THE HERESY OF GALILEO
Galileo was condemned by the Inquisition, not for his own brilliant theories, but because
he stood up for his belief in Copernicus’s theory that the earth was not, as the Church insisted, the
center of the universe, but that rather, the universe is heliocentric. Galileo was a man of
tremendous intellect and imagination living in a era dominated by the Catholic Church, which
attempted to control the people by dictating their own version of “reality.” Any person who
publicly questioned Church doctrine ran the chance of condemnation and punishment. If man
could think, man could question, and the Church could lose its authority over the masses. This
could not be tolerated in the 17th century, when the Church had the power to dictate “reality.”
Copernicus probably avoided a similar fate by confining his opinions to his students and the
university milieu, and in fact his theories were not published until the time of his death.
To be tried by the Inquisition was something that nobody could take lightly. Although in
Galileo’s time the Inquisition was becoming more and more lenient, it was known to have used
torture in the past and to have sent many heretics to burn at the stake. As late as 1600, this fate
had befallen the Italian thinker Giordano Bruno, a one-time Dominican friar who had adopted a
pantheistic philosophy of nature.
From the summer of 1605, Galileo was private tutor of mathematics to young Prince
Cosimo de’ Medici, son of the Grand Duke of Tuscany. Teacher and pupil became sincerely
attached to each other by mutual affection and deference, and this bond lasted to the end of
Galileo’s life. Galileo remained a good friend of the Grand Duke as well. In the summer of 1611,
the Grand Duke invited Galileo to a dinner party at his court. The Duke liked to gather great
scholars around him, especially when he had illustrious guests, to hear them talk about issues of
interest to the learned world. At this dinner the discussion centered on floating bodies. Galileo
maintained that bodies can float only if their specific gravity is less than that of water. Among the
dinner guests there were, however, some followers of Aristotle’s philosophies, and they argued
that bodies float if their shape is wide and smooth so they cannot cut through the resistance of the
water. Floating bodies were a topic on which Galileo was especially knowledgeable, as he had
been interested in the subject since, when as a student, he had read Archimedes. He was able to
support his point so brilliantly that one of the guests of honor, Maffeo Cardinal Barberini, sided
with him. Years later, Cardinal Barberini became Pope Urban VIII and turned against Galileo,
becoming one of his bitter enemies, but at that moment he was as congenial as one could be,
sincerely admiring Galileo’s dialectical skill. Perhaps to please the Cardinal, the Grand Duke
asked Galileo to put his argument into writing, which he did. The result was The Discourse on
Floating Bodies.
Galileo’s sharp, almost sarcastic wit made him especially suited to arguments and debates,
of which he was to have many in the following years. Some of these resulted in famous writings
that added to his lasting glory; many antagonized people of his time and turned many of them into
“enemies.”
The Peripatetics at the Grand Duke’s table were not very dangerous as potential enemies,
but his next adversary was. Even before the Discourse on Floating Bodies was published in
1612, Galileo was engaged in a conflict with an astronomer whose name he did not know and was
not to find out for over a year — the Jesuit father Christopher Scheiner (1575-1650). In 1610,
Galileo had claimed to be the first discoverer of sunspots; so had Father Scheiner, and the two
had entered into a bitter dispute. Father Scheiner had communicated his opinions on his
observations of sunspots in several letters to Mark Welser, a German patron of science. Perhaps
to avoid direct criticism, Scheiner wrote under a pen name. Mark Welser published Scheiner’s
letters and sent them to Galileo for comment without revealing the name of the author.
Galileo replied in three Letters on Sunspots addressed to Welser (in Italian, which
Scheiner could not read and had to have translated, while Scheiner had not written in his native
German, but in Latin). In his letters, Galileo severely criticized Scheiner’s views.
The greatest significance of these Letters on Sunspots, as far as the Church was
concerned, was that for the first time in print Galileo had openly endorsed Copernicus’s theory as
a reality and not as a mere hypothesis, and that he had used his own discoveries as proofs in favor
of Copernicanism. Just as important, he had unwittingly antagonized a Jesuit, the first of many.
The Jesuits were powerful in the Church, and in particular they were advisers on educational
matters. It was unfortunate indeed that so many of them sooner or later should withdraw their
previous friendship, respect, or even indifference toward Galileo to pass into the “enemy” camp.
