A Recipe for Murder
In his essay A Modest Proposal Jonathan Swift adopts the persona of an economist who is making a proposal of how to make Ireland a better place by getting rid of all of the orphan and pauper children. Through his use of Juvenalian Satire, Swift uses this type of cold-hearted, money minded businessman, to make a convincing argument as he explains the benefits this proposal would bring Ireland if followed, but gives little regard to its de-humanizing, immoral and inhumane characteristics.
The tone of this essay is harsh, cold and callused. This persona exhibits little respect for the lives of children who aren t fortunate enough to be born to a family who has wealth and means to financially support them. Instead he is more concerned with the state that his country is in and how to benefit Ireland rather than to try to take care of and provide for the children as stated:
I think it is agreed by all parties that this prodigious number of children in the arms, or on the backs, or at the heels of their mothers, and frequently of their fathers, is in the present deplorable state of the kingdom a very great additional grievance: and, therefore, whoever could find a fair, cheap, and easy method of making these children sound, useful members of the commonwealth, would deserve so well of the public as to have his statue set up for a preserver of the nation.
The undeniable lack of respect for human lives is clearly evidenced by his intolerance for others who may have been less fortunate regardless of their age. His thoughts state very clearly that unless these orphans and paupers can be useful and contribute to the good of the country then they have nothing to offer and are only a nuisance.
In this essay, Swift s use of Juvenalian satire is at its peak when he starts revealing the actual proposal. Juvenalian satire has been defined by Robert Harris as follows: [A] harsher, more pointed, perhaps intolerant satire often attacks particular people, sometimes thinly disguised as fictional characters. While laughter and ridicule are still weapons with Horation satire, the Juvenalian satirist also use withering invective and a slashing attack (1). Swift s persona continues this attack on these orphan and pauper children as he describes his proposal of fattening up these children and selling them to be eaten. He has gone into much detail analyzing how much money it would take to take care of these children for a year before they could be sold to people for food as stated in the following: I have already computed the charge of nursing a beggar s child (in which list I reckon all cottagers, laborers, and four-fifths of the farmers) to be about shillings per annum, rags included: and I believe no gentleman would repine to give 10 shillings for the carcass of a good fat child (175). He continues by justifying the benefits of lessening the number of papists; increasing money for the poor; providing fine food for the rich; and would discourage domestic abuse. De-humanizing the children and referring to them as a carcass and later comparing them to cows and other animals further perpetuates the attack. Not only does he insist that the children would be most delicious, nourishing, and wholesome food (174) but he also claims that their skin could be used to make gloves and boots for fine ladies and gentleman.
Another reason his persona uses to justify this horrible act, is that he feels that many beggars would have rather been sold for food at 1 year of age instead of living like paupers and having to live through all of the misfortunes that were sure to come their way. He assumes that those people are unhappy with their lives and also makes the mistake of believing that all of those mothers would rather have the money than have the love of their children. I ask you, what kind of mother could nurse her child for a year and sell it to be slaughtered?
Works Cited
Harris, Robert. Juvenalian Satire. A Glossary of Literary Terms and a Handbook of Rhetorical Devices.
Online. 13 June 2001
uky.edu/cgi-bin/cgiwrap/ scaife/terms?File=1aglt.html&isindex=Juvenalian+Satire
Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. Literature for Composition. 5th ed. Eds. Sylvan Barnet et al. New
York: Longman, 2000. 172-178.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth 10 Essay Research Paper MACBETHCHOICE 2
Macbeth 10 Essay, Research Paper MACBETH CHOICE 2 – Compare the changes in Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as a result of the murder of King Duncan. How are they before the murder, and what happens to each of them
Creative Writing A Murder On The Eighth
Night Was Caused By An Old Mans “evil” Eye Essay, Research Paper Creative Writing: A Murder on The Eighth Night Was Caused By an Old Mans “evil” By Oscar Villa______
Refresco De Platanos Essay Research Paper Title
Refresco De Platanos Essay, Research Paper Title: spanish recipeCategory: otherDescription: spanish recipe banana platano cookingBody of paper: patricio casper & natan SomarcoLos Ingredientes: The Ingredients:1. 3 platanos 1. 3 bananas2. 1 taza de leche2. 1 cup of milk3. 1/4 taza de azucar 3. 1/4 cup of sugar4. 1/4 taza de jugo de limon 4. 1/4 cup lemon juice5. 1/2 cucharadita de vainilla 5. 1/2 tsp. of vanilla6. 8 cubitos de hielo6. 8 ice cubesLa preparacion:1.
