Gender and Money: Limitations for Women in the Victorian City
If money is the ascribing of value to valueless matter, the basis of its power for evil over man is his forgetting of this fact. Our Mutual Friend is about a whole society which has forgotten. Instead of seeing that man has made money of dust and is the source of its value, this society takes money as the ultimate value-in-itself, the measure and source of all other value. As one of the Voices of Society says, “A man may do anything lawful for money. But for no money! Bosh!” The novel is a brilliant revelation of the results of this false worship of money.
J. Hillis Miller, “Our Mutual Friend”
How fair is this statement made by J. Hillis Miller concerning Dickens’ Our Mutual Friend? Miller suggests that the novel is singularly a testimony about the corruptive powers of money. The individual, argues Miller, becomes objectified by his or her financial value and distinction, and that distinction replaces the true identity of the individual. I agree that this notion is demonstrated in the text, and I also agree that the characters often times only regard one another based upon their financial value. For this reason, characters do lose a sense of their true individuality, as money becomes a determining factor of their status in society. But is there another factor, besides money, which also contributes to the formation of these “fake” identities? Yes, and Miller fails to take this into account. Money is not the only signifier of status and character in the novel; gender, also, determines roles and place in society for the individual and prevents certain characters from the freedom of their “true” identities. We see both men and women in the novel wrestling with money and greed, but we also see women caught in a society that places severe role restrictions upon them. I would like to look at two women from the novel, Bella Wilfer and Lizzie Hexam, and investigate certain aspects of the roles that these two played in London society. I would also like to briefly delve into some investigations about the historical moment of the Victorian City. The latter is based upon the historical descriptions of Victorian London that describe the segregation that existed between gender in the work environment. When we take these conditions into consideration, it becomes clear that women suffered not one, but two inhibitors of freedom. They, like the men are caught in the “money talks” universe, which J. Hillis Miller accurately describes; but, unlike men, these women also suffer from the oppressions of being a woman in the Victorian city. As a result, we are more understanding, and, perhaps, are not as harsh on female characters of the novel as J. Hillis Miller wants us to be.
It is first important to note the effect that money has upon the characters of the novel. We need to establish that the characters are corrupted by money, and, more importantly, we need to demonstrate the difference between male corruption with money and female corruption with money. J. Hillis Miller claims that “Dickens shows people turned into objects made by money” (Miller). This is true in the sense that characters view other characters by their wealth and social stature. Melvin Tremlow, though a minor character, is a perfect example. His acceptance in the Veneering quarters and at their dinner parties is directly linked to his status as cousin to Lord Snigsworth. Tremlow does not have to reside on the Veneering property nor does he have to attend their parties. His choice to do so, however, demonstrates how he is manipulated by the Veneerings. His stature and name is a Veneering trophy and his willingness to play that role points to his acceptance of that manipulation. Dickens has presented an example of a character that lacks “true” identity because the only identity that Tremlow obtains is based off the non-substance of wealth and stature. Miller supports this, stating, “in Our Mutual Friend all things and people have the mediated worth of a piece of paper money” (Miller).
In the same sense, Bella Wilfer is manipulated into a piece of property who is “willed away, like a horse, or a dog, or a bird.” Yet, when we consider the status of lower class women in Victorian London and the limited financial opportunities that were available to them, we no longer can look at the issue in such a black and white frame of mind as we could with Tremlow. This leads us to acknowledge the historical condition of women in the city during the Victorian Era. Wilson s chapter “Cesspool City: London” from his work Sphinx in the City addresses urban London during the Victorian Era. Much of his discussion is concerned with the limited economic roles that women could play during the time period. Wilson states, “the condition of women became the touchstone for judgements on city life” (Wilson). Women were heavily scrutinized. Moreover, what was considered proper behavior for middle class women was extremely narrow. Wilson points out that even in the most liberal cases, a woman working a man s job was never condoned. Women were encouraged, for the most part, to play the role of mother and wife. Therefore, women like Bella Wilfer have little choice but to succumb to the pressures of society. Not only are women forced to contend with the mighty buck, but they must also do so within an extremely rigid system.
