Paper
The autonomy of law and in particular the alleged separateness of law and politics has been the subject of debate since time immemorial. Many legal theorists have made the assertion that law is autonomous and is different from politics; many others have gone as far as to call the supposed separation of law and politics a mere myth.
It is the intention of this paper to make a very humble contribution to this debate. This paper is premised upon the refutation of the autonomy of law and the separation of law and politics. I will address the political content of law and show that law and politics are interrelated in that each one influences the other. Considerable attention will be given to the works of legal theorists Ronald Dworkin and Roberto Unger on the subject and in particular the notion of law is politics that was espoused by both of them. I will then go on to briefly discuss some aspects of critical legal theory.
While it is beyond the scope of this paper to indulge in an in-depth analysis of natural and positive law theories, it is useful to take as our point of departure a discussion of some of their basic elements.
Natural law writers argue that natural law is discoverable by reason in human nature.1 Aosara Lucania indicated that the basis for understanding law and social order is provided by the nature of the human soul.2 Natural law writers also agree that natural law is a higher law in that it is superior to any man-made law. Furthermore, natural law is claimed to be universal in that it applies generally to all people regardless of where in the world they are, and that it is unchangeable in that it stays the same regardless of historical changes or social attitudes and opinions.
Firstly, the name natural, in my view, is misleading because it suggests that it evolved by nature. What I mean by natural law is divine law; law that has been brought about by way of revelation by “Allah”. This natural law can be argued to be superior to man-made law because it gets its validity from God.3 Moreover, man-made law can be argued to be inferior because of the fact that it is incomplete or imperfect. This is because it is impossible for a set of rules constructed by a human being to apply to a variety of cases or situations in a neutral and objective manner to cover every conceivable situation that may arise. This is evident in the discovery of loopholes in legislation time and time again. Man-made law can also be argued to be inferior to divine law because it lacks universality. This is because, as has been emphasized above, it can not cover every conceivable case. Instead, it is designed to apply to a particular community or society.
Positive law, on the other hand, generally refers to law that is “posited” or laid down by a human agent, man-made law. Hence, the idea of “positivism” as a legal philosophy. Positivists argue that the law of legal systems is created by human acts, imposed on people, and that the proper role for legal philosophy is to come to an understanding of the nature of the legal systems rather than speculate about morality. Positivists argue that morality is not a necessary element of the concept of law, and that it can be excluded from the analytical study of law. H.L.A. Hart explained that morality is not considered as part of the definition or concept of law as positivists see it. This is because legal positivists claim to study what law is and not what it ought to be. This is one of the major conflicts between natural and positive law theories. On the one hand, the positivists’ definition of law is separated from questions of morality, politics and personal ideals. On the other hand, according to natural law, unjust or immoral statutes or court pronouncements are not really law.* Positivist theory, in this respect, seems to beg the question because it relies on the law in order to explain the law.
The legal theories of Dworkin and Unger, however, address the political content of law in order to explain the law and therefor their theories can be described as political theories of law. Both Dworkin and Unger advocate the slogan “law is politics” which means that the judiciary makes policy decisions in deciding cases just as the legislature makes policy decisions when it enacts law. According to Unger, politics is the “conflict over the mastery and uses of governmental power” and “the conflict over the terms of our practical and passionate relations to one another and over all the resources and assumptions that may influence these terms”*. Then, because law is a mechanism of social control and an exercise of governmental power, legal argument may be considered to consist primarily of political debate over what exactly forms the best social order. Unger recognizes that society is made up of various groups that advance different concepts of the human good and compete for control of government power *. He argues that ” the class struggle ensues from the development of ‘group pluralism’ and subjectivity of values in liberal society” *. Law is therefore not independent from politics, but is rather an extension of political debate, and forms an important of what Unger calls “society making activity” *.
