, Research Paper
Executive Women: Substance Plus Style
PSYC 4310
Executive Women: Substance Plus Style
The article “Executive Women: Substance Plus Style” deals with the issue of
whether the “abilities and attitudes of male managers are different from those
of female managers” and that these differences have been used to keep women out
of managerial positions. Furthermore, it suggests that it has now become
“fashionable” to state that these differences are favorable and complement the
business environment. Lastly, the article focused on several strategies that
women should follow in order to succeed as a middle or upper level manager
within a large corporation. The authors refute the notion that the differences
between male and female managers are great. They mention that “the few studies
that have looked at women and men in comparable managerial roles have discovered
more similarities than differences across sexes” (Catalyst, 1986). A test bank
from “thousands of managers and professionals in management development programs
from 1978 to 1986″ was cited as another reason why they believe there are few
differences between male and female executives. The tests revealed that
executive men and women scored equally on most areas and that executive women
are just as capable at leading, influencing, and motivating groups, as well as
analyzing problems. The authors go on to show that, despite these similarities,
women are disproportionately represented in the ranks of Fortune 500 company
executives.
Repeated references are made to studies that were conducted with 22 people, 16
men and 6 women, whose job is to select executives for top jobs. These people
are continually referred to as “savvy insiders” throughout the article. These
so called savvy insiders were tasked with providing an example of what they
considered to be a woman who “made it” and one who “derailed”. They describe
what basically amounts to a woman who utilizes characteristics of both masculine
and feminine personalities. They came up with these four contradictory sets of
expectations that women must overcome: take risks, but be consistently
outstanding; be tough, but don’t be macho; be ambitious, but don’t expect equal
treatment; and take responsibility, but follow others’ advice. The research was
based on a comparison between male and female managers and by tests that
measured personality dimensions, intelligence, and behavior in problem-solving
groups. As I had learned in a previous psychology class, personality tests are
not really an effective measure of personality, nor is an intelligence test
necessarily an accurate means of determining ones’ success in the future. I
would have been more convinced by experimental research rather than by a review
of tests or an interview with 76 people. I have noticed a trend that has been
occurring in the military in which many for women are being promoted to the
upper officer ranks than at any time before. The Admiral in charge of all Navy
training, Vice Admiral Tracy, seems to embody the principles that were discussed
in the article. To me, she epitomizes, what I would consider to be, the
quintessential executive woman. She is tough but not overbearing; she is firm,
but will listen to others’ advice; and she never seems to shed her feminine
qualities. It appears that the social dominance of males in our society is a
difficult obstacle to overcome for women who are attempting to climb the
corporate ladder. While the article states that men and women have more
similarities than differences, the differences are hard to ignore. As stated in
our textbook, Social Psychology, “men’s style of communicating undergirds their
social power, men tend to be directive and women tend to be democratic”. I
believe that the past gender role of women in our society is still affecting
what is happening today. As long as the perception that women should fulfill a
subservient role persists, I believe it will be difficult for women to achieve
equal numbers in upper management in the foreseeable future. While it is
apparent that women need to adjust their behavior to become successful, perhaps
it is time that men adjust their own behavior to better integrate what
constitutes the other half of the population of our society. It would be
interesting to see the outcome of an experimental study that observed how role
reversal training could possibly affect the attitudes of male business leaders.
References
1. Morrison, A.R., White, R.P., Van Elsor, E. (1987 August). Executive Women:
Substance Plus Style. Psychology Today, 18-26.
Другие работы по теме:
Koran Essay Research Paper The Koran or
Koran Essay, Research Paper The Koran or Qur’an is the sacred scripture of Islam. A scripture so sacred it urges a total commitment to him alone who is god. (Grolier Interactive 98). I found that
Conrad Is A Sexist Essay Research Paper
In Joseph Conrad?s novelette Heart of Darkness, Marlow?s view of women embodies the typical 19th century view of women as the inferior sex. There are only three relatively minor female characters in Heart of Darkness: Marlow?s aunt, Kurtz?s mistress, and Kurtz?s "Intended." Marlow mentions these female characters in order to give the literal aspect of his tale more substance.
Women And Shopping Essay Research Paper What
Women And Shopping Essay, Research Paper What motivates women to shop? I attempted to answer the age old question by surveying five ladies who are self-proclaimed experts at the “art” of shopping. These five ladies, Joanne, Kim, Marie, Shirley, and Kimmie sat down with me individually and this is what I basically gathered from the discussion sessions.