What does this say about Dickens and his view of women? As Wilson mentions, Dickens worked to instill proper, middle class values into women. His home for women, Urania Cottage, is testimony to this claim. Yet, it is difficult after reading Mutual Friend to uncover exactly what Dickens thought these values should be. We have two heroines who both assume the role of the dutiful and nurturing wife at the novel s conclusion. In this case, Lizzie Hexam is extremely interesting when we consider her occupational transition from the novel s beginning to its conclusion. Her work along the river, a man s job, is replaced by her responsibility to her new husband (we can consider the latter as an occupation). Is Dickens advocating such a transition? On one hand, we may think so. Dickens may in fact be suggesting that marriage responsibilities are a “step up” from manual labor implying that the later is improper for a woman of Lizzie s character. This, I think, would be an easy take on Dickens considering, again, his role with the home for women. Yet, on the other hand, Dickens may be suggesting that it is possible for a woman to do a man s work and still maintain her virtue (this is still extremely male chauvinistic as a man is defining what is “virtuous” for a woman). After all, Dickens portrays Lizzie s innocence and selflessness as the strongest elements in her character. Perhaps Dickens is suggesting that a woman s occupation and financial circumstances do not factor into her character. Based upon Wilson s accounts of the historical moment, this would have been a very bold statement by Dickens. I think, however, the fact that Lizzie eventually assimilates into the middle class role of the dutiful wife indicates Dickens belief that a “proper” woman must be taught to emulate middle class values.
I opened this discussion with the excerpt from J. Hillis Miller s essay on Our Mutual Friend, entitled “Our Mutual Friend”. In the essay, Miller contributes money as the soul factor in the determination of the individual s worth and status in society. I included Miller in the discussion for two reasons: one, he misses the boat concerning the gender s role with social status, and two (which goes along with reason one), his essay served as the afterword for the 1964 Signet Classics edition of Dickens Our Mutual Friend. Therefore, my discussion deals with female oppression on three possible levels. The first, and most definitive, is the double standard that existed for women in the Victorian City. They are subjected to the same pressures for money as men, but, unlike men, they also have extremely limited access to money. In most cases, women were required to assume the role of mother and dutiful wife in order to secure financial stability and social favor. The second level of female oppression concerning the novel is more of an inference about Dickens personal attitude toward the standards for middle class women. It is possible that he assumes that class and money have nothing to do with a woman s character (Lizzie Hexam). His personal undertakings, however, to establish a school of middle class values and proper behavior for women (Urania Cottage) indicates that Dickens probably believed that there was specific criteria (a curriculum) required to achieve these “proper” standards. The third level of female oppression that our discussion deals with is the ignorance of J. Hillis Miller. It is extremely interesting to see a critical piece–written one-hundred years after Dickens published Our Mutual Friend–contain similar aspects of female oppression that, at least, existed in the historical moment of the novel and, quite possibly, in the mind of Dickens as well.
J. Hillis Miller, 1964. “Our Mutual Friend”. Taken from Dickens: A Collection of Critical Essays. Martin Price: Editor. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. 1967
MJP
Другие работы по теме:
Raped Essay Research Paper I know about
Raped Essay, Research Paper I know about things I shouldn’t know about. Things most people dont know about, and dont want to. Rape.A word that haunts many. A year ago, I was at a party with my best friend. We were drunk, apperntly she was more than I. I wanted to leave, I didn’t want to go without her though. But, she wanted to stay with her new boy friend.
The Star Essay Research Paper In Great
The Star Essay, Research Paper In Great Expectations, by Charles Dickens, light is used symbolically through the example of Estella. Miss Havisham brings Estella up in the darkness, consequently sheltering her from the true
Oliver Twist Essay Research Paper As one
Oliver Twist Essay, Research Paper As one of the world s greatest writers, Charles Dickens has written some of the greatest classics such as: Great Expectations, A Tale of Two Cities, and Oliver Twist. In these works, Dickens often uses past experiences in his life, and develops a character that goes through the same kind of struggles.
