, Research Paper
Urban Renewal in Boston
the West End and Government Center
Boston’s West End is the most well documented neighborhood destroyed by urban “renewal,” made famous initially by Herbert Gans’s book, The Urban Villagers, 1962. Although approximately 63 percent of the families displaced by urban renewal were African-American or Hispanic, this Boston community was mainly inhabited by working class Italians. It was a little piece of Italy, with narrow winding streets alive with urban social life. Too crowded and unAmerican for the middle class tastes of City planners, it fell to the bulldozer in 1959 and was replaced by high rise, expensive apartment buildings.
————————————————
It is difficult for me to isolate the impact of *URBAN VILLAGERS*. In
my experience it was but one contribution to growing criticism of urban
renewal in the early 1960s and, with that, the physical orientation of
urban planning that urban renewal represented. Shortly after it was
published I was both a writing my dissertation in urban geography at
Clark University and a project director in urban renewal, so I
witnessed the impact in both urban renewal planning circles and in the
more academic arena. It was part of the drum of criticism that led to
the 1966 Model Cities Act and the redefinition of urban renewal and
rethinking of the field of urban planning.
I think the impact of the *URBAN VILLAGERS* might best evaluated as
part of a creeping barrage of critical writing led off by Jacobs and
*Death and Life . . .* in 1961. *Urban Villagers* was published in
‘63 and Martin Anderson weighed in from the right in ‘64 with *The Federal
Bulldozer*. At the same time planners such as Paul Davidoff (”Advocacy
and Pluralism in Planning” JAIP, 1965) were mounting a critique within
the field of planning. (Jay Stein’s *Classic Readings in Urban
Planning* 1995 includes some writing from this period.) In 1965,
The National Council of Mayors published *With Heritage So Rich* which
documented the destruction of historic buildings caused by urban renewal
and served as the mandate for the National Historic Preservation Act of
1966. Although not concerned with urban renewal directly, Blake’s
*God’s Own Junkyard* (1964) was a popular and graphically arresting
treatment of the trashing of the built environment. My own memory is
that so much was being written that we were responding to the larger
trend more than to specific books.
At the same time the Federal urban renewal program was trying to move
away from the great emphasis on redevelopment by demolition with the
initiation of the Community Renewal Program (CRP) in 1959, which was
more neighborhood and socially oriented. And the final element I will
throw in this stew is the Highway Act of 1962 which started the
metropolitan transportation studies, the goal of which was to bring the
interstate system to cities. Many cities such as Hartford tried to
coordinate the urban interstate system with urban renewal; elsewhere
the transportation planning of the state and the local urban renewal
planning was not well coordinated.
I would say, speaking from being in the trenches at that time, that the
*Urban Villagers* did not have a big direct impact on urban renewal in
cities but, along with others, laid the groundwork for changing
programs and practice. Urban renewal was a juggernaut, and work such as
Gans and others may have intensified urban renewal as its adocates and
supporters sensed they had a limited time to get their work done. The
value of Gans’ book was that it moved some of Jacobs’ generalizations
into a specific neighborhood and ethnic context that could be related
to other areas. To those of us working in Massachusetts who knew the
history of the BRA and the North End, it was a particularly scathing
critique.
I hope this helps. I would be very interested in what you find because
I think the *Urban Villagers* has become as important for its symbolism
as for its insights into community.
David L. Ames
Professor of Urban Affairs and Geography
University of Delaware
Bibliography
me andu
Другие работы по теме:
Comparison Of Kingstons And Jacksons Stories Essay
, Research Paper This paper examines the theories of Dean Barnlund regarding culture and how Shirly Jackson and Maxine Kingston demonstrate Barnlund’s ideas. The paper will specifically look at how culture dominates the behavior of people, how and why culture is so powerful that very few people realize the impact that it has on them, and how culture completely surrounds people.
Tradition Is The Guide Of The Ignorant
Essay, Research Paper Tradition is the Guide of the Ignorant In “The Lottery” author Shirley Jackson takes us to a place in which a tradition is passed down generation after generation. However, over the years, the “lottery” has lost any significant meaning and the villagers follow tradition without even knowing why the tradition exists.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper The LotteryThis
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper The Lottery This story reveals how selfish people can be in the society. In “The Lottery” villagers are an isolated group of individuals who could careless about one another, even their own family members. Although the author doesn’t explain why this village is completely separated from the rest of the world, the story truly reflects our society, that people ignore bad events happening around the world, as long those bad events do not happen to them.
