Ball Lightning Essay, Research Paper
Ball Lightning 59
Boules de Feu
Dateline:04/17/00
Another startling sighting – and certainly one of the most detailed and scientifically credible – comes from Professor Roger Jennison (Department of Electronics, University of Kent) concerning his experiences on board a late-night flight from New York to Washington in March 1963. He later wrote of his experiences in the November 1969 issue of Nature. Jennison states that the phenomenon occurred after the aircraft encountered a thunderstorm in which it was enveloped by a bright and audible electrical discharge. Some seconds later a glowing sphere some 20cm in diameter emerged from the pilot’s cabin and passed down the aircraft’s central aisle approximately 50cm from Jennison. The ball moved on a straight course the whole length of the aisle 75cm above the floor at a velocity relative to the aircraft of about 1.5 ms-1. It was blue-white in colour and its optical output amounted to about 5 to 10 Watts. Interestingly, no heat was felt when it passed close by and the limb darkening (like that of the Sun) gave it an almost solid appearance, indicating that it was optically opaque. No asymmetry could be seen in any dimension so it was impossible to determine whether or not it was spinning.
(First published in AA&ES Magazine, June 1996)
In German, ball lightning is called kugelblitz.
Professor Jennison’s experience is one of the best ball lightning sightings on record. There are reports of this phenomenon going back at least to the Middle Ages, and maybe as far back as ancient Greece. Like meteorites before it, ball lightning is one of those phenomena that science has been reluctant to accept, with a few hold-outs remaining even today.
Ball lightning, or kugelblitz or boules de feu, sometimes appears high in the sky, almost always during a thunderstorm, and usually coincident with a normal cloud-to-ground lighting strike. It has been reported appear in homes and even airplanes. It’s always round, and is reported to be anywhere from a few centimeters to a meter or so in diameter. It has been variously reported as white, blue, yellow, red, orange, or green in color. It only lasts a short time, usually less than 5 seconds, but in a small number of cases it reportedly lasted over a minute. It may descend, hover, or move horizontally, but it has rarely been reported to rise. It sometimes has a strong odor, but not always. It either vanishes silently or with a loud explosion. There are a few purported photographs of ball lightning, but it’s difficult to determine what the photos actually depict. Almost all of the evidence for the phenomenon is anecdotal, consisting of sighting reports from a variety of witnesses.
There are many theories as to how ball lightning is formed, but none that satisfactorily explains its behavior. The most popular theory is that it is composed of a plasma contained within a magnetic field. Another theory is that it is a cloud of a common gas such as methane that has been ignited by a normal lightning strike. The latter theory, however, is at odds with its reported behavior. Clouds of ignited methane would rise from the ground, rather than drop from the sky.
Ball lightning has occasionally been used as an explanation for UFO sightings. As such, it has not been a very successful explanation because the reported behavior of ball lightning is not like that of reported UFOs, not to mention that very few UFO sightings occur during thunderstorms.
One of the most interesting things about ball lightning is its similarity to the UFO phenomenon. In both we have a phenomenon whose appearance we can’t predict and whose origin we can’t explain. Science has, however, reluctantly come to accept ball lightning. Not so with UFOs. What’s the difference?
Skeptic Robert Sheaffer briefly touches on the comparison between ball lightning and UFOs in his recent book, UFO Sightings: The Evidence. He does so, in the context of jealous phenomena. He begins by defining jealous phenomena as phenomena that exhibit “suspiciously careful or watchful” behavior in selecting where and to whom they will appear. He then explains that UFOs must be a “jealous” phenomenon because they appear only to small groups or to individuals, never flying over a crowded football game or a large city in broad daylight. He adds that UFOs appear only when there is a single photographer, never when there are several photographers present. He also adds that Jealous phenomena should not be confused with rare ones. A phenomenon that objectively exists, no matter how rare, will eventually be brought into the open. He says that ball lighting is not jealous, it is simply rare. Sheaffer is admittedly attempting to show in this chapter that jealous behavior is the earmark of a nonexistent phenomenon.
