– “Zero-Tolerance? Justice Essay, Research Paper
Three Strikes Law
In recent years the surge in the population of the world has brought about new areas of concern for sociologists and criminologists. With more and more people populated our nation there is greater need for government-regulated programs to adapt with the increase. One aspect of society that has had to rapidly adjust itself constantly is the Criminal Justice system. The growing population has put pressure on the criminal justice system to decide on a method of maintaining order. There are currently two broad scopes on dealing with the problem of population control; one is the idea that we need to establish a system that keeps offenders out of prison, offering alternative punishments than incarceration to keep prisons from overcrowding. Another idea is that we need to make an example that will deter others from committing similar acts of deviance. It is this ideology that has berthed the new wave of ?zero-tolerance? justice. A form of this is the new concept of mandatory minimums. These laws require a pre-defined punishment for certain crimes no matter what the situation. A subset of these laws is the ?three strikes laws? that are being adopted by more and more states. These laws give a three-time offender a very harsh punishment once convicted of his or her third crime regardless of any mitigating factors.
First I would like to explain the ideology behind mandatory minimum sentencing. It is based on the idea that if you take an offender off the street after committing multiple serious felonies then you stop him or her from committing more. Simple plan, difficult execution. For example a man writes two bad checks in two separate instances and is convicted on it each time?boom two strikes on his record. Now two months later he walks out of a restaurant without paying his bill, as he is leaving he runs into four policemen stopping by for a coffee and sweet, rounded pastry to quell their growling stomachs. The man is arrested for theft and waits his court date. The day comes and he stands in front of the judge preparing for his punishment. He hears it and falls to his knees, twenty-five years to life in prison?for stiffing and Eat-N-Park on a bill for $4.49.
The rest of his life has been decided for him, not by the prosecution, and not by the judge, but instead by the state government. Due to the ?three-strikes law? our friend has ?struck out?, his third offense lands him a strict punishment. Because he has already accrued two felony convictions prior to this one, regardless that they were non-violent, he is going to be sent up the river, sharing a sentence with serial killers, rapists, and bank robbers?only difference is that they all have a chance for parole.
So three strikes seems like a gross exaggeration of the law, a true abomination of the justice system, cruel and unusual even. It is not that easy. What about when a child molester gets out on parole and kidnaps another, putting them through the same hell that he did the last child. He is a man that was to be rehabilitated by a state institution, deemed ?safe for society, and yet he slides into society and rips from it the innocence of youth. When this man steps in front of the judge and his time is before him, 25 years to life, everyone agrees that the punishment is just. The idea behind mandatory minimum sentencing has positive possibilities but politicians and high-ranking officials skew these motives. A senator will push for mandatory minimums to look like he or she is taking a ?bite out of crime?, not standing for ?soft touch? treatment of criminals. But what are they really doing, do they really care about the population or are they just trying to push a program that sounds like the end of crime to secure votes. Instead of analyzing the subject politicians try to use mandatory minimum sentencing as a ?quick fix? to crime. But they are building their houses on a foundation of sand. Pushing these regulations through before they are ready is like a chef sending out a chicken breast half done, just to appease the customer for that moment. The chef gets paid; the customer goes home and a few hours later throws-up for a week. Mandatory minimum laws require intense study before applying them to society. Instead like we see with so many things, society acts as the guinea pig to government programs that have never left the drawing board before their implementation.
A major problem mandatory minimum sentencing regulations that I found in my research was the fact that they took judges discretion out of the equation. They were virtually handcuffed by the regulations. If a judge has no choice on the punishment then what is his or her purpose really? If a jury finds an offender guilty of their third felony then bang?twenty-five to life in prison. All the judge can do is sign the papers. This problem is being tended to in most states though. Judges are now being given the ability to ignore prior offenses of an offender in order to prevent three-strikes laws from coming into effect. But then are they really ?mandatory minimums?? By definition what made these regulations mandatory was that there was no option. Now the judge can utilize their discretion in deciding what cases will go to the mandatory minimum.
The second problem that I identified from the reading was the criminal population that was being effected most by mandatory minimum sentencing guidelines. The original idea was that these laws would keep serious and violent offenders off the streets, but in fact eighty-five percent of those who fall under the blanket of three-strikes laws are felons convicted of minor felonies such as drug possession, or petty theft. We are filling and overfilling our nations prisons with people, who are given sentences that deny rehabilitation, when the focus should be on punishing them and trying to prepare them for a functional existence in society. For mandatory minimum laws to be effective they need to have a clearly defined focus on crimes that have a clear victim, and committed in a violent manner, with serious results. If a man walks out on a four-dollar bill for lunch is he seriously injuring the restaurant? Is this an action deserving to be defined as a strike that two more like will send him to prison for the rest of his life? The answer is no. This focus on incarceration and exodus from the idea of rehabilitation is resulting in a massive overcrowding in United States prisons.
