Conflict Between the Oral Tradition and the Written Form in The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven
The oral tradition of passing along history, information and stories of culture have been around since the beginning of time. In many cultures today, oral traditions are still the main means of passing down knowledge and history. Several problems arise from the oral tradition as a use of passing along of a people s heritage. Often as it is passed down from generation to generation some information is left out or forgotten. At this point problems arise between the written word and oral tradition. Many Native Americans still use it as a means to carry on the history of their society. The Native Americans are masters of telling stories. They are one of the few peoples without any trouble in keeping the oral tradition alive. They use the oral tradition as a means of enlightening those who have not witnessed the past. The Native Americans carry it close to their hearts. The oral tradition is where their heroes are born. The passing down of their culture through the oral tradition helps to keep their autonomy, yet many Native Americans have abandoned the practice of oral tradition to adapt to modern times and the written word. In his novel The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, Sherman Alexie demonstrates how he Native American population has kept the practice of passing along their heritage through the oral tradition despite the movement to the written word by most of society.
The Indians have always used the oral tradition as a way of immortalizing their heroes. Whether it is a mighty Plains Indian on the hunt over a hundred years ago or a young high school basketball player playing the game of their life. Every time one of the stories is told it is exaggerated a little, making the character or characters in the story greater each time. Of course there are always downfalls though as each of the legendary basketball players was built up in hopes that one-day one of them would make it to college. None of them made and as each generation passes, they pass on the tales of those great players to the next generation hoping that one of the young children on the reservation might make it one day. There was a young man about the age of Victor and those of his generation that has been immortalized in these stories. When Victor asks Adrian about Silas he replies, Do I remember? I was there when he grabbed the defensive rebound and I don t mean it looked like he flew, or it was so beautiful it was almost like he flew. I mean he flew, period. (Alexie, 47) The Indians keep retelling stories like these to keep their heritage alive. Julius Windmaker is one of the players that have been immortalized. Yet he succumbs to material things like alcohol and hope is lost in him. Stories of Julius are passed down through the generations to keep the spirit alive that one might make it off the reservation one day. That is where struggle comes into play between the oral tradition and written word. The telling of stories broadens the imagination and gives birth to hope. The Native Americans needed hope ever since the white man came to the Americas and took over the land that was rightfully the Indians. There is an old saying in sports that says, anybody can look good on paper. The imagination can make things look better though and the Indians continue to use the oral tradition to give a sense of stability in their ever-shaky world.
Thomas Builds-the-Fire is the one that continues to use the oral tradition. He chooses to close his eyes when telling his stories. It s as if Thomas is linked to his stories spiritually when he closes his eyes. Thomas speaks whatever ideas, pictures and visions come to his mind. He has been abandoned by many of his friends for the apparent reason that he has not abandoned the use of the oral tradition. He uses the oral tradition though, not as a means to continue the history of the Coeur d Alene Indians, but to tell stories that come to him. They often have a significant meaning or moral importance. Yet the younger Indians on the reservation do not understand him or the importance of the stories he tells. The other Indians of his generation have given up the oral tradition and moved onto the written word. Thomas stories bored them; therefore many of his generation simply grew tired of hearing his stories. This is an example how the Indians are turning more to the ways of the written word. It may also be due in part to the fact that the younger Indians are like any other young people of the day and age and have a shorter attention span. The main reason for the Indians not listening to Thomas stories is that they have all grown tired of the circumstances surrounding them today and they are fed up with hearing about the past that Thomas tells them about in his stories. Thomas continues to tell his stories although everyone simply ignores him and he is often found telling the stories to himself. Alexie uses Thomas in particular to demonstrate the traditional Native American culture while at the same time showing the struggle of the general Indian population s switch from the oral tradition to written word in one man.
Though the oral tradition is still practiced and held sacred by many today, many of the Native Americans inhabiting our country have changed with time and have adapted the written form. Alexie showed how hard it could be on people to adapt to a new form of passing along information. The tension that he displayed between the traditional ways of the Native Americans and those that they had to adapt to were incredible. It created inner conflict between certain people like Thomas and his peers that would not have been there in earlier times.
Другие работы по теме:
Dr Dolittle Essay Research Paper The Adventures
Dr. Dolittle Essay, Research Paper The Adventures of Doctor Dolittle The book I read was The Adventures of Dr. Dolittle. The author has an excellent writing style and the book is laid out in an easy to read format.
Indian Persecutions Essay Research Paper The text
Indian Persecutions Essay, Research Paper The text we have studied relates to the integration problem between teh white and Indian population of United States : Indians are called Native-Americans because they have lived there for centuries.