Do Sheaffer’s arguments hold water? Does he show that UFOs are “jealous” (and therefore nonexistent)and ball lighting simply rare? I think he makes several mistakes in his attempt to show this. First, he lumps all UFO sightings together, including sighting reports by pilots, meteorologists, and astronomers together with those of contactees, abductees, and UFO cultists. Having done this, he says:
Ball lightning is not reported to persist for many minutes, or even hours, as are UFOs, it is not reported to return repeatedly to the same favored individuals, as are UFOs, and it does not appear that there are fifteen million Americans who claim to have seen it – that is the number who have claimed to have seen UFOs. If ball lightning were reported as frequently as UFOs and had as many eager investigators hot on its trail, then it indeed would be remarkable that better evidence has not been obtained.
See the lumping together? If you really study UFO reports, you know that the vast majority of them are of very short duration – seconds or scant minutes, not hours. The majority of cases in the Bluebook “Unexplained” category did not involve “favored individuals” who had repeated sightings, but people who had one sighting. If you read the ball lightning sightings reports at the links below, you will see that some of those witnesses are “repeaters,” as well. Ball lightning does not have the allure to attract a cult following as do UFOs, but having a cult following doesn’t detract from the possibility of existence, as is the inference.
The main problem with Sheaffer’s analysis, however, is that he is comparing a natural phenomenon – ball lighting – with something that is supposed to be intelligently controlled – UFOs. Why shouldn’t UFOs, if they are intelligently controlled, exhibit anthropomorphic characteristics such as avoiding crowds and cities? Not that they always do so – I am reminded of a UFO that appeared to the audience of a crowded outdoor theater in China, and one that appeared over Beverly Hills, not to mention several that have appeared over military bases.
What if UFOs are both a rare and a jealous phenomenon? What if there is a core of real UFO sightings that are sightings of intelligently controlled craft whose pilots try to avoid appearing before large groups of people whenever possible?
ufos.about/science/ufos/library/weekly/aa041700a.htm?rnk=r2&terms=Ball+Lightning
Другие работы по теме:
The Ball Poem Essay Research Paper THE
The Ball Poem Essay, Research Paper THE BALL POEM by John Berriman This poem is about losing something that you love, and learning to grow up. It is about a little boy, who for the first time in his young life, is learning what it is like to experience grief at the loss of a much beloved possession his ball. To us, the loss of a ball is of minor consequence, and our reaction to it is to say O there are other balls .
Billiards Essay Research Paper Billiards evolved from
Billiards Essay, Research Paper Billiards evolved from a lawn game like croquet, which was played in the 15th century in Northern Europe and in France. The word billiard comes from either “billart,” a wooden stick or “bille,” a ball. Until recently was dominated by men. Women weren t wanted in a room where pool was taking place.
Joey Essay Research Paper Friday of the
Joey Essay, Research Paper Friday of the hump I didnt have gas mask Sgt Shin made general references in that hazing is ok in his shop and if he does it no one will say anything and if the NCOs do it that he will not say anything.
Descriptive Essays Essay Research Paper The Separating
Descriptive Essays Essay, Research Paper The Separating White Line I glance up at the scoreboard; the clock reads 2:15 left in the fourth quarter. My team is down by 3 points; we have eighty-five yards to go, and have no time outs left. I yell out the cadence and the center snaps the oblong ball into my hands. Taking a short three-step drop I glance to my left.
Baseball
’s New Rules Essay, Research Paper Baseball’s New Rules I started to watch baseball again since the World Series is starting but I have noticed that there are a couple of new rules in
Coriolis Drift Essay Research Paper The Coriolis
Coriolis Drift Essay, Research Paper The Coriolis Effect was discovered by the nineteenth-century French mathematician, G. G. Coriolis. Coriolis found that all moving objects on the earth seem to sidle from their positions-an eastward movement in the Northern Hemisphere and a westward movement in the Southern Hemisphere.
