’s Experiment Essay, Research Paper
Reality or Illusion
In Nathaniel Hawthorne?s short story Dr. Heidegger?s Experiment, one of the
central ideas of the story revolves around the idea of reality versus illusion. Of course the
overriding theme of the story dealt with the ethical dilemma of changing old age into
youth, still a major part of how the story was interpreted involved a personal decision on
how you took the story; as literal or figurative. The perception that appealed to me the
most was reading the text as literal, and concluding the experiment as reality rather then a
figment of imagination caused by the intoxicating brew.
A couple of points that Hawthorne made led me to believe that the story was
indeed a true testament of the powers of the magical water. The first is rather evident and
straight forward because it happens before a single person even raises glass close to their
lips. I am of course referring to the fifty-five year old rose that was given to Dr.
Heidegger on the eve of his wedding by his bride to be. Heidegger places the rose in the
water so there could be proof of the mysterious water?s power, but in the same act of
proving its power to his guests Hawthorne proves to us the power of the water because
when the rose regains life nobody was drunk or had even attempted to drink the water.
” The crushed and dried petals stirred, and assumed a deepening tinge of crimson,
as if the flower were reviving from a death-like slumber;”(page 3)
It is that clear cut, and completely undeniable considering that five people witnessed the
act and not one had the slightest objection.
After the first drink of the potion until the last, I was still led to the opinion that
what the guests were experiencing was in fact real and completely genuine. At this point I
will point out that it is at this exact moment where the issue of reality versus illusion
begins to take shape. However, while we left to toil with this intriguing notion, it seems
quite intentional on the part of Hawthorne to make us decide on which side we are for. I
would say his reasoning for dividing us would be to point out that while it may be real or a
delusion it?s ethical and moral message should be clear cut to everyone. Backtracking for
a second though, I would also like to dispute the argument of illusion as some people fight
in favor, of on the sole occurrence of the old images in the mirror. It seems to me that as
I mentioned above, a ploy set by Hawthorne to add a little twist to the story, and give us
the readers something to think about. While we could argue that what they are seeing is a
direct influence of the potion it would be far stretched to say that what they felt and how
they acted was fake too. Keeping in mind that these people are very old and probably way
passed their days of jumping around dancing about, it is pretty hard to say that this water
gave them enough energy and vigor to move around like youngsters but still be contained
in their old bodies. The men especially would have been hurt while the struggled like
young men in the favor of the widow as they had done with such ease. It is also a fact the
Doctor himself had seen, and without the prejudice of the drink I might add, the
transformation because he refers the men as “gay young men” (page 7) when the widow
asks for his hand in a dance.
A final example of the water?s power should not be sought any farther than the last
few pages upon which it can be found that the life of a deceased butterfly was once again
made possible by the healing nature of the water. As it clearly written the story is not told
from the stand point of the butterfly so that it might be influenced by the drink, it is told
from afar, and all who were in the story, especially the Doctor, could testify that they
witnessed the rebirth of the insect as it happened to land on the head of the Doctor.
The points I have made provided ample proof in my own mind to the notion that
this story in fact was not a delusionary tale, but rather a fictional tale meant to be
perceived as real. It is, however debatable, but what is not is the underlying message of
not to mess with mother nature, and how man if he could regain his youth, man would
probably make the same mistakes twice if he was in fact given the chance to “do it all
again.”
Другие работы по теме:
Сакристан, Мануэль
Мануэль Сакристан Лусон (исп. Manuel Sacristбn Luzуn, 5 сентября 1925, Мадрид — 27 августа 1985, Барселона) — испанский философ-марксист, переводчик и общественно-политический деятель. Профессор Барселонского университета. Кроме множества других переводов, Мануэль Сакристан сделал доступными испанским читателям «Капитал» Карла Маркса, работы Антонио Грамши, Дьёрдя Лукача, Эрнста Фишера, Герберта Маркузе, Ульрики Майнхоф и др.
Philosophy Of Language Essay Research Paper Man
Philosophy Of Language Essay, Research Paper Man initially thought that language afforded him a better knowledge of things rather than merely a designation of things. However, this is based on an exact notion of things, and no exactness exists; identity can only be conceptual, for there is nothing in life that is identical.
What Is The Significance Of Hu Essay
, Research Paper Martin Heidegger (1889 1976) was, and still is considered to be, along with the likes of Soren Kierkegaard, Edmund Husserl and Jean-Paul Sartre, one of the principal exponents of 20th century Existentialism. An extraordinarily original thinker, a critic of technological society and the leading Ontologist of his time, Heidegger s philosophy became a primary influence upon the thoughts of the younger generations of continental European cultural personalities of his time.
