Legal Vs. Illegal Essay, Research Paper
Legal vs. Illegal (Napster vs. Music Industry)
The issues that will be slugged out in federal district court in San Francisco sound a little too pop culture to be all that serious. How many music CDs are people buying these days in record stores throughout the nation because of Napster? Is the technology that Napster uses legal? Napster is, of course, the wildly popular file-sharing service whose 20 million users have downloaded some half a billion songs–most copyrighted for free. The technology that Napster has brought to music listeners across the globe has allowed the freedom of obtaining music for free and should not be shut down by the entertainment industry’s argument in federal court.
The laws that support a technology like Napster argue the legality issue of Napster; Napster is legal. The general idea of Napster’s argument is that there are enough exemptions in the copyright laws to permit Napster to exist. As long as a user of Napster is using the program for personal use and does not gain proceeds from it the program is not being used illegally. Napster cites the 1992 Audio Home Recording Act, which allows anyone to copy music for “noncommercial use”(Kahn 50). This act basically states that anyone may record music for personal use, but not for a profit of any kind. The act also makes no mention of the number of copies that may be made. Secondly, Napster’s argument rests on another act applied to Internet service providers and search engines. Napster is not responsible for its user actions with the materials that they (the user) retrieves using Napster. The 1998 Digital Millennium Copyright Act states that, “a search engine is exempt from copyright claims if the company that owns it is unaware that the information the engine retrieves violates copyrights (Kahn 51).” Napster barely meets the definition of an Internet service provider; although it is considered a search engine because of its browser capabilities. Basically theses two acts state that Napster is neither liable for its users actions and allows its users to record music (using Napster) for their private use. These are major laws that help support Napster and digital recording efforts.
Many artists themselves are pro-Napster in many aspects of what they think it brings society. Napster allows for individuals to hear and experience different forms of music; therefore purchasing and promoting artists work. Some artists argue that it allows the public to be attentive to music that artists are putting out on the market. Fred Durst from Limp Bizkit said, “We believe that the Internet and Napster should not be ignored by the music industry as tools to promote awareness for bands and market music” (Napster 1). Fred Durst was describing how the music industry needs to recognize Napster as a type of advertisement of their product. Madonna was also quoted saying; “Napster could be a great way for people to hear your music who wouldn’t have the chance to hear it on the radio” (Napster 1). This quote from Madonna helps to describe how people are enabled to hear music from different artists through Napster allowing artists to be heard and be recognized by the public. Chuck D also supported Napster’s use replying, “We should think of (Napster) as a new kind of radio—a promotional tool that can help artists who don’t have the opportunity to get their music played on mainstream radio or on MTV be recognized” (Napster 2). Chuck D also expresses the idea of Napster as a promotional tool for artists. Intern allowing listeners too experience new genres of music and artists to be heard. Other artists have supported Napster saying that is a free trade community of music and should not be shut down. Wasn’t one of the first things we were taught as a child was to share? This is what the users of Napster are doing; there just sharing music files not committing crimes. Dave Matthews describes technologies and events that occur in the music industry that are like Napster saying, “There are a lot of bigger problems in the world than whether Napster succeeds or fails…I don’t think there is a malice coming out of Napster. We allow people to tape our concerts. But my thinking was that it only makes people want to buy more and increases the devotion of people who are going to listen to us” (Napster 1). Dave Matthews said Napster is exactly what Napster itself is trying to prove in court; that it is a legal free-trade community. Courtney Love supports Napster in the legality of trading music saying, “Stealing our copyright provisions in the dead of night when no-one is looking is piracy. It’s not piracy when kids swap music over the Internet using Napster. There were one billion downloads last year, but music sales are way up, so how is Napster hurting the music industry? It’s not. The only people who are scared of Napster are the people who have filler on their albums and are afraid that if people hear more than one single they’re not going to buy the album” (Napster 2). Courtney Love tells the truth about what Napster is and what it stands for, by backing it up with physical evidence. All four of these artist allow for the courts to have an insight into the artists point of view and how Napster as a technology is not hurting the music industry, but supporting not only struggling artists but well known artists as well.
The other major point that defends Napster is the previous case about a new technology which the entertainment industry took to court. Napster’s users are not doing anything worse than if they recorded a video tape or a cassette tape for themselves. In 1984 the movie companies tried to stop Sony from selling VCRs because they feared widespread copying of movies and television shows (Kahn 50). The Sony Betamax case ruled that, “new technologies should not be judicially banned (or re-engineered) unless the only substantional use of which they are capable is unlawful” (Fitzpatrick10). This ruling of this past court case easily defends Napster, as long as it is not used for an illegal action that would violate copyright laws. This piece of evidence used in the court case against Napster is the main argument that Napster is a legal technology.