BaseBall Essay Research Paper I never did
BaseBall Essay, Research Paper I never did like the taste of dirt, but I had a mouthful of it from diving head first into second after smacking a line drive down the right field line. Sweat was trickling down my face and stinging my eyes as I wearily got up and wiped the dust off of my uniform. It was the top of the last inning and we were up 9-8.
Tennis 2 Essay Research Paper As we
Tennis 2 Essay, Research Paper As we all know, America is a nation of sports enthusiasts. Most Americans participate is some kind of sporting event, either as a spectator or as a competitor. In the pantheon of great American sports, there is one that stands out. It has been called the great American pastime.
My Theory Of The Universe Essay Research
Paper My Theory of the Universe You are about to be transported to a very strange world, read on if you dare! The planet you are on is a giant disco ball, rotating clockwise. (Earth)
How To Enter A Nineball Tournament Essay
, Research Paper How to Play Tournament Nine-ball People may think that spending eight dollars on a tournament is a waste of money. Every Sunday I go to Millertime Billiards and enter a nine-ball tournament. I never go in thinking that I?m going to win at least my entry fee back, although it would be nice. On the other hand, I always go in knowing that I will walk out understanding more about the game then the night before.
Feeling Essay Essay Research Paper The final
Feeling Essay Essay, Research Paper The final whistle blew. The game was tied, and the winner was yet to be decided. We all knew that the fate of the game was to be determined by penalties, a
The Natural An Article On Roy Hobbs
Essay, Research Paper Roy Hobbs Roy Hobbs. Who can forget the amazing baseball player? Just as quickly as Roy Hobbs came, as quickly he left like a flash of tremendous lightning. He joined the New York Knights in 1947 to what was to become their most memorable season yet. To be there watching Hobbs play was to experience magic.
Exgolf Essay Research Paper Golf is about
Ex:golf Essay, Research Paper Golf is about 10% physical and about 90% mental. A golfer has an inventory of various moods while on the course, awareness of these moods and being able to control them is what can make or break a golf game. A very crucial point in golf is determining your club distances. Many golfers really don?t know how far each club can be hit.
Lucille Ball The World
’s Greatest Actress Essay, Research Paper Just mention Lucy, and everyone knows who you’re talking about. Lucille Ball is without a doubt the world’s greatest actress and the most famous redhead. She is remembered most for her famous TV character, Lucy Ricardo, but there was more to her than just the famous character she portrayed on I Love Lucy.
Cue Ball In Hand Behind The Head
String: Billiards Essay, Research Paper CUE BALL IN HAND BEHIND THE HEAD STRING This situation applies in specific games whereby the opening break is administered or a player’s scratching is penalized by the incoming player having cue ball in hand behind the head string. The incoming player may place the cue ball anywhere behind the head string.
Terminal Velocity Essay Research Paper SC1 Investigating
Terminal Velocity Essay, Research Paper SC1: Investigating Terminal Velocity Introduction When an object falls through a fluid it accelerates until it reaches its terminal velocity. At this speed the forces acting on it are balanced.
Lacrosse Essay Research Paper During spring break
Lacrosse Essay, Research Paper During spring break I went to the beautiful state of Arizona where me and my father were going to play golf all week long. We stayed with my dads old college friends. Well me
Foot Ball Essay Research Paper SonnetThe player
Foot Ball Essay, Research Paper Sonnet The player was ready to kick the ball The other team waited to receive it He gave it a very powerful hit Coaches were screaming to give the right call
Preparation For The Gof Shot Essay Research
Paper Portfolio Final Draft Process Analysis for the Preparation of shot making Preparation for a golf shot involves deep concentration and many technicalities. It all starts with the player taking about two steps directly behind the ball, finding a line from the ball to the target. Next, comes the approach.
