’s Adventure To The Underworld Essay, Research Paper
Comparison Between Tale of Proteus and
Odysseus’s Adventure to the Underworld
“Now draw back from the pit, and hold your sharp sword away from me / so that I
can drink of the blood and speak the truth to you” (Odyssey 11.95). This quote, taken
from Teiresias as he is confronted by Odysseus’ request to learn of his way home and the
evils occurring in his palace, can very well be a climatic moment in the tale of the
Underworld (Don Nardo 121). After Odysseus learns of the happenings in Ithika and the
fate the Gods have bestowed upon him, he is forever changed. This change is part of the
metaphorical “death” Heros endure as a result of the wisdom and maturity they gain in
Death and Rebirth Myths. In Homer’s The Odyssey there are two comparable tales that
fall under this category, Tale of Proteus and Odysseus’ Adventure to the
Underworld. These two myths can easily be compared by analyzing the similarities and
differences of essential characters, the use of sensory imaging to describe the settings and
create a tone, and the metaphorical death and rebirth of the Hero as a result of his
attained knowledge and experience.
First, in order to have an accurate comparison between these two myths it is
necessary to acknowledge the similarities and differences of catalystic characters. The
first two characters are The Old Man of the Sea, Proteus and the prophet Teiresias.
Proteus and Teirisias both enlighten Menelaos and Odysseus on how they will get home
and the fate the Gods have for them. Although they both serve basically the same
perpose, there is a difference in which they each deliver the information. Proteus,
because he is a God, wants to clearly indicate to distinction between him and Odysseus
by being blunt and rude, he is proud and not as willing to give Odysseus information as
the Prophet is to Menelaos. This is evident in the first words Proteus speaks to Odysseus,
“Which of the gods now, son of Atreus, has been advising you / to capture me from
ambush against my will. What do u want?” (Odyssey 4.462). Teirisias has a very
different attitude towards Odysseus, he does not belive he is greater in anway way but
instead is very willing to answer any of Odysseus’ questions. The second pair of
characters serve as “Guiding Goddesses”, Eidothea and Circe. In Death and Rebirth
Myths, the Hero is always told of a passage to another world or advised to speak to a god
that holds a more respectable place in the divinity in order to learn what the Hero seeks
for (Harris 121+), these two Goddesses serve this perpouse. In Tale of Proteus, Menelaos
describes “Eidothea, daughter to Proteus, the Old Man of the Sea” as a kind soul who
aided him when he was desperate and did not know how he could possibly get home; “for
it was her heart that moved mostly/ when she met me wondering by myself without my
companions”(Odyssey 4.365). Eidothea advises Odysseus to seek her father, but in order
to do so must know how to bind him. The Goddess is very willing to show Menelaos
how to prove himself to her father as he asks her, “Show me the way to lie in wait for this
devine ancient” (Odyssey 4.395). Circe also plays this vital roll in Odysseus’ Adventure
to the Underworld. Before Odysseus leaves Circe’s Isalnd, the Goddess tells him, “first
there is another journey you must accomplish/ and reach the house of Hades and revered
Persephone, / there to consult with the soul of Teiresias the Theban” (Odyssey 11.490).
The distinction between the two roles these Goddesses play is first, Odysseus knew Circe
for almost a year and she had probably known for some time that when he left he would
first have to venture to the land of Hades. Menelaos situation was different, he was
hopeless and was pittied by a Goddess. A second distinction is the amount and value of
information each goddess provided. Circe gave Odysseus very valuable information
regarding routes and “creatures” he should avoid, even after it was explained by the
Prophet. She also told him of the sacrifices he had to make in order to invoke Teirisias.
On the other hand, Eidothea helped Menelaos in binding her father, but did not repeate or
give them any more valuable information other than how to receive her fathers help.