Incarceration is the dealing with criminals by taking them out of society. It is a method in which there is no focus on fixing the problem at its source, simply moving it to a secluded area. Out of sight out of mind. Rehabilitation is the method in which the institution attempts to change the offender?s outlook. They try to teach them functional manners for participating in society. An example could be educating criminals while they are in prison, giving them an opportunity to act in society without needing to rely on deviant routes. Mandatory minimum laws are an example of incarceration. They have the sole purpose of removing from society an offender that has proven that given the opportunity to exist in society they will abuse and injure other members, and will continue to do so at every chance. Now if you have a petty thief that is stealing because of they need to sustain an existence, then you have a good chance of rehabilitation if you present the opportunity to utilize socially functional means to attain economic stability. Many times opportunities are not offered to all people equally, this causes those who are shut out from legitimate chances to rely on anti-social acts to survive. By offering opportunity more evenly across the levels of society you take away the need for deviant routes of attaining goals.
In summary I feel that mandatory minimum sentencing laws are only truly effective on paper. There are too many mitigating factors that affect their true form when being exercised. Whether it be human bias, or prejudice there won?t be a means of ever having a regulation that works across the board. Problems with these regulations include the broad range of crimes it associates together, who it is really effecting, and is it really the best means of improving our society. These laws need to have a focus on only violent crimes against people to prevent abuse of the regulations and overcrowding in our prisons. I believe that those people who act against another in a way that injures the victim in a way that cannot be reversed belong locked away for a long time, but those who are merely trying to play the hand dealt to them by society simply need guidance. If society is going to punish someone for an act of deviance they must be sure that the individual is offered a chance at legitimate means, otherwise who is really to blame?
Bibliography
1. Applegate, Brandon K.? Assessing public support for three-strikes-and-you’re-out laws :Global versus specific attitudes?. Crime & Delinquency. v42 n4. Oct 1996. p. 517-534 (18 pages).
2. Benekos, Peter J.? Three strikes and you’re out! :The political sentencing game?. Federal Probation. v59 n1. Mar 1995. p. 3-9.
3. Cox, Gail Diane. ?3-Strike Debate Flares in Calif.?. The National Law Journal. Monday, July 15, 1996. p 6 (1 page).
4. DiIulio, John J Jr. ?Against mandatory minimums?. National Review. v51 n9. May 17, 1999. p. 46-51 (5 pages).
5. DiSpoldo, Nick.? Three-strikes laws?. Commonweal. v123 n12. Jun 14, 1996. p. 10- 11.
6. Lungren, Dan. ?Three cheers for 3 strikes?. Policy Review. n80. Nov 1996. p. 34-38 (5 pages).
7. McMurry, Kelly.??Three-strikes? laws proving more show than go?. Trial. January 1997. p 12-14 (3 pages).
8. McMurry, Kelly.?California Supreme Court Throws Three-Strikes Law a Judicial Curve?. Trial. August 1996. p 42 (1 page).
9. Reske, Henry J.? Three strikes, you might be out?. ABA Journal. v82. Sep 1996. p. 26.
10. ?Three strikes, you’re hoodwinked?. Economist. v330 n7849. Feb 5, 1994. p. 16-18.
11. ?Three strikes, join the queue?. Economist. v330 n7855. Mar 19, 1994. p. 28.
12. ?Three steaks and you’re out?. Economist. 1995. Nov 11. p. 54.
Другие работы по теме:
Three Strikes Law Essay Research Paper Californias
Three Strikes Law Essay, Research Paper California?s ?3-Strikes Law? In California there is a law known as the ?3-Strikes Law.? Other states such as Delaware, Florida, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, and a few other states have also adopted this law. (2) This ?3-Strikes and Your Out Law,? states that if a person has two previous violent or serious felony convictions, he or she is sentenced to a life sentence with no chance of parole.(1) It also states that if a person has one previous violent or serious felony conviction (which includes burglary of an unoccupied dwelling) he or she is sentenced to twice the term prescribed by law for each new felony. (1) California has taken this law to an extreme.
Eugenics And A Brave New World Essay
, Research Paper Eugenics. The word strikes fear in the hearts of many. Visions of Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, along with memories of Nazi experimentation and the Lynchburg sterilization colonies in the United States, cause many to dismiss the idea of cloning immediately. However, in reality, cloning has nothing to do with eugenics or genetic engineering.
