Paper
William Roy’s conception of the contemporary corporation focuses on the merger wave of the 1890’s during which which many large firms turned to public capital markets to facilitate mergers. The change that occurred in corporations was when they went from a public sphere to a private sphere. Two sectors, manufacturing and financial, came together at this time. In this book Roy criticizes the efficiency theory and relies heavily on the power theory. He felt that with the efficiency theory, anything that was done was done to maximize profits at that given time in history. The power theory looks back on history and relies heavily upon it. The main transformation that has occurred in corporate America has been the transformation of the ownership. Now corporations are owned by many people, (socialized capital) instead of an individual. “Corporations were developed to undertake jobs that were not rational or not appropriate from the perspective of the individual businessman.” (Roy, 41) This is where the transformation of public too private took place.
The corporation that exists today has been contingent and developed from pre-existing forms. It evolved from the public corporation. The emergence of the railroad, the power of anti-monopoly, anti-state method of Jacksonian anti-corporation privatized and democratized the corporation. Although the corporate retained many of its privileges, it also made these privileges available to the general public through incorporation laws. Thus, the corporation lost its hold on its public accountability.
The boundaries that were developed between the public and private could have been drawn quite differently. For instance, the manufacturing field could have maintained its power in firms that were not corporations. In addition, the corporate setting could have retained its public accountability. The state could have maintained more control over railroads and banks the way it controls highways today. Those who received the right of incorporation should have had to fulfill a public responsibility. States have performed private tasks in producing “consumer goods, trading commodities, speculating in land, and investing in enterprise.” (Roy, 44) The financial market also developed together with the federal treasury. Securities were sold through private brokers, while the state could have sold these securities directly. The boundaries are very shaky and not carefully explained.
William Roy presents a theoretical approach that argues that the concept of power provides a more sound and “more accurate foundation for understanding such economic processes as the rise of the large corporation.” (Roy, 6) He explained that only when managers of firms made decisions that were comparatively advantageous, did they survive. He thinks that efficiency theorists are functionalists. Power has influenced those who survived the competitive process, and determined the rules of the competitive process. This helps to explain why firms that survive the competitive process are not necessarily the most efficient. “American businessmen have always been aware that they share common interests at least as much as they compete over conflicting interests.” (Roy, 177) Businessmen have cooperated and there does exist a market.
The efficiency theory “is a selection process that ensures that more efficient economic forms will prevail over less efficient forms.” (Roy, 7) Under this theory, the “invisible hand” has replaced the “visible hand.” This reduced the costs of production and increased output per worker. The efficiency theory states that when people produce and distribute goods and services compete for scarce resources and only the truly efficient survive. According to the efficiency theory if something new is introduced to the marketplace it must be more efficient than its alternatives. An example of this is railroads. Railroads were developed because they were a more efficient way of traveling.
The power theory rejects some of the ideas the efficiency theory proposes. The efficiency theory attempts to explain why groups of individuals were motivated to form new corporations and not why they were able to. When corporations were formed, large amounts of resources were distributed unevenly. The efficiency theory treats uneven distribution as a flaw. The power theory treats the distribution of resources as important to the development of corporations. Also, if an industrialist is faced with the grim possibility of bankruptcy or a hope to merger, then they will most likely merger. The events that led to this decision involve power. People choose their own actions and make others act in a similar way with regards to their actions. Roy believes that size matters when controlling for other things. Labor productivity is lower in incorporated industries, so it must not be that incorporation makes firms more efficient. He believes that power is best explained in which the behavior of one person is explained in terms of the behavior of another. He believes that structural power gives an employer “that hires sociology majors rather than economics majors structures the consequences of choosing a major and is exercising power over students deciding on a major.” (Roy, 14) This idea of power, supercedes the efficiency theory.
