, Research Paper
Why do national firms become multinational? Critically Discuss.
We must first define between a national firm and one that is multinational. A definition of a national firm could be a firm that s market is mainly in the country it sells into and has no Foreign Direct Investment in any other country apart from the one in which it sells into. A multinational on the other hand is a lot harder to define because over time the very nature of a multinational has changed. For Example in 1958 Maurice Bye began to see and recognise multinational enterprises (MNE s) by the definition Multi-territorial firm indicating that a MNE was purely given the name by the amount of countries a company occupied. By 1960 this had already been updated with David Lilienthal new definition, Multinational Corporation that has become a recent standard definition. Academics see a multinational in greater depth and again the definitions are always slightly different, J.Dunning defines a MNE as an enterprise that engages in Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and owns or controls value adding activities in more than one country (1992). Dicken on the other hand believes a Trans-national corporation is a firm that has the power to co-ordinate and control operations in more than one country, even if it does not own them. This illustrates the problems of defining a multinational although we can see that there are common themes. We can therefore assume for the purpose of this text that a multinational is” firm that has headquarters in one country, but with bases, manufacturing or assembly plants in others. However Quelch and Klein argue that Any company that establishes a site on the Internet automatically becomes a Multinational corporation. (Internet Encarta) Which would suggest that most large national corporations are in fact multinational because of the very fact that a website makes them Global and open to a foreign market but this is somewhat wrong because it does not fulfil the criteria of FDI in a country.
National firms become multinational for a number of key reasons, to take advantage of overseas resources and factors of production, to be closer to there market, to avoid legislation, to gain tax advantages, to weaken domestic unions, to increase global sales and to gain monopoly power over there competitors. Although multinationals can be defined into three categories, natural resources e.g. Petroleum and Mining, manufacturing e.g. Chemicals and consumer goods and lastly the service industry for example shipping and banking. We will look at the term multinational in its broadest sense because each fragment has its own individual reasons but all of them carry common themes
Many national companies will become in a sense multinational to make use of resources abroad, for example before world war two most foreign operations established themselves abroad to secure sources of raw material, developing countries were usually the recipient of world-wide FDI, mining companies like St John d el Rey set up operations in Brazil so that they could mine gold not only in the US but also in Latin America. You can argue that even today this idea of getting closer to your raw materials has not changed because it reduces overhead costs although it is less of a factor today because increased transport networks have made it increasingly easier to get to your raw materials. Recently what has become more prevalent is that MNE s have taken advantage of the cheaper labour costs of developing countries. For example, In the United States hundreds of corporations from automakers to electronics manufacturers have moved jobs from high-wage US facilities to low-wage plants in Mexico and other Latin American nations. (R.C.Longworth, The New Global Economic Order) What is essential though when companies become transnational is that although there may be cheaper labour in developing countries often they are not as skilled. This can often lead to poorer productivity, for example, labour is X times less than there home country, but at the same time productivity could be X times less. Here it would be pointless ploughing FDI into a new foreign adventure because there is no gain.
As Kenwood and Lougheed would argue there has been an international economic market from the 1820 s but perhaps industrial growth accelerated in the last quarter of the nineteenth century, the consumption of raw materials increased phenomenally. (The growth of the international economy 1820-2000,p11) It is impossible not to argue that with an international economy there will be companies that become transnational, to get closer to there market it is for this reason many national companies become multinational. It enables there product to become internationally available, moreover with premises closer to the market there are other advantages, for example they are able to cut transport costs, thus there product is in line with home competitors and not more expensive. Another key reason why many firms become multinational is that they are able to avoid legislation in there own country which may prevent firms getting too big. (Nancy Wall and Barry Martin) More significantly though firms often become multinational to avoid trade barriers this has been very noticeable with such far east countries who specialise in electronics and automotive products moving into Europe to avoid the Common External Tariff. For a national company who has a large foreign market but does not have other premises abroad there often are a lot of tariffs to pay. The advantage of building factories in other countries here is obvious for two main reasons, first they become more global and second they are able to avoid these tariffs.
