Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper
McCulloch v. Maryland
The case of McCulloch v. Maryland was brought to the United States Supreme Court in 1819. The decisions of Chief Justice John Marshall in this case would set precedence for all future cases involving the expansion of federal power and any impediment on federal powers by state governments.
The first Bank of the United States (BUS) was created in 1791 as part of Alexander Hamilton’s financial plan. It was opposed by Jefferson, who claimed that Congress was not specifically given the right to charter a bank. Hamilton argued (along the lines of the elastic clause) that Congress had the power to do anything not specifically forbidden in the Constitution. President Washington agreed with Hamilton and the bank was given twenty-year charter (expiring in 1811). After the war of 1812, the Madison administration sought new national development. This proved difficult with the nations finances loosely organized by state chartered banks. Inflation, and a lack of regulated currency from the state banks, prompted Madison to sign a bill creating a second BUS in 1816. The new BUS imposed strict regulation of currency on the state banks and would not accept notes from banks that had overextended themselves. In retaliation, the Maryland legislature attempted to tax the Baltimore branch of the BUS. James McCulloch, the treasurer for this branch, refused to pay the tax and was brought to trial in the Supreme Court by the state of Maryland.
Chief Justice Marshall asked two questions in this case. The first question is, “has Congress power to incorporate a bank?” Marshall states, “This government is acknowledged by all to be one of enumerated powers.” Hamilton s argument Washington to charter the first BUS maintains true for this second BUS. Under the powers of the elastic clause, and simply because the Constitution does not forbid Congress from chartering a bank, it would seem acceptable for the second BUS to exist. Marshall explains that although the Constitution does not expressly mention the power to create a bank, it does give Congress the power to exercise controls over the economy as necessary. The counsel for the state of Maryland tried to argue that the elastic clause has restrictions and that it does not apply to Congress chartering a corporation, and thus Congress has no right to do so. Marshall responded to this by explaining that if the restrictions claimed by Maryland’s counsel were in fact true, Congress would be restricted in its basic rights to legislate.
Another controversy that erupts from the prosecution involves the definition of the word “necessary” in the “necessary and proper” clause. They began to interpolate exactly what the Constitution means by “necessary” and attempt to explain that creating a corporation such as a national bank is not necessary at all. Marshall examines the use of necessary in government and concludes that in this context it does not signify and “absolute-physical necessity, so strong that one thing, to which another may be termed necessary, cannot exist without the other.” Instead, it is found that necessary is more synonymous with convenient in this context. He further explains that there are varying degrees of necessity, and the degree the counsel of Maryland is citing is not merely “necessary” but “absolutely or indispensably necessary.” The decision made allows the new BUS to exist as it was initially planned to do so.
The second question asked is, “whether the state of Maryland may, without violating the constitution, tax that branch?” It was clearly expressed that all states reserve the rights to tax as necessary (except on imports and exports), unless the tax conflicts with another law or Constitutional right. “The argument on the part of the state of Maryland, is, not that the states may directly resist a law of Congress, but that they may exercise their acknowledged powers upon it, and that the constitution leaves them this right, in the confidence that they will not abuse it…. This, however, is not valid. The state government does not posses the power to interfere with the federal bank. “The sovereignty of a state extends to everything which exists by its own authority…” but the BUS does not fall under state sovereignty. This prevents state governments from conflicting with the national government. Marshall finds the tax to be impeding on the BUS enough to make it unconstitutional.
In answering the fist question, Marshall brought further understanding to what is meant by the implied powers of our government. The second question was more controversial. Marshall sought to prevent governments in separate states from conflicting. He also establishes the broad powers of the federal government as powers not to be disrupted by state governments. John Marshall’s decisions were met with praise throughout the judicial system, and set example to the scope of our federal government’s power.
Другие работы по теме:
Мак-Каллок, Уоррен
Уоррен Маккалок (англ. Warren Sturgis McCulloch; 16 ноября 1899, Оранж, Нью-Джерси, США — 24 сентября 1969, Кембридж, Массачусетс, США) — американский нейропсихолог, нейрофизиолог, теоретик нейросетей и один из отцов кибернетики.
Environmental Economic Impact Of Pollution In Chesapeake
Bay Essay, Research Paper Environmental Economic Impact of Pollution in the Chesapeake Bay The Chesapeake Bay is the nation’s largest estuary with six major tributaries, the James, the Potomac, the Susquehanna, the Patuxent, the York, and the Rappahannock Rivers, feeding into the bay from various locations in Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and the District of Columbia (Chemical Contaminants in the Chesapeake Bay – Workshop Discussion 1).
