“I am not what I am.”
An essay on Othello, question No 4.
I will discuss this quote in relation to Lacan’s ideas about language as the symbolic order. My aim is to show how Othello finds his identity threatened by
Desdemona’s reaction to his tales.
In order to explain Lacan’s ideas very briefly I will quote from Pam Morris: Literature and Feminism, (Blackwell, 1993) where she discusses the resolution of the
Oedipal crisis.
For Freud the outcome of the child’s fear of castration is its submission to the reality principle and hence its entry into the social order. For Lacan this
must coincide with the child’s entry into the language system…..Language is thus the Law of the father; a linguistic system within which our social and
gender identity is always already structured. (p. 104)
Othello’s identity in the Venetian society is his role as “the Moor”. Few people use his real name when talking about him. When speaking the given quote, Othello is
telling the Venetians how he won Desdemona’s heart by telling her the story of his life, and he now retells it to the Venetians. This tale-telling is a way of employing
the linguistic system to reshape for himself a new identity with more positive connotations than “the Moor” can offer. “The Moor” is an expression the Venetians
connect to other expressions in the linguistic system which all have a negative value. Examples are such expressions as “old black ram, a Barbary horse, lascivious,
and a devil.” The negative overtone of these words will reflect back on Othello. He can’t change his origins but he can try to change the connotations of “the Moor”.
He can fill the expression with a new content and thereby give himself an identity he can be more comfortable with. This is what Othello is doing when he is retelling
his history.
Othello is obviously a good narrator; Desdemona can’t get enough of his story. Expressions like “seriously incline”, “with haste” and “greedy ear” show
Desdemona’s eagerness for his storytelling. “And ever…./She’ld come again” shows that this has been happening over a period of time without Desdemona growing
tired of his tales. The given quote implies that Othello feels he has been too clever for his own benefit. Desdemona’s craving for his autobiography is felt as a threat; it
may jeopardize his new identity. Othello says that she would: “Devour up my discourse”. It is in this discourse that his identity exists. If she devours up his discourse,
she devours up his identity and leaves him where he started; as “the Moor”.
Desdemona may represent the all-engulfing mother of the pre-Oedipal stage. This is a stage without structure, language or identity, an opposite to the linguistic
system, the Law of the father. It is with a “greedy ear” she “devours up my discourse”. An ear is sometimes used to symbolize female genitalia and will here
emphasize the fact that Othello feels the threat to be feminine. That he, through his discourse, is devoured shows that this feminine threat is all-engulfing. If Othello
refuses to accept his old role as “the Moor” he will either be without an identity or be dragged by his self-fashioned identity back into the pre-Oedipal stage. These
options are two sides of the same coin, he will lose himself either way. To give up one’s self is the same as suicide. Both death and the pre-Oedipal stage are spheres
without language, structure, intention or identity. To give way to the one or the other will have the same result for Othello; he will no longer be a conscious being.
To save himself, Othello must get control over this “greedy ear”. Female sexuality was considered something scary which could best be controlled through marriage.
A loose tongue was a sign of loose sexuality. Othello extends this notion to include Desdemona’s “greedy ear”. He marries Desdemona and all is well until Iago
implies that Desdemona is unfaithful.
Unfaithfulness in a woman will reflect back on her husband. A cuckold is a ridiculous figure in other people’s eyes. He must be seriously lacking in person for his wife
to run after other men. Othello sees himself in the same situation as before the marriage. Instead of using her ears she is now using her sexuality to destroy the identity
he has built up for himself. I have already pointed out how ears and sexuality are connected in Othello’s mind. Either way the results are the same for Othello’s
identity. He sees his positive image of himself slipping away: “Farewell the plumed troops and the big wars/ That makes ambition virtue!….Farewell: Othello’s
occupation’s gone.” (III, iii, 352-353+360) The one way to control this threat is to passivize Desdemona completely by killing her. He realizes too late the effect this
action will have on his own situation. She was the only person who would accept the identity he had been fronting. He even had difficulties believing in it himself,
which made him an easy victim for Iago. So when he killed Desdemona he killed the positive image of himself. The person he saw as a threat to his identity was the
only person who actually sustained it. Because he had such difficulties in believing in himself he found it impossible that anybody else should do so. This insecurity
proves his undoing. His positive self-image gone, he is left a choice between “the Moor” or nothingness. The moment Emilia realizes Othello is the murderer she
reverts to calling him expressions connected to the negative image of “the Moor”: “And you the blacker devil!…thou art a devil.” (V, ii, 129, 131) He can’t stand
being this person, the only one society and the symbolic order can offer him. To construct his own identity has proven impossible. To be without an identity, a
non-personn implies death. He chooses to free himself of this unwanted identity by stepping out of the social order and the language system by means of suicide.