Volleyball Essay Research Paper VolleyballVolleyball is an
Volleyball Essay, Research Paper Volleyball Volleyball is an interesting sport. There are nine people on the court that make three lines. The person in the back row, farthest to the left, serves the ball. It is usually served overhand by hitting it with the heel of your hand over the net to the opposite team If you serve the ball and the opposing team can not return it, you get a point.
Anna Karenina Essay Research Paper Anna KareninaLeo
Anna Karenina Essay, Research Paper Anna Karenina-Leo Tolstoy It had grown quite dark and to the south, where he was looking, there were no longer any clouds. The clouds had passed over in the opposite direction. From there came flashes of lightning and the sound of distant thunder. Levin listened to the regular dripping of the raindrops from the lime trees in the garden and looked at the familiar triangle of stars and the Milky Way intersecting it in the middle with its branches.
Softball Essay Research Paper KEEP YOUR EYES
Softball Essay, Research Paper KEEP YOUR EYES ON THE BALL Although the games of baseball and fastpitch softball are quite different, watching a baseball game can improve your softball skills. This particular tip deals with a mechanic in hitting that is mandatory to be successful. It is a simple fundamental, but one that must be consistently communicated in coaching fastpitch: Keep your eyes on the ball.
Football Or Soccer Essay Research Paper Football
Football Or Soccer Essay, Research Paper Football or Soccer Many people argue about soccer and football. Football is mainly an American sport, but it is growing rapidly around the world. Soccer in the other hand is played worldwide; in many people eyes soccer is graceful and well disciplined.
Pushing An Object Essay Research Paper Pushing
Pushing An Object Essay, Research Paper Pushing an object When an object with mass is moving, that it has kinetic energy is well known. Energy quantity can be expressed in two parameters of the mass and the speed. Generally definition of energy is difficult, though the quantity can be measured easily.
A Golf Lesson Essay Research Paper A
A Golf Lesson Essay, Research Paper A Golf Lesson I guess it started when I was about twelve years old. My father took me to this place called a golf course. I did not know why or what we were
Golf Essay Research Paper GolfFrom Tee to
Golf Essay, Research Paper Golf-From Tee to Green 0013:section007 Video analysis project Instructor: My straight left arm is my only strengths in my back swing. My major weakness was that I did not rotate my shoulders far enough. This caused my entire swing to be short and inefficient. My wrists were also in an improper position.
How To Get Better At Basketball Essay
, Research Paper Hey all you amateur basketball players out there. Read this to find out how to improve your game! Tip 1:To be a great basketball player, you first must know your strengths and weaknesses. Big tall people don’t need to shoot threes and short people shouldn’t be in the middle struggling to get rebounds.
Sarah The Dog Essay Research Paper Sarah
Sarah The Dog Essay, Research Paper Sarah The Dog Sarah, wanna play fetch? Grrrr, Woof! Get yer ball! Go get it! Woof woof woof! As her slender, chocolate brown tail wags back and forth as fast as she can move it, she runs laps around the room, searching desperately for her ball like it was the only thing to drink in a desert.
How To Hit A Golf Ball Essay
, Research Paper Although golfers end the day on the 18th green, their day begins on a tee box. A drive, the first hit off a tee toward the objective hole, may seem very routine and insignificant, but, in fact, it is the most important shot taken on each hole. If golfers hit a long drive into the nicely cut fairway, they have only to hit the ball off the nicely cut grass on usually a clear path to the hole.
Rules On Golf Essay Research Paper Golf
Rules On Golf Essay, Research Paper Golf Golf is a game that we all can realte to or at least the ones who are lucky enough to play. Golf is a game that takes time and alot of time to be good at. Most people think that golf is a game that is very easy and because of this it is veiwed as a sport for the weak or nonathletes. Me personaly I love the game and I find it very easy to play.
How To Improve In Tennis Essay Research
Paper FINAL PAPER There are many ways my performance in tennis increased after joining the tennis class. The tennis class gave an insight on strategy, different strokes, serve, and different types of game situations. All of these items are key factors in winning a tennis game with great ease. The class didn’t just inform us of these factors, but it made the students in force them.