The trouble, however, initially came from other quarters. In 1613, Galileo learned from
Father Benedetto Castelli, one of his most beloved pupils, that in the course of a discussion at the
court of Tuscany, the dowager Grand Duchess, Christina de Lorena, had taken the stand that the
earth could not move because its motion would contradict the Holy Scriptures.
Galileo decided that the time had come to explain his views on the relations between
science and faith. He did this in his Letter to Castelli, which he sent, in manuscript copies, not
only to his pupil Castelli, but also to several friends. Soon afterward, in his Letter to the Grand
Duchess Cristina, he elaborated what he had written to Castelli. It was lofty and solemn and
showed that Galileo’s faith in nature and its laws went side by side with his faith in God. It
contains passages which are among Galileo’s most beautiful
Today, these views are widely shared and officially recognized by the Church. In fact, in
1893, Pope Leo XIII wrote a paper which presented the church’s official point of view concerning
the relationships between science and scripture; this statement cannot be distinguished from
Galileo’s. Even in Galileo’s time, the highest authorities of the Church did not call his letters to
Castelli and Cristina into question; but some in the Church did criticize them. To these few who
had little understanding of new developments in science, Galileo’s writings seemed an outsider’s
interference in religious matters. A Dominican friar denounced the Letter to Castelli to the
Inquisition. Another Dominican, Father Tomaso Caccini, who had once been disciplined for being
a “scandal-maker,” preached a sermon against Galileo in the popular church of Santa Maria
Novella in Florence. He concluded by saying that mathematics was an art of the devil, that
mathematicians were the source of all heresies and should be ousted from all countries. Shortly
afterward, he too testified against Galileo before the Inquisition.
Although there was secrecy surrounding the Inquisition, Galileo became aware of what
was going on in Rome and decided his presence was needed there. He was warmly welcomed
and stayed at the Villa Medici, the Tuscan embassy, on the Grand Duke’s order. Although his
friends strongly advised against it, Galileo immediately resumed his campaign in favor of
Copernicus through intense talks and discussions with almost everyone of importance in Rome
and through several new writings. In fact, several cardinals did their best to persuade him to keep
quiet in public about Copernicus, regardless of his private belief, but Galileo could not be
deterred.
Ultimately, the Inquisition never really questioned the theological views that Galileo had
expressed in his letters; and he was able to clear himself of charges of heresy and blasphemy
concerning the nature of God. The Inquisition, however, did denounce Galileo for his defense of
Copernicus’s theories, and on order of the Pope, admonished Galileo that he was not to hold,
teach, or defend the condemned opinion of Copernicus. A few days later, Copernicus’s book, De
Revolutionibus, which had been dedicated to a Pope, and which the Pope had accepted, and with
which the Church had found no fault until Galileo had started to present it as reality, was
condemned and prohibited until it should be corrected. Yet, the Roman Catholic Church had
taken no action against Copernicus’s books or his ideas until Galileo undertook his campaign to
“convert” the theologians. At the hands of Galileo, the heliocentric system threatened the
geocentric and, much more serious, God’s creation was becoming an object of direct human
observation which could be interpreted without the help of the Scriptures or of religion. In short,
Galileo was condemned because he could not keep his opinions to himself and could not resist the
temptation to expose the ignorance, deceit, and manipulation of the powerful religious leaders of
the time.
Другие работы по теме:
Who Won The War Between The Theologians
And The Early Scientists Essay, Research Paper Who Won the War Between the Theologians and the Early Scientists The early modern European scientists faced lethal religious opposition. During
Galileo Essay Research Paper Born Galileo Galilei
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Born Galileo Galilei, his main contributions were, in astronomy, the use of the telescope in observation and the discovery of sunspots, lunar mountains and valleys, the four largest satellites of Jupiter, and the phases of Venus. In physics, he discovered the laws of falling bodies.
Galile Vs The Bible Essay Research Paper
Galileo vs. The Bible Religion and science have always been conflicting studies. Religion, being based on faith, relies on the supernatural to explain life and being. Science, on the other hand, cannot do this. Scientists need to eliminate the possibility of the unexplainable in order to maintain and control group by which to measure other groups.
The HerseyBlanchard Situation Essay Research Paper The
The Hersey-Blanchard Situation Essay, Research Paper The Hersey-Blanchard Situational Theory One of the most widely followed leadership models is the situational leadership theory of Paul Heresy and Kenneth Blanchard. Situational Leadership Theory is a contingency theory that focuses on the followers.
