M Butterfly Essay, Research Paper
M Butterfly RIUve played out the events of my life night after night, always searching for a new ending to my story, one where I will leave this cell and return forever to my ButterflyUs arms.S (Hwang 3.3.1-4) With these words of David Henry HwangUs play M Butterfly, we realize that we have just been staring directly into the memories of Rene Gallimard. The fact that Rene Gallimard serves as the narrator of his memories in the play M Butterfly delivers an impression of the character behind Gallimard than could ever be achieved by the viewing of the screenplay. The existence of Marc in the play as seen from GallimardUs perspective, the fact that Gallimard serves as the main organizer of ideas in the play, and the differing roles of Helga in the two works all lead to very different impressions and interpretations by the reader or viewer. GallimardUs narration seems to be the most obvious difference between the movie and the play. While reading the play, the audience has an opportunity to get to know the personality of Rene Gallimard, as well as his feelings about certain topics. Such insight can be very crucial in the impression that a character makes on an audience. GallimardUs persona is very evident in the opening lines of the play. He remarks initially about the dimensions of the cell, the atmosphere, and the living conditions. Immediately, this paints a picture for the reader that is very accurate physically, and the reader sees that Gallimard is straightforward, and says what he means without very much preamble. As the opening scenes develop, we also see the side of Gallimard that is the dreamer. Rene definitely has visions of perfection, and they are demonstrated when he remarks RAlone in this cell, I sit night after night, watching our story play through my head, always searching for a new ending, one which redeems my honor , where she returns at last to my arms.S (1.3.7-11) Gallimard can be classified as a dreamer, and not only because he is confined to a prison cell for many years. He has a vision of how life is supposed to be, and feels rewarded when he conforms to a stereotype. For example, he says RI knew this little flower was waiting for me to call, and, as I wickedly refused to do so, I felt the first time that rush of power — the absolute power of a man.S (1.11. 8-10) Being Ra manS is important to Gallimard, and following the so called RWestern FantasyS of having an affair with an Eastern woman is tantalizing to him. Glimpses like these give the reader incredible insight into the mind of Gallimard, which are very useful to explain later actions in the story. A narrator builds a friendship with the reader, a person that the audience can trust. We see the events from GallimardUs side of things, which are much more distorted in the play than the events that occur in the movie. The removal of the narrator in the movie leaves the viewer to develop GallimardUs personality for themselves, rather than get to know how he thinks. This puts the viewer at an overall disadvantage for understanding the true meaning behind M Butterfly. Another significant part of the play that is omitted from the movie is GallimardUs best friend from school, Marc. Marc is described as a Rwomanizing cadS (1.3. 81) by Gallimard, giving the reader an obvious first impression. He is developed as a character that is there for Gallimard in times of need, and serves as someone that Gallimard can go to in times of need. A friend like this does not exist in the movie, and the viewer gets the sense that Gallimard is very quick in decision making and has little doubt about his actions. In the play, however, we know that this is not the case. There are several cases where Marc talks to Gallimard in his head, and reasoning for decisions is explained. For example, Marc says RAll your life youUve waited for a beautiful girl who would lay down for you…..As the years pass, your hair thins and you struggle to hold onto even your hopes. Stop struggling, Rene. The wait is over.S (1.9.62, 67-69) Marc could be called the devilUs advocate, as he seems to push Gallimard in the direction of pursuing his Butterfly. When Gallimard remarks that he is married and should not have an affair, Marc rebuts with RAnd an excellent one [married man] too. I cheated after……six months.S (1.9. 40-41) In the movie, Gallimard makes the
decision on his own and the viewer is never exposed to the thought process. Given that if every thought process was revealed the movie would run about six hours, it seems that the important decisions are not pondered. When the reader gets a chance to see these thought processes, it gives them a sense of who Gallimard is, how he was brought up, and how the people that he respects behave. On the other hand, the omission of this information gives the viewer of the movie no idea what Gallimard values, which in turn forces the viewer to believe that Gallimard had no trouble making these decisions and has no remorse or conscience. Both presentations create amazingly different pictures, and in turn create very different impressions. Once again, the narration in the play creates a very different image of Gallimard than the relative straight-forwardness of the movie. Another character who is very different between both the movie and the play is that of GallimardUs wife, Helga. Though a seemingly minor character in both works, her relevance is very important when discussing the character of Gallimard. In the play, the physical appearance of Helga not given, however one can only conclude that she is not particularly attractive, as the second scene of the first act describes. A woman remarks RWell, heUs not very good looking.S (1.2. 