The little drummer girl
John Le Carre’s The Little Drummer Girl is one of the finest of all spy novels. The story concerns terrorism and anti-terrorism, focussing on the Israeli/Palestinian situation, and is full of convolutions and surprises. The book’s multiple themes include the moral ambiguity of both sides, the coercive power of love, and the cost of violence to those who perform it. George Roy Hill’s film version of the book manages to keep a surprising amount of both the plot and the themes in the film, but something has been lost. The film, while good, is not one of the great spy films.
The problem is Hill. His direction is professional, but doesn’t capture Le Carre’s shadowy world of men and women willing to do anything for their cause. Hill’s great talent is for mixing drama and action with humor, as demonstrated by Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, The Sting, and The World According to Garp, among many other films with similar tones. The Little Drummer Girl comes to life on the few occasions when Hill can legitimately set a lighter tone. At all other times, even in action sequences, the film is, well, not lifeless, but also not electric.
Part of the problem would have been hard for anyone to avoid. As mentioned, the plot is complex (not by Le Carre’s standards, perhaps, but certainly by anyone else’s). Loring Mandel, the screenwriter, almost miraculously fits in all of the important elements of the story, and still manages to touch upon the major themes within a two hour script. However, this fine job of compression requires Hill to play most scenes rather slowly so that the audience can follow what’s going on. Hill has always preferred to set a quicker pace. A great script, as opposed to this very good one, or a director more comfortable with leisurely pacing might have been able to get more from the project.
The Little Drummer Girl was a controversial book which managed to offend both Palestinians and Israelis by presenting the justice of both of their causes and the savagery of both sides’ methods. The film preserves this point of view. The story concerns an Israeli plot to catch one of the most important Palestinian terrorists, Khalil. The Israeli scheme centers on the terrorist’s preference for using European women recruited to the Palestinian cause, and the relative visibility of Khalil’s brother, who is part of the terrorist organization. To make the plot work, Kurtz, the Israeli leading the operation, must infiltrate an agent into the terrorist group. He chooses Charlie, an actress with pro-Palestinian leanings. Kurtz’s first task is to convince Charlie to do it against her convictions. The method used is brilliant, playing on Charlie’s deepest insecurities and need for love rather than trying to convert her to the Israeli point of view. Now Charlie is ready to start on an adventure that will take her across Europe and to Palestinian training camps in Lebanon and will require the actress to give the performance of her life.
Diane Keaton gives a pretty good performance as Charlie. The role was originally written for an Englishwoman, but the conversion to an American doesn’t much harm the film, and was an economic necessity. There is currently no British actress of the right age with the box office power necessary to bring large audiences in. Keaton’s weakest moments come when she is onstage, doing Shakespeare and Saint Joan. She is much more convincing playing Charlie playing herself. This is the sort of a performance which might get nominated for an Academy Award, in a slow year, but certainly won’t win. Klaus Kinski is strong as Kurtz. Hill gets more from him than any director other than Werner Herzog. Yorgo Voyagis plays Joseph, the Israeli agent most responsible for recruiting Charlie. He is strong but somewhat inarticulate. The supporting cast, largely unknowns (to me, at least), is very good.
Technically, The Little Drummer Girl is a typically competent Hollywood movie, with the unusual twist that most of the technical people are Europeans. (Milos Forman also used a European crew for Amadeus, but Forman comes from Czechoslovakia, making him more inclined to use Europeans.) Since The Little Drummer Girl was shot in England, Germany, and Israel, using local talent made a lot of sense, and paid off.
The Little Drummer Girl represents an unusual thematic departure from Hollywood’s usual pro-Israel line, only possible because it was based on a novel whose moral ambiguities could not be safely rewritten while preserving the essential qualities of the novel. This film presents a point of view many people have never seen, but is evenhanded in its revelations. It’s worth seeing on this basis alone, but it also offers a moderate amount of suspense and a large helping of the kind of intellectual satisfaction given by a tight, complex plot well presented. Good performances and good production values, including fine presentation of locations, add to a rather satisfying film. A more appropriate choice of director might have led to an excellent film.
335
Другие работы по теме:
Cinderella Essay Research Paper Cinderella The stepsistersOne
Cinderella Essay, Research Paper Cinderella (The stepsisters) One day this girl decides to waltz into our home and tries to be ?Miss Everything?, but to us, she?s nothing. It?s as if she?s trying to steal all the good things we have, but thank G-d we have the control over her. We are allowed to say, ?Cinderella, do this!? and, ?Cinderella, do that!?, but we can?t take complete advantage of her (unfortunately).