Dworkin’s definition of politics is almost identical to that forwarded by Unger. According to Dworkin, political theory is that which explains and justfies the legal order. In Dworkin’s view “law is the means by which a community interprets its own basic convictions about the most desirable ways of arranging and regulating its political life” *. In order to solve legal problems, recourse to political theory is required because it these political theories that are the source of rights. In addition, because legal concepts can be interpreted in many different ways we should not rely on them to solve legal problems. Instead, we should look at the policies and intentions behind these “abstract concepts” that we have created. Dworkin sees law as fundamentally constituting an “ongoing narrative of the community’s political morality in the process of attaining justice” *. He identifies legal argument as a species of political argument, and therefore locates the source of law in politics. Legal practice, he argues, is an exercise in interpretation and that law is “deeply and thouroughly political” *. From what we have discussed above we can see that both Unger and Dworkin perceive law as a form of political activity and hence argue that “law is a function of politics and social theory, and it is not an autonomous branch of knowledge” *.
“The starting point of critical theory is that legal reasoning does not provide concrete, real answers to particular legal or social problems. Legal reasoning is not a method or process that leads reasonable, competent, and fair- minded people to particular results in particular cases *. The different in reasoning may explain the frustration of the layman with the law. This is because they cannot comprehend how, for instance, a court could come to a particular judgment in a particular case when according to their intelligent investigation of social facts and social policies they have arrived at a completely different conclusion.
Critical theory claims that legal reasoning does not provide the source for results to legal questions, rather the results come from those same political, moral, social and religious value judgments from which the law claims to be independent *. Therefore, it is argued that decisions are not based on, or determined by, legal reasoning. “The ultimate basis for a decision is a social and political judgment incorporating a variety of factors, including the context of the case, the parties, and the substance of the issues” *.
In conclusion, in light of our discussion above, we can say that far from being autonomous and separate from politics, law is actually very political. Judicial processes are just as political as legislative processes. The fact is that these ideas are rejected by many because they seem to question the legitimacy in which the liberal state depends. It is also rejected by those whose interests remains with the maintenance of the status quo.
346
Другие работы по теме:
Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council
Введение 1 История 2 Структура Список литературы Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council Введение Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council, Leh (дословно: Ладакхский автономный горный совет по развитию, Лех) — автономный горный совет, осуществляющий управление в округе Лех, что в штате Джамму и Кашмир, Индия. [1]
BDSM Essay Research Paper BDSMBDSM stands for
BDSM Essay, Research Paper BDSM BDSM stands for Bondage Discipline Sadism and Masochism. Most regard this as a perverted form of sexuality limited only to gays who they also regard
Physical Punishment Essay Research Paper Physical punishment
Physical Punishment Essay, Research Paper Physical punishment has been a problem in hitting their children so they can have discipline or not hitting them because it is not right, so what can parents do and what can they not do? Should the parents hit them to learn discipline, or should they not hit them and figure out another way to make them learn what discipline is?
Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper Pain In
Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper Pain In Punishment Part 1: Corporal Punishment in Schools The use of corporal punishment has been declining in U.S. schools. Losing public acceptance, increased awareness against school boards and educators regarding its use and legislative bans have led to the decline.
A 15TH CENTURY PAINTING IS A DEPOSIT
OF A SOCIAL RELATIONSHIP ? IS THIS TRUE OF ALL WORKS OF ART Essay, Research Paper PATRONAGE ? 15th century artists commissioned by the elites to paint chapels etc (e.g. St. Peter?s chapel) ?
Is Singapore A Model For The West
? Essay, Research Paper Is Singapore a Model for the West? Singapore has definitely made the most out of their location and their small size. But would their lifestyle and economic management work for other countries? This is the question that can only be answered by looking to the dedication and discipline of the citizens and leaders.
The Reform Of Schools Essay Research Paper
The Reform of Schools The government of Ontario proposes there is a need to make universally accepted rules in the school system. For students to be more disciplined, the government needs to achieve new province wide standards. If the new school standards will not discipline the students, and if each school entails its guidelines, then the government s province wide code of conduct will fail.
