Millennium Essay, Research Paper
My expedition into cyber-communism began when I read Brock Meeks’ “Hackers Stumble Toward Legitimacy”[1]. The article addressed a recent hackers’ convention. Interestingly, the keynote speaker was Eric Boucher[2] (alias Jello Biafra[3]), a rock star with no technical background. Numerous questions ensue. Who is Eric Boucher (alias Jello Biafra)? What does he believe? More importantly, why schedule someone with no technical background to speak at a hackers’ convention? Addressing his beliefs, his proposed Green Party platform[4] is not inconsistent with the “Manifesto of Libertarian Communism”[5]. This answer produces a more troubling question. Was his speech against corporate America mere socialist babbling or was his speech part of something more sinister, a subversive cyber-communist movement?
I am not the first to see possible communist subversion of the digerati[6]. Corey Winesett’s “Are Linux Users Really Communists?”[7] questions the nature of the relationship, if any, between open source and communism. Scott Billings’ “Heresy and Communism”[8] ponders that the Linux community’s knee-jerk reaction to negative opinions about Linux could be the result of being “under the [communists'] spell.” Before I can evaluate cyber-communism’s merits, I must define communism’s true nature and communism’s real threat to America.
Communism Revisited
Theoretical communism and practical communism have long been held as different political sociologies. Despite Marx’s call for the working class to revolt, the communist revolution’s leaders always ascend from the intelligentsia. John Stormer’s “None Dare Call It Treason” supports this fact saying:
“Fidel Castro was a product, not of the cane fields of Cuba, but of the halls of Havana University.”
“Joseph Stalin was not a simple peasant rebelling at the oppression of the Czar. He became a communist while studying for the priesthood in a Russian Orthodox seminary.”
“The membership of the first Communist spy ring uncovered in the U.S. Government was not spawned in the sweat shops of New York’s lower east side or the tenant farms of the South. [The conspirators] came to high government posts from Harvard Law School.”
Communism’s fallacy is the belief in everyone’s benevolence; yet, human nature proves otherwise. Communism cannot create a perfect society with imperfect people. Hence, to direct Utopia, communism produces a totalitarian government over the less-perfect people, ruled by the perfect people – communists. Thus, communism’s true nature creates a controlling government in the name of a better world.
Not every supporter needs be a knowing conspirator. Supporters could be “under the [communists'] spell.” Therefore, the true communist threat comes from people who can be deluded into supporting a controlling government in the name of a better world. John Stormer’s “None Dare Call It Treason” concurs with this conclusion saying:
“Communism is a disease of the intellect. It promises universal brotherhood, peace and prosperity to lure humanitarians and idealists into participating in a conspiracy which gains power through deceit and deception and stays in power with brute force.”
From Communism to Cyber-Communism
Richard Barbrook’s “The::Cyber.Com/Munist::Manifesto”[9] and “Cyber-Communism: How Americans are Superseding Capitalism in Cyberspace” (parts 1[10], 2[11], 3[12], 4[13]) draw parallels between communism and cyber-communism. He associates the Soviet Union’s gift/communist economy, where people freely exchange material goods, with the open source gift/cyber-communist economy, where people freely exchange source code. He concludes that cyber-communism promises a digital Utopia.
However, like communism’s promises, cyber-communism’s promises are not manifesting themselves. Monty Manley’s “Be an Engineer, Not an Artist”[14] cites poorly designed code to assert that unpaid programmers will work only on “sexy” projects. Scott Billings’ “Where’s the Creativity?”[15] challenges Linux supporters to show one original idea in Linux, reminding us that Linux itself is not an original idea.
Now, I am not condemning open source itself. Cyber-communism’s fallacy is funding the open source development method. Xavier Basora’s “Open Source and Nag Screens: Contradictions of the Bazaar”[16] mentions a shareware open source program to demonstrate the difficulty of funding “free” software. Eric Raymond’s “The Magic Cauldron”[17] provides many theoretical economic models, but he fails to provide any case studies to demonstrate their practicality. Red Hat follows Eric Raymond’s economic model and still suffers fiscal losses. Richard Stallman’s “The GNU Manifesto”[18] admits programmers will “not [be] paid as much as now.” Therefore, cyber-communism’s true nature moves software development to an unfeasible economic model. Andrew Leonard’s “The Cybercommunist Manifesto”[19] concurs with this conclusion in his critique of Richard Barbrook saying:
“Barbrook’s analysis does jibe well with fears expressed by some software programmers concerning the possibility that free software could prove to be an economic disaster for the software industry.”