Things Fall Apart Essay Essay Research Paper
Things Fall Apart Essay Throughout many years women have always been inferior to men in all cultures and places. Maybe it’s because men are physically stronger than women and have always had the ability to control them that way. There are also sayings that men a more intelligent than women but that is an arguable statement.
Woments Rights Essay Research Paper t was
Woments Rights Essay, Research Paper t was long ago when women were looked upon as slaves to the hard Working, man. In today’s society women now are more respected and are acceptable for many jobs as
The Declaration Of Sentiments V Now
’s Statement Of Purpose Essay, Research Paper The Declaration of Sentiments and NOW Both the Declaration of Sentiments and the National Organization for Women s Statement of Purpose are documents that represent women s fight for equality with men. The DOS, the first wave s list of demands for quality, came from radical women who did not have a voice within society while the Statement of Purpose shows the second wave s plan for the fight against discrimination.
Sound Nature Essay Research Paper
Very simply, sound is the vibration of any substance. The substance can be air, water, wood, or any other material, and in fact the only place in which sound cannot travel is a vacuum. When these substances vibrate, or rapidly move
French And German Constitution Essay Research Paper
The executive in the French Vth Republic and the executive in the Federal republic in Germany have a few similarities and many differences. Since the French Vth constitution was tailor made by DeGaulles himself, the executive in this republic is very strong and authoritative. However, the executive in the Federal Republic of Germany, (the Bundesrepublik- Germany after 1945) was made up to prevent another Hitler from raising up, so it is very weak and is more of an executive figurehead.
Fusion Heat Essay Research Paper The objective
Fusion Heat Essay, Research Paper The objective of this experiment is to find the heat of fusion of water by using a calorimeter. The calorimeter will be used to melt ice in water to find the
Comparing And Contrasting Federalists And Antifederalists Essay
, Research Paper 1. The federalist and anti-federalists were very different in the opinions they shared on how the government should be run. The Federalists had very high class and social men while the Anti-federalists had farmers. The Federalists wanted a republican government with a strong executive branch, while the Anti-Federalists wanted a participatory democracy with a minimum executive branch.
LUCY STONE Essay Research Paper Lucy Stone
LUCY STONE Essay, Research Paper Lucy Stone (1818 ? 1893) By: Meghan Monokian Well I, Lucy Stone am mostly known for being one of the most famous leaders for women’s rights in the United States. I came to be known as one of the most outspoken women of my time. I had firm beliefs against slavery and rejected the Biblical stand that men should rule over women.
Abortion Essay Research Paper There are many
Abortion Essay, Research Paper There are many women who have choices to make in life that can be difficult or easy. One very difficult decision is whether or not to terminate a pregnancy. Most people should think before they act. If a woman has to terminate a pregnancy, it is because she wasn’t planning to get pregnant or because she did not use birth control.
Islamic Women Essay Research Paper Many times
Islamic Women Essay, Research Paper Many times when feminists looked at Islamic women they criticized the man for not treating women properly. However, as Jane I. Smith states, women of Islam are not really offended by that fact, on the contrary, they believe that it is better for them.
Reiters Syndome Essay Research Paper Equal Rights
Reiters Syndome Essay, Research Paper Equal Rights for Women During the nineteenth century, the women suffrage movement was coming out full force to demand the equal rights of women in the United States and Europe. The women who supported the women’s suffrage adapted a Declaration of Principles that simply stated that, “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and women are created equal” (Perry, 1995, p.194).
Women In War Essay Research Paper Women
Women In War Essay, Research Paper Women in War and How They Made a Difference Women who served in past wars were considered heroines, and were presented with many different, honorable awards. Women served many purposes during the war. Such as: nurses who amputated and helped soldiers, translators who spoke for the French, telephone operators who connected important phone calls to different places, and many more non-combat roles.
Affirmative Action Is Equal Opportunity Essay Research
Paper Affirmative Action is Equal Opportunity Discrimination occurs all over America. The solution to this problem in the workplace and in recieving education was affirmative action, an executive order signed by President John F. Kennedy calling for an end to discrimination in the work place and education.
Sexual Harrasment Essay Research Paper Exploratory EssayHow
Sexual Harrasment Essay, Research Paper Exploratory Essay How do you determine what sexual harassment is, and when your sexually harassed? Three writers; Katie Marton, Fredric Hayward, and Phyllis Doloff, have different ideas on what sexual harassment is. All the writers wrote essays on their experiences with sexual harassment and what it means to them.
The Hormones And Development Of One
’s Sex Essay, Research Paper The Hormones and Development of One’s Sex The objectives of this article as I saw them were, (1) to show how fetal gonads acquire the ability to function as endocrine organs, and (2), to show the
Women In Buisness Essay Research Paper Even
Women In Buisness Essay, Research Paper Even though women constitute 40% of all executives and administrative posts (up from 24% in 1976), they are still restricted mostly to the middle and
Framers Ideals And Legislation Essay Research Paper
Framers Ideals and Legislation Branches on the Tree of Liberty Why, if one were concerned with protecting human liberty, would one want to make the legislative branch of government dominant rather than the executive or judicial? Are these good reasons for someone concerned with liberty to distrust a strong executive or a powerful judicial?
Womens Rights Essay Research Paper The First
Womens Rights Essay, Research Paper The First Women?s Rights Movement Was their fight successful? A group of women set out to make a point. A point that women don?t have to be dependent on men; that they can live their own lives with their own individual rights and beliefs. All these women wanted was a chance to live a life free of the constant pressures and contradictions.
Executive Privelage Essay Research Paper exemption of
Executive Privelage Essay, Research Paper exemption of the executive branch of government, or its officers, from having to give evidence, specifically, in U.S. law, the exemption of the president from disclosing information to congressional inquiries or the judiciary. Claims of executive privilege are usually invoked to protect confidential military or diplomatic operations or to protect the private discussions and debates of the president with close aides.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Analysis on the
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Analysis on the conflict men v. women found in Antigone Many conflicts can be found within various plays. In Sophocles’ Antigone one of the many conflicts found is men versus women. The king of Thebes, Creon, has a problem with women. But not only the king, Ismene, Antigone’s sister as well refers to herself and her sister as being inferior to men.
Ery Essay Research Paper Affirmative action works
Ery Essay, Research Paper Affirmative action works. There are thousands of examples of situations where people of color, white women, and working class women and men of all races who were previously excluded from jobs or educational opportunities, or were denied opportunities once admitted, have gained access through affirmative action.
Review Of Good Wives Essay Research Paper
Review of Good Wives Today, women are an intricate part of our working society. There are more women holding full-time jobs than ever before. A women’s role is just not in the house; it extends far beyond into the working world where women are even holding positions such as chief executive officers of Fortune 500 Companies.
African America Women Essay Research Paper OUR
African America Women Essay, Research Paper OUR AFRICAN AMERICAN WOMEN African American women have excelled in virtually every arena of the world?s spectrum. Born of a desire to succeed, Maggie L. Walker, Shirley Chisolm, Corretta Scott
Is Parliament Supreme Over The Judiciary And
The Executive? Give Reasons For Your Answer. Essay, Research Paper Parliament is supreme over the executive and judiciary in the way that it is the sovereign law making body. The parliament however is restricted within the constitution and it can not act outside of it. Although it does hold great power it does not have complete power due to the separation of powers.
How Were Women Treated In Julius Caesars
Time Essay, Research Paper Essay: How Were Women Treated in Julius Caesar’s Time? By: Andrew MillardWe are always striving for equality between the sexes. For many years women were seen as being less than men, and inferior to them. This is shown simply by one history-altering incident. The incident that I’m referring to is when the women were finally allowed to vote.
Men And Women Are Different Essay Research
Paper Men and Women Different? Are women and men really that different? I think so. I am at a stage in my life where I think all men are after one thing. Sex. When I sit here and think about it, I really have to think, do women and men have anything in common. Women communicate in a completely different manner than women.
Symbols Of Women Essay Research Paper Symbols
Symbols Of Women Essay, Research Paper Symbols of Women There are many symbols placed on women in today’s society. These symbols act as stereotypes that usually degrade women on a daily basis. However, many of these symbols are just a term, and have no meaning behind them. An example of this is the reference of women being referred to as “dogs.”
Executive Compensation Essay Research Paper Executive CompensationExecutive
Executive Compensation Essay, Research Paper Executive Compensation Executive compensation should be pay for performance. The direct link between pay and the company s profitability is an important factor. It can either motivate an executive to work harder for the company or to work against the company.