Last year in California voters approved a controversial ballot initiative.
Proposition 184, also known as the three strikes and you’re out law, was passed on
November 9, 1994. Under this new legislation repeat offenders, upon committing their
third felony offense, will be sentenced to a mandatory twenty-five years to life in
prison(California 667). The initiative passed by a landslide, with 76% of the voters in
favor of it. The State Senate soon after voted the bill into law, with only seven members
voting against it. The three strikes initiative stemmed from the killing of Polly Klass by
Richard Allen Davis, a convicted felon. The killing outraged the entire state but what
enraged people even more was that Davis had been in and out of prison his whole life and
was still free to kill again. Soon people began calling for laws that would put repeat
violent offenders behind bars for life. The premise of the new laws became an easy issue
for politicians to back. To oppose such legislation seemed to be political suicide, so most
politicians backed the initiative. Although many civil liberties groups opposed such
mandatory sentencing measures there was little they could in the face of tremendous voter
approval. Many voters did not realize that this bill could put potentially incarcerate people
for ludicrous amounts after the commission of a minor offense. Even more voters did not
realize the cost of implementing such a bill. Now that this new legislation has been in
effect for a year and the tremendous negative effects it have become obvious we must
repeal it.
One of the issues that must be considered when imposing mandatory sentencing is
the increased cost of incarceration. In the state of California it costs $20,000 per year to
incarcerate an inmate under normal circumstances(Cost 1). This amount of money could
put one person through a state college for two or three years. According to Beth Carter
the three strikes law has placed 1,300 people in prison for a third strike offense and 14,000
people in prison on a second strike offense(1). The current recidivism rate in California is
70%(2), which means that out of those 14,000 people that almost 10,000 will be back in
prison for a third strike. To imprison those 1,300 third strike offenders for the mandatory
minimum of twenty-five years will cost the state of California $812,500,000. To support
these inmates for longer periods of time we will have to increase the amount of money
going to our prison system. This means that either spending in other areas will be cut or
an increase of taxes. Neither of which is highly favored by voters. On a national level the
Justice Departments budget has increased an alarming 162% since 1987(Cost 2). The
money that is being spent incarcerating these people can be more well spent in other areas.
The money can be spent on crime prevention and rehabilitation, rather than retribution.
Before the three strikes law was enacted it had been estimated that to keep up with the
growing prison population on a national level that it was necessary to spend $100,000,000
per week on our prison system(Ogutu). Now that we will be having more and more
criminals behind bars we shall have to spend even more money building and keeping up
our overcrowded prisons. Of these people that taxpayers are paying to imprison Mauer
suggests that as many as 80% will be non-violent offenders. So far 80% of the second and
third strike offenses have been for non-violent crimes, most of these being drug
offenses(23). There have only been only 53 people with second and third strike
convictions for rape, murder, and kidnapping(Carter 1). This law’s lack of effectiveness
clearly does not warrant its huge price.
The other aspect to consider in the implementation of the three strikes legislation is
its effect on non-violent offenders. These are the people hardest hit by this law. It is
difficult see how society can justify sending a drug addict to prison for 25 years at a cost
of $20,000 per year when the money could be used to fund drug rehabilitation centers and
alternative programs for our youth. Most drug users are not in need prison, they are in
need of help for their addictions. If a fraction of the money it would cost to imprison them
is put toward drug rehabilitation programs it would save the state money, while at the
same time helping the individual. The three strikes legislation is directly aimed at violent
crime, but its track record has shown that it has missed the mark by a long shot. Some
offenders have been convicted for a third strike on relatively small offenses. For example,
a man named Steven Gordon was convicted for his third strike after stealing a wallet that
had $100 dollars in it. His previous offenses had all been non-violent, yet he was
convicted under our three strikes law(Franklin 26). This is not an isolated incident either.
Franklin cites numerous examples of cases where people were convicted under this
legislation for non-violent offenses(26). These types of cases just illustrate how the three
strikes legislation is targeting non-violent offenders, as opposed to its goal of targeting
violent criminals.
After one year in effect it is easy to see what our three-strikes legislation has done.
