Engel V. Vitale Essay, Research Paper
Engel v Vitale
The Supreme Court case, Engel v. Vitale, was an extremely controversial case that directly dealt with the First Amendment. This Supreme Court case established a separation of church and state. Engel v. Vitale was such an extremely controversial case that it has opened the doorway for other cases dealing with church and state.
Every morning in New Hyde Park School, in New York, students would recite “Almighty God, we acknowledge our dependence of Thee, and we beg Thy blessing upon us, our parents, our teachers and our country (Morgan 634).” A school body called the New York State Regent created this recited prayer, and said that pupils had the choice to remain silent during the prayer if they wanted to (Chandler 84). Mr. Engel and four other families thought the prayer to be offensive, and appealed their case to the Supreme Court in 1962 (Auble 1).
Engel, along with the other families, took one side of the argument. They believed that by reciting the short Regents’ prayer they were partaking in a religious activity and therefore breaking the line between church and state. They also questioned why their tax money was used to pay teachers to lead the class in school prayer. Another point that they presented to the Supreme Court was that the words in the prayer “Almighty God,” was recognizing and singling out a specific religion. These families were Jewish, Atheist, Ethical Culture Society and Unitarian and by saying these words the families believed that they were going against their own religions (Auble 1-2). The Engels’ sincerely believed that their First Amendment rights were being denied. The Constitution states in this amendment that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof” The act of reciting the short prayer clearly went against their First Amendment rights (Engel 1).
Vitale, representing the school board, presented the other side of the issue. This side stressed that students could choose not to participate in the reading of the prayer if they so desired and could leave the room or remain silent, making the prayer legal in the school. In direct contrast with the Engel approach, this side felt that the brief prayer did not in any way pick out one single religion (Auble 2). Another tactic that the opposing side took was by saying that religion has always played a key role in our society, from the engraving on our coins to our Pledge of Allegiance (Issue 2).
Six Justices voted the recited prayer to be unconstitutional and one Justice voted that the Regents’ prayer was constitutional. Justice Black delivered the opinion of the court for the case Engel v. Vitale. Justice Black addressed that the option to remain silent or leave the room was irrelevant to the case, Engel v. Vitale (Morgan 634). He further stated that the “State of New York has adopted a practice wholly inconsistent with the Establishment Clause (Lee 1).”
The case, Engel v. Vitale, ended with a 6-1 Supreme Court decision in 1962. Justice Stewart was the only dissenting opinion. He believed that since the recited prayer was voluntary, it did not favor a specific religion (Morgan 634). He also stated that “To deny students the recitation of the prayer is also denying them the opportunity of sharing the spiritual heritage of our nation.” Justice Douglas represented the majority opinion of the Supreme Court. He found that the recitation of the prayer was unconstitutional for the fact that its funds were paid by the government. He went further to explain this by saying that the salaries of the teachers, who were the leaders of the prayer, were paid by taxes, which was paid by the government. He felt that the government should have no part in paying for religious exercise (Auble 2).
The final decision of Engel v. Vitale had a considerably huge impact. Many schools followed the new law, while others found loopholes in the system and carried on with prayer in schools. Even though the court felt that the government involvement in religious practices to be offensive much of America did not. Newspapers were filled with angry letters about the decision, accusing our country and our court of not believing in God. Even some former Presidents objected to the final Supreme Court decision (Auble 2). The biggest impact that Engel v. Vitale brought about was that it was the beginning of numerous decisions concerning religion in public schools in America (Morgan 634). Also the issue of prayer in school is still debated today.
Work Cited
Auble, Kelli. “Engel V. Vitale.” corbett.k12.or.us/highschool/activities/ussc/kelli%20auble.htm (15Dec. 1998).
Chandler, Ralph, and Enslen, Richard, and Renstrom, Peter. “Engel V. Vitale.” The Constitutional Law Dictionary. California: ABC-CLIO, 1985.
