, Research Paper
VXI and PXI: Competitive or Complimentary?
Executive Summary
VXI has emerged as a powerful open architecture for automatic test systems in its short thirteen-year history. An evolving new standard for data acquisition and test called PXI has more recently gained a lot of attention. PXI marketers have been promoting PXI as a low cost replacement for VXI. This report examines the key differences between the two architectures and concludes that:
? VXI and PXI address two different market segments and will co-exist for many years to come
? Major ATE systems are currently best implemented using VXI
? VXI provides field proven reliability and minimal risk to major ATE customers
? High resolution, low speed data acquisition systems are best implemented using PXI
? Small, bench top or light weight portable test systems are suited to either architecture; customers should consider future ability to upgrade with existing module technology
History
VXI History
VXI was designed in 1987 as an open architecture by a consortium of five major instrument manufacturers: HP, Tektronix, Racal, Wavetek and Colorado Data Systems. The USAF was instrumental in kicking off this effort.
VXI is based on the VMEbus, with extensions to facilitate high performance multi-vendor automatic test systems. VXI has more than a ten-year track record as a leading architecture for military and commercial automatic test systems.
PXI History
PXI was designed in 1997 by National Instruments as an architecture for data acquisition instrumentation. PXI stands for Pci eXtensions for Instrumentation. National based PXI on the Compact PCI standard, adding features to address the unique needs of the acquisition and test markets.
In August 1997, National Instruments announced Revision 1.0 of the PXI specification. In March 1998 the specification was endorsed by 15 companies, primarily system integrators. In June 1998, the PXI Systems Alliance (PXISA) was formed to discuss and promote the use of PXI as an open standard for data acquisition and instrumentation. Several instrumentation companies have joined the alliance and developed PXI products.
As of August 2000, the PXISA voted to accept ownership of the specification, and to adopt a new revision, Rev. 2.0. Further revisions to the specification are anticipated over the next few years as the PXI Systems Alliance addresses other inherent design issues.
Committees have now been established to deal with the issues of:
1. Heating and Cooling (VXI has a comprehensive standard, PXI merely states adequate cooling must be provided.)
2. IPMI and system management (software)
3. Configuration and control of PXI resources (software)
4. Creating a 6U standard (a move highly supported by Racal in order to create a more meaningful instrument platform)
Standards
VXI has the volume required to remain viable for years to come. As an evolving new technology, PXI is dependent on the Compact PCI volume to develop economies of scale. Compact PCI is currently popular with telecommunications systems manufacturers.
Bus standards in the PC and Telecommunications world evolve much more quickly than in the test and measurement world. It remains to be seen whether PXI will develop the volumes required to remain a stable long-term standard as the PC and Telco worlds move on and evolve.
Modules vs. Cards
VXI modules have an outer metal enclosure to minimise cross-talk from slot to slot. These enclosures are connected to the chassis ground and act as a shield to prevent noise from coupling from one instrument to the next. PXI modules are cards and do not include any shielding. For high performance applications, it could become necessary for the PXI system user or integrator to experimentally identify and eliminate inter-card noise issues.
Use of modules facilitates rapid removal and replacement of instruments. High-performance and high-density VXI instruments often contain multiple PCB’s in a single module. These boards and circuits are neatly contained within the module, eliminating exposed circuitry.
The use of multi-slot “carrier” modules in VXI also lends flexibility to instrument design. For example, Racal’s two-slot Adapt-a-Switch module accepts up to six switching and digital I/O PCB’s, permitting the system integrator to create a custom configuration using COTS products.
Speed
The VXIbus backplane has a theoretical maximum of 40 Mbytes/s. This speed is more than adequate for functional test applications, whose throughput is limited by the laws of physics. For example, commercially available DMMs, operating in a low-resolution 4.5 digit mode, can only take about 1000 readings per second. Armature relays used in switch matrices have de-bounce times on the order of 15ms.
PXI has a higher speed backplane than VXI, with a theoretical maximum of 132Mbits/s. This makes it ideal for repetitive, low-speed, high-resolution measurements as are commonly found in data acquisition systems. Such systems typically measure physical characteristics such as position, temperature, strain, etc.
It should be noted that PXI systems using more that seven instruments, or built using the 6U form factor chassis, will require a PCI bridge, significantly reducing system throughput.
Conclusion
Fred Bode, editor of the VXIbus and PXI Newsletter interviewed Ron Wolf, Director of Strategic Marketing at National Instruments. Fred reported that Ron saw PXI replacing rack and stack instrumentation more than replacing VXI at the present time.
PXI is not a new low-cost replacement for VXI. The two architectures are complementary, and each is suited to a different range of applications. VXI is generally more robust and suited to high performance functional test systems. PXI is generally suited to small systems requiring lower measurement accuracy and high data transfer rates such as data acquisition systems. Neither VXI nor PXI implementations are inherently less expensive. Costs are more closely correlated to the particular functionality required. Moving forward, these two architectures will co-exist, each exploiting their unique market segments.