Roy examines socialized capital in three states, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Ohio. In this section of the book, he examines the evolution of the corporation from a tool used by states to encourage economic development and raise revenues to its emergence as a private agent. This makes the corporation available to all through general incorporation statutes with no public responsibility or accountability. New Jersey had the most limited experience with public corporations. It was an investor to Camden and Amboy, and was able to keep its taxes low. However, the state was controlled by the railroad when it should have been reversed. Pennsylvania had both mixed corporations in which it invested and public corporations. Ohio had the most activist policy. The Ohio canal system developed the region and integrated it into the national economy. Ohio experienced failure in logrolling and almost bankrupted the whole state. Roy examined three different experiences of corporate law in his study. These areas included, permissibility of corporations owning other corporations, the powers of boards of directors and the extent of limited liability. The experience of mixed and public corporations has helped shape the attitudes of the three states. New Jersey’s corporate law was the most privatized which allowed corporations broad flexibility in owning other corporations, giving power t corporate boards, and extending unlimited liability through both a general incorporation statute and special charters. Ohio was on the opposite end of the spectrum. They were suspicious of the corporate from and many limitations followed. Thus, business in Ohio was less likely to be organized within a corporation. Roy insists that economic activity need not have taken place within the socialized corporation, or atleast not within a corporation with no social responsibility. He feels that there is nothing natural or inevitable about the present configuration of rights and responsibilities that constitute the corporation. This again explains why power is better than efficiency. ” Actions are explained in terms of their relationships with other social actors. The various alternatives they have to choose from and the costs and benefits resulting from the alternatives are determined by some social actors much more than others.” (Roy, 76)
The histories of particular industries, arguing that their use of the corporate form cannot be explained by changes in their technology. The desire for monopoly control and the expectation of financers that the corporate form would be used, led firms to incorporate. If one chooses to operate outside of the corporate sphere today, the chances for success are much more risky. This has happened because of the prior history and had changed investors’ ideas about how business had to be organized. The comparison of the three states is intended to suggest that there were various paths that the development of the corporation could have taken. These three states also have similar economic development, industrialization, and integration into the national economy. The existence of the market changes how rational people behave. Competitive pressure forces rational people to think more carefully. It also increases the importance of money in these calculations. His is quite relative to the real concerns for the community and the quality of human interactions.
Другие работы по теме:
William Mckinley Essay Research Paper William McKinley
William Mckinley Essay, Research Paper William McKinley was the seventh of nine children born to William and Nancy Allison McKinley. He was born in the Niles in 1843. His grandfathers had both fought in the American Revolution, and in 1830 his paternal grandfather had settled in Niles, Ohio. There, he opened a small pig-iron foundry.
William Jennings Bryan Essay Research Paper William
William Jennings Bryan Essay, Research Paper William Jennings Bryan William Jennings Bryan was a lawyer and a statesman who changed our nation for the better. Although he had many failed attempts at becoming president, he managed to change government with his innovative ideas. He showed the nation it s problems and fixed them; all the while meeting the publics needs.
The Merchant Of Venice A Tragic Play
Essay, Research Paper The Merchant of Venice: A Tragic Play In my opinion the play The Merchant of Venice is a tragic one which is discised as being comic. Many factors of this play are derived from the current
Zefferelli Vs Luhrmann Essay Research Paper William
Zefferelli Vs. Luhrmann Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet leaves a lot of room for creative elaboration. From this has come countless versions of the play. The two that I compared are Zefferelli’s and Luhrmann’s variations. Both spawned from the original and brought new concepts to the stage.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper In William
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper In William Faulkner’s Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech, he says, “He writes not of love but of lust, of defeats in which nobody loses anything of value, and victories without hope and worst of all, without pity or compassion.” William Faulkner is referring to “He” as the typical writer today.
EFFECT O N CONT THEATER Essay Research
Paper William Shakespeare?s Effect on Contemporary Theater William Shakespeare and all of his works greatly contributed to contemporary theater in many ways. His understanding of other people allowed him to fully grasp the quality he wrote of. The works of Shakespeare contain a strong and constant truth, touching emotional and supernatural aspects of life.
King James Essay Research Paper Chapter Two
King James Essay, Research Paper Chapter Two of William James’s Pragmatism called “What Pragmatism Means” begins with the famous metaphysical question: Does the man go round the squirrel or not? What he means by this is if a man walks around a tree in a full circle, and a squirrel is one of the tree branches, how come it never occurs to the man to say that he not only walked around the tree, but the squirrel as well?
Long Term Analysis Essay Research Paper Analysis
Long Term Analysis Essay, Research Paper Analysis by a Long Term Creditor The interest a long term creditor is currently receiving is 5.6%. A long term creditor could receive as much as 22.7% working somewhere else in the same industry. So, currently the industrial average is giving 17.1% more interest than workingat Cameco Corporation, which is quite a big difference.
Love In Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Love In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet is, without any doubt, one of William Shakespeare’s most puzzling plays. Often times, the reader becomes engulfed in the mystery, trickery and deceit in this tragedy. People become perplexed while reading Hamlet when they ask themselves the question, “Does Hamlet truly love Ophelia?”.
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
Krypton Essay Research Paper The element that
Krypton Essay, Research Paper The element that I have chosen in . The people who discovered it are known as Sir William Ramsay and Morris William Travers. Sir William Ramsay and Morris William
Revolutions Essay Research Paper One of the
Revolutions Essay, Research Paper One of the six revolutions that I have studied independently is the Glorious Revolution. The Glorious Revolution took place in England during 1688 to 1689. James II and the Catholic
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet 2000 CritiqueWhen
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ?Hamlet? (2000) Critique When we watch movies, we look for entertainment. That is the only reason why theatrical movies are created. Movies create entertainment which creates money.
