’s Platonic Universals Essay, Research Paper
The consideration of Platonic universals consequently rouses controversy among philosophers. Thinkers like Bertrand Russell and Thomas Hobbes contribute reflective explanations for the undeniable usage of question-begging ideas in language and thought. While the deliberation of Platonic universals might seem to be fruitless and, at best, obscure to the layperson, it does function as a critical foundation for metaphysics and epistemology. Whether a philosopher agrees or disagrees with the idea of Platonic universals is irrelevant to the certain truth that he or she must form some opinion of them preceding most any philosophic endeavor.
To attempt to summarize Plato?s theory of universals in a paragraph would do it a great injustice but a simple, working definition of the theory is necessary to move any further. Plato?s theory can be condensed as follows: A universal (or form) is an independently existing, nonspatial, nontemporal ?something? known only through thought and that cannot be known through the senses; independently existing objects of thought; that which makes a particular thing uniquely and essentially what it is. In even simpler terms, a universal would be something like the ?redness? of an apple. According to Plato, the red quality of the apple must exist because the apple is red. But ?redness? itself isn?t a tangible thing that can be directly experienced with the senses. You cannot produce ?red? itself, only things that are red. But it is not only the fact that an apple is red that distinguishes it from other objects in the world. In addition to its ?redness?, an apple is an apple. An apple is not a pear. The quality unique to the apple is its ?appleness?. Thus, by appealing to the Platonic universals one can make a distinction between an apple and a pear, or all other things in the world.
I. Thomas Hobbes? Nominalism
Plato concluded that universals must actually exist. That is, that when ?appleness? is appealed to, something ?out there? provides classification for the thing in question. This was (and still is) a radical notion that demanded explanation and was highly susceptible to criticism. Among those critics was Thomas Hobbes, a 16th Century social and political philosopher. In his work, The Leviathan, Hobbes argued that thought is a purely material event and that universals are just a result of language.
Hobbes was a nominalist. Nominalism is the view that there are no universals over and above particular individuals2. For Hobbes, one of the answers to the question of universals could be found in the commonality of things. For instance, if a rock and a table are both hard, it is not because we refer to a universal, ?hardness? for them, it is because we use the word ?hard? to describe both of them. Another point made by Hobbes was that humans place things into categories in order to satisfy certain needs. Heimir Geirsson made a good analogy of this idea in his Metaphysics textbook, Beginning Metaphysics. He uses a weed for the analogy:
A good example of this is the term ?weed,? which is defined as a plant that is not desired or cultivated by human beings and grows profusely. This is not a natural species that would exist even if human beings had never decided to classify some plants as ?weeds.? Many human beings are interested in having a special category for plants they don?t like and that grow abundantly, and they create that category for plants they don?t like, and they create that category with that name and definition. If human beings had not worried about weeds, then there would be no weeds. Of course, there would still be plants that we now call ?weeds,? e.g. dandelions and crabgrass, but they would not be weeds. Whether or not there are weeds depends on human beings classifying these plants as weeds.2
Geirsson?s analogy is an interesting one because of the question it evokes. Why aren?t all definitions like that of the weed, i.e., human classification? Hobbes thought that they were. For Hobbes, there were no real universals. Those things, which we refer to as universals, are simply created by humans out of a need to organize the world.
II. Bertrand Russell on Platonic Universals
Bertrand Russell attempted to defend the theory of Platonic universals. In order to do this he first thought it necessary to distinguish between universals that were qualities of things and those that were relations between things. The most practical way to separate qualities and relations is to understand them through their linguistic functions.
Adjectives and common nouns express qualities or properties of single things, whereas prepositions and verbs tend to express relations between two or more things.3 For example, the sentence ?The dog ran around the tree.? Contains instances of quality and relation universals. ?Dog?, ?tree?, and ?ran? refer to a universal that is a quality of the objects and the action. When we think of ?dog? and ?tree?, we first have neutral objects that we distinguish by attaching their respective qualities, which are ?dogness? and ?treeness?. Similarly, the verb ?ran?, being in the past tense, not only attributes the quality of running to a neutral action, but also refers to a point in time when the action took place.
To think of the whole phenomenon of a dog having run around a tree, there must also necessarily exist a corresponding universal for the preposition ?around?. This universal differs from the previously mentioned ones in that it connects and relates the other universals to each other. Without it, the sentence would read something like this: ?The dog ran tree.? In order to make any sense of the statement a relation between ?ran? and ?tree? must first be established. Thus, it follows that ?around? must be a different type of universal than ?ran?, ?dog?, or ?tree?. No sense can be made of anything unless there is some understood relationship between them. Russell thought that since inference of relation universals was unavoidable, there was sufficient metaphysical evidence to approve of the ontological status given to them by Plato.
