Mueller V. Allen Essay, Research Paper
MUELLER V. ALLEN
Issue:
Did the government violate the Establishment Clause because they provided monetary support to the parents of all school-goers?
Rule:
The 1st Amendment states that the Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.
Analysis:
In 1983, case of Mueller v. Allen, made a few changes in the way the federal government helped out the children in schools. The question in the Mueller case was a Minnesota statute that allowed all parents to deduct tuition, textbook and transportation expenses from their gross income on state tax returns for their children attending elementary and secondary schools. The Minnesota law allowed a tax deduction of up to $500 for each child in grades K through 6, and up to $700 for each child in grades 7 through 12. Given that most parents of public school children incurred no tuition expenses, and that at the time 96 percent of Minnesota children in private schools attended religiously affiliated ones [1978-1979], it was clear that the bulk of the tax deductions would go to parents of children in private schools.
A group of Minnesota taxpayers brought suit against the Minnesota commissioner of revenue and Minnesota parents who had taken the tax deduction for expenses incurred in sending their children to parochial schools. The suit alleged that the law violated the Establishment Clause, because it gave financial assistance to sectarian institutions, which was a link between church and state.
Conclusion:
Justice Rehnquist’s opinion in the Mueller case made a major distinction between direct aid and indirect aid to parochial schools. He said: “It is true, of course, that financial assistance provided to parents ultimately has an economic effect comparable to that of aid given directly to the schools attended by their children. It is also true, however, that under Minnesota’s arrangement public funds become available only as a result of numerous private choices of individual parents of school-age children.”
The Court concluded that under the Mueller Court’s view, this type of indirect aid is consistent with the neutrality principle explained in the Establishment Clause because it neither advances nor inhibits religion.
Другие работы по теме:
Allen Sapp Essay Research Paper Allen Sapp
Allen Sapp Essay, Research Paper Allen Sapp is a famous Indian artist. He was born in 1928 on the Red Pheasant Reserve near Battleford, Saskatchewan. He was raised and cared for by his grandmother, Maggie Soonias because his mother died of tuberculosis. He was a sickly child who was often picked on by other children.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown point The immediate object of the attack on the British Forts at Ticonderoga and Crown Point on May 10 and 11, 1775 was first to capture the forts themselves, but also to obtain a cannon and supplies to use for the impending seige of Boston. Washington, who assumed command of the American forces on July 2, 1775, could not attempt this attack without heavy artillery, which was procured by Colonel Ethan Allen, Colonel Benedict Arnold and Colonel Seth Warner with Vermont?s Green Mountain Boys.
Equus Essay Research Paper The play Equus
Equus Essay, Research Paper The play Equus is about a young boy who viciously blinds six horses with a metal spike in a stable and the psychiatrist, Martin Dysart, who investigates the boy s mental state. It is a very complex, multileveled story, with many relationships effecting Allen s (the stabber) behavior.
Media Representations Of Violence Essay Research Paper
The article “Violence to a T” (Ogg 1997, p. 3) is typical of the style and content of crime news reporting found in the mass media. That is, most crime news stories reported in the media misrepresent the “crime problem” by focussing only on certain types of crimes. Those crimes are usually bizarre or unusual events, such as murder or kidnapping.
2001 Essay Research Paper Edgar Allen PoeEdgar
2001 Essay, Research Paper Edgar Allen Poe Edgar Allen Poe uses his stories to instill a single emotion into the reader. He uses many different aspects of the story to do this, including setting, characters, and action. For example, in the poems, “The Raven” and “Annabel Lee” he instills the emotions of despair and loneliness.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Vermont 16001800 Essay Research Paper Indian InhabitanceFor
Vermont (1600-1800) Essay, Research Paper Indian Inhabitance For over one hundred centuries before the arrival of the Europeans, thousands of Native Americans lived and died in present-day Vermont. Practically nothing is known of them except for few artifacts found in the area, and the first recognized Indians known of settling in Vermont were of the Algonquin, Iroquois, and Abenaki Nations during the 1500s.
Common Themes In Allen Ginsburg
’s Poetry Essay, Research Paper Since his first major poem, Howl, Allen Ginsberg has been a center of controversy. His poems talked about homosexuality before it was considered
Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper Over the past
Chrysanthemums Essay, Research Paper Over the past few months in class we have learned about many aspects of literature. Some examples of them are characterization, setting, style, tone, allegory, theme, and symbolism. I chose to write this essay about the symbolism aspect that is featured in so many great works of literature.
The Raven And The TellTale Heart Essay
, Research Paper Comparisons of ?The Raven? and ?The Tell-Tale Heart? Edgar Allen Poe’s story “A Tell Tale Heart,” has the protagonist obsessed with an old man’s eye. This obsession causes a conflict between the protagonist and his sanity. In ?The Raven the man imagines that a raven is a godsend, intended to relieve him of his anguish.
Edgar Allen Poe Biography Essay Research Paper
This Paper is about Edgar Allen Poe. Through out his life bad luck and misfortune seemed to follow him until his death. It seems as if from women and through out his time as an author there was no escaping it. This paper will discuss some of the misfortunes and bad luck that was in Poe’s life.
Impact Of Setting On EAP
’s House Of Usher Essay, Research Paper In the story ?Fall of the House of Usher?, Edgar Allen Poe?s use of setting is very important. The story is about a guy, the narrator who goes to visit his old childhood friend as he and his sister are dying. Roderick Usher, the friend, and his twin sister Madeline are the last remaining members of the Usher, who maintained a very tight family line.