Galieo A Look At The Math In
His Life Essay, Research Paper Galileo was born in the city of Pisa, on the day Michelangelo died. His parents determined the first, significant, event in his life. At the age of seventeen he was sent to the University of Pisa to study medicine. It is reported that Galileo’s interest in science and mathematics was roused by this problem and then further stimulated by the chance attendance at a lecture on geometry at the university.
My Ass Essay Research Paper v A
My Ass Essay, Research Paper v A Florentine philosopher, physicist, and inventor. This is a lot of work to do in one life time. Galileo Galilei did all that and even more. He is most commonly remembered for his condemnation by the Holy Office as a result of his attempting to prove the Copernican theory of the universe.
Enlightenment The Light Bulb Of The 1700
’s Essay, Research Paper Enlightenment: The Light Bulb of the 1700’s Throughout history many people have changed society with their ideas and actions. Two philosophers whose ideas and actions changed society are Voltaire
Northern Lights Essay Research Paper Northern Lights
Northern Lights Essay, Research Paper Northern Lights The Northern Light are poetry, nature’s light show, and are quantum leaps in the oxygen atom. They are elementary particle physics, superstition, mythology, and fairy tales. The Northern Lights or Aurora Borealis have filled us with wonder and inspired artists; they have frightened people to think the world’s end was at hand.
Evangelista Torricelli Essay Research Paper I chose
Evangelista Torricelli Essay, Research Paper I chose to do my report on Evangelista Torricelli. The reason I chose to do him is because he is both Italian and male. I am also both Italian and male which would be my connection to him.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo GalileeGalileo Galilee
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo GalileeGalileo Galilee was a pioneer of the modern physics and astronomy who was born on February 15, 1564 near Pisa, Italy. An Italian astronomer, he was the one who invented the telescope and discovered many undiscovered realms of the space. He was one of the few that challenge the idea of the earth not being at the center of the galaxy.
The Telescope Essay Research Paper The TelescopeIn
The Telescope Essay, Research Paper The Telescope In 1609 Galileo Galilee Constructed his first telescope. Little did he know that this would be one of the greatest inventions the world would ever see. This fairly simple creation enhanced our ability to see things that are very far away and that can?t be seen with the naked eye.
Galileo And The Telescope Essay Research Paper
Galileo was not the person who invented the telescope, but he was the first one to use the telescope to study the heavens. He made many observations using the telescope that shocked the religious world. In this short essay, I will only focus on three observations and how an Aristotlean reacts to it. These observations played a very important role on the development of astronomy.
Galileo Essay Research Paper After reading this
Galileo Essay, Research Paper After reading this letter I feel that Galileo had a very opinionated outlook on life and was heavily involved in a struggle for freedom of inquiry. Galileo was a person who had many strong beliefs and would not let people or a document have a say in what he believes.
Rene Descrates Essay Research Paper While the
Rene Descrates Essay, Research Paper While the great philosophical distinction between mind and body in western thought can be traced to the Greeks, it is to the seminal work of Ren? Descartes (1596-1650) [see figure 1], French mathematician, philosopher, and physiologist, that we owe the first systematic account of the mind/body relationship.
The Scientific Revolution Essay Research Paper During
The Scientific Revolution Essay, Research Paper During the Scientific Revolution scientists such as Galileo, Copernicus, Descartes and Bacon wrestled with questions about God, human aptitude, and the possibilities of understanding the world. Eventually, the implications of the new scientific findings began to affect the way people thought and behaved throughout Europe.
Marxism Through Galileo Essay Research Paper Marxism
Marxism Through Galileo Essay, Research Paper Marxism Through Galileo Marxism is a form of communism in which one day the common people, or the proletariats, would overthrow the power of the upper class, or capitalists. Bertolt Brecht, the author of the play Galileo, was a strong believer in this kind of communism.
The Trial Of Galileo Essay Research Paper
The Trial of Galileo Copernicus’s De Revolutionibus of 1543 was dedicated to the Pope; yet ninety years later (1633) Galileo was tried by the inquisition for espousing Copernican views. How did this come about?
Galileo Galilei Essay Research Paper Galileo GalileiFrom
Galileo Galilei Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galilei From an early age Galileo Galilei manifested his aptitude for mathematical and mechanical pursuits, but his parents, wishing to turn him aside from studies that promised no substantial return, destined him for the medical profession. But all was in vain, and at an early age the youth had to be left to follow the bent of his native genius, which speedily placed him among the most renowned natural philosophers.
