Aristotelian Essay, Research Paper
Can a Child be Virtuous?
In this paper I will argue against Aristotle and his
idea that children cannot be virtuous, as we discussed in
class. I will do this by giving concrete examples that a
certain widespread religion believes in this virtuosity of a
child. I will also use a more common example that occurs all
the time in America.
Aristotle says that children cannot be virtuous because
virtues are something that, to be acquired must be practiced
over and over again. A child has not had enough practice,
time or understanding of what he is doing to be considered
virtuous. However, I think that there are virtuous children,
and that not only Athenian gentlemen are virtuous, but
some other people also, these including children.
For my first example let us consider the religion of
Tibet. These people elect a child, in fact a newborn to be
in charge of their entire religion, this child is the Dali
Lama. They think that this child is holy, and pure.
Obviously they think that he is good, and virtuous. He has
the most power in their entire religious system of beliefs.
There are many many people who believe in this religion, and
have done so for centuries. This child is trained from a
very young age on and is selected to lead a virtuous life.
He practices things that Aristotle would view as virtuous,
for example, courage, pride, justice, and temperance. This
child could easily get in more practice time of virtuous
activity than the average person, even more than a person
who is on their way to being virtuous who is an adult.
According to Aristotle s own beliefs, there is a certain
amount of virtuous activity that must be done to become a
virtuous person. This child could easily do as many virtuous
activities by the age of 10 as say someone who is 20 in
another situation. That is one problem with Aristotle s
theory, when does the virtuous activity start adding up so
that one may become a virtuous person? How long is someone
considered a child? Do his activities not count until he
reaches a certain age, and then suddenly there is a
breakthrough and they start to count? I think not. A good
act is a good act no matter what the age, if the intent is
correct.
Those who wish to support Aristotle could in a certain
context use the Christian religion to counter the Dali Lama
example. Christians believe that all men are born sinful
and not good. There is no way that a child is any better
than anyone else. The Dali Lama would be considered just
like any other child, not virtuous. They also believe that
there is no way to become, by Aristotle s definition totally
virtuous. It is an impossibility. This is where there view
would stop counteracting the Dali Lama, and start to
contradict Aristotle himself. They think that all men are
born sinful and die sinful, whereas Aristotle thinks that it
is possible to achieve perfect virtuosity and then be happy
and never lose this state of being. He thinks it is possible
to achieve perfection.
Another example that is a little more common here in
America is the child that dials 911 to save their parents
life. This child may only be 4 or 5 years old, yet we see
the shows on TV about this little heroes all the time. Their
parents may have practiced dialing 911 over and over again
with them so that when an emergency occurred they would know
what to do. They know what is right, and display an amazing
amount of courage. They are proving that they have actually
learned what they have been taught, and took action in a
crisis.
An Aristotelian supporter would say that this child did
not fully understand what they were doing, this one act does
not make them virtuous! The child is still going to be
scared sometimes (non courageous) They are going to show a
lot of non-temperance, also a non virtuous activity, and
they were just acting out of a certain repetitive task that
they have been taught. (kind of like a pet learning a trick)
Ask their parents though if this is they way that they view
the child, ask society if they think that this child is
virtuous. They will will yes he is, not all 4 year olds dial
911 in a crisis, some just sit down and cry when the time
comes, not all children, even if they know what to do,
actually do it.
In conclusion I would like to say that I think that
there are virtuous people, and virtuous children who grow
into virtuous adults or not so virtuous adults or vice
versa. I would also like to say that although these people
may exhibit a certain amount of good, that they would not
achieve Aristotle s view of becoming virtuous because this
is impossible. These people may once be good and then turn
bad, it happens all the time, or they may have a lapse.
Humans are not perfect, and therefore cannot become perfect
at anything. Sure there are people out there who will
achieve happiness, but no one is happy in the sense that
Aristotle means it, at least not 100% of the time.