22) When immediately faced with these impressions, one can assume that a man who is fairly unattractive and has never had much with love with women would be married to a woman on similar terms. Also, there is no time at which Gallimard speaks openly about his wife, giving the reader a sense that she is not important to him. Thus, the picture of Helga is created. This picture is not shown in the movie, as Jeremy Irons does not show any type of misfortune with respect to his previous love life. In fact, the idea that Gallimard in the movie has a wife and eventually has two mistresses creates the image that Gallimard is a lady’s man, and might have had similar affairs previously. Strangely enough, these two conflicting interpretations are both acceptable within the context of each the movie and the play. Helga seems to show her face more in the play to inspire a small feeling that what Gallimard is doing is wrong. In the movie, Helga is hardly heard from, thus the viewer decides that they are married only by law, and therefore cheating on his wife is not terrible. At the end of the play, Gallimard tells Helga that he has been cheating, and her reaction is humorous. She accepts the fact that he has been cheating, and even mentions that she expected it when she says RI knew you would. I knew you would the day I married you.S (2.11.47-48) A comment like this proves the earlier impression that the reader achieved when they believed that ReneUs wife was far from important to him. Obviously, Helga was not in love with Gallimard just as he was not in love with her, and both finally understood each otherUs position. This final blow to GallimardUs credibility is only hinted at in the movie, with the depiction of Gallimard living by himself in an apartment until his Butterfly finds him in France. Again, the audienceUs perception of GallimardUs personality is different in both of these cases, with the reader of the play finding Gallimard with less and less credibility while the viewer of the movie sees the course of events as natural. This is another example of the mental creation necessary to construct the story of the play while the movie simply feeds the audience with information. In conclusion, the audienceUs perception of Rene Gallimard is much different in the play M Butterfly than in the movie of the same title. Although David Henry Hwang wrote both the play and the screenplay, the character development is far greater in the play. The reader must create a picture of Gallimard by his impressions, reactions, and interactions with characters from his past that simply do not exist in the movie. Marc, GallimardUs best friend from school, does not exist in the movie, but is the voice inside GallimardUs head throughout the play. Helga, who exists in both works, has much more bearing in the book, again shaping the readerUs impression of the kind of man that Gallimard really is. The fact that the play employs a narrator and the movie does not leads the reader down a different path, especially when the narrator is Rene Gallimard himself. The human mind is one that is capable of creating its own world. When viewing the movie, one sees a sense of Rene GallimardUs world. When reading the play, one understands his world.
31d
Другие работы по теме:
Robert Frost Essay Research Paper It has
Robert Frost Essay, Research Paper It has been said many times that all men have a common bond, or a thread that joins them together. Robert Frost?s poem ?The Tuft of Flowers? explores the existence of such a bond, as experienced by the speaker. In the everyday circumstance of performing a common chore, the speaker discovers a sense of brotherhood with another laborer.
Pale Fire Essay Research Paper Pale Fire
Pale Fire Essay, Research Paper Pale Fire, by Vladimir Nabokov, is a complex text made up of four parts. Three of the parts, the foreword, commentary, and index, are narrated by Dr. Charles Kinbote. The fourth part is a long poem written by a character named John Shade. There is much confusion as to the true identity of the narrator Kinbote, but for the sake of simplicity, I have taken the view that Dr.
Mines Essay Research Paper AntiPersonnel landmines have
Mines Essay, Research Paper Anti-Personnel landmines have been used in many wars even though the users and makers know how horrible they are, and what they do to people that are innocent, and more so, know what they do to children. Unlike the eye of a soldier, a landmine cannot differentiate between a civilian and a soldier.
David Belasco Essay Research Paper David Belasco
David Belasco Essay, Research Paper David Belasco was born in San Fransisco, California, on July 25,1853. Hisparents had come to California from London in the gold rush. Belasco grew upin San Fransisco and Victoria, British Columbia. His early education in a RomanCatholic monastery influenced his simple mode of dress and helped earn him the nickname Bishop of Broadway.
Dr. Heidegger
’s Experiment Essay, Research Paper Reality or Illusion In Nathaniel Hawthorne?s short story Dr. Heidegger?s Experiment, one of the central ideas of the story revolves around the idea of reality versus illusion. Of course the
Atwoods Theory Of Canadian Short Stories Essay
, Research Paper Atwoods Theory of Canadian Short Stories Margaret Atwood detects that in most Canadian stories there seems to be some sort of victim and their quest for survival. In the stories The Wedding Gift, The Butterfly Ward, and Skald, we find three of her four types of victims. First there are creative non-victims who are successful at not being victims, secondly, there are victims who acknowledge the fact that they are victims but who blame their situations on something they cannot control, like fate.
