Defending Materialism Essay, Research Paper
Defending Materialism
Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the world is explicable only as a world composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body. Socrates and Plato are called dualists because they think that mind and body are separate and distinct substances. Mind is conscious and non-spatial and body is spatial but not conscious. While separate, the two supposedly interact. Socrates argues that the mind and body are separable and the soul is immortal. It is through the mouth of Socrates that Plato presents his argument for dualism. The argument contains three parts. First, the harmony analogy is inconsistent with the recollection argument. Next, the harmony analogy entails that all souls are equally virtuous. Lastly, the harmony analogy cannot account for the fact that the soul can resist the body s temptations and can control the body s behavior.
Materialism, on the other hand, is a way that people consider the relations between mind and matter to be inseparable. We are physical beings and our mental reactions are just by-products of a material process; the human being is not, nor has, a non-material aspect, but is a purely physical entity. Materialists believe that the human soul cannot exist because the soul is something mental and when the body dies, the brain fails to survive as well and our concept of soul no longer exists. I believe that materialism can be defended and Socrates three objections can be disproved using Simmias argument of harmony.
Simmias harmony analogy uses harmony, lyre, and strings to defend materialism. Simmias replies to Socrates, a harmony is something invisible, without body, beautiful and divine in the attuned lyre, whereas the lyre and itself and its strings are physical, bodily, composite, earthly and akin to what is mortal. Then if someone breaks the lyre, cuts or breaks the strings and then insists, using the same argument as you, that the harmony must still exist and is not destroyed because it would be impossible for the lyre and strings, which are mortal, to exist when the strings are broken, and for the harmony, which is akin and of the same nature as the divine and immortal, to be destroyed before that which is mortal; he would say that the harmony itself still must exist and the wood and the strings must rot before the harmony can suffer If then the soul is a kind of harmony or attunement, clearly, when our body is relaxed or stretched without due measure by diseases and other evils, the soul must immediately be destroyed, even if it be most divine, as are the other harmonies found in music and all the works of artists, and the remains of each body last for a long time until they rot or are burned (Plato 36, 37). This analogy shows the soul as being mortal, as the wood and strings rot away and are destroyed, so does the soul.
Socrates states that harmony analogy is inconsistent with the recollection argument. According to Socrates, we must at some previous time have learned what we now recollect. Socrates believes that this is possible only if our soul existed somewhere before it took on this human shape. So according to this theory, the soul is likely to be something immortal. This argument sounds stable, but Simmias harmony analogy clearly disproves this, as harmony cannot occur without the lyre and strings, thus proving that there had to be a lyre and strings in order to create harmony.
The harmony analogy entails that all souls are equally virtuous can be disproved by the outcasts in the world. If each soul were equally virtuous, there would not be people like Hitler (mentioned in lecture) or Jeffrey Dahmer in the world. It is impossible for every soul to be harmonized, because they would all act alike and have the same values. To each his own harmony, for no one person is exact.
Socrates final objection is the harmony analogy cannot account for the fact that the soul can resist the body s temptations and can control the body s behavior. Socrates believes that the soul directs the body, as harmony does not direct the lyre. From a materialist s point of view, the body and soul work together, rather than Socrates belief that the soul takes over the body. When a human being gets sick, he or she will obviously not act the same as usual. The body has much control over how we act and what we do. The soul and body are in sync with each other.
The nature of being is a philosophy debate that will continue as long as there are people to think about it. It is up to the individual to determine whether the mind and body are two distinct factors and the soul is immortal, or if the soul is inseparable from the body and a purely physical entity. Both arguments have stability, yet it is easy to see that what Socrates says can be disproved through the analogy of Simmias.
Другие работы по теме:
History Of Law Essay Research Paper The
History Of Law Essay, Research Paper The history of law is very interesting. No one can really say when law began. The earliest known written law of which a copy has been found, is Ur-Nammu?s Code of 2050 BC. The copy of the code is in such bad shape, that we have only been able to decipher five articles. Archaeological evidence shows that this code was supported by an advanced legal system.
