Paper
Direct Democracy vs Representative Democracy
The term Democracy is derived from two Greek words, demos, meaning
people, and kratos, meaning rule. These two words form the word democracy which
means rule by the people. Aristotle, and other ancient Greek political
philosophers, used the phrase, `the governors are to be the governed’, or as we
have come to know it, `rule and be ruled in turn’.
The two major types of democracy are Representative Democracy and Direct
Democracy. Clearly the arguments for and against each form of democracy are
plentiful. However, it is my belief that theoretically, Direct Democracy is the
superior form of political rule. Due to problems with in the direct democratic
system, its use as a practical form of government is not even thinkable.
Therefore, in order for any form of democracy to function, Representative
Democracy is the superior form of political rule.
Jean Jacques Rousseau is considered by many to be the `Grandfather’ of
direct the democracy theory. Rousseau’s ideal society would be where the
citizens were directly involved in the creation of the laws which are to govern
their lives. He maintained that, “all citizens should meet together and decide
what is best for the community and enact the appropriate laws. Any law which
was not directly created by the citizens is not valid, and if those laws are
imposed on people, that is equivalent to the people being enslaved.
The citizens of a society must both develop and obey `the supreme
decision of the general will’, which is the society’s determination of the
common good. It is not even thinkable that all citizens will agree on what good
is. Rousseau recognized this and accepted a term of majority rule. Those who
voted against a policy which is found to be the best for the general, must have
been thinking of personal gains, rather than the gains of the entire society.
The feature which distinguishes direct democracy from other forms of
government is the idea of agreement and the key to agreement is discussion. It
is impossible to reach an agreement without discussion, because it is not right
to think that everybody will have the same opinion on all matters. But, it is
very possible, that through discussion an agreement could be reached by all
members. Representation, on the other hand allows a select few to make
decisions in their own best interest, which is not necessarily the best interest
of the society.
However, direct democracy is not the perfect method to produce a union
of the community. For a direct democracy to work, face to face communication
between all members of the community is needed. The only way this is possible
is to meet in large groups. Due to the fear of high tension, many citizens
“will not participate in these large group meeting. So in order for these
fearful people to voice their opinions they must get together in smaller, less
tensions groups, where they are not as timid to say as they wish to see happen.
A direct democracy can only work in a small group, so as a form of government
for an entire community or country, direct democracy would definitely fail. As
the membership increases, people become less involved. Once the membership
reaches the size of a country, the participation still exists, but is limited to
as low as it can go. Thus in a country, any form of direct democracy is only
possible in individual communities.
In order for a committee small enough to operate on direct democracy
principles to have any authority at all, it must represent a much larger group.
Membership in this larger group is chosen by election, so the people still have
a say in the ruling process. Since the rulers are selected by the people, the
rulers should represent what the public wants. Thus, out of direct democracy, is
born a new form of government, the Representative Democracy.
Representative democracy is not democracy in its purest form. The main
argument against representative democracy is that “No one can represent me. I’m
the only one who knows what I’m thinking and no one else can represent my
views.” We have already learned it is also impossible to represent yourself.
Through representation, chosen by the people, the hope is that all people will
be adequately represented. While everyone may not get all of their views
represented all the time, representative democracy should create a situation
where most of the views are represented.
Direct democracy is not impossible in all situations, but in order for
in to exist the following two characteristics must exist- The organization must
be local, (limited in members) and the opinions of the members must be similar
to each other. While these conditions are often found in a small organization,
when looking at a country, these conditions are impossible to meet.
In a mixed society direct democracy would lead to ineffective management,
unwanted inefficiency, and political instability. While In a representative
democracy, the representatives rely on political compromise to resolve conflicts,
and develop policies that are flexible enough to meet shifting circumstances.
The once dominant Greek culture has become out-of-date and along with it
went the hope for a direct democracy system of government. The direct democracy
theory may have worked in the small Greek towns of 500BC, but in large modern
societies, it simply could not work. Which is why the representative democracy
was started, which, while providing the citizen with less opportunity for
participation, is ideally suited for rule in modern times Thus, clearly a
direct democracy is the only true form of democracy. However, if democracy is to
be is used in a modern society, it can not take its purist form.
Другие работы по теме:
Do We Have An Elite Government Essay
, Research Paper Do we really have a democracy? Well, society is too large to have direct democracy. Even representative democracy is hard to achieve on such a large scale. Look at the voter turnout in the United States. It is lower than ever. If ordinary citizens aren’t making policy who is? One answer is the Elite Theory.