Test system engineers must take into consideration all of the above issues before selecting between a XI, PXI or rack-n-stack platform. Each has their merits depending upon the complexity, density, signal speed, project life, upgrade plans, software, robustness, field support and availability that the project requires.
Другие работы по теме:
Drug Testing 2 Essay Research Paper DRUG
Drug Testing 2 Essay, Research Paper DRUG TESTING Drug tests are a chemical analysis used to detect the presence of drugs in a small sample of urine or sometimes in blood. There are six types of drug testing: Pre-employment, Random, For-cause, Periodically Announced, Post-accident, and Rehabilitation.
Insurance And Genetics Essay Research Paper INSURANCE
Insurance And Genetics Essay, Research Paper INSURANCE AND GENETIC TESTING Do you have health insurance? When you go to the doctor do you think about how your insurance gives you coverage? When your pay check is a little short because of your premium are you angry? I would like to discuss with you what is going to happen when genetic testing becomes more widely used.
Gun Control Compair And Contrast Essay Research
Paper When it comes to guns, there are some major differences that are taken into consideration when grouping them into categories. Handguns are smaller, cancelable weapons, while Riffles are larger, non-cancelable weapons.
Dna Testing Essay Research Paper In two
Dna Testing Essay, Research Paper In two separate incidents in July of 1984, an assailant broke into an apartment, severed phone lines, sexually assaulted a women, and searched through her belongings, taking money and other items.
Genetic Testing Essay Research Paper At the
Genetic Testing Essay, Research Paper At the start of the 20th century, genetic research was in its youth. Today, our society is in center stage of a genetic revolution. Rarely does a week go by without the media reporting the discovery of a gene that is believed to be accountable for some disease or some aspect of human behavior.
Batch Essay Research Paper Discuss your stately
Batch Essay, Research Paper Discuss your stately for testing this algorithm, making sure that you include any problems that you think you may encounter. Also give examples of test data and expected results of your test data.
System Development Lifecycle Essay Research Paper System
System Development Lifecycle Essay, Research Paper System development lifecycle The classic model of software development was the Waterfall model, which considered the process as progressing through a series of stages from requirements analysis through specification, design, coding, testing to documentation and maintenance.
IQ Test Essay Research Paper Why IQ
I.Q Test Essay, Research Paper Why IQ tests don’t test intelligence The task of trying to quantify a person s intelligence has been a goal of psychologists since before the beginning of this century. The
Greek And Roman Arches And Architecture Essay
, Research Paper Architectural designs changed greatly since the ancient times. Most famous architectures and sculptures today originated from the Greek and Roman civilizations. Moreover,
Drugs Essay Research Paper In today
Drugs Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, drugs have been a very obvious problem espescially amongst teenagers and young adults. . I feel that an answer can be found if people stop
Handgun Essay Research Paper HandgunBecause the prison
Handgun Essay, Research Paper Handgun Because the prison population has doubled since 1984, it is really urgent for people to pay attention to the method of decreasing the crime rate. Basically, it is true that “locking people up is obviously not the answer to the crime problem. Training and educating people is one answer.” (Los Angeles Time, Joseph Mayfield) But training and educating people to lower the crime rate may only work under some conditions.
Student Outlook On The Sat
’s Essay, Research Paper The Sat, scholastic assessment test, is used for colleges to measure what a student may be able to do on any given day. Colleges use it as a basis for whom they accept to their college. The SAT is administered by the ETS, or educational testing service. Overall, the SAT is a long, grueling test that tends to cause mostly anxiety among the test-takers.
Upgrading Justice Essay Research Paper Taylor E
Upgrading Justice Essay, Research Paper Taylor E. Schuss English 205 31 August 2000 Upgrading Justice What is justice? By definition the word Justice can mean different things. To most Americans, justice is when someone who has committed a crime goes before a judge or a jury of his or her peers and is punished for their actions.
Animal Testing Speech Outline Essay Research Paper
Specific Purpose – To persuade my audience that animal testing is wrong and how other safer alternatives should be taken. Central Idea – By going the extra mile in using safer alternatives when experimenting with animals will not only prevent conflicts from pro-life activists, it will minimize lawsuits and morals will be preserved.
Iq Testing Essay Research Paper Edu psy
Iq Testing Essay, Research Paper Edu psy 115 Individual differences There have been many studies of IQ measurement. Some believe in testing and then looking at biology or heritage of the child. These people also like to use statistics to try to put some sort of explanation on IQ levels. Then there are other groups that use cultural ecology.
Genetics Essay Research Paper Today there is
Genetics Essay, Research Paper Today there is not a person in the United States is familiar with Dolly the lamb. She is one of the many new advances made in genetic engineering. Genetic testing is being done all over the
Project 2 Cases 2 Essay Research Paper
Project 2 Cases 2 There are several features in Microsoft Word 2000 that makes document making simple. With features like Automatic Spell Checking, that places a red wavy line under the word that is misspelled automatically. Auto Correct, which automatically corrects commonly, made mistakes that are predetermined in Word.
