, Research Paper
Paulo Freire and Ralph Waldo Emerson share a similar vision in regards to traditional
methods of education. A main common view is that both writers feel that the current education
system in most places does not allow for people to reach their full capacity. Freire and Emerson
share many other ideas regarding education such as their view of practice and theory and of free
thinking. Their works are among the most thought-evoking.
In “The American Scholar” Emerson places a strong emphasis on the role of books in
education and their usage of conveying ideas. He states that, “Books are the best things, well
used; abused, among the worst” (p. 297). This refers to his thought that the idea behind books is
indeed a well thought out one. However, aside from the possible misuse of books, there are
certain tasks that a book can not accomplish. Many are relevant only for a period of time, after
which they become obsolete and new books are required. This is one of the reasons that Emerson
feels that books alone can not provide a concrete education. They must be supplemented with
additional studies, or, according to Emerson, book studies should be combined with experiences
and applied to life. To read for the sake of knowing information is pointless; instead, man should
read with the intent to apply newly obtained knowledge to his life. Man should read with a
dissecting eye, and pick apart the prose, keeping what is relevant and discarding what is babble.
This captures the true purpose of books. Paralleling Emerson’s view of books is Freire’s idea of
theory and praxis. Man can learn all there is to know about a discipline yet he cannot fully grasp
it until he has begun to exercise his newly ascertained information. There is indeed a difference
between strictly learning theory and learning theory through practice. The theory or ideas can be
deposited in a person’s head and he or she is to put into action the unrefined concepts. Freire is
opposed to this “Banking theory” (p. 357) because he feels that it is inhibiting to the mind. In his
mind, problem-posing theory is the proper route, due to the fact that it actively engages a
person’s own ideas and personal thoughts and makes him analyze and question reality.
Freire classifies standard systems of education to be a banking system. This label is used
in a literal sense, in that Freire feels that a human brain is like a vault. In the banking system
teachers deposit information in the student and it is to be expected that the student will retain the
information until a withdrawal is requested, at which point the information will be regurgitated
back in the same form that it was put in, without any processing of the information. This idea
assumes many things about the teacher-student relationship. Among these assumptions are that:
the student begins education with a clean slate, the teacher knows best or knows all and that the
student has nothing to contribute to his own education because he or she knows nothing. One
other assumption in the banking system is that a person is not considered to be a conscious being
that interacts with others; he is considered to be a spectator, not someone who is able to make a
difference. Problem-posing education is Freire’s solution to the problems posed by the banking
system of education. The main premise of this type of education is that people are considered to
be an integral part of the world, that interact with one another. Freire emphasized dialogue in
education, or a coexistence of student and teacher in which both parties are giving and taking
from the education. Unlike in a banking system where material is presented for the sole purpose
of having the students absorb it, Freire feels that ideas are conveyed to students for their analysis
of it, because their opinion is as important as the teacher’s. According to Freire, banking
education limits and shuts down creative power , and this concept is a main concern of Emerson’s
as well. A person must be brave and free from fear, because fear arises from ignorance. A man
must be a free thinker and in the right state he is “Man Thinking” (p. 295). “Man thinking” (p.
295) is simply a man thinking for himself without the influence of outside sources. On the
contrary, it is possible for him to become a simple thinker or even the imitator of another man’s
thinking. Even ideas that come from the past can be harmful to the free thinker, and may limit his
creative mind. The study of books, for example, has the potential to transform a man from a free
thinking individual to a person that merely takes in information and spits it out. This is exactly
what Freire speaks of, however; unlike Emerson, he does not acknowledge that this can happen
on its own, without a system of education imposing it.
A final shared idea between Freire and Emerson is that the full human capacity is not being
utilized. Books and teaching inhibit man’s mind, because they contain ideas which are preset and
are rarely subject to interpretation or analysis. According to Emerson, all men have the capacity
of becoming a genius, yet he does not encourage people to be genius because sometimes too
much intellect can be over influencing. Emerson believes that our full worth is not being reached
because there are things that are constraining man’s free thinking capabilities. Similarly, yet
different, Freire says that oppressors, in some cases, teachers, are not recognizing the full capacity
or inner worth of individuals. People are being alienated from free thought, because in the
opinion of oppressors, the student’s point of view does not matter. Students are instructed and
trained to listen to the teacher as if he or she knows everything there is to know, and they must
absorb everything they are told. When a person is told the same thing repeatedly it becomes a
truth to him. This is the case with the teacher-student relationship, where students have come to
accept that their input is useless and that they in fact have nothing to present.
Emerson and Freire see eye to eye on many issues regarding the education of man. The
main concept that they share is a belief that man should think freely. All other ideas stated by
Freire and Emerson are strictly extensions of this point. The educational vision of Emerson and
Freire is for man to learn in a society free of preconceptions, where all men’s ideas are valued and
where knowledge is ascertained for the use of practice not just as an end in itself.