Compromises and contradictions towards Napster are simple, but do not overcome the total argument that Napster has against the music industry. The big concern for the music industry is that the future presence of Napster may start a loss of profits for the music industry because of the supposed illegal replication that Napster users carry out. Although most users use Napster and still buy recordings, some may never buy a recording again causing the music industry’s minor profit losses. The music companies have collected surveys that suggest the rate at which people will buy their music will decrease by 3.2% each year (AAP 1). This is the first slip in Napster’s argument, but doesn’t allow much space for the music industry to inch ahead in this court case. The information presented by the music industry may not be a legitimate survey of the public. Although the majority of individuals may not commit illegal crimes with Napster some may use it illegally. The feud of whether or not Napster is being used illegally by some users is the music industry’s major argument(Fitzpatrick 10). The only difficulty is that this kind of illegal use is untraceable on a technology like Napster (Kahn 51). If this kind of music piracy is committed there is really no way to apprehend the user. The issue of piracy of the music industry’s product is the true evidence that goes against Napster and digital recording of music. These are the major points that are against Napster’s argument, but does not really give up all that much round because of its other arguments to defend itself.
As the court case arrives, the question that people will ponder is, “Is Napster really legal?” The answer to this question is yes. With all of the points that the Napster attorneys have to back up the technology of Napster and its browser capabilities, it should and will win this battle in federal court.
AAP. “Artist Against Piracy” Launch National Media Campaign On The Issue Of Music And The Internet. [Online] Available.artists against piracy/news/press.html, October 27, 2000.
Fitzpatrick, Eileen. “Napster Appeal May Hinge On Sony Betamax”Billboard 23 September 2000, Vol. 112 Issue 39, 10.
Kahn, Jeremy. “Proving Napster Legal Is A Tough Job For Boies”Fortune 02 October 2000, Vol.142 Issue 7, 50-51.
Napster.Artists Sound Off. [Online] Available.napster/speakout/artists.html, October 26, 2000.
Другие работы по теме:
Abortion Essay Research Paper ConceptionI believe that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Conception: I believe that life begins at the ending of the first trimester through the pregnancy. I consider it a human when there is a beating heart and a brain that is functioning. A beating heart to me represents that there is life, and that there is signs of growth, while still in the mother’s womb.
Unnecessary Sacrifice Essay Research Paper Just as
Unnecessary Sacrifice Essay, Research Paper Just as we wonder how past civilizations could be so barbaric as to practice sacrifice, future generations may wonder how our society could be so barbaric as to sacrifice even the unborn. Thus abortion should not be made legal.
Opium Essay Research Paper What is opium
Opium Essay, Research Paper What is opium? What does it look like? And what were the different uses for opium? Opium is a plant which is also an addicting drug and medical remedy for sickness. Opium was first brought from Arabian traders, to bring the teaching of opium in a medical use. Opium looks like a tall growing flower which has little round poppies growing around it.
Legal And Illegal Essay Research Paper Ok
Legal And Illegal Essay, Research Paper Ok, there are 3 types of people that live in the country, Residents (both legal and illegal), citizens of the U.S., and Citizens of the
Blind Ambition Essay Research Paper Blind AmbitionJohn
Blind Ambition Essay, Research Paper Blind Ambition John Dean was counsel to the President. He wanted power and superiority. To advance up the ladder, John Dean got involved in certain activities. Some of which were not legal. One example would be the extortion of money. John Dean didn?t really think of the consequences but of the rewards.
Illegal Aliens Essay Research Paper Illegal AliensThere
Illegal Aliens Essay, Research Paper Illegal Aliens There are an estimated 5 million illegal aliens living in the United States. 300,000 are added to this number every year. It is also estimated that over one million transient illegal aliens are in the United States at any time. These estimations would be much higher if nearly three million illegal aliens were not given amnesty in 1986, allowing them to become legal members of our society.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Jason Adams
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Jason Adams Adams1 October 15, 1998 Mrs. Faulk English Per.4Euthanasia Euthanasia should be legal, because if it is their life, therefore, they have the right to be able to end their suffering. Euthanasia was formerly called Mercy killing . Euthanasia means intentionally making someone decease rather then allowing that person to die naturally.
Controlling Immigration Essay Research Paper With the
Controlling Immigration Essay, Research Paper With the many different groups of people coming to this country in search of a better life. I believe that we should better control Immigration to the U.S.. Since I am born native to the U.S. it is hard for me to say that others are not allowed to come into the U.S. But throughout this report there is evidence why control of immigration is needed.
Marijuana Essay Research Paper IssuesThe issue I
Marijuana Essay, Research Paper Issues The issue I would like to bring up is the legalization of medical and/or recreational marijuana. I feel this would be beneficial to most everyone, both users and non-users. Marijuana has been proven to help a great deal for glaucoma sufferers as stated in the Hallucinogenic Encyclopedia.