Superman And The Little Pastor Essay Research
Paper Superman and the little pastor Nietzsche: A Philosophical Biography by Rudiger Safranski 412pp, Granta, Ј25 Zarathustra’s Secret by Joachim Kohler 278pp, Yale, Ј19.95 No single adjective captures the rich, strange genius of Friedrich Nietzsche. Enigmatic, vatic, emphatic, passionate, sometimes absurd, occasionally nauseating, and often breathtakingly insightful, his works together make a unique statement in the literature of European ideas.
Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay Research Paper 2
Nathaniel Hawthorne Essay, Research Paper “Dr Heidegger’s Experiment” An eccentric aging physician, Dr. Heidegger, calls together his old friends and contemporaries to test his waters of the “fountain of
Comparison Of Descartes And Heidegger Essay Research
Paper According to Descartes, the essence of material substance is simply extension, the property of filling up space. (Med. V) So solid geometry, which describes the possibility of dividing an otherwise uniform space into distinct parts, is a complete guide to the essence of body. It follows that there can be in reality only one extended substance, comprising all matter in a single spatial whole.
Martin Heidegger Essay Research Paper Note The
Martin Heidegger Essay, Research Paper Note: The main work from which text was drawn is “The Question Concerning Technology” by Martin Heidegger. Martin Heidegger was a German philosopher, who developed existential
Analysis Dr Heidegger
’s Experiment Essay, Research Paper Analysis: Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment “If all stories were true, Dr. Heidegger’s study must have been a very curious place.”(p.2). From the very start we are warned that the stories about Dr. Heidegger may not be true. This becomes important in analyzation because we can no longer depend on the stories as fact, but at the same time we have no reason to doubt them.
Heidegger
& Nazism Essay, Research Paper Heidegger & Nazism Martin Heidegger, one of the twentieth century’s most distinguished philosophers, whose influence has spread far throughout many academic fields and thus changed the look of Western philosophy. In his 1927 book Being and Time, his first major publication, broke the trend of Western philosophy which had dominated thinking since Descartes.
An Analytical Definition Of Philosophia Essay Research
Paper Men and women have tried for years to define Philosophy. One particularly interesting attempt was made by Martin Heidegger in the late 8th Century. He is reported as saying to his good friend and lover, Patrick Hurley, “Philosophy is one large search for the being-upon another and one long journey into the being-inside.” In this sense, Philosophy is best understand as a search.
What Is The Significance Of Human Mortality
, According To Heidegger? Essay, Research Paper Martin Heidegger (1889 – 1976) was, and still is considered to be, along with the likes of Soren Kierkegaard, Edmund Husserl and Jean-Paul Sartre, one of the principal exponents of 20th century Existentialism. An extraordinarily original thinker, a critic of technological society and the leading Ontologist of his time, Heidegger’s philosophy became a primary influence upon the thoughts of the younger generations of continental European cultural personalities of his time.
DonconstructionThe Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper DeconstructionDeconstruction
Donconstruction/The Secret Sharer Essay, Research Paper Deconstruction Deconstruction is a post-structural school of philosophy and literary criticism that was developed by French philosopher Jacques Derrida. Although he is credited with its origins, he seems to have borrowed heavily from German philosophers, Friedrich Neitzsche and Martin Heidegger, who ? radically questioned the validity of basic philosophical concepts? and Chinese philosopher, Lao Tse who embraced the harmony of opposites.
Hawthorne Comparison Essay Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne
Hawthorne Comparison Essay, Research Paper Nathaniel Hawthorne has written many short stories that have common themes. One of these common themes is science versus nature and God. Hawthorne was writing during a time when many people were trying to use science to explain phenomenon that had always been attributed to a divine power.
Existentialism Essay Research Paper Existentialism has been
Existentialism Essay, Research Paper Existentialism has been defined as a philosophical movement or tendency, emphasizing individual existence, freedom and choice that influences many diverse writers in the 19th and 20th centuries. The philosophical term existentialism came from Jean Paul Sartre, a French philosopher.
Why Modern Science Is Nihilistic Essay Research
Paper Why is Modern Science Nihilistic? What is nihilism? Nihilism comes from the Latin root for nothing. Nihilism represents a belief that existence is senseless and useless. It also refers to sacrifice of meaningful existence defined by spiritual values, struggle and pain, in favor of pleasurable, comfortable and secure life.
Parade Of The Beasts Essay Research Paper
Parade of the beastsZoo: A History of Zoological Gardens in the Westby Eric Baratay & Elisabeth Hardouin-Fugier400pp, Reaktion BooksA Different Nature: The Paradoxical World of Zoos and Their Uncertain Futureby David Hancocks296pp, University of California PressThe zoological garden is a European phenomenon – as well as a European invention and export.
