Salem Witchcraft Essay, Research Paper
Was the Salem Witchcraft Hysteria
Caused by a Fear of Women?
Although there has been a long history of witchcraft, the main concentration is
from the periods of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. In the British North American
colonies alone there were over 100 witchcraft trials alone, were 40 percent of the accused
were executed. Now two professors, Carol F. Karlsen of history and Kai T. Erikson of
sociology, examine the Salem Witchcraft Hysteria to see if it was caused by a fear of
women and give two entirely different interpretations.
The first professor, Carol F. Karlsen, agreed that the Salem Witchcraft Hysteria
was caused by a fear of women. She agrees that the belief in the Puritian culture, that
women were evil, existed because they were seen as a potential threat to the order of the
society. That is why women were generally seen as witches.
When witchcraft was initially seen, it was uncertain of wether or not it would
benefit the New England society, because of the fast changing conditions of the early
settlement. By the late 1640?s, New Englanders believed that a witchcraft belief system as
integral to their society. The Puritian rituals, myths, and symbols from then on were seen
perpetuated to the belief that women were a danger to their society. This idea of women
connected directly to witchcraft was only reinforced by the newer post-Reformation ideas
about women.
West 2
Puritanism in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth century in England caused
much controversy over the nature of women and their roles in society. Puritian and
Catholic witch-hunters both believed that women were, ?evil, whorish, deceitful,
extravagant, angry, vengeful, and, of course, insubordinate and proud.? Women ?are
altogether a lumpe of pride,? one author said in 1690-?A masse of pride, even altogether
made of pride, and nothing else but pride.? One of the many reasons that women were
being seen in this way was from the increasing independence, impudence, masculine dress,
and masculine ways. It was all seen through the women?s new ways of forwardness and
liberties.
A good example was with Adam and Eve being punished for the sin of pride,
rebelling against the order of creation, but Eve was seen as rebelling both as part of man
and as man?s other. This is how Eve was seen as the fall of man. ?Yet looking upon her as
made for the man, and by the Creators law owing a subordination to him, so she may also
be looked upon as instrumental.? as said by Willard. Willard means that Eve should have
encouraged Adam to obey God since she was created to serve man, but she didn?t. This
caused her to be seen as a mischief and for the cause of the downfall of man. For the
actions of Eve God placed a special curse on the female race, ?Unto the woman he said, I
will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception: in sorrow shalt thou bring forth
children: and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee.? It was seen
that part of women?s sin was the seduction of man and another was her failure to serve
man. Although Willard never actually said that there was a direct connection between
woman and Satan, he thought that woman was influenced by the Devil and she did what
she did voluntary of her own free will.
West 3
In the Puritian society, Eve was seen as the main symbol of women as evil. She
was considered in many ways to be the first witch ever. The values of order and hierarchy
were very important to society in the Puritian culture. And the ones that could not accept
their responsibilities in the society were considered the most evil of all.
The second professor, Kai T. Erikson, took an entirely different stand on the
Hysteria of Witchcraft in Salem. She did not feel that it was caused by a fear of women,
but by a product of the Puritian colonist? efforts to restore a common sense of mission,
which they believed had vanished after the first 60 years of their settlement.
During the times of the Salem Witchcraft Hysteria, there were men from
Massachusetts that were in London trying to convince William to restore the old charter
or to issue a new one so that Massachusetts could have all of the advantages that it once
had. At these times it was understandable that the anxiety of the settlement was very high.
In the settlement it was supposed to be a land of bliss and harmony, but this was not so.
The courts were making their way through the settlement and were tearing apart the ways
of the people. The courts were filled with land despots and personal feuds. The spirit of
brotherhood which the original settlers had, had been diffused into commercial
competition, political contention, and personal bad feelings. At the time of the Salem
Witchcraft era, the way of New England had become a thing of the past by the people of
the Bay not being able to learn from their past or to see what to look for in the future.
Massachusetts had become, in Alan Hiemert?s words, ?a society no longer able to judge
itself with any certainty.?