The Indians Contribution To Their Problems Essay
, Research Paper Oklahoma History The Indians contridbuted to there problem. When the Spanish came to America there was already an indigenous people here. When Christopher Columbus first came over on the Nina, Pinta and Santa Maria,He thought they were going to find a passage to India so when they saw the people they called them Indians.
War And Peace Of The Crow Indians
Essay, Research Paper Most of the Crow Indians reside in Southeastern Montana, while many others are scattered among the Northern Plains of the USA. The Crow Indians have lived in this area for at least 300 years. Many problems arouse whether they had to do with war, politics, or land ownership issues. The Crow Indians are not known as a war-going tribe, but as a peaceful group who tried to avoid war as much as possible.
Nine Guardians Essay Research Paper Nine Guardians
Nine Guardians Essay, Research Paper Nine Guardians Throughout time man has oppressed his own kind. In The Nine Guardians man, in this case the Spanish man is oppressing the Mexican Indians. Just like history before the oppression of the Mexican Indians the oppressed revolt. In The Nine Guardians when the Indians revolt it causes death, degradation of a family, mental strain to the point of insanity and property damage, just as revolts before it.
Lennie Lenape Essay Research Paper he Lenape
Lennie Lenape Essay, Research Paper he Lenape Indians were the first people to live in what is now called New Jersey. The Lenape Indians lived in parts of Delaware, Pennsylvana, and New Jersey.
To Be An American Essay Research Paper
To Be an American In all of Americas history we have stole bits and pieces of traditions from other cultures. Throughout this we made new traditions of our own. Whether it
The Lottery Essay Research Paper At the
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper At the end of “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, Tessie Hutchinson said, “It isn’t fair.” Tessie was correct; the lottery wasn’t fair. Death wasn’t fair, especially if you were the sacrificial lamb for the sake of tradition.”Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon,” took many innocent lives each year since the first settlers.
Plains Indians Essay Research Paper During the
Plains Indians Essay, Research Paper During the 1800s, the Plains Indians were finally overcome by the white man. Several factors contributed to their downfall. In descending order, these included the near extinction of the buffalo, disease, tribal wars, and their naivete.
Indian Reservation Preservement Essay Research Paper Indian
Indian Reservation Preservement Essay, Research Paper Indian Project The Indians had every right to fight. Their land was being taken away by the whites. They were forcing them out by starving them and compressing them into small reservations. Many of the Indian leaders had felt safe before the whites began attacking and invading their territory.
Indian Movement Essay Research Paper Why were
Indian Movement Essay, Research Paper Why were the Indians forced off their land? a) Land Struggles b) Clash of Cultures Throughout the 1800s America was greatly expanding. As more settlers arrived, more were moving farther and farther west. At this time there were already natives living throughout the land that would one day make up all 50 states.
Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee Essay
, Research Paper Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, by Dee Brown. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1970. In the Introduction, the author tells how he put together a book of the oral history of the American Indians, based on the government records of council meetings with white officials. In these meetings, all Indians were allowed to speak.
I Head The Own Call My Name
– Analytical Essay Essay, Research Paper Although the Indians in I Heard The Owl Call My Name, and in The Black Robe are primitive in the technological sense, they are neither simple or emotional people.
The Seminoles Essay Research Paper The Seminole
The Seminoles Essay, Research Paper The Seminole Indians are a tribe of Indians who now have territory and reservations in Florida and Oklahoma. They once belonged to the Muskogee tribe that lived along
Iroquois Essay Research Paper The Iroquois
Iroquois Essay, Research Paper The Iroquois The Iroquois is a tribe of the Eastern Woodland indians. The Iroquois is one tribe that is seperated into five groups. These groups are called , Seneca ,
Daisy Cisneros
– Response Paper Essay, Research Paper Daisy Cisneros History 202 Response paper It was very hard to them to move from their own country were they grown up. It very difficult to leave something that you love like your relatives and all your memories, all your life its going to stay there then you have start a new life in a country that you are not familiarized with.
Oroonoko IndiansEuropeans Essay Research Paper Discrepancy Between
Oroonoko: Indians/Europeans Essay, Research Paper Discrepancy Between Europeans and Indians in Oroonoko Depicted contrary to the Europeans, who hold themselves at an exclusive level, the Indians are one of the inferior native cultures illustrated in Aphra Behn s classic Oroonoko.
Spirituals And Code Songs Essay Research Paper
Spirituals and ?Code? Songs Spirituals were songs originally used as vector for oral tradition for the African American population. Since they were conveyed orally, there were often times many versions of the same song. Many spirituals were based on African folk tales or rhythms. They were used by slaves in the south to exchange issues of freedom.