Anaximander Essay Research Paper AnaximanderAbout 530 AD
Anaximander Essay, Research Paper Anaximander About 530 AD the Neoplatonist Simplicius wrote an extensive commentary on Aristotle’s Physics. In it he reproduced the Anaximander fragment, thus preserving it for the western world. He copied it from Theophrastus. From the time Anaximander pronounced his saying–we do not know where or when or to whom–to the moment Simplicius jotted it down in his commentary more than a millennium elapsed.
H E I D E G G
E R? S Metaphysics Essay, Research Paper H e I d e g g e r? s Metaphysics and its application to Filipino?s PATRIOTISM and NATIONAL PRIDE OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY:
Good Country People Essay Research Paper Good
Good Country People Essay, Research Paper Good Country People: Like Julian in "Everything that Rises Must Converge," Hulga is a proud intellectual and has little doubt of her belief in
African Slave Trade Essay Research Paper Philosophy
African Slave Trade Essay, Research Paper Philosophy and the Afro-American Experience In this thesis, Cornel West attempts to illustrate that particular techniques in certain forms of philosophy could enable one s understanding of the Afro-American experience. West uses the term, Afro-American philosophy when referring to these techniques.
LauTzu Essay Research Paper We turn clay
Lau-Tzu Essay, Research Paper We turn clay to make a vessel; But it is on the space where there is nothing That the utility of the vessel depends. Lao-Tzu 1 When we fill the jug, the pouring that fills it flows into the empty jug. The emptiness, the void, is what does the
Metaphysics Essay Research Paper Bringing
Metaphysics Essay, Research Paper Bringing "metaphysical mind set" into my life has been a tremendously rewarding experience. It made me realize that most often humans have propensity
Existentialism Relationships In A World Without God
Essay, Research Paper Relationships in a World without God In a world in which lives are shaped by irreversible choices and by random events, a world in which everything occurs but once, existence seems to lose is substance. Life in this designless universe raises questions of identity and can cause turmoil between the relationships of the self to others, the self to history, and the self to God.
Sartre Simplified Essay Research Paper Jean Paul
Sartre Simplified Essay, Research Paper Jean Paul Sartre was born in Paris, France on June 21, 1905. When Sartre was fifteen months old, his father died and Sartre was sick with enteritis. When Sartre was well again, his mother took him to live with his grandparents in Meudon. As a kid, Sartre was given everything and always was treated like a kid.
The Scarlet Letter Literary Analysis Essay Research
Paper The Black Man of the Forest: A Literary Analysis Essay Of The Scarlet Letter In almost every story there are forces of good and evil that are in conflict. The most dangerous of these evils are those that are not obvious. In Hawthorne s The Scarlet Letter, the Black Man of the forest is none other than Roger Chillingworth.
Personhood Essay Research Paper But what of
Personhood Essay, Research Paper But what of those who, out of mischief or piety, wish to deny the power of liberalism’s fundamental premise? And those free spirits who wish honestly to resist liberalism’s claims to authority? What can be said on behalf of liberalism’s fundamental premise to them? Can reason defend freedom and equality as the political principles most appropriate to the dignity shared by all human beings?
An Existentialist Meaning Of Life Essay Research
Paper Arguably one of the most pondered questions in philosophical thought has been, “What is the meaning of life?” Humans have been put on this earth with the knowledge of self awareness and the ability to manipulate the environments that they inhabit to a greater extent than any other species on the planet.
Existentialism In The Early 19th Century Essay
, Research Paper Existentialism in the early 19th Century Major Themes Because of the diversity of positions associated with existentialism, the term is impossible to define precisely. Certain themes common to virtually all existentialist writers can, however, be identified. The term itself suggests one major theme: the stress on concrete individual existence and, consequently, on subjectivity, individual freedom, and choice.
Comparitive Sociology Essay Research Paper This paper
Comparitive Sociology Essay, Research Paper This paper is an attempt to do something that is probably not a good idea. I am going to try and take the ideas of some of the most prominent postmodern Sociological thinkers and mesh them together in some sort of coherent format. The purpose of this paper is to provide a starting place for people interested in postmodern Sociological thought.
White Noise Essay Research Paper Thanks to
White Noise Essay, Research Paper Thanks to everyone who voted for WHITE NOISE as October’s Book-of-the- Month. WHITE NOISE is probably Don DeLillo’s most popular novel, largely because most readers see it as DeLillo’s warmest and most human book. In this story, the ideas that seem to captivate DeLillo are fleshed out in real life in a way that none of his other books quite achieves.