Bernard Shaw?S Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper
An interpretation of Class Relations in Pygmalion by, Bernard Shaw
In Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion, there is a distinct variance in class relations and the way that early 20th century Britains were perceived as being different by their speech, money, wealth, style, manners, and appearance. Being a lady or a gentleman was an acquired status desirable among most of London’s society. However, in Pygmalion, Shaw tells a story about the transition of a homeless young woman with the aspiration to become a respected lady.
Eliza Doolittle is an 18 or 19 year-old young women, making a living from selling old flowers on the streets. When she comes across a rude Professor, named Henry Higgins, he sarcastically offers her to “learn how to speak beautifully, like a lady in a florist’s shop…..at the end of six months you shall go to Buckingham palace in a carriage, beautifully dressed.” This is what he proposes to Eliza when she comes to ask for English lessons from the Professor. He then makes a bet with another man, Colonel Pickering, who says he will pay for her new clothes and English lessons, if Higgins can make a lady out of her in six months. The deal is made, and Eliza is immediately washed up and put into new, clean clothes. The play begins like this, which sets the plot for the rest of the story.
An example of modern day class relations with speech can be described by linguistic anthropologists, and in an article called “Suite for Ebony and Phonics” by John R. Rickford. In this article, he discusses the African-American speech Ebonics, and the negative impact it has across America. Being called “lazy English,” “bastardized English,” and “poor grammar,” it seems to be the same thing that was going on in England during the time Pygmalion was written. I’m sure that if we were to ask Henry Higgins if that is what he thought about the way Eliza spoke he would whole-heartedly agree. However, the poor English that Eliza spoke was never considered as becoming a legal language in England.
The play begins off on a rainy night on the streets, with a lady and her daughter waiting for a cab. In this first act, Eliza asks them to buy a flower from her, with the response from the daughter, “Do nothing of the sort, mother. The idea!” When the mother gives her some change, the daughter again exclaims, “Make her give you the change. These things are only a penny a bunch … ……sixpence thrown away! Really, mamma, you might have spared Freddy that.” She then retreats disgusted and unable to believe that her mother had actually given in to the poor flower girl. Another example is when Eliza goes to get in the taxi and the driver is trying to keep her out, assuming that she has no money to pay for the ride.
When Higgins meets Eliza, he comes across as very rude, saying:
“Woman; cease the detestable boohooing instantly; or else seek the shelter of some other place of worship……A woman who utters such depressing and disgusting sounds has no right to be anywhere – no right to live…. this creature with her kerbstone English: the English that will keep her in the gutter till the end of her days…Well sir, in three months I could pass that girl off as a duchess at an ambassador’s garden party…..”
He then goes on to call her names like “squashed cabbage leaf” ; “disgrace to the noble architecture of these columns” and an “incarnate insult to the English language”. With obviously no respect for the poor girl, he would say anything that he wants to her, with no spare to her feelings at all.
An example related to this scenario can be compared to “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack”, by Peggy McIntosh. In this article, she describes how gender, race and sexual preference are a problem in America. In this case, however, it is more a subcultural problem, but it is related to the way classes differ. She discusses how white people, males particularly, have “skin color that was an asset for any move one was educated to want to make”. In her case, she thinks that most people don’t realize that they are segregating against minorities or sex.
White people have more of an advantage in our society, but it is kept as something people do not discuss, as is male advantage, with the myth that “democratic choice is equally available to all.” Oppressiveness in the United States seems to be unconscious, therefore, it is hard to put an end to it. Like in Pygmalion, class relations were part of their culture, and poor people were always looked down upon.
Even though you may expect such a well-educated man such as Higgins to be a gentleman, he is far from it. He believes that how you treated someone is not important as long as you treat everyone equally. His great secret is not to have good or bad manners but to have the same manner as all human souls. To behave as if you were in Heaven, with no third or first class, and where one soul is as good as the next, with no recognition of any personal assets. He is consistently rude to many, but is also well mannered at parties and in good times.
