Paper
Should Quebec Separate from Canada?Throughout the world, Canada is known as a domestically tranquil, economically prosperous, mulitcultural society. Yet, for some reason, in one of its provinces, Quebec, a number of people are dissatisfied with Quebec s relationship with the rest of Canada and want to secede. The issue of secession is not new, in fact, the Quebecois voted on this very same controversial subject in 1980, ending in a sixty-forty split in favor of the federalists; those who wished to remain Canadians (Channel One) In the weeks before the current vote the polls show a fifty-fifty split, marking a clear and true division among both the Anglo phone and Francophone Canadians.( ABC News) To secede would create a state of paralysis leading to an economic crisis the likes of which, Canadians have never before experienced and truly cannot imagine. Therefore Quebec should not separate from Canada.Quebec should remain a part of Canada, due to the fact that the problems facing the Quebecois wouldn t diminish or be resolved. Quebec always has been and always will be a respected, distinct society within Canada, and leaving Canada now would adversely affect more than just the Quebecois. First, the problems facing Quebec would not diminish or be resolved through separation. The economic uncertainties that have plagued Quebec, such as joblessness, high taxes, high government spending, as well as high interest rates would not lessen. Businesses would pull out of Quebec due to concerns over instability, thereby causing a higher rate of unemployment (Channel One) The rising number of people who would require financial assistance would rise dramatically, swamping, and maybe even surpassing, the government s ability to give aid ( James 78)Quebec would have to create new bureaucracy to replace current Canadian services that are designed to help improve social problems such as teen pregnancy and elevated drop out rates (Channel One). Without federal funds, this would prove to be impossible, and in all likelihood such problems would grow. Without a well educated work force Quebec will flounder in the global marketplace, adding a further burden to the government and people. History has proven that, in countries where there is such instability and economic hardship crime rates skyrocket (James 78). For years the Quebecois have complained of the repression of the French language and culture, and of unfair treatment by the rest of Canada. Yet ninety percent of French Canadians agree that the French language is more secure now than ever (Black 19) and that English speaking Canadians believe that Quebec always has been and always will be a respected, distinct society within Canada. To prove just how much they value Quebec, the Supreme Court of Canada, in its interpretation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, has recognized Quebec s status as a distinct society, and requires the consent of Ottawa( Canada s Capital) and any seven provinces that make up at least fifty percent of the population of Canada to make any changes. even that hasn t stopped Quebec s or rather Parizeau s whining. To further placate Quebec, many proposals for change have been suggested, such as, 1) The restoration and formal recognition of Quebec s traditional right to a constitutional veto; 2) Chretien (Canada s Prime Minister) has promised to never allow the constitution to be changed in a way that affects Quebec without their consent. (Wilson 14). It is obvious to anyone that Canada s willingness to create such changes demonstrates their desire to be a whole country, as well as how inflexible and childish Quebec s leaders really are.
Third, leaving Canada would adversely affect beyond just Quebec. The United States, Canada, and Mexico would all be forced to decide whether or not they will accept Quebec into NAFTA, the North American Trade Agreement (Channel One). Quebec “shouldn t take for granted” that there will be the same kind of ties , warns US Secretary of State, Warren Christopher (Lewis 4) Also, Canada would face the possibility of breaking up completely. “There are no guarantees,” predicts Gordon Gibson, author of Plan B: The Future of the Rest of Canada, “that there will be only one new country.” (Symonds A8-9). The secession of Quebec would separate the Maritime provinces from mainland Canada and a unilateral declaration of independence would most certainly result in a sharp drop in the value of the Canadian dollar, plunging Canada into a terrible recession (Gibson 134). To conclude it is fair to say that not only would Canada be incomplete without Quebec s culture and language, but the secession would have very dire consequences for Quebec because, being a Canadian, I know that Canada would punish Quebec for leaving in every way possible. The ideaof secession was just that- an idea. It will not become a reality because the Quebecois are Canadians, and Canadians belong within Canada. Should Quebec Separate from Canada?Melanie McRaeThursday, September 26, 1996
Black, Shirley. “How Canada Feels About Quebec s Status” The Toronto Star. Sept. 4, 1995: 19-20A. Gibson, Gordon. Plan B: The Future of the Rest of Canada. Ed. David Bender. Toronto, Doubleday Press, 1995. James, Thomas. ” The Economic Uncertainties of Secession.” Maclean s7 March 1995:78-84. Jennings, Peter. ABC News Nov. 8, 1995. Lewis, Connor. “How the Seccesion of Quebec Would Affect America”. The New York Times 7 Feb. 1995:26-31Valverde, Ralle. Channel One. Nov. 5, 1995
Другие работы по теме:
Quebec Sovereignty Essay Research Paper Is sovereignty
Quebec Sovereignty Essay, Research Paper Is sovereignty a viable option for Quebec? From the days of Upper and Lower Canada up until the Meech Lake accord and Charlottetown agreements, there have been never-ending conflicts between Quebec and the federal government. For decades, Canada has been hearing cries of salvation for a dying language and a repressed culture.
