, Research Paper
?Spotted Horses? and ?Mule in the Yard? are two short stories by William Faulkner that deal with comedic animal chases. Although both provide entertaining examples of Faulkner?s work in very similar settings, on the scale of literary value, ?Spotted Horses? rises above ?Mule in the Yard? in depth and insight. This superiority is result of both it?s narrative style and character development, which causes ?Spotted Horses? to produce an overall more powerful effect than ?Mule in the Yard?.
The most notable and important difference between the two stories is the contrasting narrative style. In ?Spotted Horses?, the story is told in first person point of view by a narrator who observes the major events of the story but is involved in only a minor fashion. His narration provides the audience with a look at the town and it?s inhabitants through the eyes of someone living in the county of Mississippi. This adds a realistic dimension to the image of the story. It is also through this narrative style that Faulkner weaves humor into ?Spotted Horses?. The narrator shows the story in a comic light simply through his words right from the introductory paragraph. For example, the audience is introduced immediately with a casual ?Yes, sir. Flem Snopes has filled that whole country full of spotted horses. You can hear folks running them all day and night, whooping and hollering, and the horses running back and forth across those little wooden bridges ever now and then kind of like thunder.? (349) In contrast, ?Mule in the Yard? is told in the objective viewpoint. With this type of information, the reader can only observe what is seen and heard. Therefore, it follows that the reader must infer everything about the characters and their motivations from only their actions and dialogue. Faulkner weaves humor into the story through the distinct dialogue and ironic situations that occur in ?Mule in the Yard?. For example, in the opening scene, Mrs. Hait and old Het are chasing a mule out of their yard. If the reader imagines the scene that Faulkner writes about with ??old Het?waving a shopping bag. [Yelling] ?Hoo!? [As] Mrs. Hait whirled. Again she skidded savagely on the greasy planks as she and the mule rushed parallel with one another?? (364), there is definitely humor within it. Yet, the humor is not as effective as it is in ?Spotted Horses? where it is a part of the entire tone of the story, not only in the situations but also with the interior involvement of the narrator and his interaction with the characters.
Because the narrator in ?Spotted Horses? is experiencing the scene where the action is taking place, the reader receives a richer understanding of the characters. It is almost as if the reader might know the characters personally. Importantly, ?Spotted Horses? deals with several more characters than ?Mule in the Yard?, which only has three significant characters. These characters are defined only by their actions through the objective narration. Mrs. Hait is described as an independent woman who wears ?a calico wrapper and a sweater coat, and a man?s felt hat which they knew had belonged to her ten years? dead husband? (364) and brand new high mans shoes with buttons and ?toes like tulip bulbs.? (364) The audience can only infer that she does not fear the mule based on her several confrontations with him as well as the way in which she refers to it as ?Them sons of bitches?. (364) The author can not tell the audience why she wears what she does or why she has such a motivation to get rid of the mule besides that he is a nuisance, and there is not enough development in the story to infer definitely what Faulkner intends. This is also seen in the character of old Het, who is described as a tall gangly old black woman personified by a stereotypical southern black dialect. This is seen as she addresses Mr. Snopes in town one day. She says to him, ?Miz Mannie gimme dis to give you, I wuz just on de way to de sto whar you stay at.? (370) The audience is left very little to draw upon concerning the characters and their motivations and overall purpose in the story. As a result, the few characters in ?Mule in the Yard? are significantly lesser personages than those that exist in ?Spotted Horses?.
