Marxist Industrial Relations Essay, Research Paper
Work dominates the lives of most men and women; the management of employees is a central feature of organisational life. We must strive to understand the nature of the working relationship between managers and its employees in order to fully appreciate Industrial Relations. We perceive Industrial Relations on specific issues and situations when approached and analysed, looking at how people behave and are expected to behave and how their behaviour can be influenced. In this way Industrial Relations has become established and its focus is the regulation of the employment relationship, looking at the collective aspects between the workforce and management and the combined problems of social welfare and social order. In this way Industrial Relations can be defined as ‘a set of phenomena, operating both within and outside the workplace, concerned with determining and regulating the employment relationshipґ. Industrial Relations are recognised in various extremes but in order to gain a better understanding they have been simplified into three perspectives, these are Pluralism, Unitarism and Marxism. The pluralistic approach looks at conflict as well as co-operation, assuming a society with different values, interests and objectives. The unitary perspective ranges from authoritarian to paternalistic considering an integrated group of people whilst the Marxist perspective adopts an evolutionary or revolutionary approach to social change, assuming imbalance and inequalities in society. Before we can place a value on this perspective of weaknesses and contradictions and the ascendancy of socialism over capitalism, we must first study the other viewpoints to arrange a significant conclusion. Since its significance in the 1980ґs, the unitary perspective has been an essential ideology in most organisations, placing an emphasis on harmony and working together as a team with a common objective. If conflict arises, it is seen as frictional, caused by irrational behaviour resulting from personality clashes within the organisation. This is seen as a direct result of management failure and its poorly communicated plans and decisions. The idea is that decisions by managers are made for the good of all people in the organisation but the employees fail to understand this. Unitarism represents a management ideology because the management style contains notions of leadership rather than of power. The organisation is based on a managerial prerogative that is regarded as legitimate, rational and generally accepted. Within this perspective, the management approach to resolving conflict is based on authority and paternalism, coupled with thoughts and threats and including the use of law, this coercion is regarded as a legitimate use of power; helping to control decisions and changes. Dismissal, training and development and improving communications can also remove conflict. Many corporate and human relation strategies have emerged through unitarism, helping improve interpersonal relations and communications within the organisation. The principles Just In Time (JIT) and Total Quality Management (TQM) have also been developed through unitarism. JIT refers to making an organisation more efficient by cutting warehouse costs etc., having stock delivered just before it is needed. TQM relates to increasing revenue by making quality improvements in production and manufacturing. Unitarist managers feel that trade unions are no longer necessary to protect employeesґ interests because of the advent of human resource management. The organisation is seen as being capable of looking after its own, no longer being a ‘them and usґ situation but a feeling of togetherness, thus managers are now reluctant to acknowledge any role for trade unions in authority and decision making. As a result, trade unions and collective bargaining have been resisted rather than being welcomed by managers.
Pluralism looks at diverging interests within organisations; being complex, diverse and competitive. From this point of view, the organisation is seen as multi-structured with various interest groups creating a widespread distribution of authority and power, taking away ownership from the manager. As opposed to the unitary approach, trade unions are tolerated as they do have some legitimacy, because conflict is perceived as rational and inevitable. Managers understand that the organisation is diverse, determined with differing roles of managerial and employee groups causing conflict by specific situations and management principles. Managers seek to improve efficiency, productivity and profitability, co-ordinating employees to achieve this, while employees seek to better their pay, working conditions, job security etc. This principle believes that change and efficiency will be promoted within the organisation, as employees will owe loyalty to authority and being accepted by employers. Management generally seek to maintain maximum authority as employees try to establish safeguards against arbitrary management decisions and actions. It is accepted that trade unions play a positive role so there is a need for shared decision making, through negotiations and collective bargaining. As both groups have a common interest to survive in the organisation, they are prepared to compromise by limiting their claims and aspirations to negotiable levels. Although not as dominant, the Marxist perspective is very influential, looking at the economic and social divisions between those who own the means of production and those who donґt. Employment is based on exploitation and inequality, where labour is only used when needed and profit earned is far higher than wages paid. Inequalities in society appear through the amount of power and wealth a person has. Trade unions are seen as an inevitable employee response to capitalism and are used as a balancing tool in helping employers control and legitimise their use of power over employees. Management perceive trade unions and as giving them the right to order work in return for pay. The nature of conflict is seen as inherent in economic and social systems, which is resolved through a change in society. Trade unions and collective bargaining have become established and accepted as it is seen as an employeeґs response to capitalism, expressing a difference in class and leading to developments in political awareness. With the Marxist perspective developed to legitimise control and the law supportive of managementґs interests rather than being independent, Industrial Relations are analysed and integrated in social, political and economic terms and not separated. Therefore this association of the development of the working classes must be recognised by union members, and acted upon accordingly through policies and decisions of the organisation. This viewpoint is critical of pluralists, arguing that they have a false pretence of having a valid contribution; this can also be applied to unitarism too. Pluralism is seen as maintaining an illusion of a balance of power between various interest groups, hiding the real imbalance in social power. Although we understand that Marxism is influential in organisations, from a unitary perspective, pluralism remains dominant in most firms in recognising conflict and managers have never been so in touch. It can be said that the Marxist perspective is mainly supported by determinists, those who can explain everything, therefore making the theory very limited but influential from a workers point of view. But this can raise questions, Marxism through the class conflict, ascribes trade unions to defeating capitalism. Trade unions stand for an entire workforce and there are only a few people who represent these, it can be said that they have a lack of training for this task and may well have a hidden agenda, are the working people really represented? Although there is a common concern with the inevitability of conflict and industrial disputes, Marxist and pluralists treat these differently, where pluralists agree that management decisions can be subject to appeal, agreeing to mechanisms for resolution, Marxists argue that capitalist ownership and decision making remain preserved, being legitimised by trade unions and maintaining the status quo. The Marxist perspective holds value within Industrial Relations because until this concept, there has been no prescriptive literature from a trade unions perspective. Research on strikes, wages, unemployment etc. is conducted from a government perspective while managers provide literature on human resource and organisations. As a paradigm, the Marxist perspective makes powerful assumptions, which tend to be accepted to the exclusion of any other equally valid viewpoint.