Cyber-communism, like communism, is about control. John Zedlewski’s “Winning the Open-Source Support Game”[20] proposes that one company provide technical support for all open source software. Instead, his plan would only create an open source support monopoly. Liviu Andreescu’s “What to do about Monopolies?”[21] says, “Communism has nothing to do with turning… [Microsoft's] code in open source.” To the contrary, cyber-communism wants all products to move into open source to shift control from the corporation to the digerati. Thus, the true cyber-communist threat comes from the digerati’s members who can be duped into supporting an economically unfeasible development method.
Subversion is already in progress. “Hacker”[22] originally meant highly skilled programmer. Eric Raymond’s “How to Become a Hacker”[23] redefines “hacker” as a programmer who supports open source. Robert Lemos’ “The New Age of Hacktivism”[24] observes hacking being done for political reasons. Still, halting cyber-communism is not difficult.
Halting the Red Menace
Stopping cyber-communism is simple. We need only break the cyber-communists’ source of control. End-users depend on the digerati/hackers to provide technical support. To break the dependency, we need to made technology so easy that everyone can use it, as said in John Holmes’ “The Age of Everyman Tech: The End of Geekdom As We Know It”[25]. However, Michael Kellen’s “Death to Wizards!”[26] illustrates that some, mostly cyber-communists, will oppose easy-to-use. Besides, an easy-to-use program translates into little technical support revenue for an already failing economic model.
1 msnbc/news/435153.asp
2 music.excite/artist/biography/2089
3 ipass/~jthrush/biafra.htm
4 angelfire/punk/jello2000/platform.html
5 flag.blackened/daver/anarchism/mlc/mlc1.html
6 techweb/encyclopedia/defineterm?term=digerati
7 osopinion/Opinions/CoreyWinesett/CoreyWinesett2.html
8 osopinion/Opinions/ScottBillings/ScottBillings5.html
9 nettime/nettime.w3archive/199912/msg00146.html
10 nettime/nettime.w3archive/199909/msg00046.html
11 nettime/nettime.w3archive/199909/msg00047.html
12 nettime/nettime.w3archive/199909/msg00049.html
13 nettime/nettime.w3archive/199909/msg00045.html
14 osopinion/Opinions/MontyManley/MontyManley17.html
15 osopinion/Opinions/ScottBillings/ScottBillings3.html
16 osopinion/Opinions/XavierBasora/XavierBasora80.html
17 tuxedo/~esr/writings/magic-cauldron/magic-cauldron.html
18 gnu/gnu/manifesto.html
19 salon/tech/log/1999/09/10/cybercommunism/
20 osopinion/Opinions/JohnZedlewski/JohnZedlewski4.html
21 osopinion/Opinions/LiviuAndreescu/LiviuAndreescu2.html
22 techweb/encyclopedia/defineterm?term=hacker
23 tuxedo/~esr/faqs/hacker-howto.html
24 zdnet/zdnn/stories/news/0,4586,2651320,00.html
25 osopinion/Opinions/JohnHolmes/JohnHolmes3.html
26 osopinion/perl/story/6123.html
370
Другие работы по теме:
Environmental problems in Arkhangelsk region
Threat of ecological accident as a result of business activity of the person. The industrial enterprises polluting atmosphere. Growing number of the illnesses caused by an air way and pollution of water. Environmental problems in the Arkhangelsk region.
The Post Office Essay Research Paper
“The Post Office” There has always been one place that has filled me with dread. Every time I walk into the post office I feel an overwhelming sense of disgust and threat. There are several reasons why the post office affects me in these ways. I feel so disgusted when I walk in the post office because often they do not have the materials I need.
Peloponnesian War Essay Research Paper The Peloponnesian
Peloponnesian War Essay, Research Paper The Peloponnesian War America can be compared to Athens and Sparta in terms of being the superpower nation in its time. For America, we can learn lessons from the Peloponnesian War to help us be better informed of the causes of war. One reason for the cause of war between Sparta and Athens was their involvement of allies in which President Washington warned us against doing.
The Pale Threat Imagery Essay Research Paper
The Pale Threat: Imagery of Dust in Eveline It turns the brightest colors to gray. It collects in corners, on shelves, under bureaus, and over door moldings. Left unchecked it will embolden and encroach from these safer areas on the whole of a home, eventually blending every feature into a uniform drab. To many people it is a threat to health.