West 4
Historically, as pointed out by George L. Kittrege, ?there is nothing unique in the
fact that Massachusetts Bay should have put people on trial for witchcraft, the whole story
should have been seen not as an abnormal outbreak of fanaticism, not as an isolated
tragedy, but as a mere incident, a brief and transitory episode in the biography of a terrible,
but perfectly natural, superstition.? During the Civil Wars in England was when the
witchcraft hysteria was the strongest. There may have been hundreds or even thousands
of witches burned at the stake during these times. It was seen that ever time something
rash happened it began with the burning of witches.
The witchcraft hysteria was seen only as a brief moment in time in Massachusetts
Bay by Erikson. She sees it as the first of the witch hysteria being born as a group of
excited girls who drifted around the edges of the community. The people of these times
tried to discover some place for them and in this time they searched for something that
they were unable to find.
As I have reviewed the interpretations of both of the professors for the Hysteria of
the Salem Witchcraft and if it was caused by a fear of women, I would have to agree with
Kai T. Erikson from the evidence that she has given. She spoke of the political battles that
were going on and all of the court cases that were being held due the shellfishes of the
settlers. In all of this chaos I feel that it was inevitable that something would arouse from
this madness as a scape goat for the disorder that was happening. If you read through the
argument of Karlsen, you get the sense that she herself wasn?t sure of her own evidence.
She didn?t have any solid or physical evidence to support her ideas, she
West 5
only had biblical evidence that doesn?t stand out for much. I feel as Erikson did when she
said that all of the outbreaks or wars or any disturbance of that time always started with
the execution of witches. From this evidence I can only agree with that of Erikson that
the Salem Witchcraft Hysteria was not caused by a fear of women but only of the
settlement not knowing how to deal with all of their misfortunes and chaos with having an
explanation or scape goat for them.
Другие работы по теме:
Crucible Essay Research Paper The CrucibleIn Salem
Crucible Essay, Research Paper The CrucibleIn Salem during the time of the witch trials everyone is eitherpolitically motivated to believe the girls wild antics are the work of thedevil, or they are so gullible that they think no child could ever impishlyscorn the holiness of the church. Those are the two main reasons the girlsget away with accusing people of witchcraft at first, later new reasons areintroduced.
Salem Meets Dennis The Menace Essay Research
Paper What?s the difference between Abigail Williams and Satin? Very little! Abigail turns life around for many innocent citizens of Salem. She took away their freedom and attacked their emotions. Abigail shows many similar qualities to Satin in The Crucible. She certainly rejects God and does what she wants to do regardless of whom it may hurt.
From Salem We See Essay Research Paper
The town of Salem and those that surround, From which many stories of fear abound. About Gallows Hill, Salem, many hung, Unjustly climbed the ladder rung by rung.
The Crucible 10 Essay Research Paper Adultery
The Crucible 10 Essay, Research Paper Adultery: a possible cause of Salem Trials? Could Proctor & Abigail’s adultery be responsible for some acts that happened during the prosecutions in the Salem witchtrials? One might say not, while another could say it plays a great part in the story.
Crucible Essay Research Paper When we think
Crucible Essay, Research Paper When we think of the United States we think of equality and justice for all people no matter how far back you go back in our history. Sadly, this hasn’t always been the case, in this land of hope
The Crucible And Abigail Essay Research Paper
The main characters are Abigail, Mercy, Proctor, Hale, and Elizabeth. Abigail is a girl who accuses many people of witchcraft including Elizabeth. When Elizabeth is accused of witchcraft, she comes up with evidence that Abigail accused her as a trick to get ahead in life. Although Abigail and the girls initiate the tragedy, responsibility lies with the whole Salem community.
Crucible Essay Research Paper The Crucible is
Crucible Essay, Research Paper The Crucible is a play about witchcraft. It all begins with a group of young women playing with witchcraft taught by Tituba and Abigail William?s. Reverend
Binary Thinking Essay Research Paper Binary thinking
Binary Thinking Essay, Research Paper Binary thinking related to Salem Witch Trials The Puritans were European settlers that established home in Salem Village in the 1630s. They believed that they were a dominant group because of their practices. They saw their religion as superior to any other religion.
