– Incoherence Of The Moral “Ought” Essay, Research Paper
Robert Fish
THE INCOHERENCE OF THE MORAL ‘OUGHT’
Journal Report
The Incoherence of the Moral ‘Ought,’ a journal article by Duncan Richter, is an analysis of a paper by Elizabeth Anscombe entitled, “Modern Moral Philosophy.” In this analysis, Mr. Richter is only concerned about Anscombe’s second thesis, which states as follows:
The concepts of moral obligation and moral duty (what is morally right and morally wrong, and the moral sense of ‘ought,’ ought to be jettisoned if this is psychologically possible; because they are survivals, or derivatives from survivals, from an earlier conception of ethics which no longer generally survives and are only harmful without it.
According to this thesis, Mr. Richter builds his thesis into five parts. Part one summarizes Elizabeth Anscombe’s research according to her second thesis. Anscombe’s objection is to limit the use of such words as ‘ought,’ ’should,’ ‘needs’ and ‘most.’ She asserts that there are two uses for such words, being either ordinary or objectionable. In the ordinary sense of the specific case, ‘ought,’ the word is indispensable. The meaning of this sense of the word is that if one ‘ought’ to do something, then without doing so, such a result will minimize happiness for a certain person. Conversely, the objectionable sense of the word is the ‘moral sense’ in which “a verdict is implied on the notion in question without support of a conceptual framework to make the notion of such a verdict coherent.” In other words, this seems to infer that implications to legality of any sort, whether it be the government or divine law, are objectionable to Anscombe and therefore should be eradicated from our terminology.
In parts two and three, Mr. Richter presents criticisms of the thesis based on Kurt Baier and Peter Winch, respectively. Kurt Baier seems to be less interesting on Mr. Richter’s list of priority to objecting Anscombe’s argument, but he does state his conclusion before proceeding to part three:
I conclude that Anscombe’s … arguments do not succeed in showing that all or most or indeed any of contemporary ethics is confused, incoherent, or vitiated because it operates with an incoherent conception of wrongness, duty and obligation.
The author turns now to Winch’s criticism. The main theme of which Mr. Richter concentrates on in part three is suggestion that “there is something unintelligible about a moral modality which lacks eternal justification” Winch claims that these specified modals possess a certain arbitrary aspect in that they do not “require external justification, but are rooted in natural, spontaneous human reactions to certain situations.”
Mr. Richter proceeds with part four by considering Paul Johnston’s rejection of Anscombe’s second thesis. Johnston asserts in from his book, Wittgenstein and Moral Philosophy, that moral judgments are absolute: “…it is the absolute use of these terms (i.e. ‘good,’ ‘right,’ ‘ought,’ etc.) that seems distinctively ethical.” His reasons for this assertion include that ethics and specific ethical judgments “…require, and perhaps can have, no justification.” He also explains that there is no ethical reason, to be morally good when looked upon by society, or to refrain from immoral acts.
Finally, in part five, Duncan Richter concludes by approaching Cora Diamond’s tribute to Modern Moral Philosophy and considers what response can be made to Baier and Winch, in light of this tribute. Diamond presents the moral question, ‘Why obey God?’ to which there must be and answer. She answers this by saying, ‘We can see what is would be, what breach of trust, what ingratitude, what kind of pride and folly, to refuse to obey.’ Duncan Richter adds, at the end, that the words ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ are overlooked by Anscombe and therefore causes her second thesis to seem right. In addition, he asserts that the people of today need to be ready to lay aside moral philosophy as we know it permanently.
(Journal: Richter, Duncan. The Incoherence of the Moral ‘Ought.’ Mind. January, 1995. Vol. 104. Pp. 69-85.)
Другие работы по теме:
Эфтаназия
Список используемой литературы: Журнал “Философские науки” N6, 1990: Эвтаназия” Филиппа Фут. Филиппа Фут использовала вспомогательный материал у:
Славин, Морис
Введение 1 Биография 2 Сочинения 3 Эссе 4 Публикации Введение Морис Славин (1913, Киев — 2006) — американский историк. 1. Биография Родился в Киеве, на Украине. Жил и преподавал в Огайо, США. Ученый Национального университета Янгстауна, специалист в области истории Франции, работы по истории Французской революции.
Krapp
’s Last Tape – Character Analysis Essay, Research Paper Creative Projects: Pretend you are someone in one of the plays + write a few journal entries revealing your understanding of at least one literacy element: character.