The Clan Of The Cave Bear Essay
, Research Paper The Clan of the Cave Bear starts out with a naked girl named Ayla swimming in a river. After that an earthquake occurs and she is surprised because she had never experienced one before. The earthquake kept on going, and she became even more frightened. She cried for her mother, but she was alone.
Self Esteem Essay Research Paper I compare
Self Esteem Essay, Research Paper I compare my face to the most beautiful girl in the school. I compare my personality to the sweetest girl in the school. I compare my socialization rate to the most popular girl in the school.
The Exorcist Essay Research Paper The ExorcistThis
The Exorcist Essay, Research Paper The Exorcist This book began in Iraq during an archeological dig. Father Lankester finds a small artifact that has similar traits as the demon named Pazuzu. In Washington D.C., a girl, Regan was possessed by the Pazuzu. That is when her mother getsthe help of Father Damian Karras.
Darkness Poem Essay Research Paper As a
Darkness (Poem) Essay, Research Paper As a young girl cries her father dies just another victim of a dark night Darkness creeps and shorten nights with just a glimsp pale light
Two Kinds Essay Research Paper The protagonist
Two Kinds Essay, Research Paper The protagonist Amy Tan, in the short story “Two Kinds” is a character that evolves and undergoes a lot of phases throughout the story to finally come to a point where she is happy and independent. At the beginning of the story Amy seems to be a happy and obedient little girl that agrees with everything her mom tells her.
Gender Selection Essay Research Paper The Future
Gender Selection Essay, Research Paper The Future is here The idea of being able to choose the gender of a child has not always been around. This controversy did not come about until recently because now we have the technology to perform this act of sex determination. Some say that we should be able to choose the gender of our children.
Aids Report Essay Research Paper AIDS
Aids Report Essay, Research Paper AIDS…Are You Afraid? This week when school starts, September 5th, a new child is enrolling. The school will not give out her name
Schindler Watches The Liquidation Of The Krakow
Ghetto Essay, Research Paper At this point in the movie there are people being taken out of the ghetto, especially adults. The only people left behind are children. Some of them hide in many various places including toilets, holes in the floor, and in stoves. Others were not as lucky and shot on the scene. Sometimes the parents even got to see their own children being shot.
Jane Eyre EssayIndependence Essay Research Paper Jane
Jane Eyre Essay-Independence Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre, a novel written by Charlotte Bronte, is about a young girl named Jane that struggles to discover her identity. Jane’s a girl who is “unhappy, very unhappy”(23). She grows up with relatives that treat her unfairly because her diseased family was not wealthy.
Tina 2 Essay Research Paper tina was
Tina 2 Essay, Research Paper tina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there wiltina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. littina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little tina was a bad girl. she had broken up the fabulous three trio. little chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutions.chris is now pussy wipped and will not speak to his peeps. give me some damn essay points, or there will be consequences and reprocutions.tle
Araby By James Joyce Essay Research Paper 2
?Araby? By James Joyce Essay, Research Paper Love at a young age is just an obsession. As children, our first relationships are object relationships. The people we like aren’t people; they are objects of our obsession, and our obsessions are driven by vanity and narcissism. We are obsessed with what we consider an ideal, something we create.
Letter Essay Research Paper October 16 2000Mrs
Letter Essay, Research Paper October 16, 2000 Mrs. Jensen 319 Bibb Graves Jacksonville, AL 362265 Dear Mrs. Jensen I attended Rome High School of Rome, Ga. Rome High School is about forty-five minutes from Jacksonville. Just head towards Piedmont, Al and then drive straight to Cedartown, Ga. The road signs will lead you there.
Humanistic View Journal Essay Research Paper When
Humanistic View Journal Essay, Research Paper When reading through my notes for the class, I have found that the humanistic approach to the development of personality is the most interesting. The book describes humanistic as development through interaction. Every day we come in contact with people who then influence the way we think and perceive ideas.
Poem Do You Know Mom
…? Essay, Research Paper Do you know mom…? Every night before I go to sleep, I think about you, As I lay in bed, alone in my own little world of thoughts, You are there with me “my mother.”
Arrange Marriages Essay Research Paper Arrange MarriagesThis
Arrange Marriages Essay, Research Paper Arrange Marriages This article is about a young girl who has been arranged to meet with her potential husband, the girl is from the west and he is from the east they are both from different worlds. Her parents traditions does not meet with her own so she must find away to disarrange the marriage.
