John Berger Essay, Research Paper
In John Berger?s essay ?Another Way of Telling,? Berger argues that photographs contain a ?third meaning.? Berger claims that the third meaning is personal and relies almost completely on the individual viewer. As a result, no photograph can convey the same message to any two people and no two photographs can convey the same message to any one person. Here, the validity of Berger?s assumption crumbles. All photographs communicate one absolute truth.
Berger states, ?All subjectivity is treated as private? (100). Yet, claiming that anything subjective within a photograph, its past and future, is personal only supports an absolute truth. The truth, however, is beyond the viewer?s conscious interpretation and the photograph becomes ambiguous. Berger becomes mislead when he compares an individual?s opinion of the past or future of a photograph to the actual truth of the photograph, thus surfaces ?ambiguity.? Even Berger agrees that ambiguity is the result of the viewer?s personal experiences and psychology, but he ignores what the viewer cannot see. When discussing the ambiguity of the photograph of the horse and man, page 85, Berger can only guess as to why the photograph was taken and to what the meaning is. Berger describes this process as, ? . . . a game of inventing meanings? (86). Here, Berger admits to creating meanings, based on his life experiences and his personal psychology. Obviously, if one places his or her own, fictitious meanings unto a photograph, there can never be a single meaning or truth. But what about the meaning of the photograph itself, alone, without Berger?s private interpretation? This meaning, the absolute truth, remains hidden from all viewers because of their previous experiences, their life. Although the truth may remain disguised behind an individual?s ?invented? meaning it does not follow that the truth is nonexistent.
Berger also argues that ambiguity arises because photographs break the continuity of time, which again is another falsehood. When a photograph is taken and an event captured, the past and future are irrelevant. The instant taken by the camera is true and factual. Everything that led up to the photograph and everything that follows leaves the instant photographed, and the consequent truth, unaffected. The truth conveyed by the photograph may be harder to decipher, but remains a truth regardless. Berger uses an example of a landscape photographed, page 91, to describe the effects of broken continuity. Berger claims that the light and the weather are taken from their setting and the photograph becomes ambiguous. Nothing is ambiguous about the actual instant photographed. The light and weather captured by the camera were the same light and weather as the instant of the photograph. Berger does not even attempt to apply a meaning to a landscape in his essay. Berger excludes landscapes because they are not ambiguous. There is nothing to dispute about the lighting or weather of a landscape, but the photograph must still carry a meaning. The reason Berger fails to apply meaning to landscapes is that he is unable to draw upon his own life experiences and psychology to create a mythical truth, or a personal truth. The truth is not personal; it is universal and singular, thus escaping Berger?s imagination.
If the photograph were to be replaced back into its surrounding time, fixing the continuity, would the meaning differ? Would Berger now be able to ?invent? an ambiguous meaning for the photograph? Nothing from Berger?s personal past could influence the landscape captured within the photograph; thus Berger is unable to assign meaning. When Berger is unable to assign meaning, the photograph must be clear and lucid, not ambiguous. The singular truth behind the photograph has not allowed Berger any room for a personal reading.
Another example of Berger?s attempt to falsify photographs by creating meanings for them occurs when discussing the photograph on page 101, of the parting man and woman. Berger says, ?Perhaps they are speaking. We cannot hear their words. Perhaps they are saying nothing . . .? (102). Berger would argue that this is the reason for ambiguity within the photograph, the viewer?s inability to know what is being said, if anything. But the viewer?s lack of knowledge or insight cannot affect the truth of the photograph. Berger mistakes his own shortcomings, his own ignorance, for ambiguity in the photograph. Berger is incapable of making an accurate reading and consequently conceives a personal reading. But the truth of the photograph, the same truth as any other photograph, remains unchanged. Again Berger, or any other viewer, is unqualified to see the truth.
When posing his dilemma about the truths of photographs, Berger supposes that a photograph of a door would relate the same meaning as a photograph of a crying man (100). To analyze this further, what does a picture of a door relate, even if ?ambiguous?? It is hard to create a meaning for a door, similar to a landscape. The reason being, the door is not ambiguous, the truth is unclouded. What does the photograph of a crying man convey? The image speaks the same truth, only details within the photograph disguise the truth allowing Berger to create a personal meaning. The crying man and the door both convey one truth, that of their existence and of the existence of life. Berger says that all photographs tell the past. The past is life and everything included in life, a singular truth. Life and existence vary greatly and photographs vary accordingly, but simultaneously they communicate one truth. Solid and real, the truth communicated cannot be debated. Crying men coexist with doors and their permanence may be captured on film; this is unambiguous and photographs of a single order of truth result.