The Anasazi Indians Essay Research Paper The
The Anasazi Indians Essay, Research Paper The Anasazi Indians From the scattered references made about the ancient Anasazi Indians in Tony Hillerman’s A Thief of Time, one can identify several cultural
Industrialization Essay Research Paper a Why were
Industrialization Essay, Research Paper a. Why were the Indians treated so unjustly? (12) The American settlers? greed was the basis for the injustice forced upon the Indians. At first the American?s simply wanted the land that could be used to grow or create products. Then the Indians were viewed as hostile enemies.
David And Legend Essay Research Paper The
David And Legend Essay, Research Paper The legend of David and Goliath is a very familiar one to many people. It is an oral legend that has been told from one generation to the next. It has been mostly assumed to be a fictional story. The question is how do we know it is fiction. This is the problem historians have when using the tool of oral bards or legends.
The Valley Essay Research Paper 1 There
The Valley Essay, Research Paper 1. There are several instances in “The Valley” that show that customs and traditions pass on through different generations. The first example takes place with the first sketch, Jehu. Where Hinojosa describes how a girl’s hand in marriage is traditionally asked for. Hinojosa weaves in two different generation performing the same tradition, Roque Malacara, asking for Tere, and Braulio Tapia taking in retro-spect about his own experience, when he too had to face his father-in-law and ask for his wives hand in marriage.
Pueblo Revolt Of 1680 Essay Research Paper
The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 was a very important part of New Mexico history. Because of the fact that there was 2 large groups, (Spaniards and Indians), fighting against each other there were 2 different accounts of what took place. These accounts told what took place and what led to this revolt.
Indian Essay Research Paper IndianTransformation of Native
Indian Essay, Research Paper Indian Transformation of Native American Cultures As the white man killed the buffalo, they also killed off the Indians. Indians needed buffalo to eat, defend, and stay warm. Horses helped both Indians and white man hunt, which killed off buffalo even faster. Guns that the white man brought over enabled the Indians to fight back.
Indians Of The United States Essay Research
Paper Indians of the United States There was a time long ago when there was no man in America, only animals. This was thousands of years before Columbus ever set eyes on America. What he saw was different; he saw a land populated from the north to the south. Due to the natural instinct of man to explore, the explorers just that to figure out the mysterious Indians.
Tradition Roles Essay Research Paper Tradition plays
Tradition Roles Essay, Research Paper Tradition plays an important role in a person’s life as it influences his/her actions and the way he/she thinks. Tradition instinctively shos one how to act, for tradition is merely a routine; something that is done continuously between different time intervals, whether it be a day or years.
Tobacco Use Essay Research Paper Comparative forms
Tobacco Use Essay, Research Paper Comparative forms of tobacco use In 1492 native Indians were smoking rolled up tobacco leaves. In the 16th century tobacco smoking spread to Europe. By the late 1800 tobacco tolled in paper called cigarettes were a major industry with billions being sold each year.
Everyday Use Essay Research Paper Tradition
Everyday Use Essay, Research Paper Tradition: “Everyday Use” and “The Lottery” Essay written by Pia Adams Tradition is an important part of everyone’s life. Some people follow traditions so deeply rooted in their everyday life that they don’t even recognize them as such. Why do you cook rice a certain way? Well, that’s the way Grandma always did it.
Zulu And Indians Essay Research Paper Zulu
Zulu And Indians Essay, Research Paper Zulu and Indians (Asian Indians): Zulu (KwaZulu): A small independent tribe in the North Western Africa. According to oral history, the name Zulu was first heard round about 1620 s.
The Homeric Poems Oral Or Written
Tradition Essay, Research Paper The Homeric Poems: Oral or Written Tradition Homer. A name synonomous with Greek literature and poetry. Some call him the most famous and greatest poet of the Greek society. Known for his “masterpieces” of western literature the Iliad and the Odyssey, Homer’s poems have been passed down through generations and studied by many.
Oral Tradition In Native American Culture Essay
, Research Paper The oral tradition in Native American culture, and it’s affect on modern native writers. “We are Cranes on the rise in new tribal narratives”Wrote Gerald Vizenor in his book, Interior Landscapes. Vizenor is Chippewa, and a descendant of Crane. The crane is a powerful symbol in chippewa tradition.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper The
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper The war of 1812 was one of eight that our country has fought in. This war left us with a loss of people, property, and money. It was started over many things. One of the reasons was the British impressment of American soldiers.
The World Essay Research Paper In an
The World Essay, Research Paper In an important speech, oral delivery is key, ingredients to oral delivery are tone, volume, rate, enthusiasm and clarity, how
Oral Tradition Essay Research Paper Oral TraditionMy
Oral Tradition Essay, Research Paper Oral Tradition My family has many oral traditions. I m not real for sure that there any different than anybody elses. We celebrate every American Holiday. We have very strong Baptist