CHARACTERISE BIOLOGICAL, PSYCHOLOGICAL, AND SOCIOLOGICAL THEORIES OF CRIME AND DEVIANCE GIVING EXAMPLES OF EACH EXPLAINING THE USEFULNESS AND LIMITATIONS OF EACH “APPROACH”.
There are three main theories of why crime and deviance exists in society. There are biological, psychological and sociological explanations for this occurrence. First of all deviance, in the simplest view is “essentially statistical, defining as deviant anything that varies too widely from the average” (Becker, 1963, p.4). A deviant person is one who can be described as violating the written and unwritten laws of his society.
One of the first biological theories was proposed by Paul Broca, a French anthropologist, who claimed that there were differences in the skulls of criminals when compared to the mainstream population. In the 1870’s, Cesare Lombroso, an Italian criminologist, believed that people were born with criminal tendencies. These people were regarded as a primitive form of human, a “genetic throwback” and were classed as homo delinquens (Bartol, 1980, p25?). This theory held that while social environment and learning influenced these types of people, the main factor was a biological one (Giddens, 1993, p.122).
Criminologists decided to look into family trees to find any influence of heredity. This search proved nothing as it was impossible to separate inherited from environmental influences. William Sheldon, in the 1940’s, was certain that there was a correlation between a person’s physique and their inclination toward crime and deviance. The three types of physiques were muscular, active types – mesomorphs, those with thin builds – ectomorphs and those with more flesh were endomorphs. He claimed that mesomorphs were more inclined to deviance, this may be because of the fact that gang activities usually were displays of athleticism (Giddens, 1993, p.123). This view was criticised because it was believed that if there was a causal effect between physique and deviance then it relationship had nothing to do with heredity.
Other researchers believed that criminal tendencies, in men at least, was connected to chromosomes, that is a genetic inheritance. This view stated that violent criminals were more likely to have an extra Y chromosome. Again, this was another theory that proved to be inconclusive mainly due to the small samples available for testing. Another branch of this theory was that certain types of crime may be influenced by natural tendencies to be irritable and aggressive. This is not hard and fast because researchers are not convinced that personality traits are inheritable and that even if they were then the only connection would be a remote one (Giddens, 1993, p.123).
In the end most criminologists and researchers agreed that “Genetics may play a role in criminality, but it is only an insignificant one…” (Bartol, 1980, p.25). This theory being at the forefront of investigations of crime and deviance was going to be important no matter what the final outcome was because it was going to point the way that new research would take.
The next theory to look at is the psychological theory which holds that crime and deviance are associated with particular types of personalities. Freud’s views on morality and that they stem from self-restraints learnt in childhood was applied to this theory in that people who failed to learn these self-restraints lack a fundamental morality which is more likely to lead them on a path to delinquency. This view of lack of morality prompted an important question is this trait, or lack of trait, criminal? Most of the studies have been carried out within the prison system and so all evidence is from a negative perspective. A positive outlook on the same trait might be described as adventurous, carefree and impulsive (Giddens, 1993, p.124). People might consider a life of crime or they may opt for the experiences in a socially acceptable way if they lack this fundamental morality.
Many criminologists have come to the conclusion that most criminals have much the same characteristics as the mainstream population. It is also far-fetched to believe that all criminals would share the same traits as each crime is surrounded by different circumstances.
The sociological theory takes a different view and says that any definition of crime depends on the perspective and institutions of a society. In each sub-culture the norms will be different from another in which it will be classed as deviant. Edwin Sutherland determined that the environment in which some people lived was conducive or encouraging of criminal activities and that these people because of their associations would be more susceptible to the delinquent path.
Robert Merton believed that anomie was the cause of most crime. Anomie takes place where the traditions and norms of a society are being eroded but not being succeeded by new norms. Anomie then comes into play as there are no clear “standards to guide behaviour in a given area of social life” (Giddens, 1993, p.126). This type of situation places an enormous burden on behaviour when the given norms clash with reality. An example of this is the fallacy that material success is possible for anyone no matter what their background. Unfortunately, those that do not succeed are put down for their inability to progress and are therefore there is a lot of strain on them to gain material success by any means, legitimate or not.