The Rolling Stones Essay Research Paper The
The Rolling Stones Essay, Research Paper The Rolling Stones The English rock band The Rolling Stones was formed in 1962. The five origional members of the group were lead singer Mick Jagger
Us Players Essay Research Paper Us PlayersWe
Us Players Essay, Research Paper Us Players We’ll meet you and sweep you off of your feet We’re nice and we’re funny, so cute and so sweet Surprisingly, we like the same things as you
Puberty Essay Research Paper Up until the
Puberty Essay, Research Paper Up until the age of nine or ten years, there is little difference in the physical appearance of a boy or a girl, except the genitals. Boys and girls behave differently but this is mostly as a result of ’socialisation’ or the way other people have molded the child to behave like a girl or like a boy.
Anorexia Essay Research Paper Anorexia The ads
Anorexia Essay, Research Paper Anorexia The ads in all magazines promote one thing; skinny is the only way to be. From youth girl magazines to magazines inferred for adults, all women in ads are skinny, and this represents that you have to be skinny to be pretty, or get the man, or even to get the job.
Stereotyped Essay Research Paper Two years ago
Stereotyped Essay, Research Paper Two years ago, I was 5 feet 3 inches in height. I had long, black hair. And I was very skinny. Upon seeing me, people assumed that I was na ve, innocent, shy and quiet Filipino girl. They were right!However, these all changed last year. Being the timid, non- outgoing person that I was, I wanted to try new and different things.
Legal Opinion For 8th Social Studies Essay
, Research Paper Legal Opinion A. I picked the side of New Jersey in the New Jersey vs. T.L.O case. The reason I picked that side is because the girl whas smoking on school grounds and she was not allowed to do that. Another reason is the teacher that found the girl smoking had the right to bring her to the Principals office, because she had a reason to.
Use Of Force Essay Research Paper The
Use Of Force Essay, Research Paper The Use of Force illustrates very well the feelings and emotions of a normally rational person, who, for any reason, is subjected to a situation that causes
Pastorius Essay Research Paper Encouraged by his
Pastorius Essay, Research Paper Encouraged by his father, a drummer and vocalist, to pursue a career in music, Pastorius learned to play bass, drums, guitar, piano, and saxophone while in his teens. As a result of a football injury to his arm, his ambitions were mainly orientated towards the drums, but he soon found work playing bass for visiting pop and soul acts.
Mr. Lincoln
’s Drummer Essay, Research Paper Civil War I read a book called Mr. Lincoln?s Drummer. The author is G. Clifton Wisler. It is a historical fiction story. There are a lot of characters in this book but Willie Johnston was the main character. He was born in Vermont and was in the seventh grade. He was called one of the drummer boys.
The Little Girl Essay Research Paper Her
The Little Girl Essay, Research Paper Her parents never took young girls to church, Never spoke of his name, Never read her his words, Two non-beleivers walking lost in this world,
Mxpx
–Andrea Essay, Research Paper Andrea Meeting you was just so unexpected I guess I was scared of being rejected Since you were so nice I wouldn’t think twice
Society Genders Evaluation Essay Research Paper Nadine
Society Genders (Evaluation) Essay, Research Paper Nadine 04/02/01 ENG. 1B Mrs. Garcia TH 6-9pm Society Genders What gender are you? A female or a male, what ever the classification may be, how do you then distinguish your gender role in society, and what factors help you come to a conclusion of your representation.
Childhood Essay Research Paper We were then
Childhood Essay, Research Paper We were then Children with nothing but Childhood. We played kiss Tag and suicide which Was merely a game with Throwing, and running, and Touching the side of the
The Scarlet Ibis Essay Research Paper The
The Scarlet Ibis Essay, Research Paper The Scarlet Ibis James Hurst s short story, “The Scarlet Ibis” reveals that the brotherly bond between the narrator and Doodle is an essential component in the story. If Doodle was a girl, the brotherly connection and bond would be lost, resulting in many variations throughout the story.
Big Daddy Essay Research Paper Big KidOne
Big Daddy Essay, Research Paper Big Kid One of the most recent movies that i have seen is Big Daddy. When this movie came out in theaters I knew that it was going to be a hit because the main character (Adam Sandler)
Barbie Girl Essay Research Paper Sing it
Barbie Girl Essay, Research Paper Sing it to the Barbie song… Hi ya lang niu! Hi lang jai! Want to ride in my Honda? Sure lang jai! Jump in! * I’m a Chinese girl, in a Chinese world,