Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper
Upon examining issues of mind and thought, the questions of artificial intelligence and its capabilities become important considerations for answering the ultimate question of what thought truly is. Computerized calculation is one of the few events that is somewhat analogous to human cognitive thought, so the extension of this current technology to more advanced future applications makes it a very interesting testing area for questions into consciousness. If one concludes that the advancement from cash registers to present day computers is a step closer to human thought, then we must concede that progressing technology will bring us closer and perhaps to the very point of true cognitive skills. The dilemma left to us philosophers and scientists is to determine when a machine has reached the point of thought, or at least to create a rough guideline. A.M. Turing proposed a test to solve this problem. Named, appropriately enough, the Turing test, it contains a controversial method of testing called the imitation game. The idea is to put one man and one woman in two rooms and have them questioned by an interrogator in a third room. The man would try to answer questions in a way which would suggest he is a woman. The woman attempts to answer in a way to reveal the truth of the matter. If the man fools the interrogator, it is said that he can think like a woman, or, at the very least, mimic a woman’s responses. This game can also be played with a computer in the male slot, trying to convince the interrogator that it is human. It would follow reason that if a computer could pass this test, it could think like a human, or at least mimic one. Perhaps the abilities showcased in the test alone would not be sufficient, but Daniel C. Dennett claims that “[t]he assumption Turing was prepared to make was that nothing could possibly pass the Turing test by winning the Imitation Game without being able to perform indefinitely many other clearly intelligent actions” (Dennett 93). One often cited criticism of this notion is the idea of mimicry. Imagine a program that stored an almost infinite amount of information regarding sentences and grammar and was able to spit out contextualy appropriate sentences to a wide variety of inquiries. The computer has no knowledge of what the information means; it is acting much as a parrot does. Luckily for Turing, there is no shortage of responses for this claim. First of all, as Douglas Hofstadter points outs, “[t]he number of sentences you’d need to store to be able to respond in a normal way to all possible sentences in a conversation is astronomical, really unimaginable” (Hofstadter 92). The computer would also have to contain a complex microprocessor to keep up with conversation in a timely and manageable fashion. It would have to be so advanced indeed that such a microprocessor might be considered a small scale brain, sorting through symbols and their meanings to form contextually valid responses. Accordingly, if such a machine existed, it would pass the Turing test and validate the method of testing at the same time. If a machine was capable of mastering the context-sensitive language we use, it may very well have a claim to true thought. At the very least, the computer would surpass mimicry and be labeled a simulation. Human thought is so complicated and demanding that any device that attempts to duplicate it with any success would have to be a highly sensitive simulation. Any machine that passes the Turing test must have a rudimentary “knowledge” of the information it is using and therefore is more than parrot . Assuming this is true, we must then ask hard questions about the value of simulation. The critical claim is that any simulation is just a simulation and not a real example of what it is simulating. Hofstadter finds this fallacious, as do I. First, any simulation can reasonable defined in this context as the recreation of a natural event by an agent other than nature. This view brings up the idea of levels in simulation. A good example is Dennett’s simulated hurricane in Brainstorms. From the programmer’s vantage point, the God spot, of course the simulation can be easily identified as such. On the level of the simulation, however, no such preordained order can be seen. Perhaps if we all had the vantage point of nature, we would see the entire physical universe as a large simulation created by natural forces. Ultimately, it would seem unfair to discriminate between two like events on the basis of what agent set them into motion. We are still left with the largest concern, however. What does the Imitation Game really prove? As far as I can tell, the Imitation Game proves nothing at all, yet it does not have to. As pointed out as the beginning of this investigation, the job of the philosopher/scientist is to create a guideline for judging the relative intelligence of machines. Some critics say that the Imitation Game played with humans lends no insight into how the male thinks. They say that the test will never prove the man can think like a woman. Even if this is true, it does not invalidate the test as applied to machines. The cognitive abilities of men and women are so close in nature