The Crucible And The Mccarthy Era Essay
, Research Paper The Crucible and the McCarthy Era Arthur Miller s The Crucible, depicts the Salem witchcraft trials of 1692 but is analogous to the McCarthy trials of the 1950s. In both situations, widespread hysteria occurs, stemming from existing fears of the people of that particular era. The Salem witchhunt trials parallel the McCarthy era in three major aspects: unfounded accusations, hostile interrogation of numerous innocent people and the ruination and death of various people s lives.
Crucible By Miller Essay Research Paper John
Crucible By Miller Essay, Research Paper John Proctor was the main character in the play The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller. Will the truth set you free? In Proctor?s case of choosing truth over
Crucible Essay Research Paper Does power corrupt
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Does power corrupt? In Arthur Miller s The Crucible, Miller takes his readers on a journey back to 1692 to revisit the Salem witchcraft trials. He cleverly portrays a small Puritan town and the disappearance of their commitment to each other and the truth. One of the main characters in Miller s play is Abigail Williams, who is a seventeen year old orphan with an endless capacity for dissembling .(p.8) She, along with an evil land owner, Thomas Putnam, and a distinguished judge, Danforth, is able to corrupt the town to get what they want.
Crucible Salem Episode Essay Research Paper The
Crucible Salem Episode Essay, Research Paper The Crucible The Salem witch-trials, are an historic event that occurred during the Puritan era. It was the witch-trials that decided the fate of so many of the
The Crucible Essay Research Paper ARTHUR MILLER 2
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper ARTHUR MILLER, SALEM AND COMMUNISM In this paper I am going to talk about the relations between the Salem witch trials and the Cold War. Covering this with evidence and facts about the theme. I think that this is a fair comparison and is very interesting what they have in common.
Mccarthy Era And Salem Witch Trials Essay
, Research Paper The McCarthy Era and the Salem Witch Trials The McCarthy era is very similar to the Salem Witch trials. They are both similar, because they both dealt with hysteria. Hysteria is an
WitchHunts Salem And McCarthyism Essay Research
Paper Witch Hunts: Salem and McCarthyism Imagine what it would be like to be labeled a Communist for the mere fact that you happened to sport a goatee? It happened in the 1950?s McCarthyism period! Doesn?t this sound strangely similar to the Salem witch-hunts? Perfectly normal people accused of being witches just because they were seen dancing strangely in the woods.
The Devil
’s Shadow Essay, Research Paper The Devil’s Shadow Time Setting: The Devil’s Shadow by Clifford Lindsey Alderman took place in the late seventeenth century from 1692-1693. This is the time period that the Salem
Crucible Essay Research Paper Tragic Hero EssayThe
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Tragic Hero Essay The historic happenings of the Salem Witch Trials are told in the story of the Crucible. In the Crucible, the main character is John Proctor. John Proctor is a tragic hero who is a great man but has one single flaw, pride, which will lead to his destruction.
Authority
– The Crucible By Arthur Miller Essay, Research Paper Authority. Can it be abused? Abagail and the other girls in the play, The Crucible by Arthur Miller, strongly abused their position of power. Through the authority of the girls in the court, the Witch Hysteria came about in Salem. Because of the Witch Hysteria, false accusations of witchcraft were placed on members of the community in a form of vengeance from previous misunderstandings.
Violation Of Human Rights In The Crucible
Essay, Research Paper IB English Exam A2 Question #2 : Violations of the Declaration of Human Rights during the Salem Witch Trials During the Salem witch trials, many violations of today?s Universal Declaration of Human Rights occurred. Inclusively, some are still being done today. Upon having a victim under an acusation, many articles were not respected.
