Mrs. Dalloway Essay, Research Paper
Principles of Ethics: Which ethical model is truly ethical?
Wayne Dyer said, “Live one day at a time emphasizing ethics rather than rules.” This quote rings true across all fields of profession, especially rehabilitation. Why must we follow a code of ethics and not just a list of rules? Ethics are a set of standards by which an individual or a particular group decides to regulate its behavior to distinguish between what is legitimate or acceptable in pursuit of their aims and what is not. As a professional it is important to follow ethics, to consider what is right and what is the correct behavior in a given situation. When merely following rules one does not necessarily consider these things. What is ethical must be a rule but a rule may not be ethical. A code of ethics are needed in the field of rehabilitation so we do not confuse “rights” with “right” and that we don’t let what we think of as our “rights” lead us to hurt others.
There are five principles that are the core of ethics. Beneficence applies to promoting the welfare of clients; nonmaleficence is to prevent harm to clients; autonomy is to respect clients’ freedom to make their own decisions; fidelity applies to keeping promises or commitments that are stated or implied; justice is treating clients fairly. Since the priority given each is determined by the situation, no principle always takes precedence over another. Rehabilitation counselors need to know these five principles in order to help them choose which ethical model to use in their client relationship. These ethical models are the paternalistic model, contractual model, educational model, and deliberative model.
The paternalistic model casts the provider in the role of decision maker. The paternalistic approach is reflected in the Hippocratic Oath where one swears to “benefit” the sick and “keep them from harm” but there is nothing in the oath about respecting their rights. Providers, such as physicians, have many good reasons to make judgments about which treatments, among the wide array of possible interventions, are most likely to benefit patients. Physicians have expert knowledge of medicine, and increasingly this knowledge includes scientific rather than anecdotal judgments pertaining to the effectiveness of treatments. However, the physician’s expertise does not automatically include knowledge of which aspects of health and illness are most significant for the particular patient. Evidence has accrued that physicians do not know their patients values, making them poor proxy decision makers for patients. As with most medical codes of ethics developed over the years, it articulates standards physicians should be guided by and virtues they should have and exercise. For instance, physicians are enjoined to “promote their patient’s well-being” but nothing is said about a patients right to define their own well-being” or participate in decisions affecting it. There are also implicit patient physician stereotypes in the paternalistic model. Patients are dependent individuals medically clueless and emotionally distraught, obliged to trust the doctor’s judgment and follow “doctor’s orders” while doctors are considered wise, benevolent, objective, and skillful. The clear and predominant ethical principles guiding this model are beneficence and nonmaleficence.
The contractual model is based on the notion of increased patient autonomy and participation through the use of informed consent. Informed consent is legally and morally accepted because competent adults ought not to be subjected to medical interventions without their informed and voluntary consent. Courts have ruled: “Physicians have a duty to satisfy the informational needs of the patient.” The patient may question treatment plans and question that the care provided is that which was agreed upon by the patient. This gives the client the ability and the option to refuse treatment. There are limitations to this model. There are difficulties affecting the application of the requirements. Who is competent to give consent? How much information do patients have to be given? When is consent voluntary and not influenced by a third party? Multiple providers who are involved in carious aspects of treatment also limit the model. There are limitations on the providers’ ability to describe every outcome, and whether patients can make informed choices early in the rehabilitation when they cannot understand the risks and benefits of choices.
The educational model starts off by emphasizing beneficence and nonmaleficence but then gradually reaches its goal of restoring long-term autonomy. In the early stages of rehabilitation, the provider assumes the greater responsibility in the decision making due to either a sudden illness or injury making it difficult for the patient to make informed decisions. As therapy progresses and the patient becomes more educated and informed and becomes a participating partner in the treatment. This model however emphasizes unidirectional education. The context of this model may serve to support patients adapting to our environment rather than mutual accommodation.
The discourse theory of deliberative democracy is core to the deliberative model. The theory posits that decisions made among a polity of free and equal citizens, regarding issues of collective concern, and in the common interest, are fair and binding. Decision-making processes must include all who are affected by an issue and legitimate outcomes must represent “an impartial standpoint said to be equally in the interests of all.” Thus, the deliberative democratic theory offers principles of equality among and inclusion of all individuals affected by a decision. Through the deliberative process in rehabilitation, the client, through reflection, choice, and discussion, comes to join the community and through their participation realize that they are members or a community bounded together by a common interest. Clients who participate in the community achieve autonomy and self worth. The environment and community is no longer seen as this is “yours” or this is “mine”. The deliberative model redefines the environment as one that is owned mutually by the provider and patient. One of the most important characteristics in the deliberative model is that it calls for the provider to expand and enhance their empathetic understanding of the patient. This empathetic attunement requires that the parties be able, and willing, to express and receive emotional messages.