Many large national organisations have tax advantages or grants from overseas governments which encourages them to become multinationals for example the European Union has encouraged overseas investment. If we look to the UK this is apparent with such huge plants as the Nissan factory in Sunderland a recognised black spot in the UK for employment. Nissan had huge grants to build there factory there because it would create jobs thus there would be a domino effect which would create wealth to a depleted area.
In many countries national companies face pressure from Trade Union activity to avoid this companies spread their bases around the world, this in turn weakens domestic unions. In Europe this is noticeable in such countries as Sweden who have strong Trade Unions. Often countries with weak of not even any unions are those in developing countries MNE s have taken advantage of this ploughing large amounts of FDI. For example before WWII the share of FDI going into developing countries was about sixty percent but by the seventies this had dropped to around twenty-five percent, by the mid nineties this had increased once again to around forty percent. This shows the attractiveness of developing countries to multinationals and national firms, partly the reason why national firms become multinational.
National firms become multinational to increase Global Sales, as Drucker has argued we live in the age of Social transformation whereby be have more disposable income. Many smaller national companies have turned multinational to expand production activities abroad, this can account for a number or MNE s originating from developing areas like Hong Kong and South Korea. What has been key to there success is the improvement in technology, transportation, production processes and communications.
So Have the reasons changed over time for national firms to become Multinational? It is possible to argue that firms naturally become multinational from such acquisitions and vertical/backward integration, it is hard for a national firm to become multinational purely from organic growth. Therefore it would be fair to say that firms don t actually mean to become multinational rather it is by accident that they become Global. What is interesting though is that FDI has changed, in the early 20th century it was essentially Spillover investment for example US firms would invest in Mexico and Canada. Post war it was going into developing countries like Japan and South Korea, here we see the greatest growth in FDI, data shows it rose by 251%. Today though most FDI goes into developed countries like much of Europe. However having said that my belief is that the key concepts of becoming multinational are pretty constant over time. For example in the agriculture commodities United Brands, in the 1920 s still wanted to gain from all of the above reasons, e.g. they wanted to be close to their market thus they bought plantations so that they were close to their producers. (Multinational and natural resources, p88)(Integration) Instead of having one central depot where all produce was transported to, it also gave them chance to grow quickly and gain a larger market share so they could be world leaders. This shows the incentives are still the same although where FDI goes is different.
Summary
To conclude as Raymon Vermon argues companies become multinational as the advantages abroad meant, cheaper labour, cheaper raw material and so on which reduces unit costs. Thus you become more competitive and are able to increase sales. This view though is becoming increasingly archaic as Dicken would argue in the Global Shift; this is no longer the sole reason for becoming multinational, it does not take into account the intricate ways in which firms engage in international operations through various collaborative ventures . On the other hand Steven Hymer argues that it must have an advantage over its host firms to become multinational. Essentially though there are three main stages in the evolution to become a multinational. The company must rely on export and expansion of export sales to justify building new plants abroad, a Sony power point presentation found on the internet argued the criteria for a MNE to be A companies whose foreign sales are at least 25%. Secondly foreign production, there must be a limit to foreign sales that is being halted by being a national company. Lastly the company needs to begin planning, organising, co-ordinating, production, R+D, marketing and financing to become multinational. In deciding whether the reasons for becoming multinational have changed, considering the buzz word has only been around for the best part of 40 years it is fair to say that it hasn t. Moreover if we look back to the end of the last century the only real difference is that the huge Petroleum Companies, Gold Miners and Fruit growers only became multinational to get close to there market because the transport of such goods was more difficult than it is today. Thus it was an imperative to become multinational if you were to succeed. Perhaps Richard Longworth in his recent publication, The coming crisis for first world nations, 1998 has got it right with describing multinationals as Global Corporations.
Другие работы по теме:
Financial institutions
The concept, types and regulation of financial institutions. Their main functions: providing insurance and loans, asset swaps market participants. Activities and basic operations of credit unions, brokerage firms, investment funds and mutual funds.