Joey Essay Research Paper Friday of the
Joey Essay, Research Paper Friday of the hump I didnt have gas mask Sgt Shin made general references in that hazing is ok in his shop and if he does it no one will say anything and if the NCOs do it that he will not say anything.
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper Even though
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper Even though the United States and Russia have just concluded the most far-reaching nuclear arms reduction treaty in history, the danger that nuclear weapons will actually be used is growing rather than declining. George Bush and Boris Yeltsin’s START II accord does represent an important step in winding down the U.S.-Soviet nuclear arms race (Fromuth, 1993).
Police Brutality Essay Research Paper There continue
Police Brutality Essay, Research Paper There continue to be frequent disturbing reports of unjustified police shootings, with officers firing on unarmed suspects fleeing non-violent crime scenes, during traffic stops,
Beowulf And Batman Essay Research Paper The
Beowulf And Batman Essay, Research Paper The classic hero possesses strength, ethics; and, above all, fights evil. This model applied in the time of Beowulf and still applies today, only slightly modified. As a result of such innovations as television and fashion magazines, society has come to value physical attractiveness and sexual prowess, as evident in the example of Batman, a modern day hero.
The Nuclear Threat Essay Research Paper The
The Nuclear Threat Essay, Research Paper The United States, once a defender of world peace and an international police power, seems today to be loosening the grip that has in the past prevented so much violence through out the world. At a time when “renegade” nations are arming with nuclear weapons, the Senate has voted not to ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, a document that in the President’s words “is critical to protecting the American people from the dangers of nuclear war”.
The Real Threat Of Nuclear Smuggling Essay
, Research Paper The Real Threat of Nuclear Smuggling This reading was based on the controversy over the threat that nuclear smuggling poses. It begins by going over the view of each side in a brief
Is Third Worlld Immigration A Threat To
Americas Way Of Life Essay, Research Paper “Is Third world immigration a threat to America’s way of life”? Is Third world immigration a threat to America’s way of life? I do not believe it is. I agree with Isbister. He argues that cultural impacts of immigration “are positive, constructive changes, that most Americans will benefit from living in a more multicultural society, and that tension between the different ethnic groups can be alleviated.
Nuclear Arms Essay Research Paper The United
Nuclear Arms Essay, Research Paper The United States in World War II created nuclear weapons in a secret wartime project. The U.S. spent over $2 billion dollars in 1945 on the project in fear that the Germans might succeed in creating a similar weapon. However the German’s did not seriously pursue the development of the nuclear weapons during World War II.
Cultural Identity Frank Chin
’s Donald Duk Essay, Research Paper Adolescence has been called the most difficult stage of the human being. It is a time of transition that every young person has to deal with. Today’s youth have grown up with the threat of a war, drug and alcohol within reach, teenage pregnancies, and violence everywhere.
Doomsday Essay Research Paper Doomsday The
Doomsday Essay, Research Paper Doomsday. The day when every living thing on this earth will die and will face the Creator for Judgement Day. Many people believe this will happen, and soon. Possibly New Years’ Eve, the year 2000. But will it happen? The world will soon find out. Three areas to be looked at are: the Cold War starting after the Second World War; nuclear war, its possibility of reoccurring and the way the media views the threat of nuclear war; and finally, whether the apocalypse is approaching, what the world’s military capability for a nuclear and chemical apocalypse is.
The Beach And Us Essay Research Paper
As angry waves crach on the sandy plain, Gulls fly as they escape the falling sea. Clouds form above to add the threat of rain, It’s vendetta clear to set it’s bombs free.
Fulfiling Dr Kings Dream Essay Research Paper
Dr. King is a man that preached non-violence amongst all people, a man that stood up for what he believed was right and just. This is a man that we should all respect and strive to live up to his teachings. My essay is about one event in my life that I think was something that Dr. King would be proud to see.
A Fourth Reich Essay Research Paper A
A Fourth Reich? Essay, Research Paper A Fourth Reich? Is the idea of a recurrence of the Holocaust realistic, or is this just an empty threat? According to Roskin, the Holocaust, or A Fourth Reich, is possible, but most likely improbable. He says the Neo-Nazi groups being formed in Germany at this time are nothing to be concerned with because they will never re-establish the power that Hitler once possessed.
AntiFederalists Essay Research Paper AntiFederalists were people
Anti-Federalists Essay, Research Paper Anti-Federalists were people who opposed the ratification of the Constitution. They believed strongly that the Constitution would not be able toe maintain a system of republican government because the Federalists were proposing a government that was the opposite of what they believed in.