Students And Stress Essay Research Paper students
Students And Stress Essay, Research Paper students who normally make good grades on projects and homework due to their parent’s interaction are falling behind in standardized testing while those students who do not perform as well on homework are topping the charts of the standardized tests. students who normally make good grades on projects and homework due to their parent’s interaction are falling behind in standardized testing while those students who do not perform as well on homework are topping the charts of the standardized tests. students who normally make good grades on projects and homework due to their parent’s interaction are falling behind in standardized testing while those students who do not perform as well on homework are topping the charts of the standardized tests. students who normally make good grades on projects and homework due to their parent’s interaction are
Animal Experimentation 2 Essay Research Paper Lab
Animal Experimentation 2 Essay, Research Paper Lab experimentation involving animals is inhumane. Animal testing is cruel because an animal s life is just as important as a human s life, people are exploiting animals, and animal testing doesn t show whether or not a product is safe for humans.
Persuesive Essay On Animal Testing Essay Research
Paper Over 80 Million animals die a year due to animal testing, yet it is still legal. Letting even 1,000 humans die a year due to laboratory testing would be unethical and illegal, but testing millions of animals is legal and accepted by many people in our society. The fact that animals are not equal to humans doesn’t give us the right to allow them to be sacrificed, tortured, and destroyed just so we can wear makeup, perfume, and other beauty products.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper The risk
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper The risk of executing the innocent precludes the use of the death penalty. The death penalty alone imposes an irrevocable sentence. Once an inmate is executed, nothing can be done to make amends if a mistake has been made. There is considerable evidence that many mistakes have been made in sentencing people to death.
Drug Testing In Employment Essay Research Paper
Employment Drug Testing The use of pre-employment and random drug testing by companies in the United States has grown rapidly during the past decade. Drug testing in the workplace has become an issue of great concern to people on both sides of the employment equation. The increased popularity of drug testing in the workplace, specifically in private sector employment, has created an unclear ?tug-of-war? between the desires of employers and the rights of employees.
Drug Testing 2 Essay Research Paper
Drug Testing and Corporate Responsibility: The “Ought Implies Can” Argument Drug testing has become a hot topic under the microscope recently. The problem is the question whether or not it is morally wrong to test employees for illegal drug use. In order to justify drug testing in the work place one must look to rights, among other things, to determine what sorts of controls are morally permissible.
Drug Testing At Unlv Essay Research Paper
UNLV DRUG TESTING: POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE Drug testing at UNLV is not as effective as originally thought, and have many students-athletes very upset. At the beginning of each academic year student-athletes must sign a drug testing consent form prescribed by the NCAA Committee. Student-athletes are not forced to drug test for the NCAA or intercollegiate athletic drug-testing program.
Drug Testing In The Workplace 2 Essay
, Research Paper Drug Testing in the Workplace When the question of drug testing in the workplace arises, many problems tend to come along with it. For employers, the solution is simple; drug tests are mandatory for employment. When it comes to employees, however the response might be more along the lines of It s none of your business or That s a violation of my rights .
How Are Automatic Stabilizers Used To Combat
Inflation Essay, Research Paper How are Automatic Stabilizers Used to Combat Inflation? In today?s economy, there are devices present called automatic stabilizers. Automatic stabilizers, are mechanisms which aid in the correction of an economic problem without the interference of anyone or anything.
Animal Testing Essay Research Paper The American
Animal Testing Essay, Research Paper The American Medical Association has stated that it believes that research-involving animals is essential to maintaining and improving the health of human beings. They point out that all advances in medical science in the 20th century, from antibiotics to organ transplants, has been achieved either directly or indirectly through the use of animals in laboratory experiments.
Animal Rights Essay Research Paper Many humans
Animal Rights Essay, Research Paper Many humans use animals for testing each year. Animal testing is when the animals are put through something or injected to see how they react to what medical research they have been used for.
The Art Of Ancient Rome Essay Research
Paper The Art of Ancient Rome The Roman sculptures and architectures were greatly influenced by the Greeks and also some effects by the Etruscans. Romans were influenced mostly by Greek art in many ways. It was because the variety of paintings, sculptures, and the different style of early architectures presented in every period of Roman history.
Animal Testing Essay Research Paper What do
Animal Testing Essay, Research Paper What do you think of when you hear the brand names Proctor & Gamble, Gillette, Revlor or Cover Girl? Laundry detergent, soap, lipstick? What you probably don’t think of is this. Those three company’s, Proctor & Gamble, Gillette, Revlon and Cover Girl, are four of the leading company’s who test all their products on animals.
Mdeical Benifits Of Animal Testing Essay Research
Paper Argument Essay Where would we be Without Animal Testing? Is the use of animals in research justified? Should animal experimentation be permitted? Should these animals be liberated? A logical person would say the benefits justify the research. Without animal testing, products would be based on theory.
Computing Architectures Essay Research Paper IntroductionAn organization
Computing Architectures Essay, Research Paper IntroductionAn organization s computer network is a major asset and needs extensive planning for proper function. The network design process is a long and arduous task that requires knowledge of the business need of the organization and the technical skills to achieve those needs.