Другие работы по теме:
Family Life Cycle Essay Research Paper There
Family Life Cycle Essay, Research Paper There are several ways in which the family life cycle can be analyzed in comparison to the definition of the family. They can be static, focusing on structures for instance, role relations or they can capture dynamic processes; how role relationships between husband and wife or parent and child change over time and how they are related to socio-cultural changes.
The Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper The
The Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper The industrial revolution My view of the industrial age started in the 1700 A positive effect of the industrial revolution was the greatly enhanced labor productivity brought about by the mechanization of production processes (and the resulting widespread adoption of coal or water power factory-based manufacturing).
Values Essay Research Paper A value is
Values Essay, Research Paper A value is a social principle goal, or standard held by an individual, class, or society. Values are shaped by the surrounding situations. The Industrial Revolution created new values in Western society, values that are central to our thinking today. Three things from the Industrial Revolution that directly affected people’s values were the creation of the middle class, the urbanization of cities, and the growth of rights for women.
The Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper I
The Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper I. Industrial Revolution A. Around the middle of the eighteenth century, Europeans began to substitute machines for human labor on a large scale.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper Capitalism has greatly
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism has greatly developed over the course of the twentieth century. It has been broken down into two basic models: Non-Marxist, and Marxist. These models are the Industrial society model, and the Capitalist society model. These ideals were created in the 1930 s and ran through about the 1960 s, however to keep up with the changing society these models were revised and renamed the Post industrial Society and, the Post Capitalist society which are dated from the 1960 s and 70 s.
Transformation In The Institutions Of Work And
Economy Due To Technology Essay, Research Paper The revolution or transformation in the institutions of work and economy due to technology came about through a shift in the means of production and of consumption. Means of production refers to the process by which the production of material goods is carried out in a society.
A School
’s Daily Schedule From 1912 Essay, Research Paper Cushman Indian School, Tacoma, Wash. February 1, 1912 Monday 5:45 A.M.– Reveille. 5:55 to 6:10 — Setting Up Exercise & Drill.
College Essay Essay Research Paper There
College Essay Essay, Research Paper There’s a lot of talking these days about what it will mean to live, work and prosper in the 21st century. In fact this century is being hailed as a kind of renaissance. Not the rebirth of classic art and culture, as in the 15th century, but a rebirth of what we understand to be knowledge, how to acquire it and how to use it productively.
Alteration Of The Vision Essay Research Paper
The Marxist belief being that class struggle plays a primary role in analyzing Western society in general and in understanding its allegedly inevitable development from bourgeois oppression under capitalism to a socialist society and thence to Communism.(American Heritage, 1997) was the guiding beacon of the revolution of Russia.
Industrial Revolution Essay Research Paper How Global
Industrial Revolution Essay, Research Paper How Global Warming Relates to the Industrial Revolution Global Warming relates back to the Industrial Revolution in many ways. During the Industrial Revolution many new inventions were made that would make life easier for people back then and also in the future.
20THCENTURY CAPITALISM Essay Research Paper 20THCENTURY CAPITALISM
20TH-CENTURY CAPITALISM Essay, Research Paper 20TH-CENTURY CAPITALISM For most of the 20th century capitalism has been buffeted by wars, revolution, and depression. World War I brought revolution and a Marxist-based communism to Russia. The war also spawned the Nazi system in Germany, a malevolent mixture of capitalism and state socialism, brought together in a regime whose violence and expansionism eventually pushed the world into another major conflict.
