Merely Innocent Victims Essay, Research Paper
Literary criticism on The Turn of the Screw has been divided into 3 groups, concerning the plot. The first is to take the novel at face value, and say that it is a ghost story, that the children are possessed by the ghosts. Others have said that it is a psychological drama that plays upon some of Freud?s theses – the ghosts are hallucinations of a sexually repressed girl who has been given a sudden boost in responsibility, and her madness corrupts the beautiful. The third is to say that the novel is a meta-fiction it comments on the popular gothic style of writing novels, which were often read deeply into, by repressed Victorians looking for something to be ?outraged? by, and therefore is written to be so ambiguous that it is impossible to say if the ghosts are ghosts or not. Consider the possibility that the first two ideas are combined, perhaps the ghosts do exist but the governess is driven mad by them, and eventually kills Miles in an attempt to banish the ghosts.
Critics have taken one part of the book to be the most important in the argument for the existence of the ghosts, and this is the fact that the governess describes in great detail the appearance of a man who she has never seen before. He: ?? has no hat…He has red hair, very red, close – curling, and a pale face, long in shape, with straight good features and little rather queer whiskers that are as red as his hair ?. This is enough evidence for Mrs. Grose to identify him as: ? ?Peter Quint – his own man, his [the master?s] valet, when he was here! ??. Then Mrs. Grose informs the Governess that Peter Quint is dead, but instead of protesting that she cannot have seen a dead man she accepts the fact, maybe this means that she has seen him before, after his death, and when the governess sees Quint for the first time, Mrs. Grose is shocked to see the governess at the window. Here is more proof to back up the argument that Mrs. Grose knows about the ghosts. People have said that she may have questioned the other servants as to his appearance, but left it out of the manuscript that she wrote.
Quint’s appearance, is very devilish, a man with red hair and whiskers, and Miles in the closing chapter shouts out: ?Peter Quint ? you devil ? It is said that he maybe referring to the governess as the devil, or is he calling Quint a devil.
Another point is that if James had wanted to study sexual frustration in a psychological drama, he could have written a much simpler story, and made it less elaborate. So why is the story overly complex, when there could be one child and one ghost. Also, the phallic symbols would be even more prominent.
The governess quite understandably after realising that she has seen a dead man, she tries to make sense of the situation, but this causes her to patch up the story with increasingly illogical ideas. For instance when she sees Mrs. Jessel for the first time she decides that Flora can see the ghost, because she does not look at her. ?My heart had stood still for an instant with the wonder and terror of the question whether she, too, would see; and I held my breath while I waited for a cry from her…I waited, but nothing came ?. Even though Flora says nothing about the ghost, the governess tells Mrs. Grose that: ?They know – it?s too monstrous: they know, they know! ? and goes on to tell Mrs. Grose not to ask Flora about it because?? – she?ll lie! ?. She also decides that ?the child will keep it up…[ visiting Miss Jessel] without my knowing it ?. There is no evidence that any of this is true, the Governess is deciding that it must be, because it fits with what she has seen. She decides that they are evil, because they whisper to each other, but many children whisper to their siblings, and are not possessed by ghosts. Although Miles is very intelligent, this does not mean he is bad, the governess makes out that he is supernaturally clever, because he can do mathematic feats that are ?quite out of my range? and so is therefore evil. The question of how Flora crosses the lake is also very hard to explain as how could she row from one side of the lake to the other. This is hard to explain ,like the sighting and acurate description of Quint by the governess, and backs up the argument that the childern are possesed.
When the governess and the housekeeper find Flora ?with? Miss Jessel the governess? two potential witnesses deny that they can see anything. Mrs. Grose says, ? ?What a dreadful turn, to be sure, Miss! Where on earth do you see anything??? and Flora: ? ?I don?t know what you mean. I see nothing. I see nobody. I never have?? Strangely here we see that the situation does not call for Flora to use the past tense. Does this mean that she is lying? Mrs. Grose?s response sounds much more authentic, but is this because she is more practiced as a liar, or does she truly see nothing? Flora?s denial of seeing the ghosts brings up another question – do the children actually see the ghosts? This is a difficult question, but one can always find logical explanations. At times Miles says things to the governess that seem like things a grown man might say to a woman he was wooing. When the governess goes up to Miles? room to inquire about his expulsion, and she asks what he is thinking of, he states, ??What in the world, my dear, but you???. Likewise, during the last confrontation with Miles: ?Well – so we?re alone!?. Some believe that in these situations Quint has possessed the boy and is speaking through him to the governess, but maybe this way of speaking was learnt by Miles from Quint. Mrs. Grose says that: ??It was Quint?s own fancy. To play with him. I mean – to spoil him…Quint was much too free?? Mrs. Grose?s use of the word ?spoil? is unclear. She may mean that Quint corrupted Miles, or that he spoiled him with toys and the like.