Italian National Soccer Essay Research Paper ITALIAN
Italian National Soccer Essay, Research Paper ITALIAN NATIONAL TEAM HISTORY With an extraordinary record which includes three World Cups the Federazione Italiana Giuoco Calcio celebrated its 100th birthday in 1998. The Italian team was founded on March 16th 1898 on Torino, Italy. The first president of this federation ever elected was Mario Vicary.
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper The
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper The Supreme Court case of McCulloch v. Maryland set forth important principles in American government. The case itself dealt with whether or not the Congress had power from the Constitution to establish a national bank; also, it dealt with whether or not a state could tax or interfere with the national bank.
Greg Sirico Essay Research Paper Adv American
Greg Sirico Essay, Research Paper Adv American Gov. November 14th ?98 McCulloch v Maryland Can congress incorporate a bank? Can a state tax the national government? These were some of the key issues that brought up in the Supreme Court case of McCullloch v Maryland. James Madison, the judge in this case, rules in favor of the National Government.
The Monopoly Essay Research Paper a Using
The Monopoly Essay, Research Paper a) Using Australian examples describe the characteristics of the two of the following forms: Monopoly Oligopoly The main characteristics of an oligopoly are:
Smoking Essay Research Paper There are four
Smoking Essay, Research Paper There are four distinct markets structures in the American economy. These four markets are, pure competition, pure monopoly, monopolistic competition, and oligopoly. These four market models differ as to the number of firms in the industry, whether those firms produce standardized products, or try to differentiate their products from those of other firms, and how easy or difficult it is for firms to enter the industry.
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Always True To The
“Star Spangled Banner” Essay, Research Paper Always True to the “Star-Spangled Banner” The “Star-Spangled Banner” means a lot to the American people. It represents the hardships and victories that we as Americans have prevailed against. This song perfectly depicts the challenge of the American Revolution.
The Extent Of Oligopoly Essay Research Paper
Oligopoly Oligopoly is a market structure dominated by a small number Of large firms, selling either identical or differentiated products, and there are significant barriers to entry into the industry. This is one of four basic market structures. The other three are perfect competition, monopoly, and monopolistic competition.
Lawyer Essay Research Paper A day in
Lawyer Essay, Research Paper A day in the life of an attorney. Its said that its the last job you’ll ever want. (source 1) Over thirty percent of lawyers who receive their law degrees are not practicing law
American Fed Essay Research Paper American federalism
American Fed Essay, Research Paper American federalism is a form of government in which the constitution distributes governmental powers between the national government and the subsidiary governments of the states. Article I, Section 8, and the Tenth Amendment are good examples of this definition. In Article I, Section 8, the Constitution defines the powers delegated to the national government, such as the power to regulate commerce and to enact laws necessary and proper for the execution of its powers.
Foreign Bribary Essay Research Paper Since moral
Foreign Bribary Essay, Research Paper Since moral standards vary across cultures, firms that develop in global markets have to face more complex ethical issues than if they just made business in one country and one culture. Laws and customs in one country don’t necessarily agree with the laws and customs from another country and that is what makes the international business system so complex.
Airline Safety Bill Essay Research Paper Introduction
Airline Safety Bill Essay, Research Paper Introduction (Background of Actors): There are quite a few actors in respect to interest groups and domestic airline safety. The interest groups come from varying backgrounds of business, labor, government and public interest. The actors that we are focused on are the domestic airline companies, the aerospace industry, private security firms, various labor groups, National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Department of Transportation (DOT), Congress, The World Conference on Transportation Research Society (WCTRS) and the American people.
Pure Competition Essay Research Paper Pure CompetitionThere
Pure Competition Essay, Research Paper Pure Competition There are many industries. Economist group them into four market models: 1) pure competition which involves a very large number of firms producing a standardized producer. New firms may enter very easily. 2) Pure monopoly is a market structure in which one firm is the sole seller a product or service like a local electric company.