Lenin Essay Research Paper lenin was born
Lenin Essay, Research Paper lenin was born 400 miles east of moscow, his background was highly privilaged. his father was a school inspector and in the army and his mother was the daughter of a docter. the first phase of lenins life was spent in political exile in siberia. his second phase in adult life was when he returned to russia following the collapse of tzarism. in october 1917 he became head of the russian government. his work eventually destroyed his health. during the final period of his life he was incapable of political activity. . lenin was a commited marxist who was against the old tzarism.
The Commonwealth Essay Research Paper How did
The Commonwealth Essay, Research Paper How did traditional industrial location factors influence The pattern of industry in the UK? Traditional industrial location factors were, in the words of Karl Marx: Land, Labour, Capital and Raw materials , and these greatly influenced industrial location in the UK up until the 70 s:
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay Research Paper The
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay, Research Paper The impact of the Industrial Revolution was a positive experience for some, but it was a great difficulty for others. Because of the demands for reform and protection for workers arose, government and unions began to take place. That was how the evils of the Industrial Revolution addressed in England in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
Marxist Class Struggles Essay Research Paper The
Marxist Class Struggles Essay, Research Paper The kind of class struggle between the capitalists and the working class described by Marx is without a doubt, still at work in present-day capitalist society. Although the extent to which his predictions are validated varies from one society to the next, the general theoretical framework that he explains is prevalent in many of the conditions that are present in our society.
Ndustrial Revolutions Effects On Europe Essay Research
Paper name = Justin Katz email = TRipLeZeR0@juno publish = yes subject = Europe History title = Industrial Revolutions effects on Europe papers = The Industrial Revolution had an overall positive effect on Europe. This
Heather Garcia Essay Research Paper On October
Heather Garcia Essay, Research Paper On October 23, Heather Garcia came to our communications class to talk about her experiences working in the field of communications. Ms. Garcia is originally from San Diego, California, and is class of 1998 graduate of Western Kentucky University.
Industrial Rev Essay Research Paper The Positive
Industrial Rev. Essay, Research Paper The Positive Outcome of the Industrial Revolution in Britain The industrial revolution has its share of both positive and negative effects on the society and the country as a whole. There are many aspects you must look toward, to realistically analyze the industrial revolution.
Lea Valley 2
Lea Valley – Where Is The Area Under Study Essay, Research Paper The Lea Valley Regional Park is in Picketts Lock, it is along the A1055. In this area there is recreational land use (golf course
Industrial Engineer Essay Research Paper Industrial EngineerThere
Industrial Engineer Essay, Research Paper Industrial Engineer There are many categories that the career of an industrial engineer can break down in to. Of these are quality-control, time-study, process, plane design or factory layout, production, and documentation engineers. There are also configuration management analyst, tool planner, and vendor equally supervisors.
Industrial Age Essay Research Paper Industrial Age
Industrial Age Essay, Research Paper Industrial Age The Industrial Age had positive and negative aspects. First off it was a stepping- stone to launch us into today’s world. Without it, many of us would not be here today. A
The Working Class Essay Research Paper The
The Working Class Essay, Research Paper The working class, the lowest of the hierarchy, was also referred to as the underclass. Such people were forced to lead lives of hard work that were controlled by the industry and markets. This was the only class gained few benefits from the changes the Industrial Revolution.
Communication Essay Research Paper CommunicationCommunication is very
Communication Essay, Research Paper Communication Communication is very important to your customers. An aspect of communication is personal trade. Personal trade is a customer that comes into your store and asks for you by name. This customer might be someone you spoke with over the phone and a relationship was developed.
Trade Relations With China Essay Research Paper
“A Paper Tiger on Trade” It seems that the major question surrounding the United States and its foreign relations these days is whether or not we grant China Permanent Normal Trade Relations(PNTR). Some feel that we should give it to them, while many oppose the move as well. However, the reasons to not grant China PNTR are not nearly as conclusive as those reasons to grant it to them.
Russian Revolution Essay Research Paper Many events
Russian Revolution Essay, Research Paper Many events led up to the Russian Revolution but it was sparked by just a few. It couldn’t have started without the oppression of the Russian populace. The heavy losses in World War I. The political views of famed Marxist Lenin to lead the oppressed Russian peasants and Nicholas II’s role in Bloody Sunday.
Industrial Revolution Of England Essay Research Paper
The Industrial Revolution of England in the late 19th century brought many sweeping changes along with it. The most radical change brought on by the Industrial Revolution was the installment of a free public school system. In an article written by Christopher Argyle (a scholar on the Industrial Revolution in England) he states the creation of the public school was a response to abuse of children in the workforce during the Industrial Revolution.
Four Perspective Of Feminism Essay Research Paper
Q.1(b) Feminist approaches to sociological theory have developed out of historical sites of struggle for equality. Describe the strengths and weaknesses of four (4) different feminist theoretical orientations.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.