Saddam Insane Essay Research Paper Saddam Hussein
Saddam Insane! Essay, Research Paper Saddam Hussein is back with avengeance, and his threats of world destruction aren’t to be taken lightly. The United States tried unsuccessfully to target him during the Gulf War in February 1991, however, they confidently expected the Iraq leader to be gone within months.
Aids Essay Research Paper AIDS is probably
Aids Essay, Research Paper AIDS is probably the most known and most deadly disease in the nation and probably in the whole world. It is a disease that strikes anywhere, anytime, and anyone. That is why I believe sex education is a very beneficial and effective way to let people know about AIDS.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I have
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I have an opinion on many subjects. Whether or not you agree with it is your opininon. This country, being a free country, gives me the right to persuade you to see things my way. This is my goal with the following essay.
Stand Essay Research Paper Stephen King
Stand Essay, Research Paper Stephen King’s The Stand is a thrilling novel that portrays the forces of good against evil. In the year 1991, a plague strikes America, leaving only a few
College Essay If You Could Meet Anyone
, Who Would It Be And Why – Polonius Of Hamlet Essay, Research Paper College Essay: If You Could Meet Anyone, Who Would It Be and Why – Polonius of Hamlet Polonius, father of Laertes, in William Shakespear’s Hamlet, strikes me as
Business Income In Ny 1998 Essay Research
Paper Project on business income for NY The principle source of income for the state of New York for 1998 is taxes. (in millions) Real Property 7,217 Sales and use 3,121
Kosovo Essay Research Paper Kosovo US Involvement
Kosovo Essay, Research Paper Kosovo U.S. Involvement in Kosovo War has been waged in the Balkans for thousands of years. Yugoslavia has been divided, reunited, divided again, undergone wars and been through depressions. Each country within the Yugoslavia region has experienced hardships due to a failing economy, poor leadership, and civil wars.
William Shakespeare Essay Research Paper Amazing authors
William Shakespeare Essay, Research Paper Amazing authors can induce thoughts by a single word. The ideas that can form in our heads by a small phrase are powerful. Only the most talented and capable authors can provoke such feelings within us. Who is more than able to stir these feelings in a reader but William Shakespeare? His various plays keep us entranced and curious but it is his poetry that strikes a chord deep within us.
Cinderella Essay Research Paper Reading to young
Cinderella Essay, Research Paper Reading to young children has become difficult because the selection has become so limited. For example, I have read three versions of Cinderella, Ashputtle by Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm, When the Clock Strikes by Tanith Lee, and Walt Disney s Cinderella by Campbell Grant.
Spousal Abuse In Their Eyes Were Watching
God Essay, Research Paper The theme of violence is very evident in Zora Neale Hurston?s novel, ?Their Eyes Were Watching God.? One of these evident violent actions is spousal abuse. Harsh words that cannot be recalled are spoken in moments of anger or stress. Verbal and physical abuse are as old as human relationships.
The Apprenticeship Of Duddy Kr Essay Research
Paper The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz The novel Duddy Kravitz is based in Montreal, Canada during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. The key features of the work by Mordecai Richler that strikes me, is that during this period possessing land was very important to people in Canada. Canada use to have lands divided amongst the class and race of the people.
Mr Essay Research Paper For Crane he
Mr Essay, Research Paper For Crane, he uses Maggie: A Girl of the Streets to tell a story of a girl, born into a life of misery, who has no way of escaping it. Thus, the story strikes an emotional chord in the readers? hearts and the audience empathizes with Maggie?s conditions. Crane believes in the concept of “lifting the veil” and envisions a society that can look past physical differences.
JAWS THE BOOK Essay Research Paper In
JAWS THE BOOK Essay, Research Paper In Jaws terror strikes. This terror is what fuels the story. When the first attack is learned by the worn everyone is gripped with fear. As more die this grip tightens and slowly chokes the town. The terror starts because the killer is unseen and unknown, impossible to see and impossible to escape.
Does God Exist Essay Research Paper Where
Does God Exist? Essay, Research Paper Where is God? The question does God exist is the one that most likely comes up in the minds of people when disaster strikes or tragedy occurs. Why would he let the creation he most dearly loves suffer so greatly? I am going to try to answer this question as difficult as it may seem to some people.
Was Bill Clinton A Good President Essay
, Research Paper Was William Jefferson Clinton a good president? In my opinion, Bill Clinton was not a good president. I am not saying he was the worst one we have ever had, but he did a lot of things to give himself a bad name to the citizens of the United States of America.
Nato Vs Serbia Essay Research Paper If
Nato Vs. Serbia Essay, Research Paper If NATO continues to bomb Serbia, they will be causing serious trouble. They should just mind their own business before any other altercations occur. NATO is just a big act, because their not even putting their full effort into helping Kosovo. This is just a big stunt to make NATO look good.