Jim Henson Essay Research Paper Jim Henson
Jim Henson Essay, Research Paper Jim Henson was born on September 24, 1936, in Greenville, Mississippi. He moved to Maryland in fifth grade and throughout his childhood had a strong interest in
Maryland Essay Research Paper Small though it
Maryland Essay, Research Paper Small though it is, Maryland has such a dazzling variety of natural and man-made features – remote mountains, crowded urban areas, fertile farmlands, scenic shorelines, modern industrial centers, old tobacco plantations – that the state has been called an America in miniature.
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper The
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper The Supreme Court case of McCulloch v. Maryland set forth important principles in American government. The case itself dealt with whether or not the Congress had power from the Constitution to establish a national bank; also, it dealt with whether or not a state could tax or interfere with the national bank.
Greg Sirico Essay Research Paper Adv American
Greg Sirico Essay, Research Paper Adv American Gov. November 14th ?98 McCulloch v Maryland Can congress incorporate a bank? Can a state tax the national government? These were some of the key issues that brought up in the Supreme Court case of McCullloch v Maryland. James Madison, the judge in this case, rules in favor of the National Government.
Violence Against Women Act Essay Research Paper
The Violence Against Women Act creates a right to be “free from crimes of violence” that are gender motivated. It also gives a private civil right of action to the victims of these crimes. The
British Colonization Essay Research Paper There were
British Colonization Essay, Research Paper There were three different types of English colonies bosed on who owned the colony came fom the king through a charter. All charters have certain requirements. Taxes must be collected, and the laws of a colony may not contradict those of individual. Maryland was an ecample of a proprietary colony. corporate colonies were wned by a group of investors and run through a coprpration.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper George Washington
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper George Washington may have been the Father of Our Country, but his friend John Marshall defined for the new nation what it meant to be united and to live under the rule of law.
John Marshal Essay Research Paper The Influence
John Marshal Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Marshall s Court The Supreme Court, under John Marshall, had a great influence on the development of the powers of our present day government. John Marshall s court was responsible for greatly increasing the powers of the Supreme Court and the Federal Government.
Internet Piracy Essay Research Paper In this
Internet Piracy Essay, Research Paper In this day and age where technology is rampant and advance, it is critical that we comprehend the possibilities that such technology has, no matter whether it is good or bad. From our very own households, we can now ?get connected? and experience this technology first hand.
Harriet Tubman Essay Research Paper Harriet tubman
Harriet Tubman Essay, Research Paper Harriet tubman was a runaway slave from maryland who became “moses of her people”. Her real name was Araminta Ross. She was of 11 children.She was a nursemaid for her master’s baby.One day a man went to the store without permission and was going to get whipped. He asked ross to help and she refused.He threw an iron at the boy but he missed him and hit ross.
American Fed Essay Research Paper American federalism
American Fed Essay, Research Paper American federalism is a form of government in which the constitution distributes governmental powers between the national government and the subsidiary governments of the states. Article I, Section 8, and the Tenth Amendment are good examples of this definition. In Article I, Section 8, the Constitution defines the powers delegated to the national government, such as the power to regulate commerce and to enact laws necessary and proper for the execution of its powers.
John Marshall
’s Court Rulings Essay, Research Paper Hamilton was a federalist and served as the secretary of the treasury in the 1890s. He was a strong supporter of a centralized federal government. He also advocated loose interpretation of the u.s. constitution and the use of the elastic clause. Which was an ambiguous power of the federal government stating that ?congress can do what it is proper and necessary? john Marshall?s epitomizing of these Hamiltonian principals and philosophies can be seen in several of his court rulings.
Babe Ruth Essay Research Paper BABE RUTH
Babe Ruth Essay, Research Paper BABE RUTH THE LEGEND “Babe Ruth” was born on February 16th, 1895 and died on August 16th, 1948. He loved baseball very much and it all started in Baltimore, Maryland. This is his story!
Cause And Efffect Essay Essay Research Paper
Tsunami When one thinks of all the natural disasters, that could effect the Maryland and Washington D.C. area they often think of hurricanes and snowstorms. They often forget about the possibility of a tsunami. A tsunami, often referred to as a ?tidal wave?, is a wave train, or series of waves, generated in a body of water by an impulsive disturbance that vertically displaces the water column.
A History Of The Early Assertion Of
Judicial Power Essay, Research Paper A History of the Early Assertion of Judicial Power Once upon a time there were several men planning out the best way to divide the power in a fledgling new country. Some of them wanted one big power, and others wanted three smaller ones where the power was roughly equally divided.