Another comparable and essential part to these myths is the sensory imaging used
by Homer to describe and create the settings and tones of these two tales. In Tale of
Proteus, the setting is a beach shore in the Egyptian Island of Pharos where Proteus is
King (Sherwood 261) and the story begins to unravel “at the time when the sun has gone
up to bestride the middle of Heaven (Odyssey 4.400). This image of the sun rising upon
the middle of heaven contrast with the “uncanny atmosphere of darkness and distress”
presented in the underworld (Luce 31). There are some descriptions in Tale of Proteus,
however, that create a tone of darkness such as the apparition of Proteus described by
Eidothea, “the Old Man of the Sea will come out of the water / under the bast of the West
Wind, circled in a shudder of darkening water and when he comes out he will sleep,
under hollow caverns (Odyssey 4.401), but in a whole, the beach setting is very similar to
paradise. On the other hand, The underworld in not a desirable place to be, “it is a vague,
shadowy place in habited by shadows. Nothing is real there. The Ghosts’ existece if it
can be called that, is like a miserable dream (Hamilton 42-3). The grim shoreline of
Oceanus where the Underworld is located (Sherwood 9), is described by Circe as a
dark place; ” you will find there a thickly wooded shore, and the groves of persophone, /
and tall black poplars growing, and the fruit-perishing willows; / then beach your ship on
the shore of the deep-eddying Ocean / and yourself go forward into the moldering home
of Hades” (Odyssey 11.509). This discription may indirectly imply the dark and dreary
place that is the home of Hades, but Teiresias’ opinion is first hand and very direct when
he says, “how is it, unhappy man, you have left the sunlight and come here, to look on
dead men, and this place without pleasure?” (Odyssey 11.93).
Finally, the most important factor to compare between these myths is the
metaphorical death and rebirth both Heros endure as a result of the wisdom they gain.
There is a great difference between the fate the Gods have planned for Menelaos and
Odysseus, thus there is a greater impact or change on Odysseus when he learns of the
hardships he still has to endure. On the other hand, Menelaos’ fate is “much easier to
swallow”. Although his fortune was not as bad as Odysseus’, when Menelaos is aware he
is obligated to journey back to Egypt and accomplish holy hecacombs in honor of the
Gods, he says, “the inward heart in me was broken / because he [Proteus] ordered me to
go back on the misty surface / of the water to Egypt again, a long way and a hard one”
(Odyssey 4.482). Other than learning about their fates and of their way home, both
either visualize or learn of the deaths of their comrades and family members. Once
again, Odysseus has to deal with the death of his loved ones on a harder level
than Menelaos, he witnesses their sufferings and interacts with them in the
Underworld. Although Odysseus’ experience with the death of his loved ones is harder,
the knowledge of having their family and/or friends dead deeply changes both heroes
forever. While they had been gone on their journeys to Troy, both did not know of the
happenings at their households or if the Achians they had fought along side with had
come back home. When Menelaos asks Proteus if the Achians he and Nestro left behind
come back, Proteus answers, “why did u ask me that? You should not learn it, nor know
what my mind knows, and I think you will not be free of tears for long, once you have
heard the whole story” (Odyssey 4.492). The inexplicable sorrow and emptiness
Meneloas and Odysseus bear with due to the effects of the difficult journeys they learn
they must continue to indure along with the deaths of their loved ones, causes them to
lose their will to live and sink into hopelessness and despare. A similar quote is repeated
in both Books eleven and four that capture the sorrow and pain both Heros feel, ” So he
spoke and the inward heart in me was broken, / and I sat down on the sand and cried, nor
did the heart in me wish to go on living any longer nor to look on the sunlight” (Odyssey
4.538). These two heroes experience and over whelming amount of hardships, but
because of their God-like qualities, they are able to pull themselves up from their
depression and pain and become stronger beings, thus the metaphorical death-and-rebirth
of the hero occurs.