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia in the United States gives rights to the people. Rights to those who endure the irrefutable agony of pain and suffering, rights to those who want to be cured of their pain, and rights to those that struggle to end their suffering. Euthanasia is the answer to end their suffering.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Specific Purpose To
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience that prostitution should be legal. Introduction I. Open with Impact: If Ann Landers is for prostitution, then how far out can the notion be?
Legal Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution has
Legal Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution has long been considered as illegal. But is it necessary to do so? It is said that prostitution causes inconvenience and troubles to general public. However, the act that considers prostitution as illegal causes inconvenience and troubles to prostitutes either.
Legalizing Marijuana Essay Research Paper Legalizing MarijuanaMarijuana
Legalizing Marijuana Essay, Research Paper Legalizing Marijuana Marijuana becoming legal is a topic every American should agree on. The reason being is it would benefit Americans in three ways; there would be less crowding in jails, it would create more tax income, and it would cut down the amount of crime in the country.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
Freedom Of Choice Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom Of Choice Essay, Research Paper Freedom Of Choice Since 1973 abortion has been an important controversial issue to the United States. The problem begins should it be a womans choice whether or not to terminate her pregnancyor should it be the goverments choice. This is where a woman looses her rights as a person.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My personal opinion
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My personal opinion about abortion is that it should stay legal. I believe that it is the woman’s choice because it’s her body, and no one else should be allowed to tell her what she can, and can’t do with it.
Marijuana Essay Research Paper MarijuanaBetter Kept IllegalMarijuanaColliers
Marijuana Essay, Research Paper Marijuana Better Kept Illegal Marijuana Collier?s Encyclopedia defines marijuana as a crude drug composed of the leaves, stems, and flowering buds of the Indian hemp plant, Cannabis sativa. The flowering tops of the plant secrete a sticky resin that contains the psychoactive material for which marijuana is used.
Tobacco Essay Research Paper Tobacco Products Must
Tobacco Essay, Research Paper Tobacco Products Must Be Illegal How is it possible for something that kills so many people to be legal in a country that boasts the supreme protection of it?s citizens?
The Legal Drinking Age Essay Research Paper
The Legal Drinking Age The legal drinking age is twenty-one years old. There is no justification for it to be that high. Many reasons support it being lowered. The legal drinking age in the in the United States should be changed to eighteen years old.
Legal Cheating Essay Research Paper Legal cheatingI
Legal Cheating Essay, Research Paper Legal cheating I was never really good in Latin, although I had taken it for 5 years. The final exam was near and would decide whether I failed or passed the class. There were just 6 people and all the students were very smart and had an average of about 95%. I had a normal average of 86%.
To Welcome With Open Arms Essay Research
Paper Many Americans have skewed notions about immigration, and those perceptions influence decision in Washington and presidential candidates on the campaign trail. Some people think immigration is out of control; a few suggest that it should be stopped altogether. The problem is that many people have illegal immigration and legal immigration mixed up.
Legalized Drugs Essay Research Paper I resolve
Legalized Drugs Essay, Research Paper I resolve that the use of drugs in our country should be legalized. Most illegal drugs are just as dangerous and harmful as legal ones. The wide spread propaganda that illegal drugs are “deadly poisons” is a hoax. There is little or no medical evidence of long term ill effects from sustained, moderate consumption of uncontaminated marijuana, cocaine, or heroine.
Abortion ProChoice Essay Research Paper Abortion ProChoiceIt
Abortion: Pro-Choice Essay, Research Paper Abortion: Pro-Choice It should be strictly between a doctor and his/her patient whether or not an abortion should be performed. Many Anti-Choicers give us their speeches about how immoral abortions are, but different people have different morals. I personally would not have an abortion, but I think that whoever wants an abortion should be given the option.
Why It Should Be Legal Essay Research
Paper Why Marijuana Should be Legal For my final paper I am going to do it on why marijuana should be legal. I will provide factual information that will prove that there are more reasons that it should be legal than illegal. Using studies done by doctors and scientist that prove that it is used to cure many illnesses and medical conditions.
Abortion Essay Research Paper The most important
Abortion Essay, Research Paper The most important issue in balancing individual human rights with social responsibility in my point of view is abortion. The law that was passed so that abortions would be legal was a good decision. The anti-abortions have very sound points, but it should be up to the women to make her choice.
Drugs In Sport Essay Research Paper The
Drugs In Sport Essay, Research Paper The topic I am going to discuss today is Drugs in Sport. My contention is that drugs should not be made legal in sports.
Legalizing Drugs Essay Research Paper Legalizing Drugs
Legalizing Drugs Essay, Research Paper Legalizing Drugs Drugs shouldn’t be illegal, because if drugs are illegal, shouldn’t cigarettes and alcohol be illegal as well? Making drug’s legal will have a very good effect on society and the economy. So why not just make drugs legal?