In the final scene with the governess and Miles we discover that he was expelled from his school because he ?said things? to ?those [he] liked.?. With the arrival of Quint the matter is dropped, but we are led to assume that the things were learnt from Quint either as a ghost or as a living human, and that they had homosexual connotations.
There is also no proof that Flora is lying when she tells the governess that she does not see Miss Jessel?s ghost by the lake. In fact, she seems to be frightened by the governess? behavior. In her ?sense of triumph?, the governess tells the little girl,? ?She?s there, you little unhappy thing – there, there there, and you know it as well as you know me!??. The governess? frantic anger could certainly be enough to frighten a little girl who has no idea what is happening, and such a little girl would be justified in saying, ? ?I think you?re cruel. I don?t like you!??. After all, the governess has said a cruel thing to Flora, but could her fear of the governess be so great that it makes her ill, and worry: ??every three minutes…if [the governess is] coming in??. This argument however is slightly flawed, in that it would be very unlikely that Flora would become so feverish, and start saying ?really shocking? things about the governess, even if Miss Jessel and the girl had been very close.
If we conclude there is more evidence for the children?s behavior to be explained through natural logical reasons, as opposed to supernatural ones – for instance, that Miles? way with the governess is caused by exposure to Quint while he was alive or that Flora is telling the truth when the governess thinks she is lying – then the idea of Miles being dispossessed of Quint?s spirit would not follow our logic. If we think that the governess begins the story with some mental vulnerability brought on by her sudden boost in responsibility or her repressed feelings for the master, and that her experiences with the ghosts weaken her mental state bringing it close to madness – which we can see through the governess? attempts to ?prove? that the children see and are possessed by the ghosts, as well as the fact that she has not been sleeping well – it is logical to assume that it is the governess who kills Miles. Returning to the scene when the governess, Mrs. Grose and Flora are at the lake and the governess is the only one who sees Miss Jessel, we can say that she sees Mrs. Jessel because she needs to back up her argument, and where other apparitions had been true visitations, this is a hallucination.
When Mrs. Grose denies that she sees anything the Governess calls it a ?hard blow of the proof that her eyes were hopelessly sealed?. The governess admits, ?…I felt my situation hopelessly crumble…?, for in this situation Mrs. Jessel is not there, and as soon as her proof which she needed so much is not there, she is driven close to madness, she cannot stand another visitation, because she will not let herself believe that she is mad. Then when she tries to force Miles to own up and Quint appears, she goes insane, she can take no more: ? ?No more, no more, no more!??, and kills the boy in an attempt to free herself of the ghosts. Therefore the governess begins as a repressed person suddenly put in a position of immense responsibility and ends up a nervous wreck partly due to the haunting of ghosts.
The middle path, is the only argument that has the best of both ways. Critics who support it can say that to any opposition, James is making the story ambiguous, and entering questions for the reader to keep him unsure. If this is so James does very well in maintaining the balance between the two sides, and the game of cat and mouse is full of ambiguity. The only flaw is that if James had wanted to write a Meta-fiction, why is the story so complex, and why is the ambiguity so slight, and not extremely obvious.
I propose therefore, that the ghosts in The Turn of the Screw are not figments of the governess? imagination; but, the uncertainty brought about by her youth and the sudden increase in responsibility couple with the appearance of ghosts, and they eventually drive her to murder Miles. The Turn of the Screw, can be interpreted by fusing two existing schools of thought. It is a ghost story, but the governess? insanity plays a major role in the horror of the novel.
Другие работы по теме:
My Life As A Poet Essay Research
Paper Are the philosophical, educational, and sociological theories of childhood reflected in literature for children? If so, how? To what extent does Aesop contribute to our understanding of many early children’s books?
Physical Punishment Essay Research Paper Physical punishment
Physical Punishment Essay, Research Paper Physical punishment has been a problem in hitting their children so they can have discipline or not hitting them because it is not right, so what can parents do and what can they not do? Should the parents hit them to learn discipline, or should they not hit them and figure out another way to make them learn what discipline is?
Sylvia Plath S Poetry And Charlotte Brontes
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Sylvia Plath s poetry and Charlotte Bront s Jane Eyre both incorporate an element of feminism and reveal the attitudes women from their respective time periods encountered. Both Plath and Bront express extremely feminine points of view in their work.