There are five main types of people or reactions to this sort of pressure. The first type are conformists who accept the values and norms and goes about garnering success by conventional means. The second group, innovators, accept the values but gain through illegal procedures. The next set who adhere to ritualism, conform but often lose sight of the end goal and follow the ritual of gaining material possessions for their own sake. Retreatists cut themself of from society and its values sometimes in a physical sense such as joining a self-supporting commune (Giddens, 1993, p.127). The last group is probably the most recognisable of the five being the rebels who reject the values and vigorously try to change the existing values and social system.
Cloward and Ohlin in the 1960’s linked association with anomie. This meant that where gaining wealth through legal means was almost non-existent, the temptation existed to go from petty “part-time” crime to a full-blown career in crime and deviance.
A theory that was quite influential was the labelling theory. For people who were caught for the first time it was labelled the primary deviation. It was believed that the secondary deviation occurred when the individual accepts the label of delinquent and then purposely “lives up” to the label. An uncertainty still exists with this theory in the fact that it is not known if labelling in itself causes an increase in deviant behaviour. This theory takes the stance that no act, in and of itself, is intentionally criminal which is not necessarily true in the case of murders, thefts and rapes. Most of the theorists agree that there is a rational choice to make whose stand is that the risk is worth it. Every crime also has a situation interpretations such as opportunities that are too good to miss (Giddens, 1993, p.131). This view of crime is one of action not reaction.
Labelling theory has been applauded as being the most efficient and useful in interpreting facets of crime and deviant behaviour (Giddens, 1993, p.132). However most researchers will agree that the “different theories are useful to explain certain deviant activities” (Roach-Anleu, 1995, p.45) and that understanding the social environments and context in which the crime takes place is of paramount importance.
Другие работы по теме:
Sociology By Jon M Shepard Essay Research
Paper As we begin a new millienium, it is important for us to decrease and control crime in America.To begin to do this, as our book Sociology by Jon M. Shepard states, we must recognize the extent to which crime occurs.
How Social Order Is Possible Essay Research
Paper 1. “How is social order possible?” The way in which social order is achieved has been the subject of many theories presented by respectable sociologists such as Emile Durkheim, Thomas Hobbes, George Herbert Mead, and Karl Marx. Among the most prominent of these theories are Hobbes’ “Social Control” theory and Meads’ “Symbolic Interactionism” theory.
Sonnet About Death Essay Research Paper Death
Sonnet About Death Essay, Research Paper Death is full of sorrow and surprise Sooner or later it comes at anytime. Even though I do not remember my demise In my hearts I still remember my greatest crime.
Sociology Essay Research Paper Sociology 210 Exam
Sociology Essay, Research Paper Sociology 210 Exam #2 (Essay #4) When sociologists think of the postmodern society, shopping malls are most likely the first thing to come to mind. It can be easily argued that “shopping malls are the cathedrals of postmodern society” Times have changed since Marx argued that who you are is what you do or since Durkheim argued that who you are depends on your religion.
Drugs In Society Essay Research Paper The
Drugs In Society Essay, Research Paper The most significant problem facing young people in the inner city today is one problem but many problems put together. The use of drugs and the crime that occurs all intertwine and form one big problem. Also the lack of education doesn t help the young people either.
Sociology Essay Research Paper QUESTION 1
Sociology Essay, Research Paper QUESTION 1 What is science about and how does sociology fit in it?Sociology is the scientific study of human social activity. In the effort to study human social activity sociologists brake it down into objects of analysis. The three objects of analysis are population, social structure, and the individual.
Brown And Black Colored Skin Reaches For
Help Essay, Research Paper On Saturday, Franny Chen and Yao Chen were found dead at their small apartement building in King County, Washington. A call was made to 911 by the couples ten year old son who reported to the police that his father had first Shot his mother and then proceeded to take his own life. The neighbor of the couple informed the officer that Yao Chen moved back in the house against the mothers will and continually abused Franny Chen until the day in which he took both of their lives.