In order to further shield his argument from scrutiny, Russell also thought it was necessary to adjust the language about universals in regard to their ontological position. He judged that it was preferable to allude to universals as subsisting rather than existing. To speak of some as existing implies some sort of spatio-temporal location. If the question is asked, ?When and where does this universal exist?? the answer must be ?Nowhere and nowhen,? says Russell.3 The realm of universals is rigid an unaffected by the world of perception. The term used for objects within the world of perceptions that refer to their obligatory universal cannot be used. This is also to avoid the objection that universals only exist in the mind. Russell suggested that the word subsist should be used in language about universals. This is because the term simply implies that they have being.3 In doing so, Russell seems to adequately preserve his logic from Hobbes-like arguments.
III. Conclusion
While Russell?s argument does seem to refute those made by the likes of Hobbes; it is not without uncertainty. A more obvious objection to Russell?s argument would be that of an infinite regression of universals. If there is a relation between ?dog? and ?tree?, then there must certainly also be a relationship between the relation universal ?around? and the ?whatever? (around) that it classifies. But it might not stop there. Why would there not be yet another relationship between these three relationships? Anytime there are ideas or things; there must be some relationship between them. So, for ?The dog ran around the tree,? there must be a relationship between ?dog,? ?ran,? and ?tree.? Those relationships are ?ran,? and ?around.? But of course there must be an understood relationship between ?ran? and ?around? also for the statement to make any sense. Since realists like Russell contend that these things refer to some universal, there must be a relationship between them and the universal. But now we have two universals and there needs to be a relationship established between the two universals. That relationship could be as simple as their equality as universals. And now that equality must too be a universal. And there is a relationship between that equality and its universal. This web can continue indefinitely, preventing any objective classification from exposing itself out of the statement, ?The dog ran around the tree.?
As for Hobbes, his argument has a similar fate. Using his logic, a statement?s meaning would be circular in nature. Going back to Geirsson?s analogy of the weed, we can infer the statement ?Weed satisfies the need for humans to categorize certain types of plants.? Geirsson?s own opinion of this is that now the term ?satisfy? needs to be satisfied and thus leads to a vicious circle.2
It is unfortunate that both men are dead and unable to respond to such objections. However, of the two, Russell?s point-of-view still seems to be the more persuasive. Russell, having been a mathematician as well, could have fairly easily pointed out that there is nothing subject to controversy in the idea of an infinite measure of anything. An elementary principle of mathematics is that no matter what number you have, one more can always be added. Just because this infinite amount of relationships seems to make anything impossibly complex, does not make it illogical or inconceivable. Consequently it is my conclusion that, while not error-free, Bertrand Russell?s concept of relationship universals is, so far, most impressive.
Другие работы по теме:
Барер, Бертран
Бертран Барер де Вьёзак (фр. Bertrand Barиre de Vieuzac) (10 сентября 1755, Тарб, — 13 января 1841, Тарб) — французский политик, адвокат, деятель Великой французской революции, депутат Учредительного собрания и Национального конвента.
Лабурдонне, Бертран Франсуа де
Памятник мореплавателю Бертран Франсуа Маэ де Лабурдонне (фр. Bertrand-Franзois Mahй de La Bourdonnais; 11 февраля 1699(16990211), Сен-Мало, Франция — 10 ноября 1753, Париж, Франция) — французский мореплаватель и военачальник.
Stereotypes Of Men Essay Research Paper Stereotypes
Stereotypes Of Men Essay, Research Paper Stereotypes of Men Both Scott Russell Sanders Looking at Women and Herb Goldberg s In Harness: The Male Condition discuss the idea of stereotypes of men in today s
Mathematical Artists Essay Research Paper Louie Kahn
Mathematical Artists Essay, Research Paper ?Louie Kahn said,? Even a brick wants to be something? a brick wants to be, something? it inspires. Even a common ordinary brick wants to be something more than it is? and that is what we must be (?Indecent Proposal?)
The Origin Of The Presence Of Satan
Essay, Research Paper The Origin of the Presence of Satan The United Press International stated that on October 11, 1978, a father “kept his daughter, Tina Ann, 10, imprisoned in a 3 foot by 4 foot closet in [his
HertzsprungRussell Diagram Essay Research Paper The HertzsprungRussell
Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram Essay, Research Paper The Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram or, the H-R Diagram for short, is a graph which plots stars according to their temperature and absolute magnitude. This graph reveals a pattern, which in fact is quite interesting. The H-R Diagram is named for the two astronomers, Ejnar Hertzsprung and Henry Russell, who discovered this pattern of stars.