Since ethics are vital for a rehabilitation counselor to due his/her duty, they must make sure that the ethical model they choose for their clients meet all five principles of ethics. Counselors can easily hinder a clients’ autonomy without even realizing it. In the paternalistic approach, the counselor can be blinded by their will to do no harm and to promote the welfare of their clients but may end up hindering their clients’ freedom and trust. In the contractual model where the sole guiding principle is autonomy, we have to question whether clients are really autonomous or are they merely being coerced and sold on accepting a certain treatment. The educational model encompasses beneficence, nonmaleficence, and eventually autonomy, but it is still lacking fidelity and justice. Since the guiding principle in the deliberative model is empathy, it is the one true model that incorporates all five of the principles of ethics. It emphasizes equality and justice and because of that fidelity is held up. And because empathy is guiding the counselor, there is beneficence, nonmaleficence, and the respect for the client as an autonomous person. Rehabilitation counselors need to think about what is ethical when deciding which approach to use on their clients and not be influenced by their own belief systems. If counselors follow what is ethical then they should be able to choose an ethical model in their client relationship that will benefit both the client and counselor.
321
Другие работы по теме:
Machiavelli Opinions Of A Perfect Princedom Essay
, Research Paper Niccolo Machiavelli?s work The Prince is a letter he wrote, while he was in exile to Lorenzo Medici. In his work he sought to establish a state capable of resisting foreign attack. His writings are concerned with the principles on which a state is founded, and how they are maintained. He describes the methods by which a prince can acquire and maintain political power.
Mrs Dalloway
– Analysis Of The Film Essay, Research Paper Upon viewing ?Mrs. Dalloway? I was not impressed. The movie seemed to jump from the present to the past. The character Septimus didn?t appear to have any purpose in the storyline. Clarrisa also seemed to be tightly bound by the Victorian lifestyle of the day to make her interesting to me.
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Yup Essay Research Paper The medium that
Yup Essay, Research Paper The medium that was used in Kevin Killrakis art work was colored pastels. The technique used is shading, and is very creative. Basically, what I see in Kevin?s artwork is two very one of a kind daggers.
Isaac Netwon Essay Research Paper Sir Isaac
Isaac Netwon Essay, Research Paper Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz are both accredited for the discovery of Calculus. Both of these men were born about the same and died around the same time. Both were known as supreme intellects of the 17th century.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Essay on Jefferson
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Essay on Jefferson Jefferson had destroyed political traditions. From his contradictions and defecting his priciples, Jefferson destroyed the political precedent and is a exemplatory hypocrite, which can be seen throughout his administration. Jefferson was an admired statesman who was grappling unsuccessfully with the moral issue of slavery.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Adlai Stevenson Essay Research Paper Adlai Stevenson
Adlai Stevenson Essay, Research Paper Adlai Stevenson once commented, “It is often easier to fight for principles than to live up to them. ” I have observed this statement to be true in all aspects of life, from common everyday activities
Momentum Lab Conclusion Essay Research Paper Momentum
Momentum Lab Conclusion Essay, Research Paper Momentum has an integral part in the field of physics. However, many people do not know the importance of momentum in everyday life or even recognize it. The truth is that we use momentum in just about every activity that involves motion. When we drive a car we use the principles of momentum to realize how much cushion space we need or how much stopping distance is needed when going a certain speed.
Benefits By The Confucius
’ Ideas Essay, Research Paper Benefits by the Confucius’ Ideas Modern America would definitely benefit from Confucius’ ideas and teachings. Their ideas mainly dealt with unity and peace. The Confucius’ were very
Dolls House Victims Essay Research Paper In
Doll`s House Victims Essay, Research Paper In what ways do you find Nora a victim? In what ways at fault? Nora Helmer, the wife of Torvald Helmer and mother of 3 children, is a very complex and brave
Henry Foyal Essay Research Paper Henry Fayol
Henry Foyal Essay, Research Paper Henry Fayol’s Principal of management Fayol was a key figure in the turn-of-the-century Classical School of management theory. He saw a manager’s job as:
Theory Of Knowledge
– Mathematics Essay, Research Paper “As far as the laws of mathematics refer to reality, they are not certain; as far as they are certain, they do not refer to reality.” — Albert Einstein
Reiters Syndome Essay Research Paper Equal Rights
Reiters Syndome Essay, Research Paper Equal Rights for Women During the nineteenth century, the women suffrage movement was coming out full force to demand the equal rights of women in the United States and Europe. The women who supported the women’s suffrage adapted a Declaration of Principles that simply stated that, “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and women are created equal” (Perry, 1995, p.194).