The Meech Lake Accord Essay Research Paper
The Meech Lake Accord By:_______________________ The Meech Lake Accord was an agreement made by the prime minister of Canada and the premiers of all ten provinces to improve and make changes to the constitution of Canada and thereby make it acceptable to the province of Quebec. The agreement was negotiated and signed on June 3, 1987 but was never ratified.
The Failure Of The Meech Lake Accord
Essay, Research Paper The Meech Lake Accord was an attempt by Canadian Prime Minister Brian Mulroney to get Quebec to sign the 1982 Constitution. Quebec, led by Premier Robert Bourassa, submitted five demands. The first demand, a formal voice of Quebec in Supreme Court appointments. Second, say on immigration policy toward Quebec.
Quebec The Province The People The History
Essay, Research Paper Quebec, The Province, The People, The History Quebec is a province in eastern Canada, bordered on the north by Hudson Strait and Ungava Bay; on the east by Labrador (Which is a part of Newfoundland),
Relations Essay Research Paper Events That Helped
Relations Essay, Research Paper Events That Helped Events that Hurt Neutral Events 1647 – The Commercial Alliance Between Quebec and New England was good because it shows a business partnership between two sides. 1690 – The Iroquois Peace Treaty was a neutral event because it involved the British, Iroquois, and the tribes around the Great Lakes, it had nothing to do with the New England. 1755 – The Acadians being expelled from Nova Scotia was neutral because it dealt with the French Canadians being expelled from the Maritimes to other colonies, it did not affect the Americans. 1774 – The Quebec Act hurt relations because it enraged American settlers , and they considered the it one of the Intolerable Acts which contributed to the outbreak of the American Revolution. 1775 – The American Invasion Of Quebec hurt relations because the American forces invaded Canada, and tried to take
The Differences Between Italy And Canada Essay
, Research Paper The Differences between Canada and Italy Comparing Canada to Italy show s the many differences between the two countries. The population, the physical size of the countries, the age, climate, and the people in each country are just some of the aspects that show the differences between the two countries.
Quebec Essay Research Paper Maine doesn
Quebec Essay, Research Paper Maine doesn’t see Quebec sovereignty as a threat ROCKPORT, Me. – Premier Lucien Bouchard got the message he wanted Thursday from two American politicians: Quebec’s
Quebec Nationalism 2 Essay Research Paper The
Quebec Nationalism 2 Essay, Research Paper The question of whether Quebec will secede from Canada to become an independent nation has been a hot topic in the country for several years now. It dates back to the abortive rebellions of 1837-38. In 1980, a referendum to secede was rejected by a 60-40 margin. Since then though, the numbers of Quebeckers that want to become sovereign has significantly increased.
Quebec Essay Research Paper QuebecCanada is one
Quebec Essay, Research Paper Quebec Canada is one of the most unique and diversified countries in the world. It consists of ten provinces and two territories. All parts of Canada are interesting and
Quebec And Other Provinces Separation Essay Research
Paper To what extent should the Government of Canada allow regions (provinces) to separate from the Country? To what extent should the Government of Canada allow regions (provinces) to separate from the Country? It would not be very good to Canada as a whole, but it does have some good points in its favor, especially the fact that Quebec is the only province that is seriously acting toward it.
The Patriotic Canadian Essay Research Paper For
The Patriotic Canadian Essay, Research Paper For over 130 years, Canada still keeps its word. Our Fathers of Canadian Confederation expressed their firm commitment when they signed the British North Amerian Act 139 years ago. Peace, Order and Good Government. For as long as I can remember, Canada has promoted peace any way possible.
The Future Of Quebec Province Or Nation
? Essay, Research Paper The idea of any separation movement is an emotional one, and the secession movement by the Canadian province of Quebec is no exception. Quebec is a primarily French-speaking province of 7 million that has been frustrated with being part of the primarily Anglo Canada. It has held two independence referendums and in 1995 nearly voted to officially split from Canada.
Quebec1A Essay Research Paper Quebec
Quebec(1)(A) Essay, Research Paper Quebec’s Quiet revolution: What is it? How has it changed Quebec’s society? How has it affected Confederation?The English-French relations have not always been easy. Each is always arguing and accusing the other of wrong doings. All this hatred and differences started in the past, and this Quiet revolution, right after a new Liberal government led by Jean Lesage came in 1960.
Mario Lemieux Essay Research Paper Mario LemieuxBorn
Mario Lemieux Essay, Research Paper Mario Lemieux Born: 1965 Mario Lemieux was born on October 5, 1965 in Montreal, Quebec. He had two brothers, Alain and Richard. They both also had talent in hockey, so when he was four years old, his parents sent him to the local hockey rink to learn how to skate. He was put under the watchful eye of Fernand Fichaud , Mr.