Japan
– What The United States Can Learn Essay, Research Paper What The United States Can Learn From Japan Japan and the Four Little Dragons in order to achieve their
Drilling For Oil In The Arctic Wildlife
Refuge Essay, Research Paper The question of whether to drill for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge stands clearly on the energy issues table. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is a 1.5 million-acre parcel of wilderness area bordering the Arctic Ocean to the north and the Trans-Alaska Pipeline to the south.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
FACTORS AFFECTING THE LOCATION OF A BUSINESS
Essay, Research Paper There are many factors to consider when locating a new business which all play an important part in successful sale of a product. For some firms only a few factors will be important. Other firms may need to consider and balance a complex mixture of location factors. One important factor to consider is the infrastructure of business site: 1) The business needs very good transport systems for the site the most common are (road, rail, river, canal, ports)
Cheating Essay Research Paper Students of all
Cheating Essay, Research Paper Students of all ages have been caught cheating. Recent news reports that cheating among students has risen to ?epidemic proportions?. Cheating is a contagious behavior that can be corrected through home, school, and national levels of intervention.
Three Sides Of Labor Unions Essay Research
Paper Summarize the three arguments on labor unions. To start with, the Conservatives believe that labor unions are bad. They feel that labor unions have too much power for their size. Labor unions use this power as blackmail against companies, by becoming labor monopolies. They ask too much of companies, causing either the company to shut down, or to supply more money for the employees.
Federal Government Essay Research Paper How does
Federal Government Essay, Research Paper How does the constitution divide power between the national government and the states? The constitution did not give the national government or the states total supremacy. Instead, power was distributed. The national government was given certain express powers, while some powers were reserved to the states.
Economies Of Scale
– Retailing Essay, Research Paper Aim – During this investigation I will identify the economies of scale earned by a large firm and compare them with a small firm. To make it a fair comparison I have chosen two firms associated with the same market. These are Waitrose, and a small family owned village shop, Beaconsfield Stores.
The National Debt Essay Research Paper The
The National Debt Essay, Research Paper The National Debt For the past centuries, the american people dug themselves into a big hole which is the National Debt. In this paper I will discuss the history of the national debt, effects on the debt/deficit, wais to reduce it and control the deficit. the national debt has increased every year from 1945 to 1995.
The National Enquirer Essay Research Paper The
The National Enquirer Essay, Research Paper The National Enquirer UFO causes a 40-car pileup The thunder and lightning that disturbed this cold dreary morning was caused by an unidentified flying object. Bob Thomas, a teacher at Orem High School, was driving on the freeway when he spotted a UFO He immediately called 911 on his cell phone.
International Joint Ventures Essay Research Paper Summary
International Joint Ventures Essay, Research Paper Summary: Knowledge, Bargaining Power, and the Instability of International Joint Ventures The purpose of the journal article is to identify the primary reason for instability within international joint ventures. The authors begin by defining instability and then continue by linking it to bargaining power.
Circular Flow Of Economics Essay Research Paper
The circular flow model is defined as the flow of resources from households to firms and of products to firms from households. These flows are accompanied by reverse flows of money from firms to households and from households to firms. The circular flow is comprised of the resource market, households, product market, businesses, and the government.
IT Tech Essay Research Paper FullService Firms
IT Tech Essay, Research Paper Full-Service Firms Will Bring More Spice to Web-Trading War Investors who have invested online at discount web sites may drop their current service provider and go to a full service firm. Full service firms such as Merril Lynch, Salomon Smith Barney and Paine Webber have entered into the online web trading war.
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages
The Job Of A Graphic Designer Essay
, Research Paper Graphic designers create the visual presentation and design of goods, from gravestone markers to detergent boxes, from album covers to dog food cans (The Princeton Review Guide to Your Career.) Graphic artists, or graphic designers, are the bases of the graphic world. It is their designs that are sent to layout artists and then to the printers and then onto the outside world on cd covers, cereal boxes, billboards, posters, and basically anything that has to do with a visual representation.
Globalization Essay Research Paper In our book
Globalization Essay, Research Paper In our book globalization refers to the shift toward a more integrated and interdependent world economy. Globalization has two main components, first is the globalization of markets, and second is the globalization of production.