In The Odyssey, Because the two myths Tale of Proteus and Odysseus’ Adventure
to the Underworld are both Death and Rebith Myths, they can easily be compared by
analyzing similarities and differences in essential characters, the usage of sensory
imaging to describe and create the settings and tones, and the metaphorical death and
rebirth of the Hero as a result of their attained knowledge and experience. Although their
are some differences in catalistic character traits, setting and tone, the essence of these
tales are the same. Both Heros, Menelaos and Odysseus, through another adventure,
prove themselves worthy of receiving wisdom and are forever changed by its affects,
giving birth to a new Hero.
Harris, John. “Proteus Surrenders: the life and death of death-and-rebirth.” Renascence., vol. 49. (Winter 1997). p. 121-138.
Hamilton, Edith. Mythology. Boston: Back Bay Books, 1998.
Homer. The Odyssey. Trans. Richmond Lattimore. New York: Harper and Row, 1967.
Luce, James T., ed. Ancient Writers:Greece and Rome. vol.1. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1982.
Nardo, Don. ed. Readings on Homer. Sandiego: Greenhaven,1998.
Sachs, David. Encyclopedia of the Ancient Greek World. Ed. Oswyn Murray. New York: Facts on File, 1995.
Sherwood, William. ed. Mythology of All Races: Greek and Roman. vol.1. New York: Cooper Square, 1961.
Другие работы по теме:
The Oddysey Essay Research Paper The OdysseyThis
The Oddysey Essay, Research Paper The Odyssey This book began with Odysseus finishing his tale in the King Alcinous’ palace. King Alicinous that tell Odysseus he will give him a safe passage home to Ithaca. Odysseus is not surprisingly grateful and hopes that Alcinous and his people and island are blessed by the gods.
Presidency Essay Research Paper CELEBRITY OBITUARIESOdysseus
Presidency Essay, Research Paper CELEBRITY OBITUARIES Odysseus (354 A.D.) The great adventurer Odysseus had died this year and it was thankfully the death he deserved, because unlike his lost friends who were eaten by the Cyclops, giant snake serpent, and the water cyclone that took the lives of most of his friends.
The Oddessy 2 Essay Research Paper A
The Oddessy 2 Essay, Research Paper A person who remains anonymous once said, The best way out of a Problem, is through it. Evidence of this statement is seen in several episodes of the epic poem, The Odyssey by, Homer. Odysseus is able to
Proteus Essay Research Paper Act II Scene
Proteus Essay, Research Paper Act II, Scene VI is a soliloquy delivered by Proteus, wherein he is pondering whether or not to pursue Silvia, the love of his dear friend, Valentine. We see a dramatic change in Proteus by the end of this scene.
The Odyssey Vs The Aeneid Essay Research
Paper Comparisons: The Odyssey The Aeneid Virgil was a creative genius from his time, but it can be understandable that many of his works may have been influenced from previous works of literacy. A comparison of Virgil?s, The Aeneid, and Homer?s, The Odyssey, will help to show the different aspects of Roman and Greek cultures.
The Odyssey 6 Essay Research Paper The
The Odyssey 6 Essay, Research Paper The Odyssey The Odyssey is the story of Odysseus’s journey from Troy to Ithaka. During his journey Odysseus is impeded by Poseidon and assisted by Athena. The use of olive wood as a metaphor lies in the differences between Athena and her uncle Poseidon in Odysseus’s journey back to Ithaka.
Odysseus Captain Irresponsible Essay Research Paper Through
Odysseus: Captain Irresponsible Essay, Research Paper Through his occurrences with Skylla and Charibdis, the Sirens, and Helios? cattle, Odysseus? heroic character is further disclaim in Book 12 because through all encounters Odysseus was a poor leader and put his crew in danger. His actions prove him to be selfish, boastful, stubborn, and irresponsible.
The Odessey Essay Research Paper The Odessey
The Odessey Essay, Research Paper The Odessey is a tale that has changed literature and storytelling. In this tale Odysseus is a Soldier from the battle of Troy trying to get home to his island of Ithaca, where he is king. His wife and son must wait ten years while he is trying to make his way home. In Odysseus’s absence wooer’s, or better known as suitors, learn of his absence and travel to Ithaca to win his wife’s hand in marriage.
