Employment Relations Essay The 1998 Waterfront Dispute was described by John Howard as “a defining moment in Australia s industrial relations history.” Do you agree with this statement? Support your view by discussing the events and outcomes of this dispute. John Howard s comment on the 1998 Waterfront dispute between the Maritime Union of Australia and Patrick Stevedores was a hypocritical and ignorant description of one of Australia s worst industrial relations disputes. The Australian Government considers that Australia is poorly served by its waterfront industry. The serious inefficiencies that have persisted on the waterfront, despite previous reforms, have acted as a brake on economic growth and international competitiveness.”The globalising strategies of both Labour and Liberal governments have intensified the pressure on Australian employers to maintain international competitiveness by cutting costs and increasing productivity.” (Wiseman p1) In the lead up to the 1996 federal election, the Coalition advocated the prohibition of union preference with Mr Reith arguing that “where union membership was genuinely voluntary, unions are more likely to be responsive to the needs of their members.” (Thorpe & McDonald p24) However, it is more logical to conclude that unions would be less responsive to members where membership to unions is not truly voluntary. The 1998 waterfront dispute concerned the Maritime Union of Australia (MUA), Patrick Stevedoring, Australia’s second largest waterfront company and the Federal government. It began in early 1997 when the Workplace Relations Act came into effect. Officials representing the government, the National Farmer s Federation and the chairman of Patrick Stevedoring, Chris Corrigan, devised to discard the total firm s staff and replace them with non union labour who were employed by nine different contracting companies. Some MUA members were locked out of Webb Dock in Melbourne on 28 January 1998, where a picket line was set up. On the 8 April 1998, Patrick Stevedoring locked out its 1400 permanent staff and 600 casual MUA workers. Technically the workers were not dismissed, were still employed but unable to enter their workplace.(Griffin & Svensen pp 200-201) The worst evacuation of union labour was when security guards with balaclavas and guard dogs forced the workers out. The MUA took Patrick Stevedoring to the Federal Court where temporary reinstatement orders were issued delivered. There was tremendous support for the MUA from the public, due to the media coverage of the conflict. A blockade was forced upon Patrick Stevedoring so that non unionised labour found it difficult to enter the wharves, and although they were instructed to move the backlog of cargo, they were met with an international boycott. The National Farmers Federation (NFF) colluded with the government because they too had a hidden agenda which was to reduce costs for themselves. According to Dr Wendy Craik, Executive Director, National Farmers Federation, “the low levels of efficiency in our ports has frustrated Australia s farmers for decades, because they demanded to know what happened to that efficiently produced and world best standard product, once it left the farm.”Dr Craik also claimed that “the cost of getting rural produce across the waterfront constitutes over 4 % of the export price of those goods and this cost has been directly attributable in large part to the existence of too much labour.” (www.nff.au/speech99/waterfront.html) When the Federal Court awarded the MUA with an interim injunction instructing the reinstatement of the sacked workers, Patrick Stevedoring and the government appealed unsuccessfully. The Federal Court had concluded that Patrick Stevedoring had been in breach of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, by violating the employment contracts and conspiring against union labour.
The final agreement included the destruction of 626 jobs; cuts to over 100 working conditions, including overtime and penalty rates; activities such as cleaning, security and line marking were to be given to contractors. Those made redundant would be given preference for the contract employment positions so that job losses could be decreased. The workers were no longer permitted to work consecutive 8 hour shifts and crane rates were to be increased from 18 containers to 25 per hour, in line with the target set by the government. The government s aim is to support and facilitate the urgent restructuring of the stevedoring industry. The objective is to boost productivity, lower costs, improve reliability, emphasise skills and training and introduce an effective occupational health and safety regime. The government in its ambition to reform Australia s waterfront must remember that in order to increase productivity and be more competitive, it cannot simply clean the slate and start over, but instead give workers and employers alike income security. It is fair to aim to become internationally competitive and have an edge over other countries in our industries, however, the government must look at the full picture, achieve long term goals by establishing short term changes that can aid both the employee and employer. One aspect that the government should contemplate is that of over time rates and regulations. For example, if the workers get paid double time when working over 40 hours, there is no incentive to work competently during those 8 hours per day but as soon as they start getting double time their efficiency increases. Reform of working hours should be considered, either regulating how often workers are permitted to work overtime or introducing shifts so that even if shifts overlap, the amount of containers cleared per day will increase. “Actions taken must be lawful, in Australia and internationally: Throughout the current reform process, there is no question that the Australian Government will continue to act within the law. Equally, the Government expects that unlawful action will not be taken by any party, particularly industrial action that involves interrupting Australia’s international trade and commerce, or violating Australia’s federal, State or Territory laws. The Government is taking advice on legal redress available to it to deal with any threats against Australia’s shipping interests overseas.” (www.dwrsb.gov.au/mreform/main.htm)This quote taken from a government website is in total contradiction with what transpired on the Australian waterfront in 1998. The government itself was in breach of its own laws, as too was Patrick Stevedoring, and instead of increasing the productivity of the industry, brought it to a sudden halt. However, the public did not see the government, or Patrick Stevedoring, given any kind of punishment from the legal system. John Howard – conspirer or criminal? Did the Prime Minister conspire to sack 1400 workers across Australia, who were coincidentally union members, and bring in a new and non-unionised workforce? Or was it that he was breaking the very laws that his government had implemented in the 1996 Workplace Relations Act. The changes to the Act directly conflicted with the previous government s commitment to make Australian labour more internationally competitive. Australia is a free and democratic country and although John Howard may be Australia s leader, his title gave him no right to lend a helping hand in the deterioration the waterfront worker s lives, nor did his co-conspirers Chris Corrigan, Peter Reith and John Sharp.
