The Just Life Essay, Research Paper
“The Unjust Life Is The Most Profitable Life”
Plato argues in his book the “Republic” that the just life is better that the unjust life. Although, Glaucon has legitimate arguments, Plato refutes them effectively by showing that the just life is better.
Glaucon elaborates on Thrasymachus’s argument stating that the unjust life is more profitable and happier than the just life. Glaucon gives three arguments that will backup his statement. One of the arguments state, “What is justice and where did it come from?” Justice comes from a person that makes a law that is just and lawful because they have suffered an injustice. So by making laws that are just they will minimize suffering of injustice.
The second statement that Glaucon makes is that, “All who practice justice do so unwillingly.” A person that is just will not do anything wrong because it would natural to them. It can said that an unjust person would have to plan to do an injustice, then the injustice would have to be done, and worry about get caught. The just person feels that the easiest way to stay out of trouble and be happy is to stay within the confides of the law.
The third argument of Glaucon’s statement is, “The life of an unjust person is better than a just life.” Glaucon believes that a person that lives an unjust life is better. A person is happier with an unjust life because if they can get away with unjust things they can reap the benefit and not suffer any unjustice.
Of the three arguments, the strongest I think Plato has at his disposal is the, “Unjust life is happier than the just life.” Plato in his book the “Republic” argues that the best and happier life is the just life. He explains that the person who lives a tyrannical life lives in a nightmare. A tyrannical person uses everybody in the city, as slaves in order to fulfill their desires. The person also has no one to trust and lives in fear because there is always something after him or her.
The tyrannical life is lawless and has no honor and trust. Plato explains that a city should have honor and form of trust. Without trust there is no friendship. A tyrannical person never experiences what it is like to have a true friend because they master one man over another. The person that lives a tyrannical life acts as though they are having a friendship with someone but when they have what they want they act as a stranger once again. So the person has no friendship because he or she is a slave of there own desires.
Plato compares the democratic life as the better life than of the tyrannical life. A city that is ruled by a democratic person is much better than a tyrannical life because the state is able to have honor, virtue, and friendship. When a person is able to obtain a friendship, they gain trust from another. In a democratic life the people of the city are able to have choices. They have freedom to live their lives the way that is best for them. A democracy has laws that help protect the city from injustice. So a tyrant is ruled by the worst part of the soul compared to the best part of the soul, which would be democratic soul.
I feel that Plato is right in his argument with Thrasymachus. Although I do have feeling the unjust life is better because the fact still remains that if a person is unjust they can reap all the benefits of the things they take. If they can get away with something, they will suffer no injustice and this is where I feel the unjust life is better. It is kind of a, “Finders; keeper, losers; weepers”, ordeal. If I myself have taken something from someone, then they are not getting it back.
The person that lives an unjust life has to suffer consequences of unlawful thing they commit. If a person is caught in the act then, they face jail time. Who wants to be places inside a cell for an extended amount of time because they got caught doing unjust things. A person that is just is able to have trust. Trust helps the people of a city life better because they are all equal. They don’t have any envy over one another, which bring happiness.
In conclusion, Glaucon’s arguments are legitimate but Plato’s arguments are stronger. Although, Glaucon’s arguments are tempting by showing that the unjust life is easier. The just life is better because it helps a person grow into better citizens, making life better for people around them.
Другие работы по теме:
The Republic Does Justice Pay Essay Research
Paper In the Introduction of Plato’s Republic, a very important theme is depicted. It is the argument of whether it is beneficial for a person to lead a good and just existence. The greatly argued position that justice does not pay, is argued by three men Thrasymachus, Glaucon, and Adeimantus. By incorporating all three men into a collective effort I believe I can give a more flattering depiction of injustice.
Basic Iseals Of Declaration Of Independance Essay
, Research Paper The introduction to the Declaration of Independence posses the basic of ideals of America. Four of the ideals extolled in the document are; equality, natural rights, consent if the
Just Laws Essay Research Paper The definition
Just Laws Essay, Research Paper The definition of a law as just or unjust can only come from the people whom are governed by the law in question. Although everyone should be free to decide whether or not a law is just, the only opinions that should matter are from those of the nation ruled by the law.