This different character development can be seen in examination of the character that the two stories have in common, I.O. Snopes. In ?Mule in the Yard?, the objective narrator shows us I.O. Snopes by describing him as ?a squat, pasty man perennially tieless and with a stained, harried expression? (365) who buys unruly mules from Memphis and brings them to the town where Mrs. Hait and old Het live, where they constantly get loose. While this description serves it?s purpose of description and a small development of I.O. Snopes, the version through the eyes of the narrator in ?Spotted Horses? is witness to a more subtle but more realistic I.O. Snopes. In ?Spotted Horses?, the narrator places Snopes in Varner?s with his back against the wall, his hair parted, in conversation with his cousin and a few other townsmen. The narrator continues the story as ?I.O. cackled, like a hen, slapping his legs with both hands. ?You boys might just as well quit trying to get ahead of Flem.? He said.? (361) Direct observation of I.O. Snopes reveals a broader type of character than does the one detailed in ?Mule in the Yard?. The development is particularly effective in ?Spotted Horses? because there are a great many characters for a short story, and through their characteristic role in the scheme of the narrator, certain characters become individuals more than others. This is because the reader views the story through the mind of someone who presumably is familiar with the situation and personages in the story, and the characters seem to be more realizable in certain memorable actions which define them in a subtle way. One example is Henry Armstid; a domineering selfish man who has no respect or regard it seems for his wife who he constantly tells to ??Git on back to that wagon like I told you.?? (352) He becomes more than a mere name. This is also true for Mrs. Littlejohn. She begins as a small observer of the events but becomes a major stabilizer as she takes a stand against a wild horse with a washboard, cares for the injured Mr. Armstid, comforts Mrs. Armstid, and then gives Mrs. Armstid advice on how to get her money back. The narrator of ?Spotted Horses? brings an attitude of ?regularness? to the story because he tends to look upon these characters as regular folks, yet finds the humor as well as the tragic within them. This is more than ?Mule in the Yard? can accomplish with its more simplistic basis.
Both ?Spotted Horses? and ?Mule in the Yard? are very entertaining stories by William Faulkner. Despite their common theme of animal chase, setting, and character, a more powerful story is found within ?Spotted Horses?. While ?Mule in the Yard? is well written and full of comedy, it does not delve as deeply as ?Spotted Horses? does. ?Spotted Horses? proves broader in scope due to it?s in depth narration style which provides particularly effective humor and development of characters.
Другие работы по теме:
A Character Analysis of William Faulkner's "A Rose For Emily"
In William Faulkner's short story "A Rose For Emily" he had described Emily using five adjectives. These five adjectives were identified in Part IV of his story. "Thus she passed from generation to generation - dear, inescapable, impervious, tranquil, and
Faulkner And Mccarthy
– Styles Essay, Research Paper William Faulkner and Cormac McCarthy are known for their unusual, yet honest, styles of writing. Using a variety of sentence structure, vocabulary, and syntax, the two authors allow readers to explore deeper into the true meanings behind the well-told story lines. In Faulkner s The Unvanquished and McCarthy s All the Pretty Horses, these techniques, which parallel and contrast each other, are very apparent and convey messages to the reader that help to express the passage of boyhood into manhood.
Things Are Not What They Seem Essay
, Research Paper Things Are Not Always What They Seem William Faulkner s short story A Rose for Emily centers around Miss Emily and what the townspeople think of Miss Emily. One of the themes for A Rose for Emily is appearance versus reality. This theme of appearance versus reality can be seen through what the townspeople think of Miss Emily and by the actions taken by Miss Emily.
Narrator Description Essay Research Paper What is
Narrator Description Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be
In Memory Of Emily Grierson Essay Research
Paper In the short story A Rose for Emily, (1930) William Faulkner presents Miss Emily s instable state of mind through a missed sequence of events. Faulkner arranges the story in fractured time and then introduces characters who contribute to the development of Miss Emily s personality. The theme of isolation is also presented by Faulkner s descriptive words and symbolic images.
Narrator Essay Research Paper What is narrator
Narrator Essay, Research Paper What is narrator? Narrator is the voice the author creates to tell the story. The possible ways of telling a story are many, and more than one way can be worked into a single story. Conventionally, the various narrators that storytellers draw upon can be grouped into four broad groups: the third-person narrator, the first-person narrator, the omniscient narrator and the witness narrator.
Critique On A Rose For Emily Essay
, Research Paper “A Rose for Emily is a very popular short story because of its, style , climax, and plot. The author, William Faulkner, was a “Southern” writer from Oxford, Mississippi. FAulkner bases this story on the tale of Oxford’s aristrocratic ” Miss Mary ” Neilson. She married Captain jack Hume, the charming yankee foreman of a street-paving crew, over her family’s shocked protests.