Jane Eyre An Analytical View Essay Research
Paper Jane Eyre is one of the most complex novels of the mid-nineteenth century, offering more than progressive political content and trenchant social observation. Modern readings of Jane Eyre, however, tend to focus on these aspects, often to the neglect of the novel’s many other excellent qualities.
Children With Emerald Eyes Essay Research Paper
Children With Emerald Eyes By Mira Rothenburg My book Children With Emerald Eyes, is about many children, but focused around three children placed in an institution, due to schizophrenic and autistic conditions. These children?s names are Sara, Chaim, and Danny.
Informal Essay On The Turn Of The
Screw Essay, Research Paper Informal Essay on “The Turn of the Screw” A young gentleman named Miles died yesterday. There are many mysteries surrounding his death. His sole protector and guardian, the Governess of Bly, claims that supernatural forces overtook the child. After the autopsy, I found her accusations to be nonsense.
Turn Of The Screw
– Real Ghosts? Or Not? Essay, Research Paper In the short story The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, what is seen may not necessarily be the truth. This raises the important question, “Are these ghosts real or just seen through the eyes of the governess?” There are many pieces of information in the story that lead the reader to believe these ghost are real, but at the same time there are others that question the truth, and I adjure you to believe.
Turn Of The Screw By Henry
James Essay, Research Paper Turn of the Screw by: Henry James After reading The Turn of the Screw , by Henry James, I was left with many unanswered questions. The two main questions are, are the ghosts in the story real, or are they just figments of the narrator s imagination? When I read though the essays of criticism, I took a stand on one particular argument.
Vbnfg Essay Research Paper Mrs NicholsChoosing to
Vbnfg Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Nichols Choosing to Participate June 14, 2000 Saving the Children Save the Children is an organization that was created to help less fortunate children that have little money for food and clothing. It is a nonprofit association that is working in more than 35 nations to improve the living qualities of the children and their families.
Adele Essay Research Paper In Charlotte Bronte
Adele Essay, Research Paper In Charlotte Bronte’s novel “Jane Eyre”, there is a slightly inconspicuous character that many readers may choose to ignore. The character that I speak of is Adele, the adorable French girl that Edward Rochester has taken as his own. While many people may undermine the importance of this character in the novel, it is easy to see that she plays a vital role in the coming together of Mr.
Columbine Essay Research Paper Columbine Cause and
Columbine Essay, Research Paper Columbine: Cause and Effect The Columbine tragedy has struck another victim last week. If all thoughts were that the tragedy was behind us, no one has considered the effects of the massacre. A student that was injured in the massacre was making progress on recovering, when backlash from the tragedy struck.
Television Harmful Essay Research Paper Is television
Television Harmful Essay, Research Paper Is television harmful to children? I think television is harmful to children, but I mostly think that it isn’t. There are many shows and movies on television that are harmful to children, but there are also many television shows and movies that are not. The biggest influence that television has on children is the violence.
The Scooby Doo Theory The Governess
’ Sanity And Early Ghost Appearances Essay, Research Paper The Scooby Doo Theory: The Governess’ Sanity and Early Ghost Appearances in The Turn of the Screw
Jane EyreCriticism Of The Main Character Essay
, Research Paper Jane Eyre is a novel about struggle of a little governess for self-realization and dream-fulfillment. In that determined and almost obsessive struggle Jane appears as a self-involved person in an absolute denial of the world around her. This particular layer of Jane’s complex personality is important because it shades a general course of the novel.
Anna Karanina Essay Research Paper LEAP Journal
Anna Karanina Essay, Research Paper L.E.A.P. Journal for Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy A. Section covered: Part 1 and 2 (pages 17-245) B. Summary: This story first starts out with chaos in the Oblonsky’s household. Prince Stephen Oblonsky’s wife Dolly found out that he was having an affair with their children’s French governess and threatened to move out of the house and take the kids with her.
Archetype Myths In Turn Of The Screw
Essay, Research Paper The Archetypal Myth in Turn of The Screw In one surface reading of Henry James’s Turn of the Screw, the governess appears to be a victim of circumstance. Some critics however, say that she is not without blame in the turn of events that characterizes the story. They claim that leading to her demise are certain character flaws, such as envy and pride.
Turn Of The Screw Is An Allego
Essay, Research Paper The Turn of the Screw Henry James The Turn of the Screw is an incredibly complicated and hard to understand story; it hints at much, but explains little. The fact that the story is open to so many interpretations is, in some ways, the point of the story. The Turn of the Screw is a classic example of the Gothic novel, which depends on a sound concept of evil.