It has become easy to picture the long term effects of such broad legislation on our
society. Although this law was enacted by the will of the people, it has not carried out the
will of the people. People wanted a law that would put dangerous repeat offenders behind
bars for life. Instead we are now putting an increasingly large number of non-violent
offenders behind bars for extended periods of time. It would be easy to justify the cost of
removing a violent menace from our society, but justifying the cost of imprisoning people
who are of no threat to anyone but themselves is difficult. We must look closely at what
this legislation has done so far. It has placed many more non-violent offenders in prison
than violent offenders. The legislation stands to cost the state millions of dollars per year
to incarcerate people of longer prison terms. Clearly the three-strikes law has not served
its intended purpose it must be repealed.
California. California Penal Code.
Carter, Beth. “The Impact of `Three Strikes and You’re Out’ Laws: What Have We
Learned?” Internet Article. Http://www.soc.umn.edu/ samaha/j11H1.html.
The Cost of Mandatory Minimums. Pamphlet. Families Against Mandatory Minimums,
1996.
Franklin, Daniel. “The Right Three Strikes.” Washington Monthly September 1994: 25-
30.
Mauer, Marc. “Three Strikes Policy is Just a Quick-fix Solution.” Corrections Today
July 1996: 23.
Ogutu, Fenno. Class lecture. Sociology 120. Diablo Valley College, Pleasant Hill, CA.
13 Nov. 1996.
Другие работы по теме:
Othello Act Iv Essay Research Paper Othello
Othello Act Iv Essay, Research Paper Othello Journal Act IV In Act IV of Othello, by WIlliam Shakespeare, Iago continues his torture of Othello. Iago torments Othello until Othello pratically faints. He keeps pushing
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Saddam Insane Essay Research Paper Saddam Hussein
Saddam Insane! Essay, Research Paper Saddam Hussein is back with avengeance, and his threats of world destruction aren’t to be taken lightly. The United States tried unsuccessfully to target him during the Gulf War in February 1991, however, they confidently expected the Iraq leader to be gone within months.
Aids Essay Research Paper AIDS is probably
Aids Essay, Research Paper AIDS is probably the most known and most deadly disease in the nation and probably in the whole world. It is a disease that strikes anywhere, anytime, and anyone. That is why I believe sex education is a very beneficial and effective way to let people know about AIDS.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I have
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I have an opinion on many subjects. Whether or not you agree with it is your opininon. This country, being a free country, gives me the right to persuade you to see things my way. This is my goal with the following essay.
Stand Essay Research Paper Stephen King
Stand Essay, Research Paper Stephen King’s The Stand is a thrilling novel that portrays the forces of good against evil. In the year 1991, a plague strikes America, leaving only a few
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
College Essay If You Could Meet Anyone
, Who Would It Be And Why – Polonius Of Hamlet Essay, Research Paper College Essay: If You Could Meet Anyone, Who Would It Be and Why – Polonius of Hamlet Polonius, father of Laertes, in William Shakespear’s Hamlet, strikes me as
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Nato Involvemnt Essay Research Paper The situation
Nato Involvemnt Essay, Research Paper The situation in Baltics is a terrible ordeal. NATO is attempting to help Serbians get through to the serbians and get them to sign a peace agreement. It is not yet successful. Yugoslavias president is becoming rattled, but not stopped. Every day many albanians and even serbs are dying.
The Natural Essay Research Paper I do
The Natural Essay, Research Paper I do not believe in a fate that falls on men however they act; but I do believe in a fate that falls on them unless they act G.K. Chesterton, Generaly Speaking
Poem Belong Essay Research Paper Where I
Poem: Belong Essay, Research Paper Where I belong I am weak, I am strong I will fit where I belong don’t know where it is for now but it will come, if I allow tomorrow, I start a brand new day
William Shakespeare Essay Research Paper Amazing authors
William Shakespeare Essay, Research Paper Amazing authors can induce thoughts by a single word. The ideas that can form in our heads by a small phrase are powerful. Only the most talented and capable authors can provoke such feelings within us. Who is more than able to stir these feelings in a reader but William Shakespeare? His various plays keep us entranced and curious but it is his poetry that strikes a chord deep within us.