Mrs. Pearce, his maid, treats the girl like scum when she first meets her, saying, “It’s no use talking to her like that, Mr. Higgins: she doesn’t understand you…. you must call me Mrs. Pearce not missus…..” Also, when Mrs. Pearce is showing her the bathroom, Eliza has no clue what the bath is for. “You know you can’t be a nice girl inside if you’re a dirty slut outside. ”
In the part of the play when Eliza, Mrs. Higgins and Henry meet with Mrs. , Mr. and Miss Eynsford Hill, Higgins is unwillingly forced to have tea with them. Even though the Eynsford Hill’s have no money left, and have nothing except their manners and appearance, they still act as if they are high class. However, Henry still rolls his eyes towards them. When Eliza meets with them, she tells stories that seem unbelievable to them, and uses language that they have never heard of. They all think she is just trendy and up to par on the new small talk, using the words “not bloody likely” which is just as bad as saying f–k in today’s modern day language. Mrs. Eynsford Hill is shocked, but her daughter, Clara thinks its modern, “delightful and quite innocent.”
Nonetheless, at this time, Mrs. Higgins decides that Eliza is still not presentable to the upper class of society to pass as a lady. She “gives herself away with every sentence that she stutters”, but after the six months of lessons, she is ready for the party, and passes as a lady with flying colors.
In the article, “Women, Minorities, and Indigenous Peoples: Universalism and Cultural Relativity” by Carole Nagengast, she discusses cultural relativity and how universalism is desired throughout the world. She describes how these three groups are deprived of civil and political rights. This relates to Pygmalion because she describes how these ‘minorities’ have less rights than white males with an education. Also, it describes how freedom among women is inappropiate to Eastern and Southern cultures.
Higgins remains to treat Eliza with no respect throughout the entire play, no matter who is around. In Act V, he “treats a flower girl as duchess”, and justifies it as “ the question is not whether I treat you rudely, but whether you ever heard me treat anyone else better.” Eliza doesn’t answer the question but we all know that he has treated others better than Eliza. At parties, for example, Higgins is a gentleman to the hosts and other guests, but still treats Eliza as his “experiment”. Higgins could never see the new Eliza, he just saw her as the dirty little flower girl, much like how an author never sees his work as finished, he could not view her as a lady or duchess. He has childish tendencies and immature actions that give him a limited outlook.
The entire play is based upon the goal to prove that upper class is only a matter of saying the right things, the right way, wearing the right clothes, and knowing the right people. If one has a flaw in any one of these areas, they would be automatically looked down upon by others. This was how early 20th century Europe was. If you didn’t have money, and did not talk right, or heaven forbid, no money at all, you were nothing but a worthless soul that could have been kept in the sewers with the rats. Aristocrats ran society, and they had no need for the homeless and poor.
In relating this subject to anthropology, there are a lot of points that can be made between the comparison of class relations and other issues similar to it. The study of Ebonics is a very good comparison to Pygmalion, and the way that someone speaks can effect how other people view them. Even though some think it is not an issue today, it can still be compared to early 20th century England and the way upper class looked down upon others. In the same way, many people do look down upon people speaking the too familiar sound of Ebonics.
597
McIntosh, Peggy. “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack.” Applying Anthropology. Aaron Podelefsky and Peter J. Brown. California: Mayfield. 217-220.
Nagengast, Carole. “Women, Minorities, and Indigenous Peoples: Universalism and Cultural Relativity.” Applying Anthropology. Aaron Podelefsky and Peter J. Brown. California: Mayfield. 340-352.
Rickford, John R.. “Suite for Ebony and Phonics.” Applying Anthropology. Aaron Podelefsky and Peter J. Brown. California: Mayfield. 176-180.
Shaw, Bernard. Pygmalion. England: Penguin, 1913.
Другие работы по теме:
George Bernard Shaw Essay Research Paper George
George Bernard Shaw Essay, Research Paper George Bernard Shaw was an iconoclastic writer and speaker who embraced many subjects that his peers had not yet dared to embrace. He is considered to be the best and most significant playwright since William Shakespeare. His life and career were focused mainly on social reform.
How The Blues Have Affected Modern Poetry
Essay, Research Paper Never Get Outta These Blues Alive How the Blues Have Affected Modern Poetry a term paper by: Bernard Dolan Blues Performers What are the Blues?
The Natural Essay Research Paper The Natural
The Natural Essay, Research Paper The Natural, written by Bernard Malamud starts out with Roy, an aspiring baseball player on a train with his scout, Sam. Roy is still in his younger years, while Sam is an old scout who has slowed down over the years. On the train Sam notices that a well-known sportswriter, Max Mercy, is aboard, along with Walter Whambold, a superstar ball player, so he introduces Roy to them.