Living As A Sociologist Essay Research Paper
Living As A Sociologist In this life we as human beings strive to live a relatively normal life. Living a supposedly “normal” existence is a big part of understanding sociology. This is because the same concepts that that are learned in sociology are the same concepts that people use as their basis for a “normal” life.
Crime And Robbery Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Robbery Essay, Research Paper Crime and Robbery Words 1 Thesis: “Crime is the violation of statutes enacted into criminal law by a locality, state, or the federal government” (Macionis, 218). Crimes against property include robbery of another’s personal belongings. Property crimes include burglary, larceny, and auto theft.
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay Research Paper Hate
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay, Research Paper Hate Crimes To what extent is a crime a hate crime? Aren t all crimes to some extent hate crimes? Should the consequences for a crime committed against a minority be more than that for one against a white person? The purpose for classifying a crime as a hate crime might be to raise awareness in the public to the intolerance against minorities but I believe the punishment should fit the crime and not the reason for the crime.
Crime And Gender Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Gender Essay, Research Paper Crime and Gender: Does the punishment fit? Before the jury stands the defendant. There is overwhelming evidence in the favor of the prosecution. The verdict comes back from the jury, not guilty. Why? The defendant is a woman. In our era of equal rights and civil liberties women have made great strides in their advancement and role in society, yet it seems that gender segregates when it comes to crime.
Crimonology Essay Research Paper If you look
Crimonology Essay, Research Paper If you look up the word criminology in the dictionary it would be defined as a scientific study of crime as a social phenomenon. Social phenomenon? Say what?
The Study Of Criminology Essay Research Paper
Criminology is the scientific study of crime, criminals, criminal behavior, and the criminal justice system. In the United States, it is taught chiefly in departments of criminology and criminal justice of colleges and universities. Criminologists study factors related to crime. Research in criminology involves fields such as sociology, psychology, and psychiatry.
Sociology Essay Research Paper II Sociology
Sociology Essay, Research Paper II) Sociology is the study of social behavior, which means it describes and explains society, or the rules of the group. Social behavior is any behavior that has been, or is being, conditions to any degree by interaction with others. When you read this definition you begin to understand the complexity of sociology.
Labeling Theory Essay Research Paper Liz BruceCan
Labeling Theory Essay, Research Paper Liz Bruce Can Critical Perspective Explain Crime? Many psychologists and sociologists have spent years trying to ascertain why criminals continue to commit crimes, and why certain prevention tactics still do not deter crime. There are two theories that became very prominent in the sixties, as to some of the reasons surrounding criminals, these theories are known as the labeling theory and the conflict theory.
Medicalization Of Sociology Essay Research Paper Sociologist
Medicalization Of Sociology Essay, Research Paper Sociologist utilizes several perspectives to explain individual motivations of deviance with an emphasis on biological, psychiatric, psychoanalytic, and psychological terms. The emergence of these ideals temporarily displaced social disorganization theory, which stresses a rapidly changing environment as the cause of deviant behavior.
Crime And Ethnicity Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Ethnicity Essay, Research Paper Crime and Ethnicity A crime rate difference among ethnic groups is probably a cultural universal. Chinese and Japanese Americans have lower crime rates then other Americans: Irish immigrants to England have higher crime rates. In Sweden, Hungarian and Yugoslav immigrants have a higher crime rate.
Crime And Resources Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Resources Essay, Research Paper Crime in the United States (CIUS), published annually by the FBI, is a compilation of the Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) provided by over 16,000 policing jurisdictions. It represents one of the two primary sources of data about crime in the United States, the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) being the other.
Deviance Essay Research Paper It seems to
Deviance Essay, Research Paper It seems to me that when I think about deviant behavior, I tend to think of murder, robbery and things of that nature. But even so, I still have engaged in a form of deviant behavior – I have pedaled pornography on the Internet. It is a minor thing as far as I am concerned but there are many that would put this act right up there with murder.
Deviance Essay Research Paper Theories of Deviant
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Theories of Deviant Behavior examines various theories and perspectives on conforming and deviant behavior which are products of Western scholarly thought: anomie, functionalism, social disorganization, social conflict, social control, psychoanalysis, status politics, differential association, labeling theory, etc.