The Knife Essay Research Paper The knifeBy
The Knife Essay, Research Paper The knife By: Alfred Hitchcock Everybody has read a horror story before at some point, but a story from Alfred Hitchcock is different because at the end he leaves the reader thinking what has
Leaver Cultrures Essay Research Paper Any culture
Leaver Cultrures Essay, Research Paper Any culture that takes just what it needs form the surroundings and leaves the rest is called a leaver culture. These people are very nomadic, such as the pygmies in the Forest People. Leavers move to an area that they fell they can live off the surroundings for awhile without using everything up.
The Lottery As An Allegory Essay Research
Paper Jackson s “The Lottery” as an Allegory Shirley Jackson s “The Lottery” is an excellent example of an allegorical short story. In this story, the reader learns of a town s “lottery” that takes place once a year, every year. It has been a tradition in this small rural town for many years and the villagers never question these activities, they just blindly go along with it.
East Francia Economy Essay Research Paper Booty
East Francia Economy Essay, Research Paper Booty, tribute and lan had been driving force of Eastern Empire revival on 8th century, contued in ninth century.? But also general population increase after
The Lottery And Human Detachment Essay Research
? Paper In the short story, ?The Lottery,? Shirley Jackson aids the reader in shaping some horrific images of her characters. Each and every one of the villagers Jackson portrays manages to remove herself from the lives of friends and family so that she is able to stone another fellow villager to death. Jackson clearly proves that when a person removes herself emotionally from the lives of her friends and family, she is able to kill another person without any regrets.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper At the
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper At the end of “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, Tessie Hutchinson said, “It isn’t fair.” Tessie was correct; the lottery wasn’t fair. Death wasn’t fair, especially if you were the sacrificial lamb for the sake of tradition.”Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon,” took many innocent lives each year since the first settlers.
Modernist Art In Europe Essay Research Paper
Modernist Art in Europe 1910-25 by Robert l. Herbert Herbert?s thesis of his essay is to investigate the arrival of the machine and modern art and its complexities. During WWI, modernist painting and sculpture paid major attention to machinery, science and industry. Modern art during that time has become a central factor in our culture due to its dominance in public art, museums, media and literature.
Daddy Essay Research Paper Plath
Daddy Essay, Research Paper Plath’s poem “Daddy” describes her feelings of oppression from her childhood and conjures the struggle many women face in a male-dominated society. The conflict of this poem is male authority versus the right of a female to control her own life and be free of male domination. Plath’s conflicts begin with her father and continue into the relationship between her and her husband.
Most Imp Scene
– Great Exp. Stage 3 Essay, Research Paper The most dramatic scene in stage three of Great Expectations is when Pip goes back to Miss Havisham’s to confront her about pretending to be, or at least leading Pip to believe that she was, his benefactor. At first, Miss Havisham doesn’t understand why Pip has come.
Various Styles And Types Of Music Essay
, Research Paper The names of the various styles and types of music culturally associated with my country are at first there is folk music and then there is urban music then comes all the
City And Village Life Essay Research Paper
City Life And Village Life A village is composed of small population that is not advanced whereas a city is very advanced and has large population. Life in a village is completely different from life in a city. This difference is like distinction between earth and sky. These lifestyles are totally different from each other.
Daddy By Plath Essay Research Paper Plaths
Daddy By Plath Essay, Research Paper Plath?s poem "Daddy" describes her feelings of oppression from her childhood and conjures the struggle many women face in a male-dominated society.
Things Fall Apart Summary Essay Research Paper
Things Fall Apart Essay The book “Things Fall Apart” by Chinua Achebe, is about a man named Okonkwo,who is a member of the Umuofia clan in Nigeria. Okonkwo was the son of a shameful man, named Unoka. Unoka was shameful because he feared blood, wasted money, his children and wife went hungry often and he died from a swelling stomach and limbs, and was sent to the Evil Forest to die.
Monkey
’s Paw Essay, Research Paper In The Monkey s Paw , author William Jacobs conveys the message that fate rules peoples lives, and that those who try to interfere with fate do so at their own peril. This premise is clearly shown as the plot of this clever story unfolds. Sergeant Morris reluctantly gave Mr. White the monkey s paw, but warned him of the consequences.