Deathofasalesman Essay Research Paper Through the character
Deathofasalesman Essay, Research Paper Through the character Charley, Arthur Miller illustrates how the American Dream may be achieved through hard work. To Charley, the American Dream is having a comfortable life and putting his son Bernard through college. Charely worked consistently throughout his life, never trying to shoot for too high hopes.
PygmalioA Essay Research Paper Higgins
Pygmalio(A) Essay, Research Paper Higgins’ Philosophy Professor Higgins is seen throughout Pygmalion as a very rude man.While one may expect a well educated man, such as Higgins, to be agentleman, he is far from it. Higgins believes that how you treatedsomeone is not important, as long as you treat everyone equally.
Middle Class Morality Essay Research Paper MIDDLE
Middle Class Morality Essay, Research Paper MIDDLE CLASS MORALITY Values and morals of the Victorian era are quite different than those that our society upholds today. The satirical plays, A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen, and Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw, examine the problems with certain beliefs held by the people, both men and women, of the Victorian age.
Kidnapped Essay Research Paper Kidnapped by Robert
Kidnapped Essay, Research Paper Kidnapped, by Robert Louis Stevenson has a genre that classifies as historical fiction. I selected this book because the setting takes place during the 1750 s, which is a perfect time for history. At that year many historic events occurred that have been written down in books today.
The Man Of Hypocrisy Analysis Of Higgins
In Shaws Pygmalion) Essay, Research Paper The Man of Hypocrisy Manners are the happy way of doing things according to Ralph Waldo Emerson. According to Emerson people use manners as a front to make themselves look better. Inherently, this will lead to a contradiction of the front and the reality. One such man who is most concerned with manners is the protagonist of Shaw s Pygmalion, Professor Henry Higgins.
Themes In George Bernard Shaw
’s Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper George Bernard Shaw s play Pygmalion is the story of Henry Higgins, a master phonetician, and his mischievous plot to pass a common flower girl, Eliza Doolittle, off as a duchess at the Embassy Ball. In order achieve his goal, Higgins must teach Eliza how to speak properly and how to act in upper-class society.
The Natural Essay Research Paper Bernard Malamud
The Natural Essay, Research Paper Bernard Malamud relates a story of a baseball player, Roy Hobbs, who went from a small farm to the big city life to play baseball in ?The Natural?. The story creates a contrast between the evils of the city and the purity of the countryside.
Weather Modification Essay Research Paper Weather ModificationHistoryWeather
Weather Modification Essay, Research Paper Weather Modification History Weather Modification was founding 1946 by Vincent Schaefer who was attempting to find a way to induce artificial clouds to produce precipitation in a cold cloud chamber ( modified freezer). The experiment done with a block of dry ice in the freezer was a success when his colleague Bernard Vonnegut found a chemical, silver iodide, that is almost like ice in its molecular structure, but can be carried and applied more easily.
Artificial Creation Essay Research Paper Artificial CreationThe
Artificial Creation Essay, Research Paper Artificial Creation The word Artificial, derived from the Latin word artificialis is defined as Made by humans; produced rather than natural. Since the beginning of time man has always been enthralled by a magnificent sight; however what is beautiful to one person may be uncanny to another.
Another 1984 Essay Research Paper From the
Another 1984 Essay, Research Paper From the very beginning Winston and Bernard make them enemies of their society. These characters risk their lives to try and recapture what we take for granted today.
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper is an element
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper is an element of comedy in the sThere tory Pygmalion and in the film My Fair Lady. In the play and the film alike, a woman of the streets named Liza
My Fair Lady Essay Research Paper My
My Fair Lady Essay, Research Paper My Fair Lady is a musical comedy written by Bernard Shaw, which is set in England. The story is about Elisa, who spoke very bad English, with a cockney accent, but she wanted to learn how to speak better English, so she went to a phonetics? teacher, Higgins. Elisa was very poor, so she didn?t have the money to pay for the lessons.
Pygmalion
’s Higgins Essay, Research Paper Bernard Shaw shows and describes Professor Higgins throughout Pygmalion as a very rude man. While one may expect a very well-educated man, such as Higgins, to be a gentleman, he is far from being a gentleman. Higgins believes that the way you treat someone is not important, as long as you treat everyone equally.
Brave New World Summary Essay Research Paper
SUMMARY::: We start with Bernard, who was created in the Bokanovsky Process, but was unusually smart. Smart in the way that he had his own, natural way of thinking, unlike all other humans in the Brave New World. Bernard was indeed intelligent, but because of an error during one of the processes of creation, he grew small and weak.