Abortion Is It Murder Essay Research Paper
Abortion: Is it Murder? A mother kills her baby because it is unwanted, yet she is not charged with murder. Is this right? Believe it or not, this has happened more than
A Recipe For Wakeboarding Essay Research Paper
A Recipe for Wakeboarding The first step to getting up on a wakeboard is to change into your swimming suit. The second step is to go down to the dock and take the boat off of the boatlift. Once the boat is in the water, softly turn the key until the engine fires up. Now that the boat is warm, we are ready to put on our wakeboard.
Unnecessary Sacrifice Essay Research Paper Just as
Unnecessary Sacrifice Essay, Research Paper Just as we wonder how past civilizations could be so barbaric as to practice sacrifice, future generations may wonder how our society could be so barbaric as to sacrifice even the unborn. Thus abortion should not be made legal.
Murder Scene Essay Research Paper Throughout the
Murder Scene Essay, Research Paper Throughout the murder scene of Shakespeare’s Macbeth reveals his weakness but also his strong conscience. Because of Lady Macbeth’s persuasiveness, he finds the courage to kill Duncan, but he now shows his fear, sorrow, and regret for the assassination of Duncan. When Macbeth arrives in the scene after having killed Duncan, he is shaken when he thinks he hears someone because he fears being caught.
Abortion Kills Essay Research Paper Abortion Kills
Abortion Kills Essay, Research Paper Abortion Kills Children Do you consider something with a beating heart a living creature? A baby s heart forms and starts beating in the fifth week of pregnancy, therefore that would make abortion a form of murder. Murder is classified as taking another human life. The baby that is growing inside of a woman is depending on her, so when she makes the choice to end the baby s life, she is making the choice to murder another human.
Twelve Angry Men Essay Research Paper In
Twelve Angry Men Essay, Research Paper In the story “Twelve Angry Men”, Reginald Rose shows how making one’s own decisions is one very important aspect in life. He also showed that one’s decisions should
Murder At Inverness Essay Research Paper Murder
Murder At Inverness Essay, Research Paper Murder at Inverness By Aaron Klugh Last night at Inverness, Macbeth?s castle, King Duncan was stabbed to death. Macduff was the first who discovered Duncan dead in his bedroom. Along with the King, the guards were also murdered. Macbeth said he killed the guards in a fit of rage.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Is the
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Is the Death Penalty Right or Wrong? Should we be able to execute people that have been convicted of murder or should we give them a chance to break out of jail and maybe kill other people. Well the Death Penalty has been around for a while ever since the Old West use to hang people for punishment.
8 Nights Essay Research Paper 8 nightsA
8 Nights Essay, Research Paper 8 nights -A murder on the eighth night was caused by an old mans “evil” eye. An unidentified old man was murdered in his own residence last night when his butler confessed to murdering him. The butler?s motive was to get rid of the old man?s “evil” looking eye.
Oedipus Essay Research Paper The Excruciating Truth
Oedipus Essay, Research Paper The Excruciating Truth of Oedipus Oedipus is a man of integrity and passion whose goal in life was to seek the raw truth. Throughout the story, he constantly tried to obtain that
The Murder Essay Research Paper 121096 The
The Murder Essay, Research Paper 12/10/96 The Murder In the beginning of the play, Macbeth and Banquo meet three witches. The witches predict that Macbeth will be Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor, and king. They tell Banquo that his sons will become kings. At that point Macbeth was already Thane of Glamis because of his father.
Son Of Sam Essay Research Paper David
Son Of Sam Essay, Research Paper David Berkowitz in whom he?d like to call himself the ?Son of Sam?. ?Sam? was a 6,000-year-old man inhabiting the body of a neighbor, Sam Carr. David also believed that Sam ordered him to kill. He also believed that Sam Carr?s dog ordered him to kill.
Motherless Brooklyn Essay Research Paper Motherless Brooklyn
Motherless Brooklyn Essay, Research Paper Motherless Brooklyn is about crime-scene detective Lionel Essrog. Lionel becomes diagnosed with Tourette?s syndrome. He?s unable to refrain from shouting obscene words to people who pass him on the street or he compulsively tabs people on the shoulder as he passes.