that the test may indeed lend no valuable information. With a machine, however, the cognitive differences from a human can be seen easily. The Turing test may not lay down a definite line for thought, but it is valuable for relative evaluations. For example, if one machine performs almost perfectly on the test, and another performs badly, one could conclude that the first machine is closer to human thought than its failing counterpart. What the test cannot do, however, it tell us how close the better machine is to thought. The identity of the computer as conscious cannot be proved. Kishan Ballal points out that “[w]e intuitively feel that personal identity is the paradigm for all other judgments of identity, even though personal identity cannot be justified through purely rational means” (Ballal 86). The sad truth is that at present there is no way to establish conscious identity other than asking the entity and hope it doesn’t lie. G.W.F. Hegel supports this theory of conscious identity, commenting that “[t]he self-contained and self-sufficient reality which is at once aware of being actual in the form of consciousness and presents itself to itself, is Spirit” (Hegel 637). In the Hegelian view, the computer is the only one with the correct insight to determine if it is conscious. Could this possibly suggest that the only accurate Turing test is one a computer runs on itself? Through self-inspection, or self-interrogation if you will, the computer may be able to draw conclusions on its own condition. Now while Hegel never saw the computer in any form, even he realized the limits of a test like Turing’s. From Hegel’s point of view, there is not even a test to determine if a human is thinking or merely simulating conscious existence. Personal conscious identity is an assumption. “Like other elements which form our bedrock of assumptions,” Ballal says, “personal identity is without proof” (Ballal 86). Normally, this is not a problem. The knowledge of self-existence is clearly a priori analytic. It is a self-supporting truth, exempt from the attacks of epistemological skeptics. We can then deduce that any similar being that shares the basic physiological structure probably shares the same conscious existence. These assumptions are rarely challenged except by the highly fallacious solipsism of young children. When we examine a computer, however, the same assumptions cannot be applied. Therefore, the Turing test can only go so far, for the assumptions it rests on are small in number. We must keep in mind that the Turing test is only a tool, not a proof. The test was not designed to tell if machines can think. After all, Turing himself says that question is “too meaningless to deserve discussion” (Turing 57). The test is a yardstick with no predetermined end. There is no prefect score for the test; the most current machine defines the best result. As machines continue to advance, the best result will constantly grow better, stopping only when technology advances to its peak. Thus the Turning test can only answer the question “Can machines think?” in two ways: “No” if technology stops advancing, or “We don’t know yet” if it has not stopped. Ultimately, the Turing test does have flaws and limitations, but that should not sharply downgrade its usefulness as a tool for measuring a computer’s cognitive abilities. As science grows in scope, more tests may be devised to gauge these abilities, but for current use, the Turing test clearly accomplishes what it was set out to do. Perhaps it does not offer a comprehensive proof, but it does lend insight into areas of science which were previously
Другие работы по теме:
Downhill Skiing Essay Research Paper Style Exercise
Downhill Skiing Essay, Research Paper Style Exercise 1 I can still remember the first time I went downhill skiing; it was a cold and dry November day with little snowfall. Most of the snow on the hills was that polished, jet blown, artificial-ice/pseudo-snow; not the best situation for a first timer.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Many times in
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Many times in our society intelligence is judged by test scores, careers, and success. Although these methods of measuring intelligence are not always accurate they are still used. IQ tests are given to people and the scores on these tests are supposed to reflect the level of intelligence a person has.
Phrenology Essay Research Paper Phrenology
Phrenology Essay, Research Paper Phrenology “Before phrenology all we knew about the brain was, how to slice it” — Richard Chenevix, 1828 (Victorian Web). Phrenology was a popular pseudoscience that was founded by Franz Gall. He believed that by examining the bumps on a person’s skull, you could determine ones personality characteristics, moral characteristics, and intelligence.
Flowers For Algeron Essay Research Paper The
Flowers For Algeron Essay, Research Paper The story “Flowers for Algernon”, by Daniel Keyes, that we read in English was about a mentally retarded person, named Charlie who had an operation to increase his intelligence, but the operation was a failure and Charlie is slow again. He wants to move now so society won t ridicule him for being slow again.