Bibliography
“Banking Concept of Education” by Paolo Freire
“The American Scholar” by Ralph Waldo Emerson
Другие работы по теме:
Transcendentalists Essay Research Paper America
Transcendentalists Essay, Research Paper America’s Introduction to Transcendental Beliefs To trace the origin of the Transcendental movement one needs to go back to the city of Concord, Massachusetts. There during the early 19th century many well-known and world-renowned authors were following the practices of one man, Ralph Waldo Emerson.
American Scholar By Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay
, Research Paper The American Scholar by Ralph Waldo Emerson In the essay the American Scholar, Emerson portrays the scholar as a person who learns from three main things. These things by which a scholar is educated are by nature, by books (the past) and by action.
New England Transcedentalsim Essay Research Paper Ralph
New England Transcedentalsim Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson was a nineteenth-century transcendentalism author. Self-reliance and independence were ideas that were highly valued by him as well as other transcendentalist authors of his time. The transcendentalist believed in non-conformity and a belief that nature was an influential aspect of peoples life.
Nature Essay Research Paper In the essay
Nature Essay, Research Paper In the essay “Nature” by Ralph Waldo Emerson, he talks about the wonders of nature that are commonly overlooked by man. He sees these wonders every day and is desensitized to them. Emerson tells how the same things that we think as normal amaze a child. The first time children experience something they are dumbfounded, as we should be, yet nature stays overlooked.
Emerson And The Poet Essay Research Paper
Ralph Waldo Emerson states in The Poet the question, which is what is the poet? He says that all men express their feelings, but what makes a poet is that he has more ability to express his own. For example, a poet would express the beauty of nature well, while men who are less expressive cannot give nature the worth it should be given, related to reality of course.
Ralph Waldo Emerson
“Self-Reliance” Essay, Research Paper The piece we were assigned to was a part of an essay Emerson did on self-reliance? He starts out by explaining that whether or not we act as individuals all depends on asking ourselves how much self-trust we have, or how much confidence we have in ourselves. When you really think about it, individuality is honestly not something we desire to subject ourselves to, because being an individual can lead to other people not accepting you, hating you, or accusing you of being self-righteous, disrespectful, a rebel, a freak, and so on.
American Scholar Essay Research Paper The essay
American Scholar Essay, Research Paper The essay The American Scholar by Ralph Emerson Waldo basically consists of three main parts. First Emerson writes about the scholar’s resources, which are nature, books, and experience. Second he writes about the scholar’s duties, which are basically to trust yourself and your intuitions, no matter what society tells you.
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay Research Paper Analysis
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Genius Ralph Waldo Emerson was a brilliant man who took the meaning of self-reliance to another uniform. His convoluted conceptions on Genius and Transdentalism are more in touch with self. His inhabitants and whereabouts such as the Waldon pond were very substantial to him.
Conforming Vs Not Conforming To Society
’s Expectations Essay, Research Paper “Conforming vs. Not Conforming to Society’s Expectations” The advantages of conforming to society’s expectations are obvious. You will be
Tranquility In Nature
– Emerson And Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Tranquility in Nature Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson are the two authors that I chose mainly because their ideas about nature are similar. Thoreau and Emerson were both writers who got their start writing during the nineteenth century. Their views on nature are similar, but as with every writer they show some view of different ideas that make them unique in some special way.
A Comparison Of Ralph Waldo Emerson And
Henry David Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau were both born in Massachusetts. Emerson was born in Boston in 1803. Thoreau was born in
Nature In Emerson Essay Research Paper Analogy
Nature In Emerson Essay, Research Paper Analogy of Nature Ralph Waldo Emerson explores the intricate tie amongst nature, man, and language. His function is to define reason and understanding through nature. Emerson uses the analogy between mans life and the transformation he finds through his soul. He changes the idea of logic and reason, but its meaning remains similar.
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay Research Paper IntroductionRalph
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay, Research Paper Introduction Ralph Waldo Emerson ??was truly one of our great geniuses? even though he may have a short biography (Hodgins 212). But as Emerson once said himself, ?Great geniuses have the shortest biographies.? Emerson was also a major leader of ?the philosophical movement of Transcendentalism?. (Encarta 1) Transcendentalism was belief in a higher reality than that found everyday life that a human can achieve.
SelfReliance Misunderstood Greatness Essay Research Paper The
Self-Reliance: Misunderstood Greatness Essay, Research Paper The quote that most provoked thought and emotion from within me comes from the essay “Self-Reliance” by Ralph Waldo Emerson. “To be great is to be misunderstood” was used by Emerson to explain the lagging growth of the conception of ideas and thoughts of his generation.
Ralph Waldo Emersons Self Reliance Essay Research
Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson’s “Self-Reliance” is a highly debatable piece. His ideas are often looked at insensible because much of his audience cannot fathom a life of complete self-reliance. His essay brings up many excellent points that people do not care to consider in society today. He states why people should be more self-reliant, what’s generally stopping them, and how to overcome these barriers.
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay Research Paper Americas
Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay, Research Paper Americas Transcendental Voice Ralph Waldo Emerson was one of the true fathers of transcendentalism in America. He was said to be the founding member of the smallest church. The congregation included only himself, and his church waited on the world to see his views as the truth.