The Eagle By Robert Browning Essay Research
Paper The Eagle By Robert Browning When I first read this poem my initial reaction was that this is about religion. It suggests a god-like presents, by implying that he over sees all from up above, close to the sun. He stands “ringed” or surrounded by the “azure”, or blue-sky world. This creature overlooks from high above at the churning sea, and the mountain walls.
Landscaping Essay Research Paper Computer Hacking BasicsComputer
Landscaping Essay, Research Paper Computer Hacking Basics Computer hacking is very popular. With every thing on the Internet having to cost something. Someone will try to hack that database and retrieve free information. As every on knows but doesn?t take very seriously is that hacking is illegal. Hacking is anywhere from hacking in to the school data base and change your grades to make a stop light change with a special clicker.
To What Extent Did The Home Front
In Britain Affect The Outcome Of The Second World War Essay, Research Paper To what extent did the Home Front in Britain affect the outcome of the Second World War? In September 1939 Britain went to
General Patton Part III Essay Research Paper
We see him hold his binoculars, peering at the enemy. He planed well and showed it on the way he handles the attack. He carefully placed the army units for battle. These military units are covered in camouflage to match the environment that they lay in. Then, he strikes calling the units to “fire at will.” Later, when he fights in another battle, his soldiers are having trouble crossing the river.
Mononucleosis Essay Research Paper Mononucleosis is an
Mononucleosis Essay, Research Paper Mononucleosis is an infectious virus caused by the Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV), one of the Herpesviruses. Mononucleosis is also called mono, the kissing disease, and glandular fever. It usually strikes people in the ten to thirty-five year old age group, but it can also infect younger people.
Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela has
Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela has played an important and controversial role in the history of South Africa and establishing South Africa as a Democratic country. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was
Terrorism Essay Research Paper Terrorism is becoming
Terrorism Essay, Research Paper Terrorism is becoming more and more of a threat to Americans both at home and abroad. International terrorism happens when terrorism occurs out of our country. An example of an
Chicken Pox Vs Tubercolosis Essay Research Paper
CHICKEN POX OR VARICELLA TUBERCULOSIS OR TUBERCLE BACILLI HISTORY OF CHICKEN POX Chicken pox, a highly contagious disease that strikes many people, is caused by the herpes zoster virus. The virus is transmitted by the respiratory system and carried in the bloodstream to all parts of the body. The main symptom is a rash that appears on the face and torso, but also on the extremities.
The Early Labor Movement Essay Research Paper
The Early Labor Movement, 1794- 1836 The early labor movement, between 1794 and 1836 had many strengths and weaknesses. Leadership of skilled workers in the union movement and the increased demand for these workers in the building trades were two of these strengths. Also important were the success of strikes for the ten-hour workday and the creation of the Working Men’s party.
A Summary Of West Side Story Essay
, Research Paper West Side Story The drama/musical, which parodies the story of Romeo & Juliet, takes place in a city of New York, probably in the early 50 s late 40 s. It is a tale of two rival gangs, which despises the other in a vicious circle of hate. Riff leader of the Jets; a group mainly of Polish origin and the Sharks of Spanish origin with their leader Bernardo.
John L Lewis Essay Research Paper Allan
John L Lewis Essay, Research Paper Allan Breden February 24, 2000 A working man’s man John L. Lewis John L. Lewis started life in Lucas County, Iowa February 12, 1880 the son of Thomas Lewis, a coal miner and policeman. John was welsh born. In the 1880’s and the 1890’s their family lived in a company owned shanty with an outdoor privy.
Forged Under The Sun Essay Research Paper
Forged Under the Sun American Indian stories is the story of an Indian girl’s childhood experiences and how she went to school and also talks about the different Indian customs. The book sarts out with how her
Three Strikes And You
’re Out Essay, Research Paper Running head: THREE STRIKES Three Strikes and You’re Out Kelly Jay Stewart CRIM 440 21 November 2000 Three Strikes and You’re Out
Against Three Strikes Essay Research Paper Against
Against Three Strikes Essay, Research Paper Against Three Strikes By failing to report his change of address, Eric Barr fell victim to California’s three strikes law and was sentenced to 25 years-to-life without the possibility of parole. Yes, Eric Barr broke the law and should be punished, but to send him to prison for the rest of his life for this offense is absurd.
Strike Out Three Strikes Essay Research Paper
Strike Out Three StrikesLast year in California voters approved a controversial ballot initiative. Proposition 184, also known as the three strikes and you’re out law, was passed onNovember 9, 1994. Under this new legislation repeat offenders, upon committing theirthird felony offense, will be sentenced to a mandatory twenty-five years to life inprison(California 667).