique and to avoid being different.
The Whiskey Rebellion Essay Research Paper The
The Whiskey Rebellion Essay, Research Paper The Whiskey Rebellion Mike Klenosky 11/24/96 AP History per. 4 Ms. Valentino On August 1, 1794, President George Washington was once again leading
Gold In Grendel Essay Research Paper Gold
Gold In Grendel Essay, Research Paper Gold has many different uses. In John Gardner?s novel Grendel, it is used as a motif to symbolize different aspects of a character. Though it has a constant meaning throughout the novel, it also differs according to each character. Gardner uses gold as a symbol of majesty as well as protection, greed and power throughout the novel especially related to the characters of the Shaper, Hrothgar and the Dragon respectively.
Colonial Rule Essay Research Paper The English
Colonial Rule Essay, Research Paper The English colonies set up forms of representative government consisting of an appointed governor and a legislature, a law making body elected by voters. Having an appointed governor and a legislature sometimes led to tensions. The governor and the assembly frequently disagreed over taxes, the selection of other goverment officials, and defense of the colony.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper A Macbeth and
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper A. Macbeth and Banquo, Scottish generals, are returning after crushing a rebellion against Duncan ( King of Scotland ), when they are met by three witches. The witches
Whiskey Rebellion Essay Research Paper WHISKEY REBELLION
Whiskey Rebellion Essay, Research Paper WHISKEY REBELLION: Conflict & Government Towards the end of the 16th century, the United States government experienced continuous changes in laws(taxes) and several problems(battling and removal of Indians) associated with westward expansion. Conflict was created in response to the rising taxes issued by the government on goods such as whiskey.
Rebellion Essay Research Paper Long before the
Rebellion Essay, Research Paper Long before the actual act of rebellion, the thoughts and the sentiment of rebellion linger in the soul. These thoughts and feelings continue to fester before they reach the fruition of deed. Throughout the course of an extended period of time the uprising stems its roots in the heart; the actual revolt takes place within one s self, long before one mounts a rebellious action.
Tina Turner Essay Research Paper Tina Turner
Tina Turner Essay, Research Paper Tina Turner Tina Turner was born Anna Mae Bullock In 1939 on a small farm in Nutbush, Tennessee. At the age of 13, she was left with out a mother and a father. Anna went to live with her cousin in St. Louis. When she was 16 she would go to clubs with her sister in St. Louis. While in these clubs she saw a band called The Kings of Rhythm .
2 Chronicle Essay Research Paper solomon was
2 Chronicle Essay, Research Paper solomon was a king who had a hearts desire to have wisdom and knowledge from God so that he could lead his people whcih he says is Gods people. The significant
Hamlet Kings Essay Research Paper There are
Hamlet Kings Essay, Research Paper There are many differences between the Kings Hamlet and Claudius with very few similarities. Perhaps the similarities stop at being the product of the same
Zues Essay Research Paper A Stranger in
Zues Essay, Research Paper A Stranger in the Valley of the Kings by: Ahmed Osman The book “Stranger in the Valley of the Kings” was an account of the pharaohs of Egypt in the Hyksos’ rain over Egypt.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper In Macbeth I
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper In Macbeth, I believe the story would have been completely different. Why? If it hadn?t been for the three witches, Macbeth would never have killed Duncan nor Banquo.
Descriptive Essay On William Wallace 1 Pg
. Essay, Research Paper A Descriptive Essay On William Wallace A man of low status and called by some an outlaw or bandit, it may have been that Wallace was being used by more powerful Scottish politicians as a cover for their rebellion so they would not break their feudal vows to the king of England.
1984 Book Report Essay Research Paper Winston
1984 Book Report Essay, Research Paper Winston’s first act of rebellion is buying and writing in a diary. This act is known as a thought crime and is punishable by death. A thought crime is any bad thought against the government of Oceania. Winston commits many thought crimes and becomes paranoid about being caught, which he knows is inevitable (Greenblast 113).
Spain Essay Research Paper Spain is located
Spain Essay, Research Paper Spain is located in southwest Europe. Spain?s official name is Reino de Espana, which means, ?Kingdom of Spain.? The capitol of Spain is Madrid, which is
Louis X1V Outline Essay Research Paper I
Louis X1V Outline Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction II. Political Crisis A. Religious Disputes 1.Development of science (the new philosphy) a. Undermining of church authority and Kings in Rule
Macbeth Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth who
Macbeth Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth, who is hailed by the three witches as the ancestor of kings. Macbeth is an intelligent spiritual likeness of a villain-hero who feels his own guilt
Banquo Soliloquy Essay Research Paper John SpitzerEnglishIn
Banquo Soliloquy Essay, Research Paper John Spitzer English In Macbeth, a play by William Shakespeare, Banquo’s soliloquy at the beginning of the third act explains some of his present feeling towards Macbeth. He believes that Macbeth killed to become the King of Scotland. He explains that he is the one who will start a chain of kings, not Macbeth.
Is Antigone A Feminist Or AntiFeminist Play
? Essay, Research Paper Ahmed B. Karim Antigone Essay (Is Antigone a Feminist/Anti-Feminist Play) Sunday, Oct. 31, 2000 I think Antigone was a feminist play because of three main facts. Antigone was in all the conflicts, even though Creon started them all, even though Creon had all the power, Antigone still won the war between her and Creon, also no woman in her time would even think of doing the things that Antigone did.
Louis Riel Essay Research Paper Louis RielLouis
Louis Riel Essay, Research Paper Louis Riel Louis Riel should not have been hung because he represented those who couldn t represent themselves. Louis Riel was disappointed with the way the M tis were, so he took it upon himself to represent the M tis and their rights. Even though the actions that followed, such as keeping the new governor out the colony, were illegal and very wrong.
King Arthur Essay Research Paper Real King
King Arthur Essay, Research Paper Real King Arthur In The Once and Future King, Portayal of the Middle Ages is thought to be made of magnificent castles, beautiful clothing, great kings and queens everything and everyone perfect. No proof of the.Towns back then were not pretty. Dirt thrived in cities there were diseases and crud everywhere.