Другие работы по теме:
Othello Act Iv Essay Research Paper Othello
Othello Act Iv Essay, Research Paper Othello Journal Act IV In Act IV of Othello, by WIlliam Shakespeare, Iago continues his torture of Othello. Iago torments Othello until Othello pratically faints. He keeps pushing
Critical Lense Essay Research Paper Critical Lense
Critical Lense Essay, Research Paper Critical Lense American essayist Logan Paersall Smith once said, What I like in a good author is not what he says but what he whispers. I believe this means Logan thinks a good author doesn t always say things directly but uses literary elements like characterization and symbolism to get a message across to the reader.
Othello 3 Essay Research Paper In the
Othello 3 Essay, Research Paper In the play Othello, Shakespeare uses Iago, Cassio, Roderigo, and Othello to represent hatred, loyalty, love, and jealousy in mankind. Hatred being the thing of envy and ambition presented it self in may different forms. Loyalty being one of the forms, hatred presented itself as friendly and gracious.
Othello Essay Research Paper Iago was a
Othello Essay, Research Paper Iago was a very influencel character in the play, also very cunning. he worked on the emotiotion of just about every characther. some were cassio, othello, and rodrigo.
Reputation In Othello Essay Research Paper Reputation
Reputation In Othello Essay, Research Paper Reputation plays a big role in the play Othello written by Shakespeare. Iago uses his reputation as an honest man to deceive Othello and everyone else. Othello’s reputation also plays a big role throughout the play. Cassio’s changing reputation has a big part in the outcome of the play as well.
Othello Shakespeare
’s Most Tragic Play Essay, Research Paper Othello: Shakespeare’s Most Tragic Play William Shakespeare have written many plays. His most tragic play is Othello.
Othello By William Shakespeare 1564
– 1616) Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare’s Othello epitomizes the playwright’s masterful ability to weave his characters’ intricate motives and acts into
Does Iago Have Sufficient Reason To Commit
His Evil Acts? Essay, Research Paper “evil: violating or inconsistent with the moral law…harmful…the devil, Satan.” . Does Iago fit this description, thus proving he is purely evil in his actions? Alternatively, does he have substantial motivation? In this essay I will discuss his motives and actions and come to my conclusion.
Othello Play Essay Research Paper The four
Othello Play Essay, Research Paper The four main characters in the play Othello represent four different character traits of manhood: Roderigo, the failure; Othello, the hero, yet the insane
The Manipulation Of Othello And Cassio Essay
, Research Paper The Manipulation of Othello A tragic fault is a character trait which causes the action of a tragic hero or character. Iago manipulates Othello and Cassio by using their character traits and flaws
Response Paper On Othello Essay Research Paper
HUM 125 Response Paper Othello was confronted with many betrayals that lead him in killing his beautiful wife, Desdemona. When though Othello was a great warrior as well as a person of wisdom, but even his strength or his wisdom could not stop him from felling into the hands of a villain. The hands he fell into were Iago’s.
Othello Essay Research Paper The play Othello
Othello Essay, Research Paper The play Othello was written be William Shakespeare in the latter years of Shakespeare?s career. Shakespeare composed, revised, and acted in many theatrical performances throughout his life, he also owned the Globe theater where many of his works were performed. The work Othello was based on a story by Giraldi Cinthios, Tale of a Moor, which was a mellow drama about a moor and his doubts about his wife?s fidelity.
Othello Essay Research Paper Othello EssayIn the
Othello Essay, Research Paper Othello Essay In the play Othello, the very evil and conniving character Iago deceives the main characters. He prays mostly on the main character Othello. Othello is a black general who is married to a white woman named Desdemona. In the beginning of the play Othello promotes a man named Cassio to be his right hand man in his army.
Othello Essay Research Paper In the play
Othello Essay, Research Paper In the play, Othello, by Shakespeare, villainous character, Iago, schemes to bring Othello s happiness to an end. Iago conspires to have Othello turn against his comrade, Cassio, and try to kill him for his misdeeds against Desdamona. Iago arises Othello s feelings and emotions towards Desdamona by feeding on Othello s great pride in Desdamona s devotion to Othello.
Othello Essay Research Paper Othello In the
Othello Essay, Research Paper Othello In the play “The tragedy of Othello,” one character that I thought clearly changed during the course of the play was the main character, Othello. Othello was a man of great dignity and honor. He was noble of birth, both a captain and a general, the foremost officer in the state of Venice and the new General of Cyprus.
Honest Iago Essay Research Paper Honest Iago
Honest Iago Essay, Research Paper Honest Iago In William Shakespeare’s Othello, despicable Iago, the ultimate villain, uses his intelligence and resourcefulness to exact his vengeance. By creating chaos and causing people to doubt each other Iago rises to power. In the deaths he causes as he achieves his revenge, he provides a shocking representation of absolute evil and a metaphor a out human nature.Iago’s extreme villainy, originally fueled by his jealousy of Cassio’s position, bloomed into a much greater passion.