Agatha Christie Essay Research Paper In the
Agatha Christie Essay, Research Paper In the murder mystery by Agatha Christie, Murder on the Orient Express, her style of writing can be described as one of Christie s best works, having an international trend, and being a genius with detective fiction. Murder on the Orient Express was a great book and should be read by all.
Lady Macbeth Essay Research Paper Lady MacbethThe
Lady Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Lady Macbeth The downfall of Macbeth was a great tragedy. He knew it was not right to kill the king, but he felt he had no other choice. He was trapped into doing wrong. Lady Macbeth gave him the evil ideas throughout the play. She was his driving force. Without her, Macbeth wouldn’t have done what he did.
Macbeth Downfall Essay Research Paper In Macbeth
Macbeth Downfall Essay, Research Paper In Macbeth there were a few factors that contributed to the degeneration of the Macbeth character. There were three factors that destroyed Macbeth. The main
William ShakespeareS Macbeth Essay Research Paper William
William Shakespeare`S Macbeth Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare differentiated Macbeth’s and Lady Macbeth’s reactions towards the murder of Duncan in the tragic play Macbeth. The plotting of the homicide, the actual assassination, and the actions after the slaughter demonstrate these responses due to the murder. “First, as I am his kinsman and his subject, / Strong both against the deed; then, his host, / …/ Not bear the knife myself.
Banquo Soliloquy Essay Research Paper John SpitzerEnglishIn
Banquo Soliloquy Essay, Research Paper John Spitzer English In Macbeth, a play by William Shakespeare, Banquo’s soliloquy at the beginning of the third act explains some of his present feeling towards Macbeth. He believes that Macbeth killed to become the King of Scotland. He explains that he is the one who will start a chain of kings, not Macbeth.
Mr Murder Essay Essay Research Paper MR
Mr Murder Essay Essay, Research Paper MR. MURDER ESSAY For everyone life is filled with mystery, suspense and facing the unknown. In Dean Koontz s book Mr. Murder he does just those things for the main character in the book. He helps us understand that those kinds if things can happen to us.
An Exposition On Peanut Butter Cookies Essay
, Research Paper Have you ever tried to bake peanut butter cookies, and for some reason they were a complete flap because they were dry and crunchy, too moist and crumbly, or perhaps they had a terrible taste? Well, I have discovered this cool new recipe and I have never failed at making them. Have no fear, the ultimate peanut butter cookie recipe is hear.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper The Destruction of
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper The Destruction of Macbeth Three factors that are at work to destroy Macbeth are the flaws in his own character, the forces of evil of the Devil represented by the Tree Weird Sisters, and Lady
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper In Sophocles 2
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper In Sophocles? Oedipus Rex, dramatic irony is often present in Oedipus? long speeches. Oedipus constantly sees things incorrectly, and is in denial that he
Hamlet Essay Research Paper There are many
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper There are many reasons why one would think that Queen Gertrude is clueless about the murder of King Hamlet, yet others think she was involved in the murder. People have their own opinions on this but I believe that Queen Gertrude had an idea about the murder. There are many reasons and facts contributing to my opinion on this.
Creative Writing Exercise Essay Research Paper 1
Creative Writing Exercise Essay, Research Paper 1. How does one commit a successful murder? To commit a successful murder you first must have a motive. Then after you have established a motive you must create a plan of attack. You need to come up with a way in which you are going to go about committing this crime.
Designer Comparision Essay Research Paper Armin Hofmann
Designer Comparision Essay, Research Paper Armin Hofmann s effect and significance as a Swiss designer included published the Graphic design manual: principals and practice in 1965. This book became a reference for many young designers and thus created a sort of design recipe that could be followed and repeated by others.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My view on
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My view on the abortion is pro-choice so I will debate the issue from the pro-life point of view. Abortion is in a word: murder. There is no way around it , people that have abortions are committing a crime. If one was killing a person who could defend themselves they would go to jail but the people who have abortions just get continue on with their sinful lives.
Blood In Macbeth Essay Research Paper The
Blood In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper The Symbolism of Blood in Macbeth The Symbol of Blood in Macbeth Blood is known to represent most often injury and death, but also life. Blood is an essential part of life, and without blood, we could not live. This is common knowledge, and because of this, when Shakespeare uses the symbol of blood to represent treason, murder, and death, it is easily understood and fits in perfectly with the ideas we have of blood.