The Odyssey Essay Research Paper In book
The Odyssey Essay, Research Paper In book twelve of The Odyssey, the main character, Odysseus, is confronted with three obstacles that he and his crew must conquer in order to get home to Ithaca. The first of the three obstacles that Odysseus and his crew must face are the sirens and their enchanting melody.
Odyssey Essay Research Paper In book XI
Odyssey Essay, Research Paper In book XI of the Odyssey, by Homer, Odysseus meets with several members of the underworld. These “shades” of death help Odysseus understand the importance of returning home; thus, giving him decisive steps in his re-education of life. Of the many “shades” Odysseus speaks with, the three that extend beyond the others are Antikleia, Agamemnon, and Akhilleus.
Odysseus Essay Research Paper Odysseus the Hero
Odysseus Essay, Research Paper Odysseus, the Hero The “Odyssey” is an epic story that has been a significant piece of literature since it wasfirst composed and will remain so for ages to come. One of the reasons it has been so isbecause of the hero, Odysseus. Odysseus is one of the first Greek mythic heroes renowned for his brain as well as hismuscle.
The Odyssey An Epic By Homer Essay
, Research Paper The Odyssey: An Epic By Homer What do you consider to be a hero? What traits should a hero have? My hero is Odysseus. In The Odyssey by Homer, Odysseus proves to be a true epic hero through his intelligence, bravery, and loyalty.
Did Odyssues Bring The Trouble On Himself
The Odyssey Essay, Research Paper Did Odysseus and his men bring the string of catastrophes on themselves? Yes, they did get themselves into serious trouble. With a pompous attitude, the men prolonged their journey home to Ithaca. Those who did not have Odysseus s smarts, died because of this. When they raided the Cicones village, harassed Poseidon s son, and killed the Helios s cattle, they punished themselves.
Odyssey A Hero Essay Research Paper An
Odyssey, A Hero? Essay, Research Paper An individual s characteristics are the key to their behavior. Homer s The Odyssey takes place about 700BC in the Mediterranean, near Greece. The epic tells of a man who left his home twenty years earlier to fight in the Trojan War. His mission now is to make his way home to Ithaca.
The Odyssey The Use Of Hubris Essay
, Research Paper “There is no safety in unlimited hubris” (McGeorge Bundy). The dictionary defines hubris as overbearing pride or presumption; arrogance. In The Odyssey, Homer embodies hubris into the characters Odysseus, the Suitors, and the Cyclopes. Odysseus shows hubris when he is battling the Cyclopes, the Cyclopes show hubris when dealing with Odysseus, and the Suitors show it when Odysseus confronts them at his home.
Traits Of An Epic Hero Essay Research
Paper Traits of an Epic Hero On Odysseus’ twenty year journey, he uses many of his traits to get back to Ithaca. Odysseus and his men fight the Cyclops, the Sirens and have to resist the temptation of the honeyed plants. A great epic hero, like Odysseus, needs to have numerous traits. Odysseus’ traits are strength, intelligence and self-confidence.
OdysseusThe Hero Homer Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus,The Hero, Homer Essay, Research Paper Odysseus, The Hero In today*s eclectic society, everybody*s heroes are different. However, during the era Homer*s The Odyssey was created all heroes had same characteristics. Heroes were the people who saved people, they were courageous wise and had fighting spirit.
Odysseus By Homer And Hero Essay Research
Paper Heroes are almost perfect people. Odysseus was a great Greek Hero. Just like all of us though, he had exceptional abilities and faults. You notice many examples
Man Or Boy Essay Research Paper Man
Man Or Boy? Essay, Research Paper Man or Boy? Telemakhos Can’t Decide Many boys who grow up without a father lack the direction and insight gained only through having a masculine role model. Such a boy is introduced in Homers’ epic tale The Odyssey as Telemakhos, Odysseus’ son. In the beginning of the story, Homer portrays Telemakhos as a timid and passive person who has not the strength to run out the suitors who have taken over his house.