Poem Thank You Essay Research Paper THANK
Poem: Thank You Essay, Research Paper THANK YOU There for me through thick and thin Never hesitates to lend a hand Comforts me when everything seems dim Always listens when I feel the need to express to them
Dickens
’ Sense Of Theatre Essay, Research Paper Dickens seems to have a highly developed sense of theatre, and this is proven countless times in his works. The three ‘stages’ of Pip’s life could also be called Acts, because if you were to make Great Expectations into a play, the three stages would most certainly be divided into Acts 1, 2 and 3.
Why Essay Research Paper A true friend
Why Essay, Research Paper A true friend is something that is hard to come by. They have many rare qualities. These qualities are not the same for every person. A true friend can not really be defined because each person has different qualities they look for in a friend.
Charles Dickens 2 Essay Research Paper Charles
Charles Dickens 2 Essay, Research Paper Charles Dickens (1812-1870) is one of the greatest and most popular writers in the history of literature. In his novels, Dickens combines masterly storytelling, humor, pathos, and irony with sharp social criticism and acute observation of people and places, both real and imagined.
Creative Poem Essay Research Paper Hope you
Creative Poem Essay, Research Paper Hope you are enjoying the Day! To have a friend, you must be a friend, Starting with yourself. The greatest hunger a person has is to be needed.
A Tale Of Two Cities Charles Dickens
(1812-1870) Essay, Research Paper Dickens conceived the idea for this complicated plot while acting in a play. Every event penned in A Tale of Two Cities
Because Essay Research Paper Becuase this is
Because Essay, Research Paper Becuase this is not my job, I decided early on to limit my reviews to one book per author. You can imagine, then, how hard it was to decide WHICH book of Charles Dickens to review. I mean, to choose between A Tale of Two Cities, Oliver Twist, and Great Expectations was downright cruel.
Dickens Hard Times Essay Research Paper Dickens
Dickens: Hard Times Essay, Research Paper Dickens: Hard Times Jason Gentry In this paper I would like to discuss the possibly affects that this book might have had on the world, the time around Charles Dickens, and the fact that Charles Dickens paid close attention to the world around him. Charles Dickens, born Charles John Huffman Dickens, was born on Feb. 7 1812 in Portsmouth where his father was a clerk at the Naval Pay Office.
Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Charles DickensIn
Charles Dickens Essay, Research Paper Charles Dickens In 1812, one of the greatest writers of all time, according to many, was born to the name of Charles John Huffman Dickens. Charles Dickens’ family was not well to do, and was a lower-middle class family with eight children, Charles being the second. He had a painful personal life from growing up all the way until his later years, which was mostly due to the fact of being poor.
David Copperfield 2 Essay Research Paper The
David Copperfield 2 Essay, Research Paper The many differences between James Steerforth and Tommy Traddles In the novel, David Copperfield, Charles Dickens contrasts many different characters. The main two characters that he contrasts are Tommy Traddles and James Steerforth. He displays the contrast between these two characters in many different ways.
Dombey And Son Essay Research Paper In
Dombey And Son Essay, Research Paper In an excerpt from Dombey and Son by Charles Dickens, a man’s wife just gave birth to their newborn child and he’s already planning out the future of his son. Through a god-like view, the reader sees the arrogance of Dombey and feels pity towards his wife and son. Using rhetorical devices, Dickens tells of this man and his thoughts.
A Tale Of Two Cities Foreshadowing Essay
, Research Paper Many famous writers use foreshadowing. An author needs to use different instances of foreshadowing. Charles Dickens was a great British author who used foreshadowing. A Tale of Two Cities, written by Charles Dickens, contains many examples of foreshadowing.