Другие работы по теме:
Compare Contrast Essay Research Paper Only Child
Compare Contrast Essay, Research Paper Only Child vs Siblings I want this and I want that is all you here from an only child. There are many differences between an only child and a child who has siblings. My friend is an only child and there are many differences in the way we act. She always thinks of herself first, but that is not a bad thing.
We Kool Kats Essay Research Paper We
We Kool Kats Essay, Research Paper We kool kats you left bare you left starren into nothin bang America cock of eternity you tore me up as if i were your child
April Morning Essay Essay Research Paper I
April Morning Essay Essay, Research Paper I think that some of the reasoning behind Moses Cooper letting Adam fight in the war was that Adam was no longer a small child like his brother
Parent Relationships Essay Research Paper In many
Parent Relationships Essay, Research Paper In many of the works of literature I have read in this particular class, I noticed that many of the characters are parents. Which leads me to ask the following questions? How are parent/child relationships represented in early literature and how do these representations compare with representations, either real or literary, in our society?
Abortion Essay Research Paper Many have pondered
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Many have pondered upon the meaning of abortion. The argument being that every child that is born should be wanted and others who believe that every child that is conceived should be born. The choice of a woman whether or not she wants to conceive a child is called abortion. Abortion preserves a woman?s constitutional right, relieves the undesired child of future distress, and establishes a peaceful society.
Oedipus Essay Essay Research Paper According to
Oedipus Essay Essay, Research Paper According to the Aristotelian characteristics of good tragedy, the tragic character should not fall due to either excessive virtue or excessive wickedness, but due to what Aristotle called hamartia. Hamartia may be interpreted as either a flaw in character or an error in judgement.
Poem Angel Essay Research Paper Once upon
Poem: Angel Essay, Research Paper Once upon a time, there was a child ready to be born. So one day he asked God, “They tell me you’re sending me to earth tomorrow but how am I going to live there being so small and helpless?”
Autisim Essay Research Paper Autism is a
Autisim Essay, Research Paper Autism is a relatively rare occurence it is estimated that it occurs in between 2 to 5 peple in every ten-thousand births. The main factor that makes autistic childeren different from the norm is there lack of sociability. The autistic child does not appear to even want to interact with others and many times prefers self stimulation such as flicking there fingers in front of their face or biting.
Sex Before Marriage Essay Research Paper Wait
Sex Before Marriage Essay, Research Paper Wait To Have Sex Although there are many people having sex, you shouldn’t. I am going to give you some reasons on why you shouldn’t. First of all, you
Hamlet As An Aristotelian Tragedy Essay Research
Paper According to the Aristotelian view of tragedy, a tragic hero must fall through his or her own error. This is typically called the “tragic flaw”, and can be applied to any characteristic that causes the downfall the hero. Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Prince of Denmark can be seen as an Aristotelian tragedy and Hamlet as it’s tragic hero.
Aristotelian Hero
’s Essay, Research Paper Don’t Aristotelian Hero’s Have Enlightenment? An Aristotelian hero has a hamartia, downfall, suffering and enlightenment and
Medical Terms Essay Research Paper I agree
Medical Terms Essay, Research Paper I agree and disagree with genetic engineering. I feel that it is only fair to let somebody who can not get pregnant to able to use invitro-fertilization and to pick what the child would look like. However, to choose whether sperm was from an Olympic athlete or someone with very high intelligence levels is unfair and unethical.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion I think
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I think is very bad. Abortion is the killing of an unborn child. The abortion clinics use many cruel and discusting techniques to kill the unborn baby. On way is they take a vaccuum and suck the child out break it into pieces. Another way is they take a sharp knife or something and they scrape the baby out while cutting it into pieces.
Walt Disney Essay Research Paper This book
Walt Disney Essay, Research Paper This book is about the life of Walt Disney, an American legend. The Arthur begins the tale with a view of the family before Walt Disney’s birth
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Child Care Essay Research Paper Caring for
Child Care Essay, Research Paper Caring for a pet is like caring for a child. I feel this is because you do almost the same things that you do when caring for a child, that you would do when caring for a pet. The similarities are you provide food and shelter, you provide them with entertainment, and you take them to a doctor or vettrnarin when they are sick.