“Engel V. Vitale.” http”//www.pbs/jefferson/enlight/prayer.htm#back (15 Dec. 1998).
Lee, Jenny J. “1962 Engel V. Vitale.” gseis.uncla.edu/courses/ed191.html (15 Dec 1998).
Morgan, Richard E. “Engel V. Vitale.” Encyclopedia of the American Constitution. New York: Macmillan, 1986.
Другие работы по теме:
Traditions In American Culture Essay Research Paper
Many traditions had developed within American culture that breached this wall of separation. For example, our coins have “In God We Trust” printed into them, The Pledge of Allegiance still contains the phrase “under God,” and many of our governmental ceremonies have prayer as their opening activity. For years, many public school districts mandated that the school day begin with some sort of prayer.
Zeus And Hera Essay Research Paper Many
Zeus And Hera Essay, Research Paper Many traditions had developed within American culture that breached this wall of separation. For example, our coins have "In God We Trust" printed into
To Pray Or Not To Pray Essay
, Research Paper To Pray or Not to Pray “The trend of taking God and moral teaching out of schools is a diabolical scheme,” declared the Reverend Billy Graham soon after the Engel versus Vitale and
Engel Vs Vitale Essay Research Paper In
Engel Vs. Vitale Essay, Research Paper In 1962 the case of Engel vs. Vitale came about. At first the government stated that a non-God believing person or a person of a different culture could be except from saying the prayer. The morning prayer was done after the pledging of the flag. The prayer was such; ” Almighty God, we acknowledge our dependency upon thee, and we beg Thy blessings upon us, our parents, our teachers, nd our country”.
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Communism Essay Research Paper Red Star
Communism Essay, Research Paper * Red Star * Communism is an ideal society that is unrealistic for humans to maintain. In this system major resources and means of production are owned by the community rather than by individuals. The society is without money, without a state, without property and without social classes.
Should A Moment Of Silence Be Legal
In Public Schools Essay, Research Paper In 1962 the Supreme Court decided that public schools did not have the power to authorize school prayer. This decision made public school in the U.S. more atheistic than many European nations. For example, crosses still hang on the classroom walls in Poland, and the Ten Commandments are displayed in Hungary.
Muscular Dystrophy 2 Essay Research Paper What
Muscular Dystrophy 2 Essay, Research Paper What is Muscular Dystrophy? The muscular dystrophies are a heterogeneous group of genetic musclular diseases, which have three features in common: they are hereditary, they are progressive (ie get worse over time) and each produces a characteristic selective pattern of weakness of muscle groups. (Engel 1994)
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
The Establishment Clause And Its Effect On
The Role Of Religion In American Society Essay, Research Paper The United States is a nation that has been built on a foundation of religious freedom. Since the seventeenth century, people have come to the North American continent to
Capitalism And Communism Essay Research Paper Capitalism
Capitalism And Communism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism and Communism are two totally different economic systems. Capitalism is a much better economic system than Communism. Capitalism is an economic system characterized by freedom of the market and is the economic system where you do not have freedom because the government will make most of your decisions for you.
Banning Prayer In Schools Essay Research Paper
Banning Prayer in Schools When schools first opened hundreds of years ago prayer was always enforced, and the Bible was the only book most schools had to read. Our first constitutional right states that we have the right to freedom of speech and freedom of religion, and as our right the government can not tell us when it is appropriate to pray.
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Legalize Moral Values Essay Research Paper Many
Legalize Moral Values Essay, Research Paper Many children in today’s society grow up with little or no more values at all, these children are the sons and daughters of the so called, “Generation X.” This maybe the root of America’s problems with our youth. In the mid sixties religion was taken out of our school systems, and in 1962, the Supreme Court decided that public schools did not have the power to authorize school prayer (Marks 26).