Cinderella Essay Research Paper Reading to young
Cinderella Essay, Research Paper Reading to young children has become difficult because the selection has become so limited. For example, I have read three versions of Cinderella, Ashputtle by Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm, When the Clock Strikes by Tanith Lee, and Walt Disney s Cinderella by Campbell Grant.
Mr Essay Research Paper For Crane he
Mr Essay, Research Paper For Crane, he uses Maggie: A Girl of the Streets to tell a story of a girl, born into a life of misery, who has no way of escaping it. Thus, the story strikes an emotional chord in the readers? hearts and the audience empathizes with Maggie?s conditions. Crane believes in the concept of “lifting the veil” and envisions a society that can look past physical differences.
JAWS THE BOOK Essay Research Paper In
JAWS THE BOOK Essay, Research Paper In Jaws terror strikes. This terror is what fuels the story. When the first attack is learned by the worn everyone is gripped with fear. As more die this grip tightens and slowly chokes the town. The terror starts because the killer is unseen and unknown, impossible to see and impossible to escape.
Does God Exist Essay Research Paper Where
Does God Exist? Essay, Research Paper Where is God? The question does God exist is the one that most likely comes up in the minds of people when disaster strikes or tragedy occurs. Why would he let the creation he most dearly loves suffer so greatly? I am going to try to answer this question as difficult as it may seem to some people.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Homsapians Essay Research Paper SchizophreniaSchizophrenia is a
Homsapians Essay, Research Paper Schizophrenia Schizophrenia is a serious brain disorder. It is a disease that makes it difficult for a person to tell the difference between real and unreal experiences, to think logically, to have normal emotional responses to other, and to behave normally in social situations.
Nato Vs Serbia Essay Research Paper If
Nato Vs. Serbia Essay, Research Paper If NATO continues to bomb Serbia, they will be causing serious trouble. They should just mind their own business before any other altercations occur. NATO is just a big act, because their not even putting their full effort into helping Kosovo. This is just a big stunt to make NATO look good.
Landscaping Essay Research Paper Computer Hacking BasicsComputer
Landscaping Essay, Research Paper Computer Hacking Basics Computer hacking is very popular. With every thing on the Internet having to cost something. Someone will try to hack that database and retrieve free information. As every on knows but doesn?t take very seriously is that hacking is illegal. Hacking is anywhere from hacking in to the school data base and change your grades to make a stop light change with a special clicker.
Ancient Roman Art Essay Research Paper Early
Ancient Roman Art Essay, Research Paper Early Roman art reflected previous civilizations, but astime passed, the Romans developed an artistic style completelytheir own. One very unique aspect of the Roman civilization, which setup art, was the use of public baths. At first these public bathsconsisted only of dressing room suites and bathing chambers.
The Prevalence Of Breast Cancer Among Black
Women Essay, Research Paper Exploring the Growth of Breast Cancer Among African American Women Breast cancer develops as an abnormal growth of cells accumulate within the breast. Recent studies have proven that White
General Patton Part III Essay Research Paper
We see him hold his binoculars, peering at the enemy. He planed well and showed it on the way he handles the attack. He carefully placed the army units for battle. These military units are covered in camouflage to match the environment that they lay in. Then, he strikes calling the units to “fire at will.” Later, when he fights in another battle, his soldiers are having trouble crossing the river.
Mononucleosis Essay Research Paper Mononucleosis is an
Mononucleosis Essay, Research Paper Mononucleosis is an infectious virus caused by the Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV), one of the Herpesviruses. Mononucleosis is also called mono, the kissing disease, and glandular fever. It usually strikes people in the ten to thirty-five year old age group, but it can also infect younger people.
Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela has
Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela has played an important and controversial role in the history of South Africa and establishing South Africa as a Democratic country. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was
Ode To Boys Essay Research Paper We
Ode To Boys Essay, Research Paper We like them But do they like us The ones we do never fuss They don’t stop in And we wonder why We stress, we bitch We sometimes cry
Great Gatsby Characters Essay Research Paper The
Great Gatsby Characters Essay, Research Paper The novel, The Great Gatsby, has many characters in it. Four prominent characters are Tom Buchanan, George Wilson, Daisy Buchanan, and Myrtle Wilson.