Psy2 Essay Research Paper Why IQ tests
Psy2 Essay, Research Paper Why IQ tests don’t test intelligenceThe task of trying to quantify a person s intelligence has been a goalof psychologists since before the beginning of this century. TheBinet-Simon scales were first proposed in 1905 in Paris, France andvarious sorts of tests have been evolving ever since.
Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper A Critical
Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper A Critical Analysis of “12: Machines Will Be Smarter Than We Are” In today’s rapidly changing world, technology has given us a possible future in the field of Artificial Intelligence. An August, 1999 article entitled “12: Machines Will Be Smarter Than We Are,” explains how Artificial Intelligence is inevitable.
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper Perhaps one
Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Perhaps one of the most complex pieces to the human puzzle is our sense of humor. A sense of humor not only involves intelligence and comprehension but also an array of emotions. It is not enough to just understand something humorous, but it is also necessary that an emotional and physiological response be able to occur for a person to have a sense of humor.
Chinese Room Essay Research Paper Through the
Chinese Room Essay, Research Paper Through the use of his famous Chinese room scenario, John R. Searle tries to prove there is no way artificial intelligence can exist. This means that machines do not posses minds.
Reality Essay Research Paper Virtual reality has
Reality Essay, Research Paper Virtual reality has promise for nearly every industry ranging from architecture and design to movies and entertainment, but the real industry to gain from this technology is science in general. The money that can be saved examining the probability of experiments in an artificial world before they are actually carried out could be great, and the money saved on energy could be even greater.
IQ Test Essay Research Paper Why IQ
I.Q Test Essay, Research Paper Why IQ tests don’t test intelligence The task of trying to quantify a person s intelligence has been a goal of psychologists since before the beginning of this century. The
Evolution Of Species Essay Research Paper I
Evolution Of Species Essay, Research Paper I’m sitting down at a computer that has very vast capabilities. It is capable of almost any application, but it being only the size of my history textbook, leaves it fragile and vulnerable. With a few light slams, or the pass of a powerful magnet, it’s very existence could be destroyed.
Centrifuge Essay Research Paper The centrifuge will
Centrifuge Essay, Research Paper The centrifuge will be 2.5 meters in diameter, which is about 8 feet. As the centrifuge rotates, it produces artificial gravitational forces upon attached that house various biological specimens. It is capable of producing controlled, artificial levels ranging from 0.01 g to 2.0 g.
Aibo And Robotics Essay Research Paper In
Aibo And Robotics Essay, Research Paper In our society today, advanced technology robots are hardly ever seen in the entertainment market. Robots that have the ability to perform tricks like AIBO are far too expensive to be brought out into stores. Lots of people don t even know about advanced technology entertainment robots.
Can Machines Think Essay Research Paper Artificial
Can Machines Think Essay, Research Paper Artificial Intelligence is a broad topic, consisting of different fields, from machine vision to expert systems. Nowadays with the use of high level techniques, computers have been programmed to solve many difficult problems, but the products that are available today are only a sample of what is coming in the future.
Success Secret A High Emotional IQ Essay
, Research Paper This article keys in on a different type of intelligence called emotional intelligence. Psychologist Daniel Goldman wrote the book titled “Emotional Intelligence” in 1995. Emotional intelligence
Stress Essay Research Paper Coping with stress
Stress Essay, Research Paper Coping with stress and maintaining good health are important parts of maintaining and developing intelligence. (Nick can cope with stress very well. This, among other things, makes him very cool.) One cannot expect one s intelligence to develop if one is preoccupied with poor health or excessive stress.
Artificial Restraints In Lord Of The Flies
Essay, Research Paper Artificial Restraints in Lord of the Flies “GOLDING PUTS SO MANY ARTIFICIAL RESTRAINTS ON HIS STORY IN ORDER TO EMPHASISE HIS POINT, THAT THE WHOLE THING COMES OUT TOO NEATLY AND, IN FACT, REDUCES THE POWER OF HIS MESSAGE.”
Police Essay Research Paper The PoliceWhy is
Police Essay, Research Paper The Police Why is it that so many minorities have a problem with the police? Are all minorities simply unruly, or is it that police officers with lower intelligence levels and a false sense of power abuse their ability to mistreat people they do not like? In my opinion, I believe that police officers should have to go through more of a rigorous training and have minority sensitivity training before they are given their badges.