An Analytical Definition Of Philosophia Essay Research
Paper Men and women have tried for years to define Philosophy. One particularly interesting attempt was made by Martin Heidegger in the late 8th Century. He is reported as saying to his good friend and lover, Patrick Hurley, “Philosophy is one large search for the being-upon another and one long journey into the being-inside.” In this sense, Philosophy is best understand as a search.
Not A Christian Fallacies Essay Research Paper
Ignore fact and reason, live entirely in the world of your own fantastic and myth-producing passions; do this whole-heartedly and with conviction, and you will become one of the prophets of your age. Bertrand Russell wrote this controversial statement in his essay, How to Become a Man of Genius. Bertrand Russell was a man who some deemed one of the most provocative philosophers of his time.
Virtues Of My Life Order Courage Patience
Essay, Research Paper Virtues of My Life: Order, Courage, Patience In order to survive in 1996, there need to be at least some standards and goals of morality in a person’s life. Moral excellence is definitely hard
Did You Just See That Essay Research
Paper Humdrum Conundrum: Does or does it not make sense to insist that how each person sees things depends entirely on that persons unique time, place, and subjective judgement? on their cultural background?
Advertising Analysis Essay Research Paper We see
Advertising Analysis Essay, Research Paper We see them in the subways, bus stops, magazines, and television, but what do they mean? How do they manage to catch our attention? Advertisements often find ways to sell their products by psychologically manipulating people. The advertising industry makes us envious of others and convinces us to be unhappy with what we have (Valko).
Society And It
’s Influence On Conventionality Essay, Research Paper Essay Conventional and Sterile Tuesday Nov. 07, 2000 It is my understanding that people grow up in a society of conventional and sterile ways of life. Some societies have a tendency to raise people to be similar in their way of thinking. People are educated to have the same morals, beliefs (within their own culture), and, or opportunities at an education.
Erdos Essay Research Paper Justin AndrewsErd sPaul
Erdos Essay, Research Paper Justin Andrews Erd s Paul Erdos was born in Budapest, Hungary on march 26,1913. He was the son of Lajos and his mother Anna Both parents were math teachers. Which is most likely where Paul received his math influence. His sisters died of scarlet fever around the time he was born this making his parents very protective of little Paul during his childhood.
The Place Of Science In A Libe
Essay, Research Paper In his essay, “The Place of Science in a Liberal Education,” Russell Bertrand explains how a liberal education is obtained through a literary education and an education based on science. His goal is not to attack literary education, but to draw attention to theachievements and excellencies in science in the present.
How Does Logic Help Us Clarify Or
Solve Problems? Essay, Research Paper Everyday people employ the use of logic to help them clarify or solve problems. Logic may only provide validity or highly probable ideas, but the
BakerS Childhood Essay Research Paper The excerpt
Baker?S Childhood Essay, Research Paper The excerpt explains Baker?s childhood growing up in the 1930s. He lived in Belleville, NJ with his younger sister Doris, and his single mother. This story to talks about Russell growing up and how his mother pushed him to work and be responsible as a young adult, but all he wanted to do is listen to ?Dick Tracy meets the Stooge Viller? on the radio reading his book.
Positivism Essay Research Paper Positivism is a
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism is a system of philosophy based on experience and experimental knowledge of natural sensation, in which metaphysics and theology are regarded as inadequate and imperfect systems of knowledge. (www.eb) The 19th-century French mathematician and philosopher Auguste Comte first called the doctrine positivism, but some of the positivist concepts may be traced to the British philosopher David Hume, the French philosopher Duc de Saint-Simon, and the German philosopher Immanuel Kant.
The Sweet Hereafter Essay Research Paper If
The Sweet Hereafter Essay, Research Paper If there is one aspect of the novel The Sweet Hereafter that has been overlooked by many readers, it is the method in which Russell Banks coincides the major events of the novel to the seasons of the year. More particularly, to the seasonal extremes of the year, the chilling frost of January and the suffocating warmth of August.
Rumble Fish Essay Research Paper SummaryRumble fish
Rumble Fish Essay, Research Paper Summary Rumble fish is a narrative story where a boy named Russell-James meets up with his old friend Steve and remembers the past. It all started with Russell-James (Rusty-James was his nickname) saw his old friend Steve. They talked for a while when Russell-James is reminded about the knife fight he had 5 years ago because of his reunion with Steve. {Flashback} His story started out with him being told that he would be killed in the yard behind the ally by Biff in the late afternoon.
Achilles The Super Yuppie Essay Research Paper
Achilles: The Super Yuppie In the beginning of Homer s The Iliad, Achilles is arguing with Agamemnon over a girl. Since Achilles does not get what he wants, he decides to leave the battle that they are in. However, this is no small battle, this is the Trojan War. Achilles action shapes the outcome of the battle, for the next fifteen or so books, with the Greeks losing.