College Essay Essay Research Paper It would
College Essay Essay, Research Paper It would be conventional to choose a parent, family member, friend, or teacher as a significant source of influence in ones life. However I am not conventional or at least I try not to be. I am very open-minded and observant. My personality and work exhibit eclectic-laden themes drawn from a chaotic world of sources in which I perceive.
Hate Literature Essay Research Paper Hate literaturematerialism
Hate Literature Essay, Research Paper Hate literature/materialism currently exists on the internet, and is expanding at a high rate, causing disturbance to society. Although the internet is known to be a free base to express opinions, thoughts, and general information, exploiting that particular use can be rather dangerous, especially when offending one’s culture.
The Long Death Of The Plains Indians
Essay, Research Paper “The long death? is an appropriate title for the book describing the slow death of the Plains Indian?s way of life. It took many years for the white man to alter and ruin the lives and homeland of the Plains Indians as the tribes suffered tremendously in the process. The Indians soon became warriors, to no avail, in hopes of defending their land against the settlers.
Journalism Essay Research Paper While Burl Osborne
Journalism Essay, Research Paper While Burl Osborne is a strong believer in the right to free speech, he said that ” the urge to censor is the reaction of well-intended people to the expression of views that they find repugnant.”
Arch Bishop
– Becket Essay, Research Paper Before being named Arch Bishop, Becket found his pride in serving Henry and performing his duties as his Lord Chamberlain, all the while searching for his true honor and pride. He found them to be defending the honor of God and the Church after he became Arch Bishop.
Age Of Reason Essay Research Paper The
Age Of Reason Essay, Research Paper The age of reason was a time of Empiricism and of Materialism, which brought out philosophers like John Locke and George Berkeley as well as authors like Swift and Pope. These philosophers and authors belong to the Age of Reason because of their use of anti-emotional thought and the idea of Occam’s razor.
Socrates And The Self Defense Clause Essay
, Research Paper The question of Morality and what it means: Throughout the recorded history of man, there has been a series of questions continually asked by each generation. ?Who are we? Where are we going? Why? Is there a God?? Are just a few of the questions that continue to engage the minds of so many today.
Themes Materialism Essay Research Paper In the
Themes: Materialism Essay, Research Paper In the novel, The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald successfully portrays that materialism as the corrupt source of the society. Like Fitzgerald, Jay Gatsby is a sensitive young man who idolizes wealth and luxury, and falls in love with a beautiful young woman while stationed at a military camp in the South.
AtticusTo Kill A Mocking Bird Essay Research
Paper Atticus is the town’s most respected lawyer. He is not wealthy, but he is well off in the community and kind towards everyone. He has been assigned a case of defending a black man accused of rape. Now he is both revered and reviled by the townspeople. After all, they do live in the south in the early 1930’s.
Global Warming Essay Research Paper My position
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper My position on global warming is that despite the media’s claim of a rising climate, in reality there is no cause for concern. Inane reports regarding global warming are yuppie-tree-hugger propaganda. The information defending their case is misleading and inaccurate.
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
French Revolution 4 Essay Research Paper The
French Revolution 4 Essay, Research Paper The causes of the French Revolution, being provoked by this collision of the powers of the rising bourgeoise and an sinking aristocracy defending its privileges, was the Financial debt of the government and the long-standing political differences in the government.
Character Of Beowulf Essay Research Paper The
Character Of Beowulf Essay, Research Paper The Character of Beowulf Beowulf is a truly unique character in the realm of Anglo-Saxon poetry. Two main traits that make him stand out are his assertiveness and his yearning for fame. Beowulf shows incredible courage and confidence by slaying both Grendel and his mother.
Materialism Vs Dualism Essay Research Paper Materialism
Materialism Vs Dualism Essay, Research Paper Materialism vs. Dualism There is no doubt that we are physical beings, but there is a question as to where our consciousness comes from. Can this consciousness come from a completely physical make up or do we have another non-physical entity? Does consciousness come from a physical brain or a non-physical mind? The two competing views of this question are materialism and dualism.