Comparison Of Movies And Books Essay Research
Paper Many people compare an English literary work to different movies of their time. An example of this is Pygmalion by Bernard Shaw. A story about a woman transformed into a spectacular beauty pushed into royalty, but never loses her identity, is very similar to a movie directed by Don Bluth called Anastasia.
Creation Of Eliza Essay Research Paper PygmalionShawBernardPygmalion
Creation Of Eliza Essay, Research Paper PygmalionShaw,Bernard.Pygmalion. Creation of Eliza can be viewed from two completely different angles dependent on if you look at Eliza’s side or Professor Higgins side. Beginning with Eliza we see that she was a poor flower girl who sold penny bunches to afford a living.
Death Of A Salesman Analysis Project Essay
, Research Paper Character Analysis Assignment All of the characters in the performance ?Death of a Salesman? have special traits that are indicative of their personality and literary purpose in the piece. Each serves a particular purpose and symbolizes distinct goals, functions, or qualities. One by one, the author places every character in a specific location to contrast, or emphasize another character?s shortcomings, mistakes, or areas of strength.
Pygmalion Act IIII Essay Research Paper The
Pygmalion Act IIII Essay, Research Paper The trio return to Higgins’ Wimpole Street laboratory, exhausted from the night’s happenings. They talk about the evening and their great success, though Higgins seems
Pygmalion 2 Essay Research Paper During
Pygmalion 2 Essay, Research Paper During the time of the play, Pygmalion, classes in England were seemingly artificial. It is shown very well in Act III during one of Mrs.
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper In the play
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper In the play Pygmalion, by George Bernard Shaw, lessons regarding speech, relationships, and the nature of society are taught. It is intensely and deliberately didactic .
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper Pygmalion and My
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper Pygmalion and My Fair Lady are a modern parallel of the story of Pygmalion, legendary sculptor and King of Cyprus, who fell in love with his own statue of Aphrodite. At his prayer, Aphrodite brought the statue to life as Galatea. George Bernard Shaw’s play Pygmalion is the story of Henry Higgins, a master phonetician, and his mischievous plot to pass a common flower girl, Eliza Doolittle, off as a duchess at the Embassy Ball.
Pygmalion Essay Essay Research Paper According to
Pygmalion Essay Essay, Research Paper According to a Greek myth, Pygmalion, an ancient sculptor living on Cyprus Island, worshipped the goddess of love, Venus. The local women disgusted him, so he sculpted himself the perfect one for him; Galatea. Higgins undertakes a similar project, to sculpt a duchess by changing the appearance and the manners of a flower girl.
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper Pygmalion Higgins
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper Pygmalion: Higgins’ Philosophy Professor Higgins is seen throughout Pygmalion as a very rude man. You would expect a well-educated man, such as Higgins, to be a gentleman, however, he is far from it. Higgins believes that how you treat someone is not important, as long as you treat everyone equally.
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper Comparing Pygmalion to
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper Comparing Pygmalion to My Fair Lady Numerous times a piece of literature is changed into a movie or musical it s plot and or theme has been changed to suit the director s thought of what would appeal to the public. One such example is Bernard Shaw s play Pygmalion. In this play Shaw s purpose and ideas were horribly misconstrued to the point at which he was forced to write an Epilogue to try to reconcile the injustice done to his masterpiece.
Dog Dreams Essay Research Paper Dog DreamsFor
Dog Dreams Essay, Research Paper Dog Dreams For the past five years my dream has been to own a male Saint Bernard pup out of my old Saint Bernards, Samson and Delilah. Patty, the woman that owns my old companions called and informed me that Delilah was pregnant and was expected to deliver within the next week. I knew that my dream was coming true and I would get my pup.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarVeni
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Veni, vidi, vici. ?I came, I saw, I conquered.? These are the words of the man who changed the course of Greco-Roman history, Julius Caesar (Bernard 34). Julius Caesar
Pygmalion Essay Research Paper DiscriminationSociety has been
Pygmalion Essay, Research Paper Discrimination Society has been split apart since renossance England. The novel Pygmalion written by Bernard Shaw demonstrates that proper speech and a fake appearance can easily fool the upper class English. Different levels of society are usually seperated because of money, appearance and speech, and attitude.