Metaphysics Essay Research Paper METAPHYSICSTHEORY OF KNOWLEDGE
Metaphysics Essay, Research Paper METAPHYSICS THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE AND BEYOND The complex knowledge of metaphysics ? once comprehended ? is capable of helping an individual reach self-realization. Aristotle, a renowned man of thinking, conjured metaphysics to help understand the theories of intelligence – - it?s core of existence and where it comes from, truth, and cause.
Internet And Cyberspace Essay Research Paper My
Internet And Cyberspace Essay, Research Paper My research project tries to delve into commonly misunderstood or badly formed interpretations of the Internet. In this assignment I analyze common web terms such as the matrix, cyberspace, virtual reality and to an extent artificial intelligence. I explore the interpretations of people from a wide array of society with regard to these Internet concepts.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Intelligence hereditary
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Intelligence: hereditary or acquired? Is intelligence determined primary by heredity or by the environment? This issue has aroused intense debates because many believe it has a little bit of both, but to what extent? The ones that believe that believe that every person is born with a fixed amount of intelligence argue that there is little one can do to improve intelligence, so special education programs should not be expected to produce an increase in the children?s IQ.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper INTELLIGENCEIt is widely
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper INTELLIGENCE?It is widely debated whether psychologists define intelligence accurately, though most agree that intelligence is the global capacity to act purposefully, think rationally, and deal effectively with the surrounding environment. Their views stem from observing a rather small fraction of the brain’s measured activity, approximately 10 percent, and subsequently cannot actually categorize a person’s mental capacity, other than achieved levels of concentration.
Mr Essay Research Paper Aspects of the
Mr. Essay, Research Paper Aspects of the Perfect Female The ideal woman of today’s society would contain the following qualities: intelligence, honesty, a sense of humor, spontaneity, assertiveness,
Artificial Insemination Essay Research Paper Artificial insemination
Artificial Insemination Essay, Research Paper Artificial insemination is the injection of SEMEN into the vagina by instrumental means. The first artificial inseminations of viviparous (live-bearing) animals were performed by the 18th-century Italian physiologist Lazzaro Spallanzani, who proved that the male contribution to reproduction resided in the semen, although he did not recognize spermatozoa as the fertilizing agents.
Artificial Intelagence Essay Research Paper Artificial IntelligenceArtificial
Artificial Intelagence Essay, Research Paper Artificial Intelligence Artificial Intelligence once something that people thought could only come out of science fiction novels and movies. But today that could all change because of a robot called Cog. Cog is an artificial intelligence that its creators have given a body.
Why Do People Want To Destroy Images
? Essay, Research Paper Religion Puritanism 16th and 17th centuries ? dispute over terms of the Settlement which banned artificial worship but did not specify decoration such as church windows and crosses in
Why Does The Universe Exist Essay Research
Paper Why Does the Universe Exist? Consider that the universe is some sort of toy or form of entertainment for some prime mover, his point, his own entertainment, would be then why the universe exists. The Bible claims that the Christian deity created the universe and placed humans in it that they might be in awe of his power.
Sin Is Ignorance
– Socratic Definition Of Sin Essay, Research Paper Sin is Ignorance – Socratic definition of sin Sin is ignorance. This is well known Socratic definition of sin which, like everthing Socratic, is an opinion always worthy of attention. The difficulty with the Socratic definition is that it leaves undetermined how ignorance itself is to be more precisely understood, the question of its origin, ect.
Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper Artificial IntelligenceArtificial
Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Artificial Intelligence Artificial intelligence is a highly debatable topic. You either believe that it may be achieved or think it can’t, and the middle is a little shady. Artificial Intelligence is the study to create a machine that can act like a human brain, including emotions, and consciousness.
Information Technology Essay Research Paper Information TechnologyThe
Information Technology Essay, Research Paper Information Technology The purpose of my article is to study the impact of information technology and artificial intelligence on the organization, privacy and control, research and instructional practices and ethics. Evolution of information technology has affected all these practices, and has helped them in improving their performance in some way.