Reverend John Hale In The Crucible Essay
, Research Paper In the play The Crucible by Arthur Miller John Hale goes through some very distinct character changes. When Reverend John Hale first arrives in Salem he is quite conceited about his field of work which is the ?demonic arts.? He believes that he is an expert on witchcraft even though he has never condemned someone as a witch.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper The witch
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper The witch trials in Salem, Massachusetts in the early sixteen hundreds was a time of uneasiness and suspicion. Anyone could easily turn in his or her neighbor on the
Crucible Essay Research Paper The Crucible
Crucible Essay, Research Paper The Crucible The Crucible takes place in Salem, Massachusetts in 1692. It begins with a sense of witchcraft in the air, when we find out that Reverend Parris (the town minister) and the town are
Three Sovereigns For Sarah Essay Research Paper
The movie, Three Soverighens for Sarah, takes place in Salem town during the trials of 1672. Three sisters, Sarah, Mary, and Rebecca were accused of witchcraft. Some young girls thought themselves to believe that the three sisters were bring all the witchcraft to them. The girls continuously did things to make the towns people believe that they were under a sort of spell caused by the sisters.
Salem Witch Trials Essay Research Paper Salem
Salem Witch Trials- Essay, Research Paper Salem Witch Trials- Superstition and witchcraft resulted in many being hanged or in prison. In the seventeenth century, a belief in witches and
The Salem Witchcraft Trials Did The Devil
Make Them Do It Essay, Research Paper The Salem Witchcraft Trials: Did the Devil Make Them Do It? One of the most devastating events in history was the Salem Witchcraft Trials. Due to a few hysterical girls’ accusations and the fear of a village, twenty people were executed and hundreds were put in jail. Now the question still asked today is, “Were the people accused really witches possessed by the devil?” The belief today is that no, they were not witches nor were they involved with the devil.
Salem Witchcraft Trials Essay Research Paper Salem
Salem Witchcraft Trials Essay, Research Paper Salem Witchcraft Trials If one person believes something, all the rest will follow. Modern day people learned this in Salem, Massachusets during the witchcraft trials. Hysteria is a main cause
The Witchcraft Hysteria Essay Research Paper The
The Witchcraft Hysteria Essay, Research Paper The Witchcraft Hysteria In 1692, in Salem Massachusetts, the superstition of witches existed in a society of strong puritan beliefs. Anybody who acted out of the ordinary was accused of being a witch, and then the accused would actually be forgiven if they admitted it and told the court of anyone else that was with the devil.
Witchcraft And Wicca Essay Research Paper Witchcraft
Witchcraft And Wicca Essay, Research Paper Witchcraft and Wicca When you think of Witchcraft, and Wicca what comes to your mind. Historically people have associated Witchcraft with evil and regard people as using Witchcraft as harming others. The terms Wicca and Witchcraft can be used interchangeably, but there is a distinction.
John Hale Vs John Proctor Essay Research
Paper Rev. John Hale vs. John Proctor The characters of John Hale and John Proctor in ?The Crucible? can be compared and contrasted according to their key traits, goals, and
Death Of The Innocent Essay Research Paper
Death of the Innocent In Arthur Miller s The Crucible, the shear madness of the Salem witch trials is explored in great detail. Historically, there are many theories on how the accusations were started such as moldy flower, resulting in the accidental taking of narcotics, or a simple break down in society.
The Crucible Essay Essay Research Paper During
The Crucible Essay Essay, Research Paper During the Salem witch trials of 1692, many innocent people die as a cause of being accused of witchcraft. In this time period where people believe the most obscure and inconsequential stories, it is common sense for them to believe in witchery. One author named Arthur Miller, docuemented these trials in a play called The Crucible.
The Crucible Reasons Innocent People Confessed To
Witchcraft Essay, Research Paper Living in Salem, Massachusetts in 1692 during the Witchcraft Trials must had been an uncanny event to experience. The entire witchcraft hysteria started because people were
Salem Witchcraft Trials Essay Research Paper One
Salem Witchcraft Trials Essay, Research Paper One of the most devastating events in American events in American history was the Salem Witchcraft Trials. Due to a few hysterical girls’ accusations and the fear of a village, twenty people were executed and hundreds were put in jail. Now the question still asked today is, “Were the people accused really witches possessed by the devil?” No, they were not witches nor were they involved with the devil.