Letting Go Essay Research Paper Letting GoMany
Letting Go Essay, Research Paper Letting Go Many people hate to let things go. People find security and comfort in their possessions and the company they keep. If all this is ripped away from a person, it can
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper In William
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper In William Faulkner’s Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech, he says, “He writes not of love but of lust, of defeats in which nobody loses anything of value, and victories without hope and worst of all, without pity or compassion.” William Faulkner is referring to “He” as the typical writer today.
Barn Burning By Faulkner Essay Research Paper
In William Faulkner?s ?Barn Burning,? the main character is Colonel Sartoris Snopes, or ?Sarty? for short. This young boy is torn between loyalty to his father and morality, and this story deals with that struggle.
William FaulknerS A Rose For Emily
” Essay, Research Paper William Faulkner?s first published story was ?A Rose for Emily. He wrote many stories after this but one particular that can be compared to this story is a Light in August. Throughout both of these works Faulkner uses his own events from his home in Mississippi and focuses on the themes relating to the ruins of the Deep South in the post- Civil War era.
The Psychosis Of Emily Grierson In William
Faulkner’S “A Rose For Emily” Essay, Research Paper Through the use of third person point of view and elaborate, repetitive foreshadowing, William Faulkner describes how numerous elements contributed to Miss Emily’s deranged behavior in the short story, “A Rose for Emily.” Not only does Faulkner imply paternal oppression, but there is also a clear indication of insanity that is an inherent pattern in the Grierson family.
The Styles And Themes Of Willi Essay
, Research Paper One of the greatest writers of the 20th century is William Faulkner. He was born and raised in the southern state of Mississippi which greatly influenced his style of writing. Faulkner liked to use a variety of styles and themes in his works. In one of his most famous books, As I Lay Dying, he uses streams of consciousness, while in, A Rose for Emily, his style and theme is very morbid and grotesque.
A Perspective Look At 2
A Perspective Look At “A Rose For Emily” Essay, Research Paper Outline Thesis: As any reader can see, ?A Rose for Emily? is one of the most authentic short stories by Faulkner. His use of characterization, narration, foreshadowing, and symbolism are four key factors to why Faulkner?s work is idealistic to all readers.
The Sound And The Fury By William
Faulkner 1929 Essay, Research Paper “They took the flag out, and they were hitting. Then they put the flag back and they went to the table, and he hit and the other hit. Then they went on, and I went along
William Faulkners
“As I Lay Dying” Essay, Research Paper The main purpose for most of William Faulkner?s novel, As I Lay Dying, is to bury their beloved mother and wife, Addie Bundren, in a town called Jefferson, which is a very long and strenuous trip for them to make. The statement death shapes life perfectly describes this chain of events.
The Barn Burning Blues Essay Research Paper
William Faulkner’s short story, “Barn Burning”, is about a family’s struggle created by their father. the main character and father, Abner Snopes, is a self-ritous “no-good” who
O Henry Essay Research Paper O Henry
O. Henry Essay, Research Paper O. Henry was the pen name for William Sydney Porter an American short story writer. Porter was born on September 11, 1862, in Greensboro, North Carolina, the son of Dr. Algernon Sidney and Mary Jane Virginia Porter. When Porter was three, his mother died, and his father, his brother, and he moved into the house of his grandmother and his Aunt.
A Roses For Emily Essay Research Paper
william faulkner’s “A Rose For Emily’, and Charlotte Gilman’s “A Yellow Wall paper” are alike in many ways. The two women are in similar situations, both are violated by
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper The Southern
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper The Southern Grown Faulkner William Cuthbert Falkner was born on September 25, 1897 in New Albany, Mississippi. He was the eldest of four brothers from Murry and Maud Butler Falkner (later in his life he restored the “u” to the family name). As a child William always had a strong interest in the arts.