Turn Of The Screw Essay Research Paper
The Turn of the Screw The novel, The Turn of the Screw, is written by Henry James. The characters in this novel are the governess, Miles, Flora, Mrs. Grose, Quint, and Miss Jessel. The apparitions in The Turn of the Screw are real.
The Turn Of The Screw Essay Research
Paper The Symbolic Color of Black in The Turn of the Screw In The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, black clothing worn by the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel foreshadows evil and darkness throughout the novel. Throughout the novel, James creates a character that is “in the dark.” The phrase “in the dark” means to be without knowledge.
The Turn Of The Screw
– Evaluation And Critique Essay, Research Paper The Turn Of The Screw Thesis Statement: While ?The Turn of the Screw? initially appears to be a typical ghost
Essays On Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper
Reaction to Jane Eyre Jane Eyre is a very famous novel written by Charlotte Bronte and was published in 1847. I like Jane Eyre. She has a mind as well as a heart. Since she was a child in the Gateshead, she has had her own opinion for most of the things. She is brave, independent, and obviously different from other children.
Home Daycares Vs Community Daycares Essay Research
Paper Michael Pratt W. Howard Com. 111-28 October 29, 1999 In Home Daycares vs. Community Daycares Choosing a daycare for your children is one of the most important descisions for most new parents. There is the choice of an in home daycare or a community daycare. In home daycares the children will receive more personal care, there will be less children presant, and they are more geared to the personal needs of the parents.
Settings In Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper
Jane Eyre Authors use different types of literary devices such as setting in their works to reveal theme. Setting can be described as the time and place in which an event occurs. It is a major factor in revealing plot and showing character development. The setting in The Grapes of Wrath allows the reader to see the poor conditions in the dust bowl that the Joad family was forced to live and the opportunities they had in California; however, they were unable to obtain them.
Commercialism In Schools Essay Research Paper Commercialism
Commercialism In Schools Essay, Research Paper Commercialism affects children everyday. Children are targeted by companies to become life-long buyers of their products. When commercialism is brought into schools it is harder for children to learn to make educated decisions about their purchases. Kids need to be educated and given proper instructions about how to be objective towards advertisements.
Moll Flanders By Daniel Defoe Essay Research
Paper Book Report Michelle Williams Moll Flanders by Daniel DeFoe CHARACTER SKETCH Moll Flanders: A woman in the 17th century who was born in Newgate ( a prison) and spent twelve years as a whore, twelve years as a thief, was married five times, committed incest, was sentenced to death, but given a reprieve, and was transported to Virginia were she finally prospered.
Moll Flanders Essay Research Paper The Role
Moll Flanders Essay, Research Paper The Role of Motherhood in Moll Flanders In Moll Flanders by Daniel Defoe, there is no true development of maternal feelings over the course of the novel. At times throughout the story, what appear to be maternal feelings are really overshadowed by either guilt or a hidden motive.
Miss Temple
’s Influence On Jane From The Novel Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre is set during the Victorian period, at a time where a women s role in society was restrictive and repressive and class differences distinct. A job as a governess was one of the only few respectable positions available to the educated but impoverished single women.
Daisy MillerTurn Of The Screw Essay Research
Paper Henry James does an extraordinary job in establishing innocence in two distinguishable scenarios. Henry James, author of The Turn of the Screw and Daisy Miller uses somewhat of a superficial approach in using youth and beauty, in order to institute innocence. This is the basis for conflict in the stories.
Parents
’ Role Essay, Research Paper ?Roles of Parents? All parents love their children. They sometimes even sacrifice their lives for their children. But is only love enough for a child to grow up with? Why do parents need a child? This is the first question parents should ask themselves before anything else. Lots of parents think they have enough reasons for having a child but do parents need children to satisfy themselves, to dedicate their love to him/her, or to train a good, useful person for the society they?re living in.
Raising Children Essay Research Paper When I
Raising Children Essay, Research Paper When I gave birth to my children I thought I had gone through the toughest part of having children. When anyone talks about having children, they
Jane Eyre 2 Essay Research Paper Jane
Jane Eyre 2 Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre The story begins when Jane is 10. Her parents are dead and her aunt at Gateshead Hall has taken her care of. There she lives a miserable life with her cousin John who bully’s her. After a fight with John she is put in the room where her uncle died. There she has a nightmare.
Morbid Satisfaction Essay Research Paper Even in
Morbid Satisfaction Essay, Research Paper Even in her first glimpse of Miles, the governess in Henry James’s Turn of the Screw feels instant adoration and affection for the boy who she describes as innocent, at least by outward appearance. As she grows to know Miles, she develops not only an attachment towards him, but an obsession as well.