Faked Smile Essay Research Paper I sat
Faked Smile Essay, Research Paper I sat on the cliff facing the sea, Mixed emotions accompanied me, Did I say or do anything wrong, That broke the bond that could have last long.
Dickens Biography Essay Research Paper In the
Dickens Biography Essay, Research Paper In the Charles Dickens novel, A Tale of Two Cities, symbolism in used to portray the themes though out the book. Through his characters and their actions as well as their
Conflict Management Essay Research Paper In the
Conflict Management Essay, Research Paper In the dictionary conflict is defined as a struggle, a battle, even mutual antagonism. Some people seem to thrive on creating conflict while others do their best to avoid conflict.
Charles Dickens Essay Research Paper Charles John
Charles Dickens Essay, Research Paper Charles John Huffam Dickens was born in Portsmouth in 1812, the second child of a large family. His father was the son of a butler and a housekeeper, and worked as a clerk in the Navy Pay Office. The family moved to London when Dickens was three and to Chatham in Kent two years later.
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper TitleGreat Expectations
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper Title Great Expectations Author Charles Dickens was born in Portsmouth and moved to London on his twelfth. Because his father spent more than he earned, Dickens had to work in a blacking factory, of which he was very ashamed. This had a great influence on his writing, because he attacked the social differences in the Victorian age.
Crying Again Essay Research Paper The Sky
Crying Again Essay, Research Paper The Sky is crying again And i am crying again. When did it start? When will it end? How’d i wind up with out a friend? Tears from my heart cling to my soul.
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper In the
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper In the novel Great Expectations, by Charles Dickens, many characters have a great influence on Pip’s life. The characters that affect him most are Magwitch, Pip’s benefactor, Estella, whom Pip adores, and Joe, Pip’s best friend throughout the novel. Some of the people in Pip?s life, unfortunately, drew him away from the fact that social status does not matter as long as you have a good heart inside.
A Character Sketch Of Joe Gargery Essay
, Research Paper A Character Sketch of Joe Gargery Joe Gargery might not be the smartest or wisest of Dickens’ characters, but he is definitely one of the kindest and most humane. Although Miss Havisham
Gender Bias In Dickens Essay Research Paper
?Charles Dickens preferred workers the way he preferred Victorian women: grateful for favors received, humble, patient, and passive.? (Scheckner) Charles Dickens entered this world on February 7, 1812; he was born in Lindsport, Portsmouth, England. The time period in which he lived and the location in which he dwelled are both important because they had a great effect on his writing.
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper Great ExpectationsWhat
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper Great Expectations What are your expectations in life? Are yours similar to anyone else? In Great Expectations by Charles Dickens the main character Pip has many expectations. By reading this book I have found that Pip and I have many similar and different expectations in life.
A Christmas Carol Essay Research Paper Charles
A Christmas Carol Essay, Research Paper Charles Dickens and A Christmas Carol Born in 1812 Charles Dickens grew up in a small town in London. Dickens grew up in a poor family. His family, sent to debtors jail before he became old enough to fend for himself, convinced him to find work and stay out of the jail. Dickens worked anywhere, from law offices to newspapers as a young child. ( New Standard Encyclopedia D-155) A Christmas Carol, written by Dickens, has changed many things in the world today, especially Christmas traditions and religion.
The Playground Essay Research Paper I have
The Playground Essay, Research Paper I have a friend I used to know who had a playground where we would go The times we had are fresh in my mind but they are from another time
A Tale Of Two Cities Faults Of
Social Structure Essay, Research Paper A Tale of Two Cities: Faults of Social Structure Charles Dickens has been acclaimed as one of the foremost satirists of the
Friends Always Essay Research Paper what is
Friends Always Essay, Research Paper what is a friend ? one who is caring, sharing,open and honest. one who won’t judge you,one who will take you for you.one who will put up with all your ups and downsone who is totally understanding. one who knows who you really are and accepts everything about you, one who respects you