Othello Character Flaw Essay Research Paper Yes
Othello Character Flaw Essay, Research Paper Yes, I fully agree that you must be careful of outward appearances. Appearances can be very deceiving, as we saw in the play Othello. Othello did not know that Iago had a hidden agenda, had Othello known that Iago was untruthful, this Shakespearean tragedy would not of happened.
Othello 4 Essay Research Paper Othello isn
Othello 4 Essay, Research Paper Othello isn t a play about racism as much as it is a play about jealosy, conflicting values, and the power of suggestion. Some racism is displayed within the play, but that is simply a reflection of how most minorities were treated in the time period when the population in Europe was predominantly of white skin color.
Othello Summary Essay Research Paper Plot Summary
Othello Summary Essay, Research Paper Plot Summary Iago is passed over for a promotion by his commander, Othello, a Moor and a general in the service of Venice, and vows revenge. Othello has just
Jealusy In Othello Essay Research Paper The
Jealusy In Othello Essay, Research Paper The emotions of jealousy in the characters in Othello In Othello Shakespeare presents everybody with the tragic spectacle of a man who, in a spirit of jealous rage, destroys what he loves best in all the world. Such a spectacle must of necessity be painful, whatever the object destroyed and whoever the destroyer, but it is doubly painful and deeply tragic when we see a noble man brutally killing his pure, faithful and loving young wife in the mistaken belief that she was cheating on him.
Othello Essay Research Paper Jealousy is a
Othello Essay, Research Paper Jealousy is a green-eyed monster. Jealousy can corrupt a person into a monster. In the play Othello, by William Shakespeare, the character Othello was corrupted by jealousy
Why Isn
’t Shakespeare’s Othello Called Iago Essay, Research Paper Should William Shakespeare’s Othello be called Iago? It is possibly his greatest tragedy, yet it has many problems, curiosities, and questions. That is one specific question that should definately be thought about. I believe Othello is a good name for the play.
Character Analysis Of Iago In Othello Essay
, Research Paper Character Analysis of Iago in Shakespeare’s Othello In William Shakespeare’s “Othello”, the character Iago is, at least in my point of view, the main and most interesting character. Iago is in virtually every scene in the play, and has his hands in almost all doings within the play. Iago is truly one of the greatest villans in literature.
Othello Act 5 Analysis Essay Research Paper 2
Othello: Act 5 Analysis Essay, Research Paper Othello: Act 5 Analysis Iago’s intelligence causes the self destruction of Othello. He appears to be the most intelligent person in the play, Othello, by the way he acts and
The Theme Of Revenge In Othello Essay
, Research Paper The Theme of Revenge in Othello Revenge is a constant theme throughout the play Othello. It is portrayed through the character Iago. Iago is determined to destroy Othello and his loved ones. This retribution is a
ShakespeareS Othello
– Iago Essay, Research Paper In act one of Othello, Shakespeare?s character, Iago, shows how deceitful and disloyal people can be. Iago?s disloyalty towards Othello and Cassio is portrayed through the lies
Othello Essay Research Paper OthelloIn Othello we
Othello Essay, Research Paper Othello In Othello, we encounter Iago, one of Shakespeare?s most evil characters. Iago is an officer in Othello’s army and is jealous of Cassio’s promotion to Lieutenant. Through deception and appearance, we see many lies and clever schemes unfold. The astonishing thing about Iago is that he seems to make up his malicious schemes as he goes along without any planning.
Shakespere Essay Research Paper In all of
Shakespere Essay, Research Paper In all of Shakespeare?s great novels there are many experiences, tragic or otherwise that one can learn from. Shakespeare?s novel Othello is not an exception this rule. Throughout Othello there are many examples of mistakes made by the characters that a reader can learn from.
Jealousy In Othello Essay Research Paper Jealousy
Jealousy In Othello Essay, Research Paper Jealousy in Othello In Shakespeare’s Othello, Iago plots Othello’s destruction when he is passed over for a promotion. Iago tells Othello that Desdemona has been unfaithful to him and provides
Othello Essay Research Paper OTHELLO THE MOOR
Othello Essay, Research Paper OTHELLO, THE MOOR OF VENICE Othello is a Moorish nobleman and soldier of fortune, inclined into the vale of years. Now in the service of the Venetian State as a general against the Turks. Othello is said to be ? great of heart,? ?honorable and valiant,? ?of a free open nature, that thinks men honest that but seem to be so,? and ? thus easy victim to the ?green eyed monster??JEALOUSY.? At the beginning of the play, Othello appears as a noble, generous, composed man.