Communism Vs Democracy Essay Research Paper The
Communism Vs. Democracy Essay, Research Paper The United States of America is a country that believes in democracy and has unfavorable ties with communist countries. The United States has tried for decades to improve relations with the countries that don t practice democracy. History shows disagreements between the United States and dictators of these irreverent countries, disagreements that brought the world to the brink of nuclear war.
A Republic Is A Better Form Of
Government Than A Democracy Essay, Research Paper “A Republic is a Better Form of Government than a Democracy” I agree that a republic is a better form of government than a democracy. In order to come to this decision I had to research the definitions of each. A republic, according to Webster’s Dictionary, is a government in which supreme power resides in a body of citizens entitled to vote and is exercised by elected officers and representatives responsible to them and governing according to law.
Democracy Essay Research Paper DemocracyThesis Is democracy
Democracy Essay, Research Paper Democracy Thesis: Is democracy a possible form of government? With out it the world would be full of chaos and injustice. Democracy is the form of government that America has today. We are able to vote on whom we want to run our government. We have a say in what goes on in our lives and our future.
Freedom Essay Research Paper As with any
Freedom Essay, Research Paper As with any government, there is the necessity of an economy, or else the government would fail because economy is one of the basic necessities of a government. With a democracy like we have in a country of our size, managing this economy becomes a big problem. One important factor is; In a country based on freedom, how much are we willing to give up to keep the economy stable? None? A little bit? All of it? The answer is not as simple as any of those.
Germany
’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Essay, Research Paper Germany’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Steve Rice Political Science 90 Computer Project
True Democracy Essay Research Paper Complete and
True Democracy Essay, Research Paper Complete and true democracy is almost impossible to achieve, and has been the primary goal of many nations, beginning from ancient civilizations of Greece and Roman Empire, all the way to the government of the United States today. In any system, which claims to be democratic, a question of its legitimacy remains.
America The Modern Day Athens Essay Research
Paper America: The Modern Day Athens “We do not copy our Ancestors, but are an example to them. It is true we are called a Democracy, for the administration is in the hands of the many and
Winston Churchill
’s Quote Analysis Essay, Research Paper Winston Churchill’s Quote on Democracy “Many forms of government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe.
Greece Government Essay Research Paper Government in
Greece Government Essay, Research Paper Government in Greece Our next stop on our journey through ancient Greece will describe the government of Greece to you. Ask yourself the following questions and read the answers to learn more about how ancient Greece was ruled and who made the laws that you would have followed.
Democracy Essay Research Paper Ricky Ramoutar Critical
Democracy Essay, Research Paper Ricky Ramoutar Critical Lens M.E. Sullivan said, “Democracy is only as successful as the people who make it work,” proves itself in the novel Lord of the Flies. I agree with this statement because, if there are to many people opposing one thing there will be war. The boys in this book struggled back and forth trying to establish a stable government.
Mill Essay Research Paper John Stuart Mill
Mill Essay, Research Paper John Stuart Mill on Proportional Representation Two very different ideas are usually confounded under the name democracy. The pure idea of democracy, according to its definition, is the government of the whole people by the whole people, equally represented. Democracy as commonly conceived and hitherto practiced, is the government of the whole people by a mere majority of the people, exclusively represented.
Socrates On Democracy Essay Research Paper In
Socrates On Democracy Essay, Research Paper In Plato?s Euthyphro, Crito and the Apology, we learn of Socrates? highly critical view of the democracy. Socrates believed that democracy was a flawed
VOICE OF DEMOCRACY Essay Research Paper VOICE
VOICE OF DEMOCRACY Essay, Research Paper VOICE OF DEMOCRACY AMERICAS ROLE FOR THE NEXT CENTURY Americas role for the next century will be to stay economically stable. That will be no problem unless
Define Democratic Government Essay Research Paper 1
Define Democratic Government Essay, Research Paper 1. Define Democratic Government. Suggest three Democratic inadequacies in Britain today. Democratic government is a political system based on the principles of freedom and equality. Democratic government mental systems embrace multi-party Parliament.
Legitimacy Of The Government Essay Research Paper
Democracy Representative democracies are based on the will of the people. There is no myth to this statement. Joseph Schumpeter said, “The democratic method is that institutional arrangement for arriving at political decisions in which individuals acquire the power to decide by means of a competitive struggle for the people’s vote.” If this is true, one may ask where the will of the people comes into play.