The Fountainhead Howard Roark And Objectivism Essay
, Research Paper The Fountainhead: Howard Roark and Objectivism In the novel The Fountianhead, Ayn Rand uses the main character, Howard Roark, to express her daringly original philosophy–Objectivism. Like
Islam Essay Research Paper The political system
Islam Essay, Research Paper The political system of Islam is based on the three principles of Tawhid (Oneness with Allah (God)), Risala ( Prophet hood), and Khilafa ( Caliphate). Tawhid means that Allah alone is the Creator, Sustainer, and Master of the universe and of all that exists in it- organic or inorganic.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Shadow Selves In Mod Fiction Essay Research
Paper A common theme in both Mrs. Dalloway and Heart of Darkness is the shadowing of characters. In Heart of Darkness, Kurtz acts as Marlow s shadow self, and as a catalyst, that brings Marlow to a realization about himself. In Mrs. Dalloway, Septimus acts as Clarissa’s shadow self, and as well, the catalyst that brings her to an understanding of herself.
Computer Scientist Essay Research Paper The title
Computer Scientist Essay, Research Paper The title computer scientist can be applied to a wide range of computer professionals who usually design computers and the software that runs them, develop information technologies, and develop and adapt principles for applying computers to new uses. Computer scientists perform many of the same duties as other computer professionals, but their jobs are distinguished by the higher level of theoretical expertise and innovation they apply to complex problems and the creation or application of new technology.
Untitled Essay Research Paper As John Stuart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper As John Stuart Mills, I believe that my philosophy on government will satisfy the needs of the society. Throughout the 1880?s people have revolted under the circumstances that the government is focused on the society and the individual. My system focuses on liberty, meaning the rights and principles of the individual of a society.
Statue Of Liberty Essay Research Paper I
Statue Of Liberty Essay, Research Paper I chose to write about the Statue of Liberty. The Statue of Liberty serves as a symbolic fixture of the principles America was founded on. She represents freedom, liberty, and opportunity. The location of the Statue of Liberty is an amazing feat in itself, it is right in the middle of a very wide and a very deep Hudson river, and at the time it was brought there, with the limited technology, was amazing.
Sun YatSen Essay Research Paper Sun YatSen
Sun Yat-Sen Essay, Research Paper Sun Yat-Sen helped the growth of Nationalism during the early 20th century. After experiencing and studying in Hawaii, he got a taste of what the western world was like. Sun wanted to help westernize China to keep up with the world s technology and economy. His goal was to nationalize China.
Clarissa And Septimus Essay Research Paper In
Clarissa And Septimus Essay, Research Paper In Virginia Woolf?s book, Mrs. Dalloway, Clarissa Dalloway and Septimus Warren Smith grow up under the same social institutions although social classes are drawn upon wealth; it can be conceived that two people may have very similar opinions of the society that created them.
Mrs Dalloway By Virginia Woolf Essay Research
Paper With a comparison to Clarissa Dalloway and Septimus warren smith. These citizens grow up under the same social institutions and although classes are drawn up on wealth; it can be conceived that two people may have very similar opinions of the society that created them. The English society which Virginia Woolf presents individuals that are uncannily similar.
Principles Of Management Essay Research Paper Management
Principles Of Management Essay, Research Paper Management is a set of activities directed at an organization’s resources with the aim of achieving organizational goals in an efficient and effective manner. The first function of management is planning and decision making. Planning is setting and organization’s goals and deciding how best to achieve them.
Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysics Of Moral Essay, Research Paper Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Moral The central concept of Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of
Differentiation By First Principles Essay Research Paper
The question says you should differentiate y = x2 by first principles. This means you are not allowed just to write down the answer using any ’short-cut’ rules, but must use the ‘official’ method as follows: First, consider a sketch of the graph of y = xІ (right). You have to find an expression for , which represents
The Physics Ofkites Essay Research Paper The
The Physics Ofkites Essay, Research Paper The Physics of Kites Kites are such interesting items. They are toys for many and learning tools for others. To really understand them, one must take into account some laws of Physics. Physics supplies the answer for exactly how a kite can fly and manuever in the air.