TranscendentalismRalph Waldo Emerson Essay Research Paper TranscendentalismRalph
Transcendentalism:Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism: Ralph Waldo Emerson Transcendentalism, in philosophy and nature, is the belief in a higher reality than found in sense experience or in a higher knowledge than achieved by human reason. Transcendentalism upholds the goodness of humanity, the glories of nature, and the importance of free individual expression.
Transcendetalism A Comparision Of Emerson And Thoreau
Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson: Nature Crossing a bare common, in snow puddles, at twilight, under a clouded sky, without having in my thoughts any occurrence of special good fortune, I have enjoyed perfect exhilaration. Almost I fear to think how glad I am. In the woods too, a man casts off his years, as the snake his slough, and at what period soever of life, is always a child.
Ralph Waldo Emerson 2
Ralph Waldo Emerson’s Philosophy Essay, Research Paper Emerson s Philosophy Ralph Waldo Emerson, nineteenth century poet and writer, expresses a philosophy of life, based on our inner self and the presence of the soul. Emerson regarded and learned from the great minds of the past, he says repeatedly that each person should live according to his own thinking.
American Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper American TranscendentalismTranscendentalism
American Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper American Transcendentalism Transcendentalism as espoused by Ralph Waldo Emerson is essen tially an idealist philosophy, derived from Kant’s concept of the Tran scendental and opposed to the skepticism of Locke and the Empiricists. In the essay The Transcendentalist, Emerson wrote, “[Kant showed] that there was a very important class of ideas or imperative forms, which do not come by experience, but through which experience was acquired; that these were intuitions of the mind itself; and he denominated them Tran scendental forms.”1 According to Emerson’s understanding of Kant, Transcendentalism becomes a union of solipsism, under which the only verifiable reality is thought to be the self, and materialism, under which the only verifiable reality is the quantifiable external world of objects and sense data.
Biography Of Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay Research
Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson certainly took his place in the history of American Literature . He lived in a time when romanticism was becoming a way of thinking and beginning to bloom in America, the
Poems And Writings By Ralph Waldo Emerson
Essay, Research Paper An Analysis of the Poems and Writings by Ralph Waldo Emerson The thoughts and feelings of Ralph Waldo Emerson are uplifting, empowering and can make one feel like their actions matter in a world surrounded by cynicism and despair. His poem “Give all to love” hints briefly at the pain he experienced in his life and his views on love and the human experience.
Thoreau And Emerson Comparison Essay Research Paper
A Comparison of Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson?s Beliefs Essay written by Kelly Cooper A Comparison of Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson?s Beliefs concerning Simplicity, the Value and Potential of Our Soul, and Our Imagination.
A Biography Of Ralph Waldo Emerson Essay
, Research Paper One of Americas most influential thinkers and authors was Ralph Waldo Emerson. Ralph Waldo Emerson was born in Boston on May 25, 1803. Emerson’s dad died when he was only eight, which forced his mom to take in boarders to support the family’s needs. When Emerson was only 14, he entered Harvard, where he ran became a sort of secretary for the president of the university.
Ralph Waldo Emerson 3 Essay Research Paper
Ralph Waldo Emerson was born in Boston Massachusetts in 1803. (Gagne 1 ) Emerson grew up with five brothers and two sisters. ( Yanella 1 ) He was highly educated and graduated from Harvard at the age of eighteen in 1821. He then attend the Harvard Divinity school in 1825. (Yanella 3) Due to Emerson’s sophisticated style, he is difficult to read but such an interesting poet that in the end a person never regrets the effort to understand this important figure in American culture.
Emerson And The Transcendentalists Essay Research Paper
Ralph Waldo Emerson was a great essayist. I like reading about Emerson. He was very interesting. His essay “Self Reliance” told me that I could be an individual, a non-conformest. Many people were influenced by him, including Henry David Thoreau, a neighbor in Concord. Mr. Thoreau wrote the famous book Walden, which details his experiences living alone in the woods of Concord, Massachusetts.
EmersonThoreau Essay Research Paper Emerson and ThoreauEveryone
Emerson-Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Emerson and ThoreauEveryone in the world is an individual. We have the right to be who we are and to live each day to the fullest. Ralph Waldo Emerson discusses individuality in his essay from “Self-Reliance.” He has many ideas in his essay, mostly to be individuals and to not waste time conforming to society.
Transendentalism In Emerson
’s Poetry Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson always considered himself a poet despite his many volumes of Essays and other works. Therefore this essay only deals with Emerson s poetry. Emerson told a lot with his prose but he told more with his poetry. Often, fundamental aspects of transcendentalism are shown through literary devices in his poetry.
Emerson Essay Research Paper Emerson
Emerson Essay, Research Paper Emerson “self-Reliance” Misunderstood Greatness The quote that most provoked thought and emotion from withinme comes from the essay “Self-Reliance” by Ralph Waldo Emerson. “Tobe great is to be misunderstood” was used by Emerson to explain thelagging growth of the conception of ideas and thoughts of hisgeneration.
Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism was an
Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism was an important movement in literature that occurred during the years of 1836-1860. Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau were the best-known transcendentalists. Ralph Waldo Emerson gave the German philosopher, Immanuel Kant, the credit for making ?Transcendentalism? a familiar term.