Archelaus
– The Unhappiest Of Men Essay, Research Paper Question – Why does Socrates think Archelaus is the unhappiest of men in Gorgias? Archelaus, a tyrant is presented in the dialouge as an evildower who experiences no remorse for his crimes. He lives a kind of life that objectifies unlimited power and unrestrained pleasure.
Fear And Religion In Lucretius Essay Research
Paper Religion is one of Lucretius favorite topics to argue against in his poem On the Nature of Things. What religion does to man and the fear of the life after death that is instilled on the living is unjust per Lucretius. For while the nature of the gods must necessarily of itself enjoy immortality, the life of men lay foully groveling, crushed beneath the wait of a Religion.
Socrates To Conform Or Not
– A Struggle Essay, Research Paper To Conform or Not? Socrates- A Struggle When one is pondering the question, what do the laws mean by stating that Socrates needed to be obedient because of all that the laws have done for him, you can find the meaning in the text of the Crito. The law states, that if they were not there, Socrates would not have been born.
Untitled Essay Research Paper The Republic written
Untitled Essay, Research Paper The Republic written by Plato examines many things. It mainly is about the Good life. Plato seems to believe that the perfect life is led only under perfect conditions which is
Statutory Rape Essay Research Paper In the
Statutory Rape Essay, Research Paper In the face of unjust laws, I believe that civil disobedience is mandatory. I have a scenario to defend my argument. I introduce to you Stan Lippy. Stan is a 19 year old student at Louisiana State University and he loves his girlfriend. Unfortunately, she is a 17 year old high school student with over-protective parents.
Death Penalty 9 Essay Research Paper After
Death Penalty 9 Essay, Research Paper After reading “The Death Penalty” by William Raspberry several topics surfaced in my mind. The death penalty is unjust and very ridiculous sentence for a human being . Capital punishment is not as effective as most people believe. There are alternative and beneficial solutions in place of the death penalty.
Philosophy Essay Research Paper There exists a
Philosophy Essay, Research Paper There exists a story, about a certain Ring of Gyges. In short form, the story goes like this: A man happened upon a ring on the finger of a corpse inside of a hollow bronze horse. He took the ring from the corpse and put it on his finger. He continued to wear it as a regular ring, until the night of his monthly meeting to discuss the state of his flocks.
Crito Essay Research Paper In the Last
Crito Essay, Research Paper In the Last Days of Socrates the dialogue ?Crito? recounts Socrates last days before his execution. Socrates had been accused of corrupting the youth and not worshipping the Gods
Socrates Vs Thrasymachus In The Republic Essay
, Research Paper The Republic is one of the finest examples of a Platonic dialog. The subject matter discussed therein is difficult to summarize, at best. Covering subjects such as politics, the fine arts, education, it is no wonder so many have written volumes analyzing its various aspects. However, the driving force behind the many discussions is pursuit of the answer to the simple, yet evasive question, “What is justice?”
Socrates On Democracy Essay Research Paper In
Socrates On Democracy Essay, Research Paper In Plato?s Euthyphro, Crito and the Apology, we learn of Socrates? highly critical view of the democracy. Socrates believed that democracy was a flawed
Civil Rights And Disobedience Essay Research Paper
By acting civil but disobedient you are able to protest things you don?t think are fair, non-violently. Henry David Thoreau is one of the most important literary figures of the nineteenth century. Thoreau?s essay ?Civil
The Ideals Of Justice Essay Research Paper
The idea of justice has been very prominent in the readings and discussions that we have had this quarter. The Old Testament and Plato’s Republic both give definitions and ideals of justice, but sometimes these ideas are contrasting or even hypocritical in their respective practices. These books both give examples of justice and how people come across their individual ideas of what justice is.
Socrates Essay Research Paper Socrates arguments that
Socrates Essay, Research Paper Socrates arguments that it would be wrong to escape from prison is as follows. In Critos, Socrates explains to his friend Crito that escaping from prison would go against many of the thins that he (Socrates) believes in; seeking virtue, seeking the truth, not repaying an evil with another evil, obeying the laws of the state and so on.
Mahatma Gandhi Essay Research Paper Mahatma GandhiThere
Mahatma Gandhi Essay, Research Paper Mahatma Gandhi There are far too many accomplishments in the life of Mohandas Gandhi to be covered in a single essay, for he was and still is one of the most idolized people in history. His beliefs of unity and equality are still shared today by millions of people around the world.