William Bennett Essay Research Paper In William
William Bennett Essay, Research Paper In William Bennett?s ?Announcing a Public Campaign Against Select Day-Time Television Talk Shows?, William Bennett gives his view of the content that is being
The Human Brain Essay Research Paper An
The Human Brain Essay, Research Paper An English project by Chad Johnson and Emily Hicks This page has been accessed 799967 times since March 25, 1996. Announcing 123novels!
William Blake Essay Research Paper This week
William Blake Essay, Research Paper This week I was scheduled to work with Irene Balli. She is one of dining services main managers. She mostly oversees all of the banquets that go on here at Marywood. On the 16th of April was the Cor Marie, which is a very large banquet that consists of all major heads of all departments at Marywood.
Descriptive Essay On William Wallace 1 Pg
. Essay, Research Paper A Descriptive Essay On William Wallace A man of low status and called by some an outlaw or bandit, it may have been that Wallace was being used by more powerful Scottish politicians as a cover for their rebellion so they would not break their feudal vows to the king of England.
The Three Types Of Businesses In The
United States Essay, Research Paper A corporation is a business chartered by a state or the federal government that enjoys limited liability and has unlimited life. It is a business organization owned by its stockholders. As compared to the proprietorship and partnership forms, the corporation offers the following advantages: limited liability, unlimited life, and the ease of transfer to a new owner.
William Wordsworth Essay Research Paper Wordsworths Way
William Wordsworth Essay, Research Paper Wordsworth?s Way of Explaining His Past ?William Wordsworth, English poet, one of the post accomplished and influential of England?s romantic poets, whose theories and style created a new tradition in poetry ? ( Microsoft Encarta 1). Wordsworth began writing poetry when he was still in school, but it wasn?t until 1793 that any of his poems were published. ?Wordsworth?s political and intellectual sympathies underwent a transformation after 1800.
William Lloyd Garrison Essay Research Paper William
William Lloyd Garrison Essay, Research Paper William Lloyd Garrison: Uncompromise During Times of Compromise William Lloyd Garrison (1805-1879) was an American journalist and adamant abolitionist. Garrison became famous in the 1830s for his uncompromising denunciations of slavery.
William Shakespeare Essay Research Paper William ShakespeareA
William Shakespeare Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare A complete, authoritative account of Shakespeare?s life is not available; thus there is a lot of supposition surrounding few facts. William Shakespeare was generally believed to born on April 23, 1564 to Mary Arden and John Shakespeare in Stratford-upon-Avon, Warwickshire.
Another BIll Gates Essay Research Paper William
Another BIll Gates Essay, Research Paper William or Bill Gates was born on October 28, 1955. Bill had two sisters and they grew up in Seattle. Their father William H. Gates II is a Seattle
Education Essay Research Paper The Georgia Lottery
Education Essay, Research Paper The Georgia Lottery Corporation The Georgia Lottery was created in November 1992 by the people of Georgia to enhance education funding. The Lottery for Education Act createdthe Georgia Lottery Corporation (GLC) to oversee and operate the lottery. Rebecca Paul was hired in February 1993 as president of the GLC, andfour months later, on June 29, the Georgia Lottery was launched.
Television Essay Research Paper Televised debates between
Television Essay, Research Paper Televised debates between the nominees of the two major parties have become standard fare in contemporary presidential election campaigns. The authors of this important volume maintain that television has altered the very nature of presidential debates profoundly, that the demands of television have dictated the structure and formats of contemporary debates, and that the visual content of presidential debates plays an important role in the way that candidates exercise influence in televised debates.
Contemporary Design Essay Research Paper Contemporary design
Contemporary Design Essay, Research Paper Contemporary design is usually client based. The designer usually focuses on the presentation of ideas and statements through the collection rather than designing for any specific occasion. Contemporary design is more conceptual, because of this I am going to concentrate on the concepts and imagery associated with the idea of modern, futuristic clothing.
Neuromancer By William Gibson Essay Research Paper
When Neuromancer by William Gibson was first published it created a sensation. Or perhaps it would be more precise to say that it was used to create a sensation, for Bruce Sterling and other Gibson associates declared that a new kind of science fiction had appeared which rendered merely ordinary SF obsolete.
Braveheart Essay Research Paper Braveheart The movie
Braveheart Essay, Research Paper Braveheart The movie Braveheart is based on the control of England over Scotland. England in that time was ruled by Longshanks who made it a very powerful country because the government very rich. The English would go around and kill harmless Scots and by mistake they killed William Wallace’s girlfriend.
Forms Of Organization In Business Essay Research
Paper There are three main forms of organization in business: sole proprietorships, partnerships and corporations. Now according to the text, a vast majority of businesses are sole proprietorships in this country. However, the bulk of the sales are found in corporations. With this in mind, I believe that a corporation is the way to go.