Forever Failure Essay Research Paper Forever FailureEverything
Forever Failure Essay, Research Paper Forever Failure Everything was peaceful in my Haudenosaunee village. There were some disputes on land from time to time with other villages, but they were never as greedy as these white bearded monsters. They not only took away our homes, but also the land of our ancestors.
Nature
’s Presence Essay, Research Paper Nature=s Presence It was sunny one afternoon campus. The sun was high in the sky. I was sitting underneath a weeping willow tree, with the sun at my back. Watching the birds fly over head and the ground hogs chase each other by my feet. Trying to follow the path of the ground hog, before it descended to its= underground layer was making me dizzy.
Bell Jar Essay Research Paper The Bell
Bell Jar Essay, Research Paper The Bell Jar is about a young reporter, Esther Greenwood, and her life during an all expenses paid trip to New York in the 1950?s. Esther won the month long
Love 2 Essay Research Paper LoveBenjamin Franklin
Love 2 Essay, Research Paper Love Benjamin Franklin once said, “If you would be loved, love and be lovable.” Love is something we are all in at least one time or another in our life. There are many different meanings for the word love and many people interpret it differently. Love as defined by Webster s dictionary is a profoundly tender, passionate affection for another person.
Chaos Theory Essay Research Paper Chaos TheoryWhen
Chaos Theory Essay, Research Paper Chaos Theory When Edward Lorenz decided to run his meteorology test from a halfway point in order to save time he had no idea that he would stumble on one of the largest theories of our time. In 1961 he took the data from a computer printout and entered it into the system. The information he was using was the data sheets from a previous test he had run.
Poetry Of Robert Frost Essay Research Paper
A Look at the Theme of Separation in the Poetry of Robert Frost The creation of borders and boundaries has been around since the beginning of civilization. The division of property and possessions among individuals establishes a sense of self-worth. The erection of fences and walls keeps property separate.
Lying In A Hammock At William Duffy
’s Farm In Pine Island, Minnesota Essay, Research Paper Lying in a Hammock at William Duffy’s Farm in Pine Island, Minnesota by James Wright Over my head, I see the bronze butterfly,
Monarch Butterflies Coevolution With Milkweed Essay Research
Paper Monarch Butterflies (Danaus plexippus) and Butterfly Weed (Asclepias tuberosa) Monarch Butterflies and Butterfly Weed, a type of milkweed, have coevolved as plant and pollinator. This means that they both rely on one another to survive. Milkweed is the primary source of nutrition for monarchs.
Helen
’s Garden Essay, Research Paper -Journal- Helen s Garden With the advent of the warm season upon me I decided to explore my new surroundings in a new town. I had driven past a beautiful garden setting
Valves Essay Research Paper Valves The primary
Valves Essay, Research Paper Valves The primary purpose of a valve is to direct the flow of fluids by starting, stopping, and throttling flow to make modern processing possible. Valves are designed to withstand pressure temperature, and flow, and can be found in homes and industry across the world. The most common valves found in the manufacturing industry are gate, globe, ball, check, butterfly, plug, needle, three-way, diaphragm, relief, angle, and multiport.
Three Rules For A Good Book Essay
, Research Paper The two books that I read this summer are: “California Blue” by David Klass, and “Mr. Tucket” by Gary Paulsen.”There are three rules for writing a good book. Unfortunately no one knows what
Poem About Life Moving Too Fast Essay
, Research Paper Slow Dance Have you ever watched kids on a merry-go-round? Or listened to the rain slapping on the ground? Ever followed a butterfly’s erratic flight?
Slow Dance Essay Research Paper S L
Slow Dance Essay, Research Paper S L O W D A N C E: *BR* *br* Have you ever watched kids*br* on a merry-go-round*br* Or listened to the rain*br* slapping on the ground?*br**br*
Butterfly Revolution Essay Research Paper Dear Mom
Butterfly Revolution Essay, Research Paper Dear Mom and Dad, This camp you sent me to is so crazy! I was really starting to like it at first. I had a lot of fun playing the games and meeting the people. Everyone excepted me for who I
Rorsachach Ink Blot Test Essay Research Paper
Rorsachach Ink Blot Test The Rorschach inkblot test is a psychological projective test of personality in which a subjects interpretations of ten standard abstract designs are analyzed as measure of emotional and intellectual functioning and integration. The test was named after Hermann Rorschach a Swiss psychiatrist who lived from 1884-1922.