The Crito Essay Research Paper The dialogue
The Crito Essay, Research Paper The dialogue of The Crito, by Plato, recounts the last days of Socrates, immediately before his execution was going to take place in Athens. In the dialogue, Socrates friend, Crito, proposes that Socrates escape from prison. Socrates considers this proposal, trying to decide if escaping would be just and morally justified.
Crito Essay Research Paper Crito Days before
Crito Essay, Research Paper Crito Days before the ship arrives in the city of Athens, to take away the life of Socrates, after he has been sentence to death by an unjust jury. Crito one of the closest friends of Socrates tells Socrates to escape and not die because of an unfair cause. Crito also tells Socrates that he has many friends that are willing to sacrifice everything to see him live.
The Outsider By Albert Camus Vx The
Trial By Franz Kafka Essay, Research Paper The Priest(Kafka vs Camus)The Outsider, written by Albert Camus, and The Trial, written by Franz Kafka, are two books that have been critically acclaimed since the time that they were published. There are critics that claim that The Outsider is a dull book, and is not even a read-worthy book.
Antigone Civil Disobedience Essay Research Paper The
Antigone: Civil Disobedience Essay, Research Paper The short play, Antigone, was written in 441 B.C. by the Greek playwrightSophocles. It deals with some of the most basic problems that affect a society.One of them is Civil Disobedience. Civil Disobedience both a right andresponsibility of a person to fight an unjust law.
Thoreau Essay Research Paper Thoreau
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience emphasizes the need to prioritize one’s conscience over the dictates of laws. It criticizes American social institutions and policies, mostly slavery and the Mexican American war.
How I Got Into College Essay Research
Paper Throughout my life I have adapted to certain things that are truly unequal, unfair, and unjust. There has always been a mountain in the way of a goal or a dream. But the mountains of life aren?t always there to make things difficult. They are there to make you fight for what you want. And I feel that you have to fight to succeed this day and age.
Al Gore
’s View On Abortion Essay, Research Paper This article deals with Vice-President Al Gore?s view on abortion. Al Gore is a strong advocate of a women?s right to choose. He supports the Clinton administrations ask for a $35 million increase in federal funding of family-planning services. They also support a $4.5 million grant to fund security improvements for abortion clinics at risk of violence by pro-life activists.
Living In The Past Present And Future
Essay, Research Paper Some people claim that the living in the present can actually cause more harm than good. They say that in order to lead a productive and profitable life, one must study both the
Short Essay On Life In Virginia
Colony Essay, Research Paper Life in Virginia Colony Being a stranger to the New World, one would expect a rich land with much to offer, abundant in natural resources, and profitable. However, this was not the case in the Virginia colony. The dream was deceiving: life in New England was challenging and was held together by inadequate leadership and a poor economy.
The Unjust Assassination Of Julius Caesar Essay
, Research Paper One of the basic needs of human nature is to control something in one’s life whether it be money, or a group of people. Throughout the long history of politics people have fought for control of the government using many different means both just and unjust. One of the immoral ways to gain power in a political system is by assassination.
Rawls Essay Research Paper Can the Unjust
Rawls Essay, Research Paper Can the Unjust be Rectified Can the Unjust Be Rectified? Robert Nozick, in his essay Rights and the Entitlement Theory, discusses the rights of individuals and just acquisition. He makes it clear that these rights and/or acquisitions cannot be taken away by anyone, either by an individual or by a collective identity such as the state.
Should You Obey An Unjust Law Essay
, Research Paper Should you obey an unjust law? According to the theory of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, 18th century French political philosopher, ?in a democratic society the state represents the general will of the citizens, and that in obeying its laws each citizen is pursuing his own real interests.? Thus, in an ideal state, laws express the general will.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone and The
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone and The Mother Death surrounds us all. It is a common reminder of the life we have around us. Death is seen in people, nature, and animal’s everyday. It brings us sadness and pain. It is something that is not easily dealt with and sometimes may seem unjust. It helps us become better people by accepting death and learning from it.
The Crucible And Inherit The Wind
– Injustice Essay, Research Paper Both Cates, in Inherit the Wind by Lee and Lawrence, and Procter, in The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, are both subjected to unjust laws. Both demonstrated that , “if the law is of such a nature that it requires one to be an agent of injustice toward another, then I say break the law,” as stated by Henry David Thoreau.