Job Letter Essay Research Paper To Whom
Job Letter Essay, Research Paper To Whom It May Concern: I am enclosing a copy of my resume for your files and review. I am an individual who responds to challenges and works both independently or as a part of a team,
Marijuana For Migranes Essay Research Paper 1
Marijuana For Migranes Essay, Research Paper 1) Russo, Ethan M.D. (1998). Cannabis for migraine treatment. Pain, 76, 3 8. This particular journal entry is actually a historic review on the benefits of utilizing cannabis for the medicinal use of relieving migraines. In an attempt to find a journal that might actually have a case study or something on the affects of marijuana on a human, I forgot that there probably would not be many studies done due to the hazardous impact that comes with inhaling marijuana smoke.
A Review Of The Eat More Weigh
Less Hawaii Diet Essay, Research Paper A Review of The Eat More, Weigh Less, Hawaii Diet The Eat More, Weigh Less, Hawaii Diet claims that you can “eat all the food you want, never have that feeling of hunger, still lose weight, and be healthier than you ever have been” simply by eating the traditional foods of Hawaiians.
Appraising My Test Taking Skills Essay Research
Paper The advantages of my test taking skills are effectiveness,organization, and good review tools. Thus, the disadvantages are manageable review time and strategy planning. I find myself mostly “stuck” on planning a strategy.
Synopsis Of The Great Gatsby Essay Research
Paper Synopsis of The Great Gatsby Review The review that I read by Charles E. Shain said that gatsby was no more great the any other man of his time. The reason for this is that Gatsby was trying to live in the past, to try to recapture what he once had. Sure he had very much money, ?gonnections?, and many acquaintances, but this does not make a man great.
Judicial Review Essay Research Paper Judicial ReviewThe
Judicial Review Essay, Research Paper Judicial Review The Supreme Court is the only court designated in the constitution. Within it is the Chief Justice of the United States, and eight associates. Being the highest court it is the last resort for all federal court questions. The Supreme Court has the power to determine whether something is constitutional or not, which makes them the final authority.
The Fighting Ground Journal Essay Research Paper
Journal 1- It is a warm and pleasant day. I really want to go to war ,against the German Hessians for my self and for my country. I askedmy father while I was cleaning his musket if I could fight for mycountry , he said no because I was too young. I don t care I said tomyself I m gonna run out early morning and enlist in a platoon for theAmericans.
Walden Journal Essay Research Paper Walden JournalI
Walden Journal Essay, Research Paper Walden Journal I sat one night and watched the white snowflakes falling against the dark back drop of night. The flakes reminded me of all the people ive seen comming together in conformaty. Each flake started out individually born in the skys and melting together to form one massive pile.
Got The Blues Essay Research Paper Got
Got The Blues? Essay, Research Paper Got the Blues? Every little thing counts unless you wrote the movie review of Varsity Blues. The reviewer for Our Take at ScreenIt.Com obviously did not come from a town where sports where heavily pushed nor does it seem that he or she has ever played a competitive sport. The repetitiveness of calling it an MTV high school generation movie lacks telling what it is actually about.
Review Of Ceremony Essay Research Paper Review
Review Of Ceremony Essay, Research Paper Review of Ceremony Ceremony, written by Leslie Marmon Silko, traces the alienation and destruction of a young Native American who must first come to terms with his past before he can overcome his post-traumatic stress. Throughout this novel, there are many symbols and examples of how not only the main character, but his culture as a whole was ignored, rejected, and destroyed.
Smoking 2 Essay Research Paper Smoking and
Smoking 2 Essay, Research Paper Smoking and Relaxation 7 References Allen, J. (1994) Health values. Journal of Health Behavior, 18, 34-39 Jenks, J. R. (1994) Smoking and satisfaction and motivations. Journal of Social Psychology, 134, 847-849. Morgan, H. (1995) Tobacco smoking and gender. Journal of Educational Research, 88, 301-308.
The Diary Of Anne Frank
– Book Report Essay, Research Paper The Diary of Anne Frank is about a girl that kept a diary while hiding from Nazi?s in Amsterdam for two years. The diary ends when the Nazi?s found her and her family. Her
Desperate Essay Research Paper ORIENTAL RUG REVIEWAn
Desperate Essay, Research Paper ORIENTAL RUG REVIEW An Oriental rug magazine. From the first issue, a tabloid published in March 1981, through a transition to a full-color magazine in 1987, collectors and dealers with a serious interest in Oriental rugs and textiles have turned to Oriental Rug Review for auction reports, international market reports, book reviews, exhibition reviews, interviews, humor, and a wide range of feature articles, both scholarly and anecdotal.
My Tuesdays With Morrie Essay Research Paper
Journal 21 “ I felt the seeds of death inside his shriveling frame, and as I laid him in his chair, adjusting his head on the pillow, I had the coldest realization that our time was running out.”(Pg. 59) That is what Mitch Albom, a journal writer for the Detroit Free Press, said as he lifted his old college teacher from his wheelchair to his recliner.