William Faulkner Literature Giant Essay Research Paper
William Faulkner: Literature Giant ?The man himself never stood taller than five feet, six inches tall, but in the realm of American literature, William Faulkner was a giant? (?Faulkner,? American 101). The background and early years of Faulkner?s life sets the stage for his outstanding success in literature.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper Faulkner William
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper Faulkner, William (1897-1962), American novelist, known for his epic portrayal, in some 20 novels, of the tragic conflict between the old and the new South. Faulkner’s complex plots and narrative style alienated many readers of his early works, but he was recognized later as one of the greatest American writers.
WILLIAM FAULKNER Essay Research Paper American writer
WILLIAM FAULKNER Essay, Research Paper American writer, William Cuthbert Faulkner, poet, and novelist has a style all his own. Varying talent from poetry to novels, critics can tell his style is different from the average writer. William?s style is easily identified by his repetition of words to his run on sentences.
Spotted Horses Vs Mule In The Yard
Essay, Research Paper Spotted Horses Vs. Mule in the Yard William Faulkner wrote two short stories, which are alike in many aspects. Spotted Horses and Mule in the Yard are short stories that both involve comic animal chases and financial transactions. Even though the stories are written by the same author, have similar characteristics, and share similar plot features, they are entirely different stories.
A Rose For Emily Critical Analysis Essay
, Research Paper William Faulkner, a writer brought up in the South, displayed the upbringing and lifestyles of people in a certain town. The theme revolved around the life of a lady name Emily Grierson. She is a southern woman, whose failed attempt at life is kept secret from her town until her death. By explaining her upbringing by a stern father, her midlife climax and her slow journey through a secluded life to her death, Faulkner shows how clinging on to tradition by Emily’s father ruined her life.
Pauls Case And Barn Burning Essay Research
Paper The stories ?Barn Burning? written by William Faulkner and ?Paul?s Case? written by Willa Cather both have two separate characters with very similar troubles. Each has a uniquely sad narrative. ?Barn Burning? is a sad
A Rose Essay Research Paper A Rose
A Rose Essay, Research Paper A Rose In the 1930’s people still thrive on gossip, particularly in a small town. People are overly curious and cruel at times, especially when it comes to Emily Grierson’s mental disorder. In “ A Rose for Emily,” William Faulkner traces Miss Emily’s increasing dementia and foreshadows the surprise ending.
Comparing William Faulkner
’s Two Short Stories, A Rose For Emily And Barn Burning Essay, Research Paper Symbolism If we compare William Faulkner s two short stories, A Rose for Emily and Barn Burning , he structures the plots of these two stories differently. However, both of the stories note the effect of a father s teaching, and in both the protagonists Miss Emily and Sarty make their own decisions about their lives.
Analysis Of Faulkner Short Stories Essay Research
Paper Response to the Faulkner Short Stories In each of these stories, Faulkner communicates to the reader through very strange characters. In “Was”, we hear of a story that basically stems around a runaway slave. The two Uncles are very stereotypical. The other owner was also very stereotypical. Basically, in this story, the white men are trying to apprehend a slave that has run off to see his girl.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper Biography on
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper Biography on William Faulkner William Faulkner was born in New Albany, Mississippi on September 25, 1897 and then moved to Oxford, Mississippi with his family at the age of 5. Most of the novels written by William Faulkner take place in the area in which he himself was born and raised.
Life And Style Of William Faulkner Essay
, Research Paper The Life and Style of William Faulkner William Faulkner was a writer in the early to mid 1900?s. Faulkner was born into a life of a well-known family and a somewhat rich family. Faulkner also has a very unique style and this paper will show his unique style in the story ?A Rose for Emily.?
Rose For Emily Essay Research Paper Analysis
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Analysis of ?A Rose for Emily? In William Faulkner?s short story, ?A Rose for Emily,? obsession plays a key role in the developing personality of the protagonist, Emily Grierson. Because Emily was
William Faulkner 2 Essay Research Paper William
William Faulkner 2 Essay, Research Paper William Faulkner William Faulkner is one of America s most talked about writers and his work should be included in any literary canon for several reasons. After reading a few of his short stories, it becomes clear that Faulkner s works have uniqueness to them. One of the qualities that make William Faulkner s writings different is his close connection with the South.