Chicken Or Egg Essay Research Paper Which
Chicken Or Egg Essay, Research Paper Which came first, Chicken? Or Egg? The answer is that this is the wrong question. The trouble here is the word ‘First’s. A human life contains many firsts, so the word comes easily to our lips. For example, a creationist could ask how the metamorphosis of a butterfly occurred for the ‘First time’.
Symbols In Hesse
’s Demian Essay, Research Paper In Other Words: Symbolically Representing Transformation A physical transformation is an incredible thing to watch. Whether it is a butterfly emerging from its cocoon, or a child growing up, it is always interesting to see the “before and after”. In the novel, Demian, the character Sinclair goes through a series of transformations prompted by his ongoing relationship with the Demian family.
Olympic Legends Essay Research Paper Tristan YapuncichOlympic
Olympic Legends Essay, Research Paper Tristan Yapuncich Olympic Legends 9/21/00 Olympic Legends There are many important Olympic athletes. Three of the most amazing, however, are probably Jim Thorpe, Florence Griffith Joyner, and Mark Spitz. These legends were suberb athletes as well, as amazing people.
Lady Macbeth In The Tragedy Of Macbeth
: The Essay, Research Paper Lady Macbeth in The Tragedy of Macbeth; the “Iron Butterfly” In William Shakespeare’s, The Tragedy of Macbeth, Lady Macbeth is the dominator of the play. Lady Macbeth’s character is not as eclectic as her husband’s but it is just as dramatic. Lady Macbeth has a rich and fascinating combination of qualities.
Lord Of Fliez Essay Research Paper The
Lord Of Fliez Essay, Research Paper The Red Dress and The Day of The Butterfly are two very interesting stories, written by an exceptional Canadian author, Alice Munro. Both of these stories are well written and can be associated with what goes on in today s society. The principal characters, human relationships, and the importance of symbolism exist, in both of these stories, strongly.
The Butterfly Revolution Essay Research Paper After
The Butterfly Revolution Essay, Research Paper After reading the book, ?The Butterfly Revolution,? I have concluded that the story was great. I give the book two thumbs up. I give the book two thumbs up because it is a smooth and easy reading. The book also has a good flow of events, the book is written in a first-hand account form, the books reading level is that of its suspected readers, (young adults), and has great, descriptive writing.
WHAT YOU MEAN TO ME Essay Research
Paper WHAT YOU MEAN/MEANT TO ME WHEN I SEE YOU WALK BY, WHEN YOU DON’T STOP TO SAY HI, ALL I CAN DO IS SIT BACK AND SY, FOR I CAN’T FORGET THAT TIME, THAT TIME WHEN YOU MADE ME CRY,
M Butterfly Essay Research Paper M ButterflyAct
M. Butterfly Essay, Research Paper M. Butterfly Act 1, scene 11, Gallimard, the love stricken French Diplomat in China announces his decision to try an experiment. (Act 1, Scene 11). Upon thinking up this experiment, he reverts back to a memory of Madame Butterfly where Cio-Cio-San fears that the western man who catches a butterfly will pierce its heart with a needle, then leave it to perish. (Act 1, Scene 11).
Swimming Essay Research Paper SwimmingSwimming is the
Swimming Essay, Research Paper Swimming Swimming is the act of moving through the water by using the arms, legs, and body in motions called strokes. The most common strokes are the crawl, backstroke, breaststroke, butterfly, and sidestroke.
Macbeath Essay Research Paper Anthony Sears12298Period 2Macbeth
Macbeath Essay, Research Paper Anthony Sears 12-2-98 Period 2 Macbeth Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are two megalomaniacs. Their actions in the first two acts are very childish and selfish. Their lust for power and control over runs their lives and becomes something to die for. Lady Macbeth is very persuasive, and Macbeth will almost follow her very word.
An Exceptional Butterfly Essay Research Paper An
An Exceptional Butterfly Essay, Research Paper An Exceptional Butterfly The grass was covered with delicate, colorful flowers and the meadows were never-ending. Each natural object was carefully placed as if Mother Nature had a specific place in mind. The warming sun shined brightly on the beautiful green grass.
Illusion In M Butterfly Essay Research Paper
Illusion in M. Butterfly In David Henry Hwang’s play M. Butterfly we are introduced to Rene Gallimard who has unknowingly been sexually involved with another man for twenty years. The idea of mistaken gender within the play causes the reader to question how could one mistake his/her lover’s gender for so long? In Rene Gallimard’s search for self-identity he ignorantly chooses illusion over reality.
Butterfly Moon By Tauna M Robley Essay
, Research Paper Butterfly Moon by Tauna M. Robley Tika pulled her curtains open. Her long golden hair reflected the moon’s rays. “Hello Moon,” Tika said.