Urban And The Council Of Clermont Essay
, Research Paper There are many accounts of that day in November, 1095. Some were written by monks, others by bishops, and even a few by warriors themselves. Historians are constantly asking, “What exactly did Pope Urban II say at the council of Clermont to persuade Christians to set forth on such a difficult venture as the Crusades?” One man, an early 12th century cleric named Fulcher of Chartres wrote perhaps the best historical chronicle of the events at Clermont and the speech of Urban II.Fulcher begins his account with a prologue that states how blessed the journeymen of the Crusades were to take up such a conquest.
Fitting The Poor Into The Econ Essay
, Research Paper In the article “Fitting the Poor into the Economy” Herbert Gans provides a number of antidotes to poverty which i fell will help sturgling familys and
Social Evolution Essay Research Paper Herbert Spencer
Social Evolution Essay, Research Paper Herbert Spencer and Franz Boaz had two opposing theories on the social evolution theory. Each theory was difficult to prove but great theories. But both theories had it s ups and downs . Herbert Spencer was born in England, he is best known for developing and applying the evolutionary theory to philosophy and psychology.
Anaylsis Of The Painted Bird By Kosinski
Essay, Research Paper Kosinski emphasizes social change in his chilling account of the nightmares of World War II. As Hitler uproots Europe, a young boy experiences horrors unimaginable to Western civilization. Despite the unrelentless actions of the villagers toward the strange boy, the reasons for such actions changed from those of fear of the boy himself to the fear of the punishment administered by the Germans had learned about the boy living in the village.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Singer
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Singer s Gimpel the Fool is written in first person point of view, and the narrator, Gimpel, is the main character in the story. In the opening paragraph in the story Singer shows how reliable of a narrator that Gimpel is. Gimpel shares many of the nicknames he has had given to him in school, including imbecile, donkey, flax-head, dope, glump, ninny, and fool.
Great Expectations 4 Essay Research Paper Charles
Great Expectations 4 Essay, Research Paper Charles Dickens wrote Great Expectations in the 19th century. His main character, Pip, recieves money from a benefactor, but does not find out who it is until the end. The question Dickens may have tried to get across was, “do you believe money makes you happy?” Well, it depends on who you ask.
The Need For Honesty Essay Research Paper
The Need for People Honesty. Everyones heard the tale of the Boy who cried Wolf right? Sure, shepherd boy thinks he’s funny, makes a fuss about imaginary wolfs, villagers come running – no wolf. Then when wolfs actually do come, he yells and screams, yet villagers weren’t about to play his game again, his sheep get nailed by the wolves.
The Choking Doberman Essay Research Paper My
The Choking Doberman Essay, Research Paper My Analysis The Choking Doberman by Jan Harold Brunvand; is a collection of urban legends and their meanings and/or origins. It discusses various urban legends and there apparent meanings. Each chapter provides several versions of a single legend and several other related legends, along with Brunvand s synopsis of each and quotes from people he surveyed.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper In Shirley
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper In Shirley Jackson?s “The Lottery,” she uses the element of surprise. The way the story ends is unlike anything anyone could predict. There are however several alternative ways
Buzzwords And Labels Essay Research Paper In
Buzzwords And Labels Essay, Research Paper In Merriam Webster?s Collegiate Dictionary poverty is defined as the state of one who lacks a usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions. We all have heard the terms used to describe the underclass, but are these buzzword or labels harmful to our society? In the reading Deconstructing the Underclass written by Herbert Gans, discusses the effects of buzzwords or labels.
Suburban Living Vs Urban Living Essay Research
Paper Suburban Living Vs. Urban Living In the early nineteenth century, during the Industrial Revolution, Americans gradually began selling their farms and trading the common suburban life with the adventurous fast-pace urban life. Today the majority of the American population chooses to dwell in cities, towns or suburbs; however, there are still many families living the country lifestyle.
Joel Chandler Harris Essay Research Paper Joel
Joel Chandler Harris Essay, Research Paper Joel Chandler Harris’ stories are so impressive because of the way he presents them and because of their humorous wisdom. Unlike many stories about black culture, Harris’ stories were taken from blacks that he had actually known. Moreover, stories such as “How Mr.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Slips of
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Slips of Fate In the short story "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson, the author uses irony to expand on a theme of traditions that continue although they are ludicrous and barbaric. "Like a lamb to slaughter" comes to mind for both the characters in this story and the reader.
Urban Heat Islands Essay Research Paper Urban
Urban Heat Islands Essay, Research Paper Urban Heat Islands For more than 100 years, it has been known that two adjacent cities are generally warmer than the surrounding areas. This region of city warmth, known