Letters Of War Essay Research Paper Letters
Letters Of War Essay, Research Paper Letters of War ?Spartan mothers of old, who, when their sons went forth to battle for freedom and their native land, said to their sons:
Tolerance Comes Into Play Essay Research Paper
Tolerance Comes into Play Tolerance is a good virtue to own, without it there is no way to succeed. To Kill a Mockingbird is a great novel written by Harper Lee. In this book, a great deal of tolerance is shown by Atticus. His tolerance is shown especially in the town, when dealing with his kids and when talking to Aunt Alexandra.
Question Can A Person Perform Evil Acts
Voluntarily? Essay, Research Paper Question: Can a person perform evil acts voluntarily? ?Evil corrupts the evil doer.? ?Is there anyone, then, who wishes to be harmed by those he associates with, rather than to be benefited?? In defending himself against accusations of corruption and evil, Socrates argues in his apology that no person performs evil acts voluntarily.
Individuality Essay Research Paper
“If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.” Self-reliance creates individuality through believing in one’s self and defending those beliefs. The ability of one to be a non-conformist and make choices on their own, brings into being individuality.
Defending Hester Prynne Then And Now Essay
, Research Paper Defending Hester Prynne Then and Now When deciding between prosecuting or defending the character of Hester Prynne in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novel, The Scarlet Letter, it would be well to keep in mind the words of Alexander Pope: “To err is human, to forgive divine.” The sin of adultery in itself is not the question here, but the degree of punishment for that sin is.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Retired professor and
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Retired professor and psychoanalyst Ernest Van den Haag, by defending the right to commit suicide, made an appeal to J.S. Mill?s principle. Van den Haag said that people should have the right to choose as they please, as long as no one else is hurt (Hallock 13). According to the constitution, people have the right to decide death, not the government (Dority 8).
The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism And Materialism
Essay, Research Paper The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism I am faced with the philosophical task of defending either dualism or materialism, depending on which one is most attractive to me. So either I support the theory of dualism, which is the belief that there is both a physical and a spiritual state, or I believe in materialism, which is the belief that everything that exists is material or physical.
To Kill A Mockingbird Effects Of Racism
) Essay, Research Paper To Kill a Mockingbird is a wonderfully written book by Harper Lee. It takes place in the 1930?s which was a time that was known for its racism. The following essay will explain how racism effected certain characters in the book.
American Civil Liberties Union Aclu Defending The
Ku Klux Klan (Kkk). Essay, Research Paper Living in a free society is a benefit as well detraction. In our country the First Amendment of the constitution gives us freedom of speech. However this right to free speech comes with the sacrifice of having to hear opinions that are repugnant to the majority. So we have the incongruous situation, like oil and water, of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) defending the Ku Klux Klan (KKK).
Abortion Essay Research Paper ABORTIONThe coexistence of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper ABORTION The coexistence of opposite and conflicting feelings about abortion is centuries old. Most arguments against granting women the right to abortion are based on religious and moral prohibitions, defending the sanctity of human life. Opponents of abortion rely on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person from the moment of conception.
To Kill A Mockingbird Part 1 Essay
, Research Paper Do you remember reading To Kill a Mockingbird? I think that this is a novel that I won’t ever forget. I will start out this responce by telling you about my favorite character, which is Scout. She is a tomboy, which not everyone likes, especially Mrs. Dubose. Scout likes to hang aroud with Jem, and most of the time he lets her.
John Kellogg Essay Research Paper Surgeon food
John Kellogg Essay, Research Paper Surgeon, food reformer; born in Tyrone Township, Mich. (brother of Will K. Kellogg). Born into a Seventh Day Adventist family, he took a course in a “hygieotherapeutic” school. He rejected this approach and took regular medical training, finishing at Bellevue Hospital Medical College (New York City) but with a thesis claiming that disease is the body’s way of defending itself.
What Price Freedom Essay Research Paper How
What Price Freedom Essay, Research Paper How hard would you fight to defend something you believed in? Hundreds, thousands, probably million of lives were lost fighting for what they believed in; fighting to defend America. Why, are you thinking? What could have been so important that these men felt they had to fight until the end? Would you believe that those men fought for you, me and the rest of the population.