349
Другие работы по теме:
Indigenous People
’s Rights Essay, Research Paper In recent years, increasing awareness of exploitation of indigenous culture and intellectual property has led to recognition of the need for more effective protection of indigenous rights in Australia. Aborigines, the indigenous people of Australia, are severely disadvantaged in terms of poverty, poor health, over-representation in the prisons, employment opportunity, and housing.
Business Knowledge Essay Research Paper Using Your
Business Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Using Your Business Knowledge 1. Babysitting-I make very good money and it?s a very good learning experience on how to deal and take care of children which is something that everyone needs to eventually learn in life.
Australia In The VIetnam War Essay Research
Paper The only time Australia has come under direct attack from another country, was when Japan bombed Darwin and sunk a number of ships in Sydney, during World War 2. The question then has
History Of Australia Essay Research Paper History
History Of Australia Essay, Research Paper History of Australia 1901 2000 Between the years of 1901-2000, much occurred in the history of the proud, independent nation. Over more than 100 years ago, Australia fought the battle for federation against England. Australia proposed to be an independent, self-governed nation of six states and territories.
Racsim Essay Research Paper Racism is a
Racsim Essay, Research Paper Racism is a very big issue. I think most people say things without realising they are being racist. This doesn t excuse their behaviour but most people
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
Australia
– Monarchy Or Republic Essay, Research Paper Australia – Monarchy or Republic Even before James Cook discovered this continent that later would be named Australia, there where people living on this continent. They are being called Aboriginal and are the origin population of Australia. In the year of 1788 the first convicts are being sent to Australia because of over crowded prisons in Britain.
Why Australia Joined World War I In
1914 Essay, Research Paper In 1914, Australia joined the First World War. Although it was seen as a European war, the Australia government decided that Australia should support its ‘Mother Country’, Britain. The prime-minister at the time, Joseph Cook, stated Australia’s position : “Whatever happens, Australia is a part of the Empire, right to the full.
How And Why Did Federation in Australia
) Occur? Essay, Research Paper Federation was the coming together in 1901 of the six separate Australian colonies to form what is now the Commonwealth of Australia. It occurred for many reasons including: to unite the defence of Australia; to make uniform bank laws; taxes and tariffs resulting in better trade and communication between states; and to put the ?White Australia? into practise.
Australian People Essay Research Paper Australian PeopleThe
Australian People Essay, Research Paper Australian People The population of Australia is 18,438,824.The Birth Rate is 13.73, per 1000 people. The death rate is 6.89 per 1000 people. Those two were per year on average. The migration rate is 2.71 immigrants per 1000 people. The Life expectancy is higher than the US at 79.64. (Male 76.69, Female 82.74) There are three major ethnic groups in Australia.
Greenhouse Effect Essay Research Paper Greenhouse EffectThis
Greenhouse Effect Essay, Research Paper Greenhouse Effect This effect is the result of certain atmospheric gases letting sunlight through to the earth’s surface, while not letting energy radiated outward from the earth’s surface. This results in a net buildup of solar energy in the Earth’s atmosphere, because the flow in is greater than the flow outwards.
How And Why Australia
’s International Relationships Have Changed Through Its Participation In Overseas Conflict. Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will answer the question- how and why have our(Australia’s) international relationships changed by our participation in overseas conflicts ? The answer to this is that we have had changed international relationships, more independence, it ended Australia’s isolation, it gave greater social rights to women, it affirmed Australia’s alliances with the world powers and most importantly it gave Australia an identity.
Australia Essay Research Paper Did you know
Australia Essay, Research Paper Did you know that Australia is its own country and continent? It is also the world s smallest continent and largest island with an area of 7, 671, 930 sq km. It is said to be the oldest country in the world, but it was discovered last. Australia is one of the most interesting places on the earth, because it has everything.