Relationships In The Odyssey Essay Research Paper
Relationships in the Odyssey Essay Throughout the Odyssey, there are many relationships that represent love between two people. These relationships show loyalty, compassion, and the wanting to be near one another. Two of these kinds of relationships are between Odysseus and Telemakhos, and Odysseus and Penelope.
Odyssey Essay Research Paper The Odyssey
Odyssey Essay, Research Paper The Odyssey: Odysseus, the Hero The “Odyssey” is an epic story that has been a significant piece of literature since it was first composed and will remain so for ages to come. One of the reasons it has been so is because of the hero, Odysseus.
Odysseus And Aeneas Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus And Aeneas Essay, Research Paper Odysseus and Aeneas are very alike in some ways and very different. They are both epic heroes except that one is Greek and the other is a Trojan. Odysseus is from the Greek tale The Oddessy, which was written by the famous Greek poet Homer. His quest is to find his way back home after a long journey.
Surreptitious Odysseus Essay Research Paper When The
Surreptitious Odysseus Essay, Research Paper When The Odyssey was written, the Greek poet Homer defines his main character, Odysseus, as a great war hero. As the story progresses, Odysseus is many things other than the average warrior on a long, perilous journey home. One outstanding characteristic of this not so typical man is his wiliness.
Odysseus Essay Research Paper OdysseusOdysseus is without
Odysseus Essay, Research Paper Odysseus Odysseus is without a doubt an epic hero. He goes on a perilous journey even though not by his choice. He saves his comrades from great evils. He is considered to be a great military tactician and he is known around the world as a great man. All of those qualities and feats make Odysseus an epic hero!
Odysseus Heroism Essay Research Paper Odysseus heroismThe
Odysseus Heroism Essay, Research Paper Odysseus heroismThe journey in Homer’s tragic poem involves a test which will prove whether the main character, Odysseus, is worthy of achieving his goal. To be worthy is to posses the qualities of a hero, such as strength, courage, faith, intelligence, politeness, hospitality, respect for the gods and attachment to his family.
The Odysseus Essay Research Paper Telemachi is
The Odysseus Essay, Research Paper Telemachi is the son of Odysseus and Penelope in the epic novel, “The Odyssey”. Telemachi’s role in the novel reiterates the strength and courage of Odysseus. The
The Odyssey In Popular Culture Essay Research
Paper Many forms of popular culture today are inspired by themes, characters, and other references in various types of classical literature. John Denver?s song ?Calypso? is about the relationship between men and women, and he bases this comparison on the relationship between Kalypso and Odysseus in Homer?s the Odyssey.
Odysseus The Great Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus The Great Essay, Research Paper Odysseus the Great Of all the mythological heroes, Odysseus would have to be the greatest. His adventures strengthened him and made him wiser. Although his men assisted him in his warfare, Odysseus was always at the heart of the battle. Odysseus was a true epic hero.
Odysseus And Circe
’s Meeting Essay, Research Paper Odysseus and Circe?s Meeting Odysseus and his comrades arrive at the ?island of Aeaea, the home of the beautiful Circe, a formidable goddess, with a mortal women?s voice.? (Homer10.135-137). Following the transformation of Odysseus?s crewmembers being turned into pigs.
Godlike Odysseus Essay Research Paper Odysseus son
Godlike Odysseus Essay, Research Paper Odysseus, son of Laertes, was godlike in many ways, but he also showed some human or mortal characteristics. In The Odyssey by Homer, he shows this in a few ways while on his way home to Ithica from the land of the Lotus-eaters, and also when he is home. Either something upsets him like a human would get upset, or he does something a human would do and normally wouldn’t see from a god.