Strawson Russel Essay Research Paper Philosophy
Strawson $ Russel Essay, Research Paper Philosophy of Language December 1, 1999 Strawson?s Criticism of Russell The main point of Strawson?s essay is to essentially to disprove Russell?s theory of descriptions. Strawson felt that Russell, along with the rest, had somehow lost the sense of reality that he now hoped to reestablish in his analysis.
Betrand Russell The Problems Of Philosophy Essay
, Research Paper Betrand Russell: The Problems of Philosophy The value of Philosophy is, in fact, to be sought largely in its uncertainty. The man who has no tincture of Philosophy goes through life imprisoned in the
Persuasion By Jane Austen Essay Research Paper
Persuasion Jane Austen’s Persuasion depicts a young woman’s struggles with love, friendship and family. Anne Elliot who is pretty, intelligent and amiable, had some years before been engaged to a young naval officer, Frederick Wentworth, but had been persuaded by her trusted friend Lady Russell to break off the engagement, because of his lack of fortune and a misunderstanding of his easy nature.
Advertising Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Advertising Critique Essay, Research Paper The first of the three ads that I have selected is from The New Yorker magazine. It is an ad for Russell Athletic. This is a company that makes sports wear. In the ad, you see a man wearing their product. The man is vigorously working out and is in good shape. The outfit from Russell Athletic is supposed to perform, according to the caption on the left.
Phil201 Essay Research Paper The Only Truth
Phil201 Essay, Research Paper The Only Truth Existing”We are, then, faced with a quite simple alternative: Either we deny that there is here anything that can be called truth – a choice that would make us deny what weexperience most profoundly as our own being; or we must look beyond the realm of our “natural” experience for a validation of our certainty.”A famous philosopher, Rene Descartes, once stated, “I am, [therefore] I exist.” This statement holds the only truth found for certain in our “natural” experience that, as conscious beings, we exist.
What Is Induction Does It Work
? Essay, Research Paper Introduction: In this essay I will begin by explaining what induction actually is. Then I will highlight the difference between induction as a form of reasoning and deduction in an attempt to clarify the main ‘Problem with induction’. Next I will go through a number of different philosophers attempts to deal with this problem as well as pointing out a number of extra problems with induction.
Value Of Philosophy Essay Research Paper What
Value Of Philosophy Essay, Research Paper What is the value of Philosophy? The word ?philosophy? is derived from two ancient Greek words, ?philos? meaning ?love of? and ?sophia? meaning ?wisdom?. Philosophers are lovers of wisdom. They have had the time and resources to sit back and wonder about what things really are like when all the pieces are fitted into one final accounting.
Bertrand Russell The Value Of Philosophy Essay
, Research Paper The Value of Philosophy Consider a man that looks to material needs as the necessities of life. He moves through his world in a twenty-four hour cycle of the mundane, never reaching for a less ignorant existence. Bertrand Russell believes that these “practical men”, as society deems them, are wrongly named.
Movie Review Essay Research Paper Movie Review
Movie Review Essay, Research Paper Movie Review “Gladiator” is a movie about ancient Rome that released at May of this year. There are four major characters in this movie, which are Russell Crowe, Joaquin Phoenix, Richard Harris and Djimon Hounsou. This movie is directed by Ridley Scott. Since it contains violent materials, it is rated R and is restricted to minor audience.
Truth II The Only Truth Existing Essay
, Research Paper Truth The Only Truth Existing [This is my second and last essay of Philosophy 201]-RJ The Only Truth Existing “We are, then, faced with a quite simple alternative: Either we deny that there is here
World View Of Bertrand Russell Essay Research
Paper The World View of Bertrand Russell In today’s world, it is difficult to know just what is correct among the ideas of the universe, what we are and how we came to be, and how we should live as human beings and as a society. Bertrand Russell, an agnostic philosopher, approaches these questions and tries to answer them according to what science has proven throughout history.
Seti Bertrand Russell Essay Research Paper Bertrand
Seti: Bertrand Russell Essay, Research Paper Bertrand Russell wrote, “There are two possibilities. Maybe we are alone. Maybe we are not. Both are equally frightening (Jakosky 1).” The question of life in the universe is one that leaves many in a state of bewilderment. It becomes even more interesting when it leads to another question – that of intelligent life in the universe.
Louis Xvi Essay Research Paper Bertrand
Louis Xvi Essay, Research Paper Bertrand, Louis, LouisXVI , New York: Longmans, Green and Co, 1928, 355pp. The reign of Louis XVI as described in this wonderful pice of literature, is glorified as being one of the few great ages in the history of western man. During his rule, the French culture achieved a perfection that was formerly unknown.