Galileo Galilei Essay Research Paper Galileo Galilei1564
Galileo Galilei Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galilei 1564 -1642 Galileo Galilei was born on February 15, 1564 in Pisa, Italy. Galileo pioneered “experimental scientific method,” and was the first to use a refracting telescope to make important astronomical discoveries.
Galileo Galilei Essay Research Paper Galileo was
Galileo Galilei Essay, Research Paper Galileo was an Italian mathematician, astronomer, and physicist. He was born in Pisa, Italy on February 15, 1564. In the mid 1570?s, he and his family moved to Florence and he started his formal education in a local monastery. He was sent to the University of Pisa in 1581.
Galileo Galilei
“founder Of Modern Experimental Science” Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galilei “founder of modern experimental science” Galileo Galilei was one of the most remarkable scientists ever. He
Galileo 2 Essay Research Paper Galileo s
Galileo 2 Essay, Research Paper Galileo s Scientific Revolution Against the Church The scientific revolution was not only a challenge to a government but was also a challenge to a deeply rooted religion. The Church, having been influenced by Greek philosophers, viewed the world as a creation by God, complete with lawfulness, regularity and beauty.
Life Of Galileo Essay Research Paper Betrolt
Life Of Galileo Essay, Research Paper Betrolt Brecht s Life of Galileo , depicts key episodes in the life of the great Italian physicist, Galileo Galilei. The central concern of the play is the essential conflict between Galileo and the Catholic Church. The scientist s heretical discoveries about the solar system brought him to the attention of the Inquisition and led ultimately to his theories being silenced by the Church.
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo “Whereas Galileo spent his last days under house arrest and was formally condemned by the Church for his scientific views, the elder Darwin was widely
Galileo Essay Research Paper Galileo was an
Galileo Essay, Research Paper Galileo was an Italian physicist and astronomer who with the German astronomer Johannes kelper initiated the scientific revolution that began the work of Sir Isaac Newton. Galileos main interest was astronomy he used the telescope which he invented using optic lenses to see sunspots on the sun loonier mountains and valleys the four largest satellites of Jupiter and the phases of Venus.
Galileo 2 Essay Research Paper GalileoGalileo 15641642
Galileo 2 Essay, Research Paper Galileo Galileo (1564-1642), was an Italian physicist and astronomer, who, with the German astronomer Johannes Kepler, initiated the scientific revolution that flowered in the work of the English physicist Sir Isaac Newton. Born Galileo Galilei, his main contributions were, in astronomy, the use of the telescope in observation and the discovery of sunspots, lunar mountains and valleys, the four largest satellites of Jupiter, and the phases of Venus.
Ancient Astronomy Essay Research Paper Astronomy has
Ancient Astronomy Essay, Research Paper Astronomy has been a source for myriad ideas influencing every subject. The stars have existed since the dawn of man. People have looked to the universe to determine physical location, gain spiritual direction and to track time. Many early scientists used astronomy to make careers for themselves and print their names in all the history books of time.
Galileo
& His Impact On Society Essay, Research Paper Known to some people as the father of modern science, Galileo impacted this field in such a way that he was put on trial for going against the Catholic Church?s beliefs, because he supported the Copernican theory that the Earth revolved around the sun. The Church?s belief was that the Earth was in the center of the universe and all heavenly bodies went around the Earth (geocentric theory or Ptolemaic theory, followers of Aristotle believed this too).
Galileo Science And The Church Essay Research
Paper Wanting people to know that there was a double fault in the conflict between Galileo and the Church Father Langford writes an account of the facts in Galileo, Science and the Church.
Galileo And Church Essay Research Paper Galileo
Galileo And Church Essay, Research Paper Galileo, Science and the Church, by Jerome J. Langford, are about the trials and tribulations of Galileo with the Roman Catholic Church in the 1600?s. The
Galileo Essay Research Paper GALILEOGalileo 1564 1642
Galileo Essay, Research Paper GALILEO Galileo (1564- 1642) was an Italian astronomer and physicist whose discoveries in mechanics and astronomy contribute greatly to the progression of Science. He started his Science career at the University of Pisa where he studied to be a physician. Galileo made his first important discovery while still studying in Pisa when he was only 19, it was when he was in the cathedral observing the swinging action of the hanging lamps, he wondered if the duration of their swings was always the same regardless of the distance they traveled.
The Science Of Galileo Essay Research Paper
THE SCIENCE OF GALILEO The play Life of Galileo is considered a masterpiece and one of the most relevant plays of the 20th century. It addresses the social and political problems of the late 16th and early 17th centuries.