Cause And Effect Pollution Essay Research Paper
Pollution has been a threat to the world for a long time. Many people think about it, but don?t know what they can do about it. It is affecting many things and must be reduced. Is there anything you can do?
Industry Analysis Essay Research Paper Industry Analysis1
Industry Analysis Essay, Research Paper Industry Analysis 1. The threat of new entrants into the senior housing industry is low and not a major threat to established companies in the industry. One major barrier to entry is the large amount of capital needed to build or purchases housing communities and to provide trained personnel such as managers and nurses to fill them.
Drug Use In International Sport Essay Research
Paper With all the hype of payoffs to IOC members in the media today, it might sound as if that is the greatest threat to internataional sport. The real threat to the Olympics and international sport is the use of dangerous drugs which enhance the performance of professional and Olympic athletes around the world.
Hamlet Explication Essay Research Paper Hamlet Explication
Hamlet Explication Essay, Research Paper Hamlet Explication In Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, Rosencrantz speaks Act 3 Scene 3 lines 11-23. The lines that he speaks are in response to the Kings request that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern take Hamlet to England immediately. The king feels that Hamlet’s madness is a threat to him and tries to convince the men that it is a threat to the kingdom and that it would be in Hamlet’s best interest to go to England.
Ufo Apocalypse Response Essay Research Paper The
Ufo Apocalypse Response Essay, Research Paper The first recurring theme I found throughout the article was the reason for UFO beliefs. In the middle of this century, we had extreme fear of world destruction due to the Cold War and nuclear threat. Coincidentally, this is about the same time “contactees” started reporting encounters with extraterrestrial beings who brought with them a warming for humanity of eminent worldly destruction due to their weapons of mass catastrophe.
Hazards In Placentia Essay Research Paper Hazards
Hazards In Placentia Essay, Research Paper Hazards in Placentia Earthquakes are probably the number one hazard that affects my area. I live about six to seven miles from the Whittier Fault and about 16-18 miles from the Newport Inglewood Fault. Just about a week or two ago, we experienced an earthquake around 2:30 a.m.
The Past And Present State Of Terrorism
In Canada Essay, Research Paper Reactionary Policies In the Wake of Terrorism Internal Affairs and Canada’s previous position on terrorism A terrorist Tunnel: Issues concerning Canada’s borders and the present threat of International terrorism
Geology 10 Essay Research Paper Exercise 2
Geology 10 Essay, Research Paper Exercise 2: Mass Wasting Mass wasting is a phenomenon that has resulted in over one million deaths and billions of dollars of damage in its recorded history. Mass wasting is classified by the rate at which debris moves down slope. For instance, rockfalls move at speeds of over thirty-MPH, while mudslides travel at around twenty MPH.
Japanese Internment During Wor Essay Research Paper
In May of 1942, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, which called for the eviction and internment of all Japanese Americans. After Pearl Harbor, all Japanese were looked upon as being a threat to
Essay 2 Essay Research Paper Threatening Forces
Essay 2 Essay, Research Paper Threatening Forces Oct. 22 Threatening forces are every where we look in life. Almost anything could be considered a threat in today s society. The poem by James Joyce, I hear an Army Charging Upon the Land, contains evidence of a threatening force. The threatening force in this poem is punk rock kids at a punk rock show.
Near Earth Objects Essay Research Paper Near
Near Earth Objects Essay, Research Paper Near Earth Objects What are NEOs? Where do they come from? Do they pose any real threat to Earth? Can they provide viable space resources? All of these questions are now
Stress And Stress Management Essay Research Paper
Stress can be loosely defined as anything that is experienced as a threat to your stability or equilibrium. A portion of your nervous system is activated to ready the body to meet the demands brought on by an emotional upset. The stress responses is a physiological response to stress that results in heightened mental and physical awareness such as elevated heartrate, faster breathing, dilated pupils, and tense muscles.
Causes Of The Cold War Essay Research
Paper Causes of the Cold War The Cold War occurred during a time of rebuilding for Europe. It characterized international relations and dominated the foreign policies of
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
The Fairfax Resolves Essay Research Paper We
The Fairfax Resolves Essay, Research Paper We “can not be considered as a conquered Country” because we are “Descendants not of the Conquered, but of the Conquerors.” With this implied threat of military action, the Fairfax County Resolves challenged the unconstitutional actions of the British government.