The Contemporary Debate Over Constitutional Interpretation Essay
, Research Paper The debate over the role of the judiciary in the government has been going on for a long time. Some say that the Supreme Court has overstepped the boundaries that it is to operate by, while others believe that much of the Constitution was written in such a way that it needs to be interpreted according to the situations that have arisen in today’s society.
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay Research Paper The
Industrial Revolution DBQ Essay, Research Paper The impact of the Industrial Revolution was a positive experience for some, but it was a great difficulty for others. Because of the demands for reform and protection for workers arose, government and unions began to take place. That was how the evils of the Industrial Revolution addressed in England in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
Christian And Byzantine Art Essay Research Paper
Early Christian and Byzantine art started after Jesus? death in the first century ranging and ending to the fourth century AD. The art produced during this period was secretive because Christianity was not a formal religion but as a cult; the Romans and rest of Europe persecuted Christians so the artist disguised their work with symbols and hints of Christian aspects.
Constitution Essay Research Paper Three documents such
Constitution Essay, Research Paper Three documents such as The Constitution of the United States, Thomas Malthus?s Essay on the Principle of Population, and Karl Marx?s and Friedrich Engel?s Communist Manifesto all possess many similarities, yet there are also differences. The intentions of the authors are similar, due to the times these documents were written, and the historical contexts are a reflection of their worlds around them.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
How Has Religion Affected History And Literature
? Essay, Research Paper ?And for the support of this declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of Divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes and our sacred honor.? With these words, penned by the eminent political scientist Thomas Jefferson, the struggling colonies known as the United States proclaimed their independence from Great Britain and began an adventure that would develop this small nation into a world superpower.
Bulimia Nervosa Essay Research Paper Bulimia NervosaJune
Bulimia Nervosa Essay, Research Paper Bulimia Nervosa June Engel (1993), found that today s society s idealization of thinness is producing an alarming increase in eating disorders especially among young women. The never-ending efforts to lose weight and conform to the media image of an ideal shape are leading more and more young people to diet at the cost of health.
Cocksucker Essay Research Paper blah blah cock
Cocksucker Essay, Research Paper blah blah cock blah oversial widespread issue today is the right to have prayer in public schools. The proposed amendment reads: To secure the people s right to acknowledge God according to the dictates of conscience. The people s rights to pray and to recognize their belief, heritage or traditions on public property, shall not be infringed.
Suspending Christ From The School System Essay
, Research Paper Suspending Christ from the School System I believe there is a connection between no prayer in our school system and its inevitable fall from grace. Ever since the 1962 judgement Engel v Vitale our school system has deteriorated. The judgment was between a group of parents who sued a New York public school district for requiring students to begin each school day by reciting a nondenominational prayer.
Byzantine Architecture Essay Research Paper Byzantine ArchitectureThe
Byzantine Architecture Essay, Research Paper Byzantine Architecture The architecture of the Byzantine Empire was based on the great legacy of Roman formal and technical achievements. Constantinople had been purposely founded as the Christian counterpart and successor to the leadership of the old pagan city of Rome.
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Religious Holidays Essay Research Paper Questioning the
Religious Holidays Essay, Research Paper Questioning the Constitutionality of Celebrating Religious Holidays at Public Expense. It is unconstitutional for local, state or federalgovernments to favor one religion over another? Government can show favoritism toward religion bydisplaying religious symbols in public placesat taxpayer expense, by sponsoring events like Christmasconcerts, caroling, or by supporting the teaching ofreligious ideas.
Show Carefully How A Market Demand Curve
Can Be Derived From Individuals? Indifference Maps And Budg Essay, Research Paper I will split the answer to this question into four distinct parts. Firstly I will show how indifference curves and budget constraints can
Principles In Prayer Essay Research Paper Principles
Principles In Prayer Essay, Research Paper Principles in Prayer There is a growing trend in America today that something drastically needs to be changed about our school system. The public is scared to send their children to a place where they could potentially be shot, stabbed, beaten, or be subjected to drugs on any given day.