Canada 2 Essay Research Paper The Physical
Canada 2 Essay, Research Paper The Physical Regions of Canada Canada is divided into six regions. The regions are the Atlantic region, the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River region, the Shield region, the Plains
The Past And Present State Of Terrorism
In Canada Essay, Research Paper Reactionary Policies In the Wake of Terrorism Internal Affairs and Canada’s previous position on terrorism A terrorist Tunnel: Issues concerning Canada’s borders and the present threat of International terrorism
Canada Railway Essay Research Paper When in
Canada Railway Essay, Research Paper When in life you have something established and something that is dependent in you life, it is hard to survive when it is gone. In Canada the VIA rail line is just that, established and a tradition in Canada. To take something such as this away would in fact devastate many different people.
Bilingualism Essay Research Paper BilingualismWhat is Bilingualism
Bilingualism Essay, Research Paper Bilingualism What is Bilingualism? Bilingualism is the ability to fluently speak or write two languages. Canada is a bilingual country that has English and French, as it s two official languages. Canada has an Official Languages Act, which was passed in 1969 by Minister of Justice Pierre Elliott Trudeau.
The Canada Act Essay Research Paper
The Canada Act By 1980 the constitution was no longer as well suited for the country of Canada. Changes were needed to be made in the constitution which had not been touched over the last 113 years. The Prime Minister wanted to secure a bill of rights in the constitution but also wanted to patriate the BNA Act. This meant to bring the act from British hands into Canadian control.
IDENTITY Is Not A Strong Enough Word
Essay, Research Paper How do others see Canadians, do Canadians have a unique national identity? Although the United States (US) has some influence on most countries, Canadian life revolves around the US, and sometimes, how much we hate Americans. Most countries cannot say that they are made up of two separate nations (English and French), Canada, on the other hand, can say this.
To What Extent Should Nationalism Be Encouraged
? Essay, Research Paper Nationalism is very important towards a person’s self pride towards the country they live in. Nationalism is the base on what a country stand for and how strong the country is as a whole. With this in mind do people go over board and express this sense of pride to an extent to which it can be dangerous.
Quebec To Be Separate From Canada Essay
, Research Paper Vote No For Quebec To Be Separate From Canada I urge you as a fellow Canadian to vote NO! to the upcoming referendum question. Canada as a whole has many unique qualities. Our most valued
Quebec Essay Research Paper Quebec SeparationQuebec has
Quebec Essay, Research Paper Quebec Separation Quebec has always been trying to maintain it s cultural identity. The path that led to separatism is long and winding one. The French saw Confederation as the only solution in 1867. They needed Confederation to remain in control of their own language, religion and way of life.
Le Quebec Essay Research Paper Le Quebec
Le Quebec Essay, Research Paper Le Quebec et la Guadeloupe en Comparaison Le Quebec et la Guadeloupe sont deux mondes differents qui sont unis par la langue francaise. Un se trouve au plein nord du continent americain, et l?autre se trouve dans la mer Caribe dans les Antilles. Le Quebec a de temps froid la plupart de l?an, en meme temps que la Guadeloupe est characterise par un climat tropique.
Quebec Should It Be Allowed T Essay
, Research Paper If Quebec were to separate, this would certainly have a devastating impact on Canadian society. What many upholders of the separation issue do not realize is that Quebec’s needs as a province are being met by Canada’s current federal system. The fact that Canada is bilingual is its greatest attribute and changing that would change Canada’s stature in the world.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Clinton
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper Clinton Jolts Canadians With a Plea On Federalism In Ottawa, Canadians on both sides of the nation’s deep linguistic divide say they were stunned by President Clinton’s unexpectedly passionate appeal for national unity and federalism.
Quebec Separation Essay Research Paper Quebec as
Quebec Separation Essay, Research Paper Quebec as a separate nation was fine until the British conquest, now as time has passed Quebec is trying to shift toward separation again but with financial problems, government trauma and the twenty- first century approaching rapidly separation is an unattainable feat for Quebec.
Canada Essay Research Paper Canada is a
Canada Essay, Research Paper Canada is a land of great diversity and variety. With a population of 28 000 and the second largest country in the world, it has many cultural, physical and climatic differences.
Third Summit Of The Americas Essay Research
Paper The Third Summit of the Americas The Summit of the Americas, 2001, was held in Quebec, Canada. In spring 2001, (April 20-22, 2001), the 34 democratically elected heads of government from North, Central, and South America and the Caribbean gathered in Quebec City for the Summit of the Americas, 2001 — the third Summit of the Americas.
The French Language Charter Essay Research Paper
Expository Essay – The French Language Charter In 1977, the French Language Charter (Bill 101) was introduced to the residents of Quebec by the Parti Quebecois . It made French the official language in the province. Bill
Terry Fox Essay Research Paper Terry Fox
Terry Fox Essay, Research Paper Terry Fox was born in Winnipeg, Manitoba, but raised in Port Coquitlam, British Columbia, a community near Vancouver on Canada’s west coast. As an active teenager involved in many sports, in 1977 Terry was only 18 years old when he was diagnosed with bone cancer and forced to have his right leg amputated six inches above the knee.