Parental Responsibility Essay Research Paper Parental ResponsibilityBecoming
Parental Responsibility Essay, Research Paper Parental Responsibility Becoming a parent requires a lot of responsibility. The life a person invisions their child to have is determined by the support they provide. A child s youth is the most important stage in contributing to his/her future. In most cases, parents are the ones who are responsible for their child s behavior.
School Violence Essay Research Paper Every day
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Every day a child is hurt purposely, or accidentally by another classmate. There are many things that cause people to take violence out on other people. It could possibly be parenting, bullies, television, and even video games.
Child Pornography Essay Research Paper Child PornographyPornography
Child Pornography Essay, Research Paper Child Pornography Pornography is a serious issue that will never be ignored or dismissed. Focusing directly with child pornography. Pornography, viewed by an adult is a pill stimulating the mind, inducing sexual arousement and pleasure, but when a child views pornography, an affect of social behavior starts.
Night Terrors Essay Research Paper Night TerrorsNight
Night Terrors Essay, Research Paper Night Terrors Night terrors are relatively common occurrence that appears mostly in young children typically between the ages of three and five year olds. A night terror usually occurs after the child goes to bed. Night terrors can be hereditary. If you or your spouse had them as a young child, most likely your child will get them too.
The Dead Child Essay Research Paper An
The Dead Child Essay, Research Paper An overview of the short story “The Dead Child” The Dead Child written by Gabrielle Roy is a story about how an young inexperienced substitute teacher helps her students to deal with the death of their peer-Yolande. The story takes place in a small Metis villege in Manitoba on a summer day in June during The Great Depression.
The Childhood Essay Research Paper It has
The Childhood Essay, Research Paper It has been noted that people consider their childhood as a nostalgic period. The childhood is one of the three main stages of life: childhood, adolescence, and adult age. Childhood might be the nostalgic period but is it the happiest? In this paper we shall demonstrate that childhood could be considered as the happiest period.
It Ain
’t Easy Being A Child Essay, Research Paper I know I haven’t been an easy child, But love for you lies underneath my whims; There is no way I could be tame or mild: I need sometimes to shout and wave my
Child Poverty Essay Research Paper CHILDREN AND
Child Poverty Essay, Research Paper CHILDREN AND POVERTY IN CANADA The purpose of this project is to discuss child poverty and child welfare practice. There is a need to critically examine the issue and situate the causes of
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Child Abuse Essay Research Paper Child AbuseWhy
Child Abuse Essay, Research Paper Child Abuse Why do some people feel the need to commit child abuse? Child abuse is something that affects many children in the U.S. It is not something to be taken lightly or to be over looked. Those people who commit abuse against children are people who are mentally unstable and are dangerous to society.
Disciplining Your Child Essay Research Paper Disciplining
Disciplining Your Child Essay, Research Paper Disciplining your child can be rough on the child but mostly on you. Disciplining your child is a hard thing to do when it comes around. The main thing parents worry about is when should I discipline, how should I discipline, and what are some things I can do instead of disciplining.
Child Abuse Essay Research Paper Smacking and
Child Abuse Essay, Research Paper Smacking and the Damage Done There has always been a fine line between discipline and child abuse. What a parent thinks is right may not always be what is healthy for a child. “The Broken Chain,” by M.F.K. fisher is an essay about a young girls history of child abuse. Though many people feel that disciplining a child physically is acceptable, abuse is abuse!
Child Labor Essay Research Paper My opinion
Child Labor Essay, Research Paper My opinion is that child labor was one of the most terrible acts in the 1800 s. I am sure that there were more than enough adults to take care of the jobs that small child had to do. I think that child labor sick and twisted and anyone who believes in it should not be considered human.
Child Abuse Essay Research Paper Child AbuseIn
Child Abuse Essay, Research Paper Child Abuse In this country the problem of child abuse is very serious. Child abuse can happen to almost any child. The abuser and the child may seem