The Particular Features Of The Employmentsystem In
Essay, Research Paper The Particular Features Of The EmploymentSystem In Japan One of the unique and well known features of theJapanese employment system is permanent employment forworkers. Japanese corporations responses to recessionaryperiods provide an opportunity to sort out the myths from therealities of the Japanese permanent employment system.
Sexual Harassment Essay Research Paper Sexual Harassment 2
Sexual Harassment Essay, Research Paper Sexual Harassment, a form of unlawful sex discrimination. Under federal law in the United States, sexual harassment is unwanted verbal or physical behavior of a sexual nature that occurs in the workplace or in an educational setting under certain conditions. Such behavior is illegal if it creates an environment that is hostile or intimidating, if it interferes with a person’s work or school performance, or if acceptance of the harasser’s behavior is made a condition of employment or academic achievement.
Welfare Essay Research Paper In brief first
Welfare Essay, Research Paper In brief, first, the global economy has brought with it high rates of unemployment and economic inactivity in much of Europe. It has also generated strong pressures to de-regulate and create flexible labour markets with sharp rises in wage dispersion, part-time, temporary and casual employment particularly in the UK and USA.
Article 23 Essay Research Paper Universal Declaration
Article 23 Essay, Research Paper Universal Declaration Of Human Rights ARTICLE 23 -Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment-
Economic Divergence In Australia Essay Research Paper
Economic divergence in Australia ? it is an issue that I feel all Australians should be aware of and deal with, because if the gap is not bridged, then Australia’s economic prosperity and social fabric will be under serious threat. Evidence of this divide is seen with the differences in unemployment rates and household income between the urban and rural regions.
ImmigrationPauline Hanson Is Wrong Essay Research Paper
Pauline Hanson?s view on migration is incorrect. Ceasing migration would not be good for Australia either culturally or economically. An intelligent and sophisticated immigration program, which focuses strongly on skilled and business migration, can have a beneficial impact on our economy.
Rockhampton Essay Research Paper Rockhampton Facilities and
Rockhampton Essay, Research Paper Rockhampton Facilities and Popular Attraction Compared to Other Cities Rockhamptons biggest attraction would be that it is the beef capital of Australia. {more information how it was the beef capital and when it was} Rockhampton was discovered in 1850 when gold and copper were discovered about 100 km away promoting this town’s growth as an agricultural market and port.
Australian Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper Australian
Australian Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper Australian Foreign Policy Topic 2 Due Date: 26/5 Teacher: Br Smith Student: Luke O?Connor ?Australia was a good friend to the Indonesian independence movement in the years after World War 2, but Australia stood silently by as Dutch New Guinea was given to Indonesia.
Afl Essay Research Paper AFL football is
Afl Essay, Research Paper AFL football is one of the most loved sports in Australia. This popular game attracts over 13.9 million people a year. It has, according to research conducted in 1999 the 3rd highest number of registered players in any Australian sport with the figure standing at 447,436.
Eucalyptus Trees Essay Research Paper The eucalypt
Eucalyptus Trees Essay, Research Paper The eucalypt is one of the tallest trees in the world. There are more then 600 species of eucalypts in Australia. Blackbutt, jarrah, karri, stringybark, ironbark are common names of eucalypts that grow in various parts of Australia. More than ninety per cent of Australia’s trees are eucalypts.
Aboriginals In Australia Essay Research Paper ABORIGINIESHoW
Aboriginals In Australia Essay, Research Paper ABORIGINIES HoW WERE THEY TREATED? Since the beginning, Australia was said to be a colony of settlement, not of conquest. The legal fiction of terra nullius- the land belonged to no one with no official negotiations, no treaties was how the land is said to be the basic injustice on which modern Australia was built.
Welcome To Australia Essay Research Paper Welcome
Welcome To Australia Essay, Research Paper Welcome To Australia Australia is one of the most popular holiday destinations in the world. Thousands and thousands of foreign people come and visit Australia each year. This is due to our vast variety in our landscapes and animals. Also our weather is perfect in most places, especially on the coast.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Australian Report Essay Research Paper Essay Australian
Australian Report Essay, Research Paper Essay Australian Realm Why despite Australia?s visible advantages in natural resources, accessible ports and a huge educated population is Australia?s GNP growing at such a stunted
The English Language Essay Research Paper This
The English Language Essay, Research Paper This House affirms that the British Empire was a great success whose effects are still beneficial to the world. The world distribution of English users is divided into three categories : English as a native language; for example, UK, USA, Australia, English as a second language; for example, India, Singapore, Ghana, Philippines, and English as a foreign language; for example, France, Japan, Thailand.There are 72 countries with Englishs as an official language and 9 countries with English as a first language:Australia, Great- Britain, Canada, Ireland, Japan, Luxembourgh, Netherlands, New Zealand, and the USA.