The Raven Essay Research Paper The RavenOnce
The Raven Essay, Research Paper The Raven Once upon a midnite dreary, while I pondered, weak and weary. Edgar Allen Poe, The Raven, This poem is mainly about his wife dying and her being sick and his depression and anger. Nameless here forevermore, Only this and nothing more, Darkness there and nothing more, Tis the wind and nothing more.
Mary Jo Bang Essay Research Paper Bill
Mary Jo Bang Essay, Research Paper Bill Mueller April 18, 1999 English 1-2 Prof. McMullen Mary Jo Bang : Apology for Want Quiet, unassuming, serene. These characteristics define the appearance of poet Mary Jo Bang. There is, however, another side to the humble St. Louis native which is not readily apparent by either her looks or her demeanor.
Fall Of The House Of Usher By
Egar Allen Poe Essay, Research Paper Will Lewis “The Fall of the House of Usher” The story starts out with the narrator riding up to an old and gloomy house. He stresses that the overall persona of the house is very eerie. The reason he is at this house is because he received a letter from an old friend by the name of Roderick Usher.
Edgar Allan Poe Essay Research Paper Poe
Edgar Allan Poe Essay, Research Paper Poe’s Never Ending Loneliness “From childhood’s hour I have not been/as others were; I have not seen/ as others say I could not bring/ my passions from a common spring. From the same source I have not taken/ my sorrow; I could not awaken/ my heart to joy at the same tone;/ and all I loved, I loved alone.”
Allen A Dale Essay Research Paper Why
Allen A Dale Essay, Research Paper Why do individuals pass down stories orally instead of by writing? Before the time period that writing even existed, individuals had no choice, but to express themselves orally. During this time, they passed down these stories from generation to generation, but there may have been some minor changes because of the misinterpretation of the readers of the stores.
Allen Ginsberg Essay Research Paper What exactly
Allen Ginsberg Essay, Research Paper What exactly does it mean to be American? What are the boundaries of freedom and liberty? Do we have the freedom to speak from the heart? Allen Ginsberg believed so, and he did just that.
Gods And Goddesses Of Greek Mythology Essay
, Research Paper The gods and goddesses that the Greek people believe in make up the Greek mythology studied today. These divine characters represent a family living on Mount Olympus who intervene frequently in the lives of the human characters in Greek plays. They are omnipresent, for they are always observing mans actions and working through human nature.
Smoking 2 Essay Research Paper Smoking and
Smoking 2 Essay, Research Paper Smoking and Relaxation 7 References Allen, J. (1994) Health values. Journal of Health Behavior, 18, 34-39 Jenks, J. R. (1994) Smoking and satisfaction and motivations. Journal of Social Psychology, 134, 847-849. Morgan, H. (1995) Tobacco smoking and gender. Journal of Educational Research, 88, 301-308.
Annabell Lee Essay Research Paper In the
Annabell Lee Essay, Research Paper In the poem Annabell Lee the poet Eggar Allen Poe brings out the theme that true love will never die. This is a poem that is timely in its relevance. There are few
Edgar Allen Poe Essay Research Paper Edgar
Edgar Allen Poe Essay, Research Paper Edgar Allen Poe Edgar Allen Poe, the greatest American teller of mystery and suspense tales in the 19th century was a tormented artist. He struggled to become the accomplished author he is
Annie Essay Research Paper In Edger Allen
Annie Essay, Research Paper In Edger Allen Poe?s poem ?For Annie? it illustrates Poe?s life as being an illness, which has finally come to an end. For example, on lines 29 & 30 Poe writes, ?With a fever called ?Living? That burned in my brain?. It?s odd how Poe reverses the ways of death and life. He feels that life is an illness and that death is a cure for the illness called life.
Life Of Edgar Allen Poe Essay Research
Paper The name Edger Allen Poe is known through out the world, some might even consider it a household name. His literary works have sold millions of copies everywhere in the world. Poe never knew of any of these fames during his life. He wasn’t considered popular, he was considered a failure.
Lillian Hellman Essay Research Paper Hellman
Lillian Hellman Essay, Research Paper Hellman’s Character Models Lillian Hellman was born on June 20, 1905 in New Orleans, Louisiana. Her father was of German Jewish ancestry (Brody 1). Hellman grew up in many different regions of the United States. Since Hellman moved around a lot as a child, she had a “fragmented” education (Brody 1).
The Old Man And The Sea Analysis
Of Santiago Essay, Research Paper The Old Man and The Sea: Analysis of Santiago Ross Mueller Mr. Harocopos AP. English 11 29 September 1996 Ernest Hemingway had a specific type of character in each and every one
The Masque Of The Red Death By 2
The Masque Of The Red Death By Edgar Allen Poe Essay, Research Paper Edgar Allen Poe’s ?The Masque of the Red Death? is an elaborate allegory that combines objects in the story with visual descriptions to give focus to the reader’s imagination. In the story, a prince named Prospero tries to dodge the Red Death through isolation and seclusion.
Athletic Scholarships Essay Research Paper There are
Athletic Scholarships Essay, Research Paper There are many good athletes in professional sports today. There are many good athletes in college sports today also. Some of the biggest names in sports are Mark McGwire, Steve Young, Michael Jordan, Allen Iverson, and so on. Now, imagine if all of those players never made it to the pros.