Review Of Reviews Essay Research Paper I
Review Of Reviews Essay, Research Paper I chose to review John Updike?s Review ?It Was Sad? from the October 14th issue of ?The New Yorker?. In the review, Updike examines
Green Tea Essay Research Paper Green tea
Green Tea Essay, Research Paper Green tea and black tea have recently been the topic of many scientific articles and experiments. There have been many findings in the past several years that link tea with the prevention or decrease in many diseases and cancers. For my critical review, I chose to delve into the subject of the benefits of black, green and oolong (red) tea.
Frankenstien The Book Essay Research Paper Journal
Frankenstien The Book Essay, Research Paper Journal Chap. 24-end # 17 The end of the novel was left very open. I felt as though there is no conclusion. Where is the sequel? I think that Walton will not continue Victors quest to see the monster dead. The monster only had one reason to live, and that was to make Victor s life a living hell.
Play Review On West Side Story Essay
, Research Paper Drama Play Review on West Side Story The musical Play that I did my review on was West Side Story by Jerome Robbins. I saw this play at the Woodland High School with my family. We went to see it because my older brother, Nick was in it.
Journal Entry From 1920
′S Essay, Research Paper May 22, 1921Sandy s Journal Dear Kitty, Something really big and I mean BIG happened today.It s is almost too incredible to believe. My fingers are still shaking as I try and write. But I ve got to get this down because whatever happens, these pages will be proof that I was at this amazing place.I found a giant club in the downtown district.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book ReviewFor
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review For Whom The Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway Pages Read: 74 (really busy) For Whom The Bell Tolls begins with a pyrotechnic for the Russian army reviewing the land where he must blow a bridge to stop enemy movement. He is a little overwhelmed by the task he is assigned to complete yet he is mentally sound in his manner and seems to know exactly how to handle himself in the situation.
Jay Leno Book Review Essay Research Paper
BOOK REVIEW The book I read was “Leading With My Chin”. The author is Bill Zehme. I enjoyed reading this book because of its excellent detail. I would definitely recommend this book to someone that is a Jay Leno fan or like to laugh a lot.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book Review
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review Eric T. LibeerPark Hill South High School Thursday, May 27, 1999 Book Review By Eric Libeer Homeland, John Jakes’s formidable noel about the final explosive events of the nineteenth century, is the first in a series that will focus attention on a new “Jakes” family, the Crowns.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Reid FarmerAmerican
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Reid Farmer American History Book Review #1 March 7, 2000 Book Review # 1 The book that I chose to read was called The Governor And The Rebel, by Wilcomb E. Washburn. Wilcomb was a very qualified person. He passed away on February 1, 1997. He got his Ph.D. in the History of American Civilization at Harvard University.
Journal Writing Essay Research Paper Journal Writing
Journal Writing Essay, Research Paper Journal Writing I write a lot in class but I don’t like writing one bit it gets on my nerves cause my hands are very sensitive and my hands get so tired that don’t even want to type anymore and that messes me up a lot cause in my English class you are required to write a lot. Now if it were typing that a whole other story but that’s not going to help me in life to come cause when you go get a job you are required to have punctuality.
Review Of A Review Essay Research Paper
Review of a Review Mark Caro seems to let one flaw ruin an entire movie. In his review of “Unbreakable” Caro admits that the duration of the film is commendable, but its ending is too disappointing to look past. He begins by comparing “Unbreakable” to the highly acclaimed “The Sixth Sense”. By saying that “The Sixth Sense” viewers will be, “on the lookout for clues that might telegraph the inevitable final twist” Caro puts the idea in our minds that we should all expect the same type of ending.
Literature Review
Literature Review Group 7 Literature review is about the features of monopoly that leads to customer dissatisfaction, random pricing and lack of innovation due to absence of perfect competition.
Anne Frank Journal Essay Research Paper Journal
Anne Frank Journal Essay, Research Paper Journal #1 I think that when Mr. Frank, Mrs. Frank, Anne, and Margot needed to hide from the Nazis in Mr. Kraler loft in his factory the living conditions were so appalling. They only had two rooms and one space for Peter to sleep in. I feel it is amazing how two families, the Franks and the Van Daans, and one dentist, Mr.
International Joint Ventures Essay Research Paper Summary
International Joint Ventures Essay, Research Paper Summary: Knowledge, Bargaining Power, and the Instability of International Joint Ventures The purpose of the journal article is to identify the primary reason for instability within international joint ventures. The authors begin by defining instability and then continue by linking it to bargaining power.