Organized Crime Essay Research Paper What underlying
Organized Crime Essay, Research Paper What underlying factors lead to the prevalence of organized crime? Organized crime by definition means crime that is committed by a number of people that are organized in a series of networks. These crimes that are committed are often well planned out and involve a number of people all working together under one, or sometimes a few, men in power and leaders of the group.
The Deviance Of Marijuana Smokers Essay Research
Paper The Deviance of Marijuana Smokers Marijuana smokers were once considered regular members of society. In 1937 all that changed when marijuana was banned and made illegal. The smokers were labeled
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Chad HeldtSociologyPeriod
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Chad Heldt Sociology Period 1 4/28/98 The Death Penalty Should It Be Allowed Or Not? In my paper I plan to give my opinion and my position on the death penalty. I believe the death penalty should be for hardened criminals like the Charlie Mansons of the world and people like that.
Social Deviance Essay Research Paper A A
Social Deviance Essay, Research Paper A). A young man on the campus of Indiana University was brutally attacked last night. The students name has not been released yet, but early confirmations from local sources have said that it was Kent Harvey, the young man blamed for the firing of former Head Basketball Coach Bobby Knight.
Deviance Essay Research Paper When we speak
Deviance Essay, Research Paper When we speak of deviance, every individual can have a different definition of what deviance is and what it stands for. What I may take offensive, might be element of
Deviance Essay Research Paper Deviant Behavior Sociologists
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Deviant Behavior Sociologists use the term deviance to refer to any violation of norms- whether the infraction is a minor as jaywalking, or as serious as murder. This deceptively simple definition takes us to the heart of the sociological perspective of deviance, which sociologist Howard S.
Jail And Deviance Essay Research Paper 111196Sociology
Jail And Deviance Essay, Research Paper 11-11-96 Sociology 102 Application paper The visit to the jail, brought new insight to the terms mentioned in the book. In the chapter on deviance, we learned about the deviant people that are part of our society.
Deviance And Prostitution Essay Research Paper In
Deviance And Prostitution Essay, Research Paper In sociology, the term deviance refers to all violations of social rules, regardless of their seriousness (Essentials of Sociology 136). Deviance is an individual or organizational behavior that violates societal norms and is usually accompanied by negative reactions from others.
Crime And Deviance Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Deviance Essay, Research Paper Crime and Deviance Deviance is the recognized violation of cultural norms. Laws have been made to help curb deviant behavior. When there is not a particular law in place for certain behavior then a rule may apply. For example, you do not run the risk of being arrested for belching at the dinner table, but you may be excused without finishing dinner if a “no belching at the table” rule is enforced at your home.
Durkheim On Sociology Essay Research Paper To
Durkheim On Sociology Essay, Research Paper To begin his article Durkheim is says that Sociology is in the stage of system-building because the problem is proposes is not clear-cut. What he is saying here is that Sociology is not a fully excepted science at this time because of the uncertainties that possesses.
Rise Of Sociology Essay Research Paper The
Rise Of Sociology Essay, Research Paper The Rise of Sociology The field of sociology evolved as a response to the impact of profound social and political fragmentation experienced in the West. A fundamental shift in both social and intellectual patterns created by the economic evolution of the eighteenth century led to great concern among scholars of the period.
Sociology 101 Essay Research Paper Sociology 101By
Sociology 101 Essay, Research Paper Sociology 101 By: Chris Reeh This article is about Spanish rabbi-poet named Judah Halevi. He lived in a society in which Jews were socially powerless. They were also influenced heavily by the dominant Islamic culture. He wrote many poems and books. His poetry brought a deeper sense of the Jewish spirituality to many people.
Crime In Nyc Essay Research Paper i
Crime In Nyc Essay, Research Paper i think that crime is the most serious pronlem in nyc today because the have too much drugs guns rapiest pickpockets and hit and run drivers. Crime is very high in nyc.The people in nyc needed more cops in the subway parks maybe that qill lower crime.Some time you would call 911 if the drug activities in your area you have to qait at least halfhour for them to come to me more young pwople are getting involve in crines these days ages renges from 9-17yrs most of them ends rp in jail by the time they are twenty years old.