Entomology Essay Research Paper Entomology is the
Entomology Essay, Research Paper Entomology is the study of insects, involving their biology and control in relation to their environment and to man. Entomology also had an independent scientific discipline which had roots in biology.
Joe Essay Research Paper aggressionPleasure sports are
Joe Essay, Research Paper aggression.Pleasure sports are simply played for pleasure. Score is usually not kept. The athletes participating are usually on occasion doing it for fun and exercise. A majority of athletes who have been playing sports since they were little, have probably been pounded into their heads that to be successful in sport, you need to be aggressive, and at some times, unnecessary.
High School Cuts Essay Research Paper Our
High School Cuts Essay, Research Paper Our principal recently asked for the student?s opinions on the ?school cuts? proposal. This proposition proposes that all extra curricular activities be cut until the money
Bush Tax Cut Essay Research Paper After
Bush Tax Cut Essay, Research Paper After a great 8 years under President Clinton s fiscal discipline in the government, we have had a great economic surplus that included other huge surpluses as well. President Bush wants a huge tax cut that obviously can increase interest rates and recreate the loss of consumer and business confidence that had the same deficits during the late 80 s and early 90 s.
Philosophy A Comprehensive Definition Essay Research Paper
The word ?philosophy,? by definition, is extremely vague and ambiguous. It can be related to anything to do with thought, perception, and even basic human existence. Therefore, in defining philosophy, perhaps it is easier to simply state what it may or may not involve rather than trying to find a concrete and simplified definition.
Bruce Lee An Ideal Role Model Essay
, Research Paper In the Book Bruce Lee: They Died too Young, writer Jon Lewis tells the story of the greatest martial artist that ever lived. Known as Lee Jun Fan only to his family, Bruce Lee was an enthusiastic boy who took a special interest in the martial arts. Unfortunately,his life was cut short at the age of only thirty-two.
High Performance Training For Track And Field
Essay, Research Paper Phillip Lucas Mr. Tarlow 120 English The book I have chosen to research is High Performance Training for Track and Field. Every since the age of nine I have been in love with track. My uncle would make bets with the other guys in the neighborhood that their kids couldn’t beat me in any all out sprint.
What Does It Mean To Be Moral
Essay, Research Paper What does it mean to be moral? Our morality is used every day in every situation and decision we make. Morality is very much a part of who you are. To be a person who is moral you know what is right and wrong on your own.
Impertinence Toward Parents Essay Research Paper As
Impertinence Toward Parents Essay, Research Paper As years go by, it seems that children have little or no respect at all for their parents. Personally, I have an aversion to children who disrespect people older than them. Those children have no manners and probably were not taught any by their parents. The problem is not only with children, they are expected to do it because they do not know any better.
High School DropOuts Essay Research Paper HighSchool
High School Drop-Outs Essay, Research Paper High-School Drop-Outs How can students be motivated to stay in school? First of all, I think the students should be motivated mainly by their parents and then by their teachers. Parents should motivate their children by telling them how being a high-school graduate will help them in life.
Revolutionary War Essay Research Paper The Prussian
Revolutionary War Essay, Research Paper The Prussian Baron von Steuben, being a newcomer to the Revolutionary cause in America, was in a position to see many of the deficiencies in military discipline and their causes. The reasons for his unique insight may have been due to the fact that he was distanced from the revolutionary ideals in America, and as a result, was able to better observe and understand them; and ultimately use them to shape his new and successful form of discipline in the Continental Army.
Puerto Rico Essay Research Paper PUERTO RICOAmong
Puerto Rico Essay, Research Paper PUERTO RICOAmong all the Caribbean territories Puerto Rico has the closest association with the United States. In 1952 a new constitution made Puerto Rico an autonomous part of the United States called the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, or Estado Libre Asociado de Puerto Rico.