Pea Ridge Essay Research Paper Pea Ridge
Pea Ridge Essay, Research Paper Pea Ridge, Ark. At dawn on March 7, the head of the Confederate column had reached Telegraph Road, but the tail was still back at Little Sugar Creek. Van Dorn now made another snap decision: to save time, Price’s division would proceed south on Telegraph Road on the east side of a rocky hill called Big Mountain; McCulloch’s division would move south on Ford Road on the west side of Big Mountain.
Daniel Webster Essay Research Paper Born January
Daniel Webster Essay, Research Paper Born January 18, 1782, in Salisbury, New Hampshire, Daniel Webster was a central figure in the nation’s history. He successfully combined his political and legal career and played a role as lawyer, congressman, orator, secretary of state, leader of two parties, and a presidential candidate.
Thurgood Marshall Essay Research Paper Thurgood MarshallThurgood
Thurgood Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thurgood Marshall Thurgood Marshall was born on July 2, 1908, in Baltimore, Maryland. Thurgood was the grandson of a slave. His father, William Marshall, instilled in him from youth an appreciation for the United States Constitution, and the rule of law. His father became Chief Steward of the prestigious Island Club, while mother Norma Marshall, a graduate of an all black college in Maryland, taught in a segregated Baltimore Elementary School.
Federalism Essay Research Paper Federalism the balanced
Federalism Essay, Research Paper Federalism, the balanced division of state and federal powers, is an essential principle of the United States Government. On occasion this balance is contested or violated and court cases ensue. These court cases over time have shaped and defined federalism and the powers, rights, and position of state and national governments.
Douglas Essay Research Paper Frederick Douglas Frederick
Douglas Essay, Research Paper Frederick Douglas Frederick Douglass was born in Tuckahoe, Maryland, near Hillsborough. He doesn?t know for sure of his age, he has seen no proof and his master will not inform him. Most masters prefer for their slaves to stay ignorant. He believes that he was around twenty-seven and twenty-eight when he began writing his narrative – he overheard his master say he was about seventeen years of age during 1835.
Federalism From Its Beginning To The Present
Essay, Research Paper From its early beginning in the minds of the Framers of the Constitution to its state today. The United States system of federalism has changed greatly through landmark court decisions, congressional decisions, and strong presidential influence. In the next few paragraphs I will take you through the history of federalism in the United States.
Speech On Blacks Essay Research Paper Blacks
Speech On Blacks Essay, Research Paper Blacks on the Eastern Shore I enjoyed Clara Smalls presentation about blacks on the eastern shore. It was interesting to learn that in the early 1600?s blacks were primarily indentured servants. Blacks only worked for so long then could be released. Some blacks even owed land and had slaves of their own.
Billie Holliday Essay Research Paper Billie HolidayBillie
Billie Holliday Essay, Research Paper Billie Holiday Billie Holiday was a famous jazz singer in the 1930 s and 1940 s. She was born in Baltimore, Maryland in 1915 with the name of Eleanora Fagan. She became successful as by singing in various bands before embarking on a solo career. Billie Holiday was one of the first successful African American females.
Our Trip To Miami Essay Research Paper
Our trip to Miami, Florida We are traveling to Miami, Florida. We are leaving from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. We will be traveling through 7 states. The capital of Pennsylvania is Harrisburg. Independence Hall is in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The states we are flying over are Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, And Florida.
Judicial Activism Vs Judicial Restraint Essay Research
Paper Judicial activism and judicial restraint are two opposing philosophies when it comes to the Supreme Court justices’ interpretations of the United States Constitution; justices appointed by the President to the Supreme Court serve for life,and thus whose decisions shape the lives of “We the people” for a long time to come.
Ira Aldridge Essay Research Paper Ira Aldridge
Ira Aldridge Essay, Research Paper Ira Aldridge was one of the best Shakespearean actors of all time. He played many of the Shakespearean roles like Macbeth, and King Lear. But his most famous role was Othello.
John Marshall Biography Essay Research Paper John
John Marshall Biography Essay, Research Paper John Marshall: Father of the Modern Judiciary If George Washington is the father of our country, and James Madison the father of the Constitution, then few will deny that John Marshall is the father of our modern federal court system. It is surprising, then, that there are so few serious studies of the Chief Justice’s life.
Antietam Essay Research Paper The Battle of
Antietam Essay, Research Paper The Battle of Antietam Union Losses – 12,410 Confederate Losses – 10,700 On September 4, 1862 General Robert E. Lee crossed the Potomac into Maryland
5 Steps To Prepare For An Interview
Essay, Research Paper Intro to Business November 11, 2000 Five Steps in Preparing for an Interview 1. Tell me something about yourself a) Graduated from a single sexed college preparatory school, Garrison Forest in Baltimore, Maryland. Now finishing my fourth year at the College of Charleston, double- majoring in Business Administration and Pre-Law.