The Ancient City Essay Research Paper The
The Ancient City Essay, Research Paper The Ancient City Pompeii How democratic was Pompeian politics? In order to answer the above question, it is first necessary to consider the exact meaning of the term democracy . Whilst it is difficult to give an exact definition of the word, it is certainly possible to create a list of the implications of democratic government for a society and its citizens.
Jacksonian Democracy 2 Essay Research Paper Jacksonian
Jacksonian Democracy 2 Essay, Research Paper Jacksonian Democracy The Jacksonian’s view of themselves is accurate in all but a few areas. Jacksonian democracy paved the way for more equality among the common people. Yet with all the changes that were made during the Jacksonian, the equality that was achieved was only held among the white men of the day.
Substantive Democracy And The American People Essay
, Research Paper I’m Afraid of Americans Before one can answer the timeless question of what taxation policy should be implemented onto the American public, one must ask, what type of democratic policy should the US follow? One approach, known as the Substantive Democracy, states that if policy is in the interest of the people than it shall be put into effect.
The American Oligarchy Essay Research Paper America
The American Oligarchy Essay, Research Paper America: The Pretense of Democracy The Aristotelian view of democracy showed democracy as a supreme state of being, promoting equality more than anything. It allowed every person to have as much say in a government as any other person, and yet still allowed individuality to reign.
Democracy Essay Research Paper The Struggle For
Democracy Essay, Research Paper The Struggle For Democracy: Chapter One: Democracy and American Politics. The idea of a democracy has become a tremendous part of people?s lives. It is a system that is basically ruled by the people. In the first chapter of the textbook ?The struggle for Democracy?, we learn about the many ideas and views of a democratic society.
Plato Essay Research Paper Plato was a
Plato Essay, Research Paper Plato was a philosopher in the time of the distinguished Greek philosophers. He wrote a book entitled The Republic in which he explains some of his philosophy on subjects ranging from education to government. Plato constructed a model by which he proposed all governments evolve.
Roman Vs Greek Gov
’t Essay, Research Paper Ancient Governments: A comparison of ancient Greek democracy and Roman republic Even today, the ideals of government expressed and used by the ancient Greeks and Romans are well known. Although the Greek democracy and the Roman republic have many resemblances they also have many differences.
Fundamental Orders Of Connecticut
– First Constitutiuon Essay, Research Paper Fundamental Orders of Connecticut (1639) Direct Democracy. . .A New Beginning In search of more fertile land and greater political and religious
Whats Wrong With Communism Essay Research Paper
Whats Wrong With Communism Aaron Dummer 2/24/97 Period 5 I would go to Russia. I would speak on Government. This is what I would say: I am here today to tell you about freedom. I am here to tell you
Jacksonian Democracy Essay Research Paper Jacksonian DemocracyThe
Jacksonian Democracy Essay, Research Paper Jacksonian DemocracyThe Jacksonian’s view of themselves is accurate in all but a few areas. Jacksonian democracy paved the way for more equality among the common people. Yetwith all the changes that were made during the Jacksonian, the equality that was achievedwas only held among the white men of the day.
Whitman
’s Democracy Essay, Research Paper Whitman’s Democracy “I speak the pass-word primeval, I give the sign of democracy, By God! I will Accept nothing which all cannot have their counterpart
American Democracy Essay Research Paper American Democracy
American Democracy Essay, Research Paper American Democracy The American democracy is one of the most peaceful kinds of government in the world although it is a long way from utopia. The democracy in which we live has many strengths and weaknesses. Neither strengths or weaknesses out weigh one another, but it is necessary to have both due to the varying definitions.
The Evolution Of Democracy Essay Research Paper
Claire Munger The Evolution of Democracy Democracy is more a Utopian aspiration rather than a concrete description of any government. A common understanding of democracy, often applied to unworthy situations, is simply that the masses will govern themselves. This understanding was articulated by an Athenian statesman, Pericles, “Our Constitution is named a democracy, because it is in the hands not of the few, but of the many”(Cummings & Wise, 1971, p.20).
Juan Carlos Essay Research Paper Juan Carlos
Juan Carlos Essay, Research Paper Juan Carlos Report Juan Carlos I, the current king of Spain, was crowned on November 22, 1975. The crowning of Juan Carlos restored democracy to Spain after the dictatorship of Francisco Franco.
Democracy In China Essay Research Paper During
Democracy In China Essay, Research Paper During the 1980?s, China came under the rule of a new man. His name was Deng Xiaoping. China?s culture and views on trade were greatly influenced by Deng, yet he failed in establishing a democratic China. Contrary to many people?s beliefs, Deng did not create any democracy in China.