Chemist Essay Research Paper Becoming a chemist
Chemist Essay, Research Paper Becoming a chemist takes a lot of hard work and discipline. One very importan aspect of being a chemist is English, Comunication is of the utter most importance
The Dead Poet That Kill Himself (A
Response To _Dead Poet’s S Essay, Research Paper The movie Dead Poet’s Society raises an interesting question: When educating teen-agers, is it better to use the school’s policy of Tradition, Honor, Discipline, and Excellence or Mr. Keating’s philosophy of carpe diam (seize the day)? Mr. Keating believed that people should “suck the marrow out of life” and live like a free thinking person even at the young age of seventeen.
Taekwondo Essay Research Paper Eng Comp ITaekwondoTaekwondo
Taekwondo Essay, Research Paper Eng. Comp. I Taekwondo Taekwondo, usually thought of by most people as just a way of fighting, and as being a brutal sport. People consider it brutal because of all the kicks, punches, throws, and arm and wrist locks; they usually aren?t open minded enough to see the way it benefits people especially children.
Disciplining A Child Essay Research Paper In
Disciplining A Child Essay, Research Paper In today s society children are becoming more and more disrespectful. Most parents do their best to make their child understand what is acceptable behavior and what is not. When a parent spanks a child, he or she should then realize they have made a mistake and know not to do it again, but usually they mess up once more.
Marcelino Essay Research Paper The catalyst for
Marcelino Essay, Research Paper The catalyst for the intense drama that follows is this scene: One exasperated monk, trying to instill discipline in a beloved orphan boy, conjures up a rule. He exclaims, “You must NEVER climb this stairway!” to the attic.
Disciplining Your Child Essay Research Paper Disciplining
Disciplining Your Child Essay, Research Paper Disciplining your child can be rough on the child but mostly on you. Disciplining your child is a hard thing to do when it comes around. The main thing parents worry about is when should I discipline, how should I discipline, and what are some things I can do instead of disciplining.
Child Abuse Essay Research Paper Smacking and
Child Abuse Essay, Research Paper Smacking and the Damage Done There has always been a fine line between discipline and child abuse. What a parent thinks is right may not always be what is healthy for a child. “The Broken Chain,” by M.F.K. fisher is an essay about a young girls history of child abuse. Though many people feel that disciplining a child physically is acceptable, abuse is abuse!
Spanking Essay Research Paper In western society
Spanking Essay, Research Paper In western society, spanking is often not seen as a suitable way to discipline youth. In fact, spanking is a good way to discipline by helping to build self-awareness and morality, it is beneficial to
Discipline As Folklore Essay Research Paper There
Discipline As Folklore Essay, Research Paper There is no need to argue whether discipline has a role in society. The types, severity, and appropriateness are debatable, but it surely serves a purpose. This applies on a global scale, with groups such as NATO and the UN, all the way down to individual households.
General Patton Essay Research Paper His methods
General Patton Essay, Research Paper His methods of attack, his persuasive speeches, and his decisive tactics made General Patton a vital part to United States success in wars. He showed nationalism and pride for United States. On the beginning of the video, we see his personality to war and life. Patton had a unique ability to speak using profanity in his speeches to put down the enemies and raise the morale of his country.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
Child Discipline Essay Research Paper The discipline
Child Discipline Essay, Research Paper The discipline of a child must always come from the parents, as society says. Power corrupts, however, and absolute power over another person can corrupt absolutely. Taking advantage of the thinness of the line between discipline and abuse, a parent often doesn?t have to answer to anyone if and when they cross that line.
Law And Society Essay Research Paper Law
Law And Society Essay, Research Paper Law and Society The function of law in a society is more or less universal. It acts as a deterrent to control the evil and treacherous behavior of humans, to maintain discipline and imposes restrictions on some freedom. We live in a chaotic and uncertain world. Without an orderly environment based on and backed by law, the normal activities of life would be lacerated with chaos.
Education The Law And Discipline Essay Research
Paper Michael Weiland November 23, 1999 V. Nichols Education, the Law, and Discipline Discipline is a touchy subject in education. Educators must respect the legal rights of citizens as protected by the Constitution of the United States, Judicial decisions, and State and local Laws. In particular, students who have been identified with disabilities are protected by one of several pieces of legislation at the Federal level.