Другие работы по теме:
The Pigman
– Analysis Of John Conlan Essay, Research Paper John Conlan is a main character in the book The Pigman. He doesn’t act, think and have a social reputation as many people might
Pigman Essay Research Paper The Pigman by
Pigman Essay, Research Paper The Pigman by Paul Zindel The Pigman is about two teenagers (John and Lorraine) who make friends with an elderly man (Mr. Pignati). They then abuse his trust in them and the elderly man dies.
The Birth Narrative Through The Gospels Of
Matthew Luke And John (Comparison) Essay, Research Paper The birth narratives of the gospels of Matthew, Luke and John are versions of the stories of the Messiah’s birth. They are not exactly the same. John’s gospel doesn’t even give word of the virgin birth. In Biblical Theology class, we remembered each birth narrative as “the one with the shepherds,” or “the one with the wise men.” Matthew’s gospel starts with the Messiah’s genealogy.
The Pigman Essay Research Paper In the
The Pigman Essay, Research Paper In the novel, The Pigman, writing by Paul Zindel the main characters are Mr.Pignati, John and Lorraine. They all meet by chance and each becomes a trespasser on another’s life. However, John and Lorraine each gain something from their experience with the Mr.Pignati. Mr.Pignati, John and Lorraine all have their own individual reasons and desires for wanting to be with each character.
Jesus In John Essay Research Paper Jesus
Jesus In John Essay, Research Paper Jesus in John When reading the gospels of the New Testament, it becomes evident that the personality of each of the authors affected their understanding, interpretation, and impression of Jesus and his works. In John, the gospel that I chose to read for this paper, Jesus is portrayed in a more godlike, omnipotent manner.
Cheers A Semiotic Analysis By Berger Essay
, Research Paper Cheers : A Semiotic Analysis by Berger In Arthur Asa Berger s essay, he conducts a semiotic analysis of the comedy television show Cheers. In his analysis of the show he points out many characteristics that refer to semiotics. Even though one could not agree with all of his findings, many of them are reasonable.
Pig Man Essay Research Paper Three individuals
Pig Man Essay, Research Paper Three individuals with varying personalities and backgrounds come together in a strange and magical way to help each other strengthen in their weak points. Lorraine who is self-conscious has John to make her happy and forget about her worries. John does not have many weak points except that he smokes and drinks.
John Dalton Essay Research Paper John Dalton
John Dalton Essay, Research Paper John Dalton was born on September 6, 1766, in Eaglesfield, England. He was the son of a weaver and received his early education from his father also at a Quaker school in his hometown, where he began teaching at the age of twelve. In 1781 he moved to Kendal, where he conducted a school with his cousin and older brother.
Blind Ambition Essay Research Paper Blind AmbitionJohn
Blind Ambition Essay, Research Paper Blind Ambition John Dean was counsel to the President. He wanted power and superiority. To advance up the ladder, John Dean got involved in certain activities. Some of which were not legal. One example would be the extortion of money. John Dean didn?t really think of the consequences but of the rewards.
Owen Meany Essay Research Paper Owen Meany
Owen Meany Essay, Research Paper Owen Meany lived his life to the fullest and lived to make the people that he loved happy. John gets accepted to attend University of New Hampshire and Owen follows John. Owen follows him for the reason that he feels John cannot cope with University and he feels he needs to be there to assist him.
Jfk Jr Essay Research Paper John F
Jfk Jr Essay, Research Paper John F. Kennedy Jr. John Fitzgerald Kennedy Jr. was born on November 25, 1960, two and a half weeks after his father was elected president of the United States and less than two months before his father was inaugurated. Three years later, that father, murdered by an assassin’s bullet, was buried on John’s third birthday.
Crucible By Miller Essay Research Paper John
Crucible By Miller Essay, Research Paper John Proctor was the main character in the play The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller. Will the truth set you free? In Proctor?s case of choosing truth over
John Brown Essay Research Paper John Brown
John Brown Essay, Research Paper John Brown’s raid on the federal armory at Harpers Ferry, Virginia, In October 1859, involved only a handful of abolitionists, freed no slaves, and was over in two days. Although many
John Locke Summary Essay Research Paper John
John Locke: Summary Essay, Research Paper John Locke: The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge: Summary Understanding and knowledge is what makes man superior to all other beings according to John Locke. However, the bounds of this understanding and knowledge are questionable. Is some knowledge innate? How certain can we be about beliefs and the knowledge we have? John Locke attempts to give some insight as to the answers of these questions in his work, The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper God in
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper ?God in Heaven, what is John Proctor, what is John Proctor? (Act IV, pg 138) The Crucible is a story of love, pity, revenge, and forgiveness. It details the lives
John Vincent Atanasoff Essay Research Paper John
John Vincent Atanasoff Essay, Research Paper John Vincent Atanasoff inventor of the electronic computer In any scienctific field, there needs to be a person with the vision to define the future. John Vincent Atanasoff was a genius with such a vision. He developed the first electronic digital computer that has dramatically changed our lives.
John Bardeen Essay Research Paper Bardeen John
John Bardeen Essay, Research Paper Bardeen, John 1908-91, American physicist; b. Madison, Wis. He was known for his studies of semiconductivity and other aspects of SOLID-STATE PHYSICS. The first
John Minnie And Petie A Love Triangle
Essay, Research Paper Karen Rayne Mrs. Wolf English 102.004 2 March 2001 John, Minnie, and Petie, A Love Triangle: Comedy and Tragedy in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles
The Outcasts Of Poker Flat 2
The Outcasts Of Poker Flat – John Oakhurst Analysis Essay, Research Paper John Oakhurst is the main character in ?The Outcasts of Poker Flat?. John is an outstanding person and has some phenomenal traits. Such as that he is unusually calm, courageous, and modest.John has shown numerous times in ?The Outcasts of Poker Flat?, that he is an extraordinarily calm person.
Crucible Essay Research Paper Tragic Hero EssayThe
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Tragic Hero Essay The historic happenings of the Salem Witch Trials are told in the story of the Crucible. In the Crucible, the main character is John Proctor. John Proctor is a tragic hero who is a great man but has one single flaw, pride, which will lead to his destruction.
Keats Essay Research Paper John Keats John
Keats Essay, Research Paper John Keats John Keats is one of the finest poets ever to write inEnglish. By the time of his death at the age of 25, he hadaccomplished more than all but the finest writers haveachieved in a full lifetime.”Endymion”, the poem was thefirst major work he undertook.(Microsoft) Keats was born to a family of humble means, the eldestof four children.
Basics On Keats Essay Research Paper John
Basics On Keats Essay, Research Paper -John Keats was born in 1795 and died in 1821 -John Keats was born in Moorfield, England -John Keats had two brothers, George and Tom, and a sister Fanny
Green Mile Essay Research Paper The Green
Green Mile Essay, Research Paper The Green Mile was about a murder of two girls. When the father is told by the mother that the 2 little girls are missing, he gets a whole crowwd together to look for the little girls. They
Character Sketch Of Mr Pignatti Essay Research
Paper Character Sketch of Mr. Pignatti Mr. Pignatti is just a big kid at heart. He was very lonely until John and Lorriane came along. He is a closed man and tries to hide his feelings
John Kennedy Essay Research Paper JOHN F
John Kennedy Essay, Research Paper JOHN F. KENNEDY John Fitzgerald was born in Brookline, Massachusetts on May 29, 1917. He graduated from Harvard University in 1940. Which
John Hale Vs John Proctor Essay Research
Paper Rev. John Hale vs. John Proctor The characters of John Hale and John Proctor in ?The Crucible? can be compared and contrasted according to their key traits, goals, and
The Crucible 2 Essay Research Paper In
The Crucible 2 Essay, Research Paper In the book, The Crucible, Abigail Williams and her childish friends take advantage of the situation in their hometown of Salem, Massachusetts. At the time, there was